Best Solution for Home Media Storage

mandj_dad

n00b
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
1
So I am now in possession of thousands of pictures and countless hours of home video. As I place more and more of these memories on my machine (and the kids download 100 songs a day) I realize I need more storage asap.

Specifically, I need a significant storage that will GUARANTEE these memories are safe or I will end up in Divorce Court. I will need to access from my main computer and a HTPC someday.

So I am considering RAID5 (software, mobo, or hardware) or WHS. Any thoughts as to which of these (or another) would be best would be appreciated.
 
... I need a significant storage that will GUARANTEE these memories are safe or I will end up in Divorce Court ... o I am considering RAID5 (software, mobo, or hardware) or WHS ...


Use of either RAID 5 or WHS alone will not keep you out of Divorce Court ... that would require backups (note that is plural) stored offsite (in-laws house). :D

Would suggest WHS ... scheduled backups of your desktops to WHS ... scheduled backups of WHS to external media and store it offsite.
 
I use unRaid for all my media storage. It is not in and of itself a complete backup solution. It does protect you from a drive failure like RAID5 does but in a slightly different way. Do some reading on the site, forum, and wiki and you can figure out if this is a good solution for you.

For offsite storage i suggest something like Mozy, Carbonite, or AmazonS3.
 
I'm too am using unRaid by limetechnology (http://lime-technology.com) and am very happy with it. It is very efficient storage-wise as it allows you to mix/match drives of different sizes and types at the sacrifice of one drive for parity. It is easy to add or replace drives and is manage via a Windows browser, so it manages like a NAS