Between these two fps styles, which do you prefer?

Between these two fps styles, what is your favorite?

  • Fast paced fps (quake3, ut99, ut2k4)

    Votes: 59 46.1%
  • Army style combat (cod, bfbc, moh)

    Votes: 66 51.6%
  • I dont play fps'

    Votes: 3 2.3%

  • Total voters
    128
Eh, BC2 and COD are two entirely different kind of games. They may share the whole modern warfare theme, but their core gameplay mechanics and pacing are pretty distinct and different. I just don't think the way you categorized them do them justice.

All minor quibles aside, while I grew up on Q3 and UT'99, I have found that I enjoy the more recent "modern warfare" themed FPS' slightly more.
 
Army style for the win. It makes the gamer feel like they are living the action of a firefight without really dieing.




Eh, BC2 and COD are two entirely different kind of games. They may share the whole modern warfare theme, but their core gameplay mechanics and pacing are pretty distinct and different. I just don't think the way you categorized them do them justice.

All minor quibles aside, while I grew up on Q3 and UT'99, I have found that I enjoy the more recent "modern warfare" themed FPS' slightly more.

This is very true. CoD and BC2 are completely different in the way they are played that is. CoD is a more fast paced in your face fps, where as BC2 is strategic and more tactical. Both require teamwork in Multiplayer but BC2 I feel takes the cake for the more tactical game. Agreed with the category mix up.
 
Known**

:)


But yea I like more of the military shooters.. I hate COD's enemy behind your back every 3 seconds.. But love BFBC2's "wide open, having to make a trek to charlie and capturing it" feeling.
 
I have a soft spot in my heart for UT and Quake. Preferably UT99.

I really like BC2, CoD but they are just kind pub games for fun. If I want to take something really seriously I'll be dueling in UT/Quake or playing CS.

I've been playing CS competitively with the same team since 2005. They are like my family.
 
Where's the option for other?

I prefer stealth/sneaking games or exploration games or sandbox games.

I don't think any of the things you posted.

quake3, ut99, ut2k4, cod, bfbc, moh, etc. all suck.

Give me Stalker, GTA IV first person mod, Mirror's Edge, Oblivion, etc.
 
Last edited:
Dont prefer one over the other, it just depends what Im in the mood for.

The original CoD felt a lot more "army" style compared to the modern ones.
 
I prefer the tactical aspect and (semi) realism of military-type shooters, although the fast paced Quake variety can be good for a laugh in certain situations.

Where's the option for other?

I prefer stealth/sneaking games or exploration games or sandbox games.

I don't think any of the things you posted.

quake3, ut99, ut2k4, cod, bfbc, moh, etc. all suck.

Give me Stalker, GTA IV first person mod, Mirror's Edge, Oblivion, etc.

Based on the games mentioned I think this poll was pretty much directed towards multiplayer FPS. I am a big fan of first-person sandbox games as well, though :)
 
I still prefer twitch shooters. I wasn't the best at them, but they were definitely more entertaining and didn't promote the dumb camping.
 
I prefer the tactical aspect and (semi) realism of military-type shooters, although the fast paced Quake variety can be good for a laugh in certain situations.

I hardly ever play fast paced shooters like quake, but one day I played Quake Live and it's funny as hell in those moments where you "one-up" someone at health pack or s specific gun over and over or get a ridiculous rocket kill you weren't expecting.

Tactical shooters are where I get serious though, shooters like Counter Strike and in the past Rainbow six.

Then there's shooters like Mohaa which I guess nowadays could be categorized with shooters like Call of Duty where they aren't tactical nor fast paced, but somethin in between.
 
Fast paced like UT/Quake.

To be honest the skill bar in modern tactical shooters like CoD/MW/BC2 are all gimped, it's very much rock/paper/scissors which forces this really fake teamwork which basically just requires everyone to do their job well, but no 1 person can really dominate the map on their own.

The skill bar in fast paced action shooters like quake and UT the skill range is way higher and it allows better players to actually sway the game somewhat more than something like BC2. As a long term gamer with good skills, the lack of effort to reward in tactical shooters leaves me wanting...games like BC2 are really fun but it doesn't matter how hard you fight as an individual you'll never take down a squad of decent medics who just res each other.

In something like UT if you brought your A game you could plough through swaths of people and turn around an entire match almost single handedly, it was a much more satisfying relationship between the effort you put in, and the reward you got back.
 
wow, 21 to 21.

I like fast paced deathmatch type games. Some of the CS:S mods like gun game turbo deathmatch are pretty fun.

Quake III, UT 2004, SOF II are some of my favorites.

I do like some of the more strategic games like Medal of Honor and the like.
 
Tactical shooters are where I get serious though

Same here.

To be honest the skill bar in modern tactical shooters like CoD/MW/BC2 are all gimped, it's very much rock/paper/scissors which forces this really fake teamwork which basically just requires everyone to do their job well, but no 1 person can really dominate the map on their own.

