Better online store than Newegg?

nray

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 20, 2006
Messages
316
Last year I did over $117,000 of business with Newegg for my day job, and generally I've been happy with them.

I've also been using Newegg for home purchases, and during a recent computer build a 4GB set (two 2GB modules) of G.Skill memory I bought ended up being incompatible with my MSI P6N SLI Platinum motherboard (which I bought at the same time), and G.Skill recommended I return them to Newegg for a refund. Newegg would take the G.Skill memory back, but only after charging me a $55 restocking fee (and they weren't covering return shipping either). I asked politely if they'd waive the restocking fee, and they refused.

There's nothing in the specifications of the memory either on Newegg's site or G.Skill's site which would have led me to believe that the memory wouldn't have worked, and I'm wondering if anyone has any other online vendors who will treat me better in a similar situation?

For work, I have a number of other companies who would like to do as much business with me as I've been doing with Newegg, and I'm going to start talking to them as well - I'm really disappointed with how Newegg has handled this situation.
 
Yeah the restocking fee sucks but just like circuit city, its just something you have to deal with. Zipzoomfly has been ok for me and ClubIT. I would avoid TD.
 
Smaller companies like xoxide, jabtech etc may be more willing to work with you I would guess. Restocking fees are pretty standard and most won't be waived which sucks as you never know how a product is until you take it home, regardless of how many reviews you have read.
 
i doubt that any company will be willing to give you a full refund on an open and used item, no matter how short it was used for. would you like to receive a used item though it said it was new? or would you like to lose money on hardware you sell if youre a business owner? those are the only two things that can come about from giving full refunds for open or used items. neither are even close to being fair.

these are the sort of risks you take when you build your own system. this is the downside to freedom of hardware, its very difficult to make every single piece of hardware compatible with one another but im sure youd agree its worth the small risk
 
Last year I did over $117,000 of business with Newegg for my day job, and generally I've been happy with them.

I've also been using Newegg for home purchases, and during a recent computer build a 4GB set (two 2GB modules) of G.Skill memory I bought ended up being incompatible with my MSI P6N SLI Platinum motherboard (which I bought at the same time), and G.Skill recommended I return them to Newegg for a refund. Newegg would take the G.Skill memory back, but only after charging me a $55 restocking fee (and they weren't covering return shipping either). I asked politely if they'd waive the restocking fee, and they refused.

There's nothing in the specifications of the memory either on Newegg's site or G.Skill's site which would have led me to believe that the memory wouldn't have worked, and I'm wondering if anyone has any other online vendors who will treat me better in a similar situation?

For work, I have a number of other companies who would like to do as much business with me as I've been doing with Newegg, and I'm going to start talking to them as well - I'm really disappointed with how Newegg has handled this situation.

It's your responsibility to make sure the RAM you pick for your motherboard is compatible. If you have not returned the RAM yet I would check to see if your system can boot with another set of RAM and manually set the voltage on the memory to 2.0-2.1 volts. Save your settings and then put the G.Skill RAM back in to see if it works. Perhaps the G.Skill requires 2.0-2.1 volts to boot and the motherboard is defaulting to 1.8.

I presume when you ordered the parts you did it on your personal account? If you have a history with Newegg they'll be happy to waive the restocking fee.. at least in my case they did. Perhaps you should let them know about your business account? ;)

PS: Customer service for xoxide isn't that great IMO.
 
It's your responsibility to make sure the RAM you pick for your motherboard is compatible.

I am aware of that.

If you have not returned the RAM yet I would check to see if your system can boot with another set of RAM and manually set the voltage on the memory to 2.0-2.1 volts. Save your settings and then put the G.Skill RAM back in to see if it works. Perhaps the G.Skill requires 2.0-2.1 volts to boot and the motherboard is defaulting to 1.8.

The G.Skill requires 1.8V-1.9V according to the specifications. By booting with only one stick in place I was able to then get into the BIOS and move the voltage up, and then able to boot with both sticks, however then running extensive Memtest 86+ tests at each and every voltage in the 1.8V to 2.0V range demonstrated different amounts of memory errors. A Newegg comment by someone else said they also got errors at stock speeds but were able to eliminate errors by running the memory at 533 instead of 667, something which I'm not willing to do (primarily because I did not pay for 533 memory, I paid for 667 memory). That lends credence to the idea that G.Skill has in fact produced memory which is not to their published specifications.

