BFG ES-800 failed on me...I think

JayteeBates

[H]ard|Poof
Joined
Jul 21, 2007
Messages
5,540
So I went to turn on my system last night for some BC2 action and nothing happened. 5VSB was on as the power and reset switches on my ASUS P6TD were lit up but I could not get the supply to turn on. I thought I might have some issues as once a couple months ago I moved things around on my tech bench and it wouldn't come on until I had moved the hard drives to another physical position.

So anyway after disconnecting it from everything I tried to manually draw down the 5VSB and see if the power supply fan would come on which it did not. So needing a supply quickly and, not willing to wait for shipping I went to the only place around Best Buy and picked up a Corsair TX850.

The BFG ran for about a year pushing at first a QX6700 OC'd to ~3.1GHz and a BFG GTX 295 with two mechanical hard drives then later the sig rig. However I had noticed that lately if I was playing BC2 the game would randomly crash to desktop. This was happening more and more and after the fact that kinda makes sense if my 5870 wasn't getting the jucie it needed that the 3D game would just blink out and the system would return to desktop.

The Corsair has everything working again normally however I was wondering if anyone else had a similar problem with any power supply where it just stopped working but still put out the 5VSB?

Also I saw a "Rocketfish Gaming Power Supply 1000W" there on the shelf for $20 less than the Corsair at $129 bucks but A) I never heard of them for power supplies and B) I generally think you get what you pay for with regard to power supplies. Anyone got any good bad stories about them?
 
Last edited:
The Corsair has everything working again normally however I was wondering if anyone else had a similar problem with any power supply where it just stopped working but still put out the 5VSB?

Yes, happens often enough when I have units fail load testing.

Anyone got any good bad stories about them?

Rocketfish is one of BestBuy's house brands and the last time they did not fair so well. We have not reviewed the 1000W model though so I can't really tell you if that particular model was a good unit or not.
 
In the ES-800, the +5VSB is literally a separate power supply within the power supply, so it's not unusual for there to be +5VSB to continue to work if the PSU failed otherwise.
 
Bummer the BFG was visually an excellent looking unit. I got it on sale from the egg a good while back when they seemed to be blowing them out at super low prices. So for what I paid it did ok, I am just glad it didn't take out anything else when it went.

jonnyGURU, I saw your review of the TX850 and seems like it should be fine for my rig but I'm wondering if I should open it up and tighten those screws =) I probably won't but those type of things annoy me.

Also I went and checked my BFG registration seems like it lasted about two years:

Model: ES-800 800W PSU
Serial Number: 0811u000797
Purchase Date: 11/11/2008
Purchase Place: Newegg
 
Out of curiosity, what was teh serial number of your unit?

I have 2 BFG ES-800 power supplies, one i bought new and the other second hand.

The brand new one was a early model 815xxx power supply. It, to date, has taken out an ASRock 780a SLI motherboard (thought it was a bad board, but little did I know), a BFG 590SLI motherboard and 2 8800GT video cards (the 590 mobo and video cards were an all-at-once failure).

The second hand one is a 835xxx serialed unit, it basically has been rock-solid, generates less heat than the first, earlier serialed, one and has been rock solid even powering 2 GTX280s and an Asus Maximum III Formula motherboard with a quad-core Phenom II and 8gb of DDR3 ram. It does generate more heat when loaded like that, but has been trouble-free. The earlier units where known for issues with voltage noise when heavily loaded, and I think my early unit is one of hte problem-children in that regard as it seems to be fine until you start demanding more current. When it took out the ASRock 780a motherboard it was driving a 9950BE and a GTX280 overclocked (which should be no problem), but the power supply itself would start pouring out the heat when gaming heavily. Much more than I would expect for ~500 watts of demand.

I was going to RMA it, but when I finally got around to it I heard of BFG pulling out of the graphics market and figured the entire company as soon to follow, so I skipped the RMA and will just use it as a test supply/bench unit for supplying 12v for other projects.
 
Ahh, just noticed yours is even an earlier batch than mine was.

JonnyGURU, was it common for the earlier batches to have a year or so mortality rate? Or be more suscpetable to failure if they were pushed hard?
 
The TX is working well had zero problems last night with about a ~3 hour BC2 session.
 
Back
Top