From what I understand of BC2 this is the case (haven't played it), but not so much in CoD. It is possible to go "lone wolf" in MW2 and more or less carry your team to victory. In my experience one person (myself included) certainly can dominate the map on their own.
 
Yeah you're right, MW titles are more arcade shooters than anything and good players can stand out a little easier, they also suffer somewhat from skill normalization though gotta make it easy for the newbs at the expense of skilled players :)
 
If this is a question between fast vs slow, unrealistic vs realistic, then my choice would always be fast and unrealistic FPS games because they just have adrenalin gameplay. Apart from good skills and strategy, it's the reflex that is highly involved in fast paced shooters. A reason why when I played Quake 3 / Warsow and practised Table Tennis few times a week was such a good mix for me.
 
Option #4
I actually enjoy both equally. It just depends on my mood I guess. Today was an Army style combat day (although I didn't vote).
 
Known**

:)


But yea I like more of the military shooters.. I hate COD's enemy behind your back every 3 seconds.. But love BFBC2's "wide open, having to make a trek to charlie and capturing it" feeling.

For a long time I've thought of how awesome a wide open MMO game with CoD type controls and gameplay would be. I like the wide open areas of Battlefield and Bad Company but the control mechanics piss me off. It almost feels as bad as Killzone 2.

I almost wanna start up my own game company.
 
A bit tired of military shooters honestly as a setting. They've basically dominated the genre the last few years, and even "sci-fi" type shooters really play and look like modern military shooters.

I actually was a bit hoping Battlefield 3 would move up in eras and be set in the far future or space or something.

What happened to the Tribes series? I've never actually played it, but conceptually it seems like Battlefield in the future/space.
 
I can't choose because the categories are crappy. COD and BFBC are fairly fast paced high action games. Are you looking at COD TDM or COD HC S&D? They are extremely different games that don't fit into the same category at all. Also thrown into the mix is vehicles, some people like them some people don't.

What about games like Natural Selection, where does that fit in?

UT and COD are not the only games in existance there are a lot of different kinds of games out there. I will vote if the poll ever gets better options.
 
I really can't vote for either. There was a time I played anything that was a FPS,but now my interest is in open world,non-linear shooters like the STALKER and Fallout games.
 
people are complaining too much.

Just break it down like this: 1. rocket launchers and strafe jumping. 2. realish guns with realish movement.
 
Are you serious? According to my genre meter there are fast paced FPS'es, fast paced FPS'es with soldier skins and no jump-pads, tactical FPS'es and Red Orchestra
 
Any chance of slower "halo" style?
Posted via Mobile Device

Slow-paced arena FPS...speed, regenerating health (in the form of shields) and vehicles are really the only things that separate Halo from the UTs and Quakes, IMO. The pre-Reach Halo games had every player with the exact same loadout and have weapons and powerups placed throughout the maps for players to grab, which is very arena-ish.
 
Twitch I guess. I enjoy BC2 style as well, but I'm better at Quake Live than I am BC2.
 
i think the modern CoD/BF games are little to quick on the kills. basically you kill every person you see and die any time someone sees you that you dont see. there are far to many one shot kills.

quake3 might be called fast, it takes more to kill someone and i think it has better combat because of that. you have time to turn around, you have time to jump/dodge, you have time to fight back.

my vote is fast pace. simply for the time to kill factor.
 
The arena shooters never had reloads, bullet spread/drop/travel or recoil to worry about, though - you could fire a minigun at full-auto with no insane recoil or bullet spread to worry about. To say that the military shooters are without skill isn't very accurate.
 
Fast paced like UT/Quake.

To be honest the skill bar in modern tactical shooters like CoD/MW/BC2 are all gimped, it's very much rock/paper/scissors which forces this really fake teamwork which basically just requires everyone to do their job well, but no 1 person can really dominate the map on their own.

The skill bar in fast paced action shooters like quake and UT the skill range is way higher and it allows better players to actually sway the game somewhat more than something like BC2. As a long term gamer with good skills, the lack of effort to reward in tactical shooters leaves me wanting...games like BC2 are really fun but it doesn't matter how hard you fight as an individual you'll never take down a squad of decent medics who just res each other.

In something like UT if you brought your A game you could plough through swaths of people and turn around an entire match almost single handedly, it was a much more satisfying relationship between the effort you put in, and the reward you got back.

I much prefer fast-paced FPS for these reasons. It's pure skill, shooting, dodging, movement.
 
Fast paced!

PrincessFrosty said it best earlier.

In Quake/UT you have weapons for all ranges, in both hitscan and projectile varieties; you aren't limited in your destructive capacity. You also move fast and can take a lot of damage. In other words its entirely up to your own skill to get frags and survive.

In BF/CoD you have a bunch of similar weapons that are all more or less the same, maybe a rocket launcher too. But you move slow and die in a few hits. So you are always limited by the game.
 
Back
Top