I presume when you ordered the parts you did it on your personal account? If you have a history with Newegg they'll be happy to waive the restocking fee.. at least in my case they did. Perhaps you should let them know about your business account? ;)

In my last email exchange with them I did let them know, and their response was to help out only if I bought something else of higher or equal value, however I had already purchased a new set of memory from ewiz at that point. (Incidentally, the new memory I have received from ewiz works without producing any errors in my P6N SLI Platinum.)

PS: Customer service for xoxide isn't that great IMO.

Thanks, good to know.
 
i doubt that any company will be willing to give you a full refund on an open and used item, no matter how short it was used for. would you like to receive a used item though it said it was new? or would you like to lose money on hardware you sell if youre a business owner? those are the only two things that can come about from giving full refunds for open or used items. neither are even close to being fair.

I would hope in this instance that Newegg would not try to resell that memory to someone else, but rather send it back to G.Skill for analysis or do further testing themelves in-house to determine whether they should put a general disclaimer on the memory so that people don't fall into the same trap that I did.

And the way I look at, I invested 7 hours of my time - very valuable time, I might add - diagnosing problems with G.Skill memory for Newegg and I let them know the results at no charge, enabling them to take action and provide better customer service to other Newegg customers based on my experience. The least Newegg could have done when I reported the problem with the memory to them was to say then that I could return them for a full refund if I buy another product of equal or higher value, I should not have to have a series of email exchanges back and forth to get to that point, all the while treating my time and effort that I made as an IT professional working with a product they sold me as worthless or worse yet, as some sort of cost to them.

these are the sort of risks you take when you build your own system. this is the downside to freedom of hardware, its very difficult to make every single piece of hardware compatible with one another but im sure youd agree its worth the small risk

I am aware of these risks, and as a professional I take every measure to minimize them and communicate everything I find with all relevant parties in a clear manner to help everyone involved in the industry as a whole.
 
The G.Skill requires 1.8V-1.9V according to the specifications. By booting with only one stick in place I was able to then get into the BIOS and move the voltage up, and then able to boot with both sticks, however then running extensive Memtest 86+ tests at each and every voltage in the 1.8V to 2.0V range demonstrated different amounts of memory errors. A Newegg comment by someone else said they also got errors at stock speeds but were able to eliminate errors by running the memory at 533 instead of 667, something which I'm not willing to do (primarily because I did not pay for 533 memory, I paid for 667 memory). That lends credence to the idea that G.Skill has in fact produced memory which is not to their published specifications.

You could've gotten some defective RAM. I'm surprised G.Skill didn't suggest that. Then again, they would lose a bit of money.....
 
MMMMmmm newegg. Just bought 1100 bucks worth of stuff in the past 3 weeks. RMA'ed 1 item only 12 restocking fee. The best part is you print your UPS label from home then just drop it off so simple.

Newegg is the best I have used, and your experince doesn't sound that bad they let you return it and get most your money back they could of just said....um no.
 
Newegg usually waives the restocking fee if you purchase a replacement from them. It sounds like you got defective sticks, so they should have RMA'd it without restocking fees, or G.skill should have RMA'd it for you. I've used several of their DDR2-800 sticks, and they all worked great.

RMA them through G.Skill and sell them on fleabay or FS/FT forums.
 
Newegg rocks my socks.

OP sounds like you got hosed by gskill support, not newegg. if the sticks don't perform at stock settings on a known working mobo without known compatibility issues, then the sticks are bad, as simple as that. RMA FTW. Blaming Newegg for the gskill rep trying to save $550 FTL.
 
you didnt mention that the ram was faulty at its rated speed. this adds a whole new scenario. in this case, you have the right to RMA it to g.skill

newegg has the best customer service ive ever experienced in my life. they go out of their way to make people happy, its almost unbelievable. i love them

now if only they had some free shipping coupons :p
 
you didnt mention that the ram was faulty at its rated speed. this adds a whole new scenario. in this case, you have the right to RMA it to g.skill

I agree I had the right, but should I have to fight with the component maker for an RMA?

I'm actually thinking that maybe the best bet is to go with someplace like datamemorysystems.com - I've done business with them for over 10 years, and while I've been using Newegg more in the last two years for my memory purchases, I'd always send friends and family to DMS for their RAM purchases because they've got competent sales people, stand by their product, and are based in New Hampshire (and my friends and family are in Massachusetts). Shipping is fast, and competent, english-speaking phone support is a quick call away (G.Skill's email support was broken english).

I'm beginning to think that at the least I should just stop purchasing memory from Newegg, since this has been such a fiasco. I've avoided these fiascos (out of pre-emptive DDR2 voltage paranoia) with the systems I've bought memory for at work by sticking with DDR2 memory strictly rated for just 1.8V or getting EPP RAM for motherboards that support EPP.
 
I agree I had the right, but should I have to fight with the component maker for an RMA?
Yes... it was THEIR product that was defective.

nray said:
I'm actually thinking that maybe the best bet is to go with someplace like datamemorysystems.com - I've done business with them for over 10 years, and while I've been using Newegg more in the last two years for my memory purchases, I'd always send friends and family to DMS for their RAM purchases because they've got competent sales people, stand by their product, and are based in New Hampshire (and my friends and family are in Massachusetts). Shipping is fast, and competent, english-speaking phone support is a quick call away (G.Skill's email support was broken english).

Sounds to me like the problem lies with G.Skill and not newegg... I've never had a problem with newegg's customer service, but I've only had to return one item (shipping damage) in the years I have dealings with them. Tell me... does datamemorysystems.com sell G.Skill?

nray said:
I'm beginning to think that at the least I should just stop purchasing memory from Newegg, since this has been such a fiasco. I've avoided these fiascos (out of pre-emptive DDR2 voltage paranoia) with the systems I've bought memory for at work by sticking with DDR2 memory strictly rated for just 1.8V or getting EPP RAM for motherboards that support EPP.

Again, I believe your problem lies with G.Skill and not Newegg. Maybe if you had purchased OCZ, MUSHKIN, CRUCIAL or CORSAIR memory, you would have gotten "competent, english-speaking (fluent) phone support" from them, gotten an RMA and avoided newegg's customer support entirely... which in reality, they shouldn't be responsible for "defective" products (not caused by shipping/packing damage).

In the end it is your money (or client's money) to spend... most people who use newegg... seem to have little issues with their dealings with them, I'm sorry to hear of your problems, but I think you're putting blame on the wrong company.
 
Sounds to me like the problem lies with G.Skill and not newegg... I've never had a problem with newegg's customer service, but I've only had to return one item (shipping damage) in the years I have dealings with them. Tell me... does datamemorysystems.com sell G.Skill?
No, datamemorysystems.com builds their own memory, like any big memory maker (Crucial, Corsair, etc.)

Again, I believe your problem lies with G.Skill and not Newegg. Maybe if you had purchased OCZ, MUSHKIN, CRUCIAL or CORSAIR memory

At the time I was purchasing this memory three weeks ago Newegg carried only TWO brands of DDR2 667 memory that was 2GB per stick, and it was Geil and G.Skill, that's it. There was no OCZ, Mushkin, Crucial, or Corsair available in that capacity and speed. If you look now, there's also Wintec and Kingston (Crucial is only available at DDR2 533).

you would have gotten "competent, english-speaking (fluent) phone support" from them, gotten an RMA and avoided newegg's customer support entirely... which in reality, they shouldn't be responsible for "defective" products (not caused by shipping/packing damage).

Did I tell Newegg to carry memory from a vendor (G.Skill) who handled the problem with their memory incorrectly? No, Newegg chose to carry G.Skill. If G.Skill does a lousy job handling problems, I don't see why it should fall to the customer (me) to tell the manufacturer what they should do for me contradicting what they suggest, and then if I don't fight them, having to pick up the tab for the manufacturer's mistake. A retailer should stand by the product they're selling and do what's right for the customer.

I spent money on brand new memory that I expected to work and have good support from the manufacturer, I did not spend money on bad/defective/not-as-described memory with lousy support from the manufacturer and a retailer who then charges me for discovering the fact.

What separates a good retailer from an excellent retailer is what they do for a customer when things go wrong, and in this instance Newegg was merely good. I think those of you who are defending Newegg are comparing them to what else is out there (online and retail), and I don't ultimately judge retailers by what my options are but by what they ideally should be (and I judge them all that way).

Sadly, the level of service available to customers is going down across the board. People want their goods cheap over everything else (it's clearly been more important than domestic production for most people, so much for patriotism in the retail sense). The biggest reason I have been shopping at Newegg has not been price, but they are the only online computer parts retailer with an interface to their inventory which is designed in even a half-sensible way. It's the power search and multiple pictures that are mandatory for me to be able to purchase parts (and complete systems I build from parts) online, because for my job I build and support all the hardware and software on a network that I built and manage for over a hundred users, and I NEED to know EXACTLY what I'm buying. I am the leader of a two-person IT team who supports over a hundred users across several projects with several different departments, and there isn't an item out of the $117,000+ in goods I bought last year that I didn't personally handle. The fact that Newegg happens to be one of the less expensive sellers has just been a perk.

Meanwhile Bestbuy is putting companies like CompUSA out of business because Best buy has had more success at getting people in the door with low prices on a narrow range of big ticket items and then raping them on accessories and extended warranty plans. CompUSA tried to play the same game (rather than actually do a good job at selling computer-related stuff and expanding their parts offerings) and lost. Microcenter is ok, but you have to deal with very aggressive sales staff who work off of some sort of commission and like to stick their bar-coded employee stickers on items you're buying even if you don't need and didn't use their help at all (frankly I just feel bad for them and let them). And there's no Fry's on the east coast at all, so Microcenter is now just about it and if you're not near Cambridge, MA, Long Island, NY, Radnor, PA or Fairfax, VA, then forget it.

And you're telling me I just need to suck it up and *like* this situation?
 
Sounds to me like the problem lies with G.Skill and not newegg... I've never had a problem with newegg's customer service, but I've only had to return one item (shipping damage) in the years I have dealings with them. Tell me... does datamemorysystems.com sell G.Skill?

No, datamemorysystems.com builds their own memory, like any big memory maker (Crucial, Corsair, etc.)



At the time I was purchasing this memory three weeks ago Newegg carried only TWO brands of DDR2 667 memory that was 2GB per stick, and it was Geil and G.Skill, that's it. There was no OCZ, Mushkin, Crucial, or Corsair available in that capacity and speed. If you look now, there's also Wintec and Kingston (Crucial is only available at DDR2 533).



Did I tell Newegg to carry memory from a vendor (G.Skill) who handled the problem with their memory incorrectly? No, Newegg chose to carry G.Skill. If G.Skill does a lousy job handling problems, I don't see why it should fall to the customer (me) to tell the manufacturer what they should do for me contradicting what they suggest, and then if I don't fight them, having to pick up the tab for the manufacturer's mistake. A retailer should stand by the product they're selling and do what's right for the customer.

I spent money on brand new memory that I expected to work and have good support from the manufacturer, I did not spend money on bad/defective/not-as-described memory with lousy support from the manufacturer and a retailer who then charges me for discovering the fact.

What separates a good retailer from an excellent retailer is what they do for a customer when things go wrong, and in this instance Newegg was merely good. I think those of you who are defending Newegg are comparing them to what else is out there (online and retail), and I don't ultimately judge retailers by what my options are but by what they ideally should be (and I judge them all that way).

Sadly, the level of service available to customers is going down across the board. People want their goods cheap over everything else (it's clearly been more important than domestic production for most people, so much for patriotism in the retail sense). The biggest reason I have been shopping at Newegg has not been price, but they are the only online computer parts retailer with an interface to their inventory which is designed in even a half-sensible way. It's the power search and multiple pictures that are mandatory for me to be able to purchase parts (and complete systems I build from parts) online, because for my job I build and support all the hardware and software on a network that I built and manage for over a hundred users, and I NEED to know EXACTLY what I'm buying. I am the leader of a two-person IT team who supports over a hundred users across several projects with several different departments, and there isn't an item out of the $117,000+ in goods I bought last year that I didn't personally handle. The fact that Newegg happens to be one of the less expensive sellers has just been a perk.

Meanwhile Bestbuy is putting companies like CompUSA out of business because Best buy has had more success at getting people in the door with low prices on a narrow range of big ticket items and then raping them on accessories and extended warranty plans. CompUSA tried to play the same game (rather than actually do a good job at selling computer-related stuff and expanding their parts offerings) and lost. Microcenter is ok, but you have to deal with very aggressive sales staff who work off of some sort of commission and like to stick their bar-coded employee stickers on items you're buying even if you don't need and didn't use their help at all (frankly I just feel bad for them and let them). And there's no Fry's on the east coast at all, so Microcenter is now just about it and if you're not near Cambridge, MA, Long Island, NY, Radnor, PA or Fairfax, VA, then forget it.

And you're telling me I just need to suck it up and *like* this situation?

so buy somewhere else dude. "you" did "$117,000" business with newegg (through a job or otherwise) and are having to go back and forth with them over a $55 restocking fee? I find it hard to believe they wouldn't try to work with you to get this issue resolved amicably, even though this does seem to be 100% a g.skill issue.
 
i don't hear a lot of complaints about the egg, but yours are a bit of an end around to get there, don't you think?

Did I tell Newegg to carry memory from a vendor (G.Skill) who handled the problem with their memory incorrectly?

lol. come on man.
 
so buy somewhere else dude. "you" did "$117,000" business with newegg (through a job or otherwise) and are having to go back and forth with them over a $55 restocking fee? I find it hard to believe they wouldn't try to work with you to get this issue resolved amicably, even though this does seem to be 100% a g.skill issue.

Our company does billions in business but we don't throw $55 away. Heck, we'd pull out our lawyers before refunding $55, lol. You make it sound so insignificant (which it technically is), however, it's still money and if a vendor treats you like that, then you just can them.

I agree, you just need to be a piranha with them until you get better sales managers.
 
Our company does billions in business but we don't throw $55 away. Heck, we'd pull out our lawyers before refunding $55, lol. You make it sound so insignificant (which it technically is), however, it's still money and if a vendor treats you like that, then you just can them.

I agree, you just need to be a piranha with them until you get better sales managers.

$55 isn't worth losing a good customer or losing a good vendor, assuming he had been happy with the previous $117,000 he spent. I'm merely pointing out that I would think that newegg would work with him if he had done that much business with them on the restocking fee if he went through the proper channels and really is as pissed off as he seems to be in this thread.
 
And you're telling me I just need to suck it up and *like* this situation?

I never said anything like that. ^^^

Re-reading my own post, I think I was trying to tell you that your frustrations were misdirected.

Prior to using Newegg (almost exclusively), I used mwave.com (almost exclusively). In a span of 4 years I purchased well over $63K in parts with mwave (for personal and friends/family). I had several issues with them and didn't appreciate the fact that there was a language barrier there either. Hell! I even tried speaking Mandarin, Cantonese and Shanghinese to help them with THEIR language issues... didn't help. I then discovered Newegg.com... and have not shopped anywhere since. Newegg does NOT have the lowest prices... they just had a better ordering/shipping system (after they stopped ripping people off with the SHIPPING COST PER ITEM BS policy they had).

As far as carrying products, you're right... a retailer SHOULD stand behind the products they sell, but in the same vein the MANUFACTURER should even more so... which wasn't the case. Newegg carries alot of different products.... personally, I'd NEVER buy a Rosewill product (or Raidmax, or Bytecc)... would you? (also wouldn't buy any brand of memory besides the brands I listed in my previous post, because of the same reasons)

Again, I'm not saying what they did or how you were treated was handled properly, I'm just saying that the MANUFACTURER should be held responsible more so than the retailer.

What if newegg were to handle things like ::cough MONARCH COMPUTERS cough:: and close up shop tomorrow.... and G.SKILL were still in business manufacturing the same exact RAM, would you just eat the cost of that RAM or would you work at gettting a replacement from G.SKILL????
 
I buy computers as part of my job too.

Talk to Zones, CDW, or Westwood Computer Corporation. Tell them you're buying for a company, and ask for a corporate account and negotiate a discount based on amount of money you're spending on computer electronics per year. Just funnel your purchase requisitions through the 3 representatives assigned to each of your 3 accounts and get their prices. Talk to the 2 lowest to give them a chance to undercut each other beyond the initial discount. Take the lowest price and buy from them.

May not see many amazing bargains on a broad corporate discount, but you'll be able to get a decent deal everytime instead of list pricing. And if you have problems, you have the direct phone number of your account reps to talk things out with. They'll also be able to explain things and make recommendations to you if you have questions.

Those 3 don't have restocking charges because again, this is corporate business so they're not worried about you trying some funny business with e-bay or returning boxes of rocks. They're more worried about keeping you happy so you'll continue to funnel business into your account. It's not worth protecting themselves on one purchase when you're moving hundreds of purchases.

(I can dig up some contact information for those companies if you're interested enough to send a PM. I don't know how much purchasing you need to do to get corporate discounts from each company, but it's worth it to see if you've got enough.)
 
All I know is Newegg.com refunded me for a monitor I bought and was past 30-day initial period. Yeah, I paid the restocking fee, but it was worth it to ditch that POS for an LCD I love to this day.
 
the fact is, you blamed the wrong company. you can make up all the excuses you want but the truth remains, this is a g.skill problem not a newegg problem and i hope youre not bothering them or giving them a hassle about it because they have great customer service and when people start pissing them off because they *expect favors from them* thats when theyre gona stop doing favors out of the goodness of their hearts. so please just take care of your issue with g.skill or pay the restocking fee.
 
the fact is, you blamed the wrong company. you can make up all the excuses you want but the truth remains, this is a g.skill problem not a newegg problem and i hope youre not bothering them or giving them a hassle about it because they have great customer service and when people start pissing them off because they *expect favors from them* thats when theyre gona stop doing favors out of the goodness of their hearts. so please just take care of your issue with g.skill or pay the restocking fee.

Bothering them?

I recounted what already happened - a week ago I exchanged two emails with G.Skill, then three with Newegg, and as I explained already I've halted all business with Newegg (personal and work) while I reconsider where I purchase from, and I came to this forum to ask other people's opinions on other vendors. (I don't feel it is worth my time to take things any further with Newegg because I've explained once to them the situation in an email, and if that representative doesn't want to do anything further, then clearly Newegg doesn't care enough about my business, and that's not my problem.)

I expect no favors, and I'm not hassling anyone. I just wanted people's knowledge of and experience with other vendors, and I thought it might be helpful to have recounted why I was even considering it so that if anyone had a specific situation similar to mine that had been handled better at another retailer, they could let me know. It was not my intention to create a thread where we could debate who was most to blame in my situation or to go over extensive re-analysis of the situation and sequence of events, nor am I here to change anyone else's opinion of Newegg or any other retailer.
 
Talk to Zones, CDW, or Westwood Computer Corporation. Tell them you're buying for a company, and ask for a corporate account and negotiate a discount based on amount of money you're spending on computer electronics per year. Just funnel your purchase requisitions through the 3 representatives assigned to each of your 3 accounts and get their prices. Talk to the 2 lowest to give them a chance to undercut each other beyond the initial discount. Take the lowest price and buy from them.

Thanks, best advice so far. Up until about two years ago I had been working with Dell, CDW, and PC Connection, and it wasn't until last year that I switched nearly all my business to Newegg. Dell kept changing account reps on me every few months and making minor errors, CDW screwed up on something pretty big, and I've recently been in touch with PC Connection again. I've never heard of Westwood... and I'll pick things up with you via a PM.
 
Back
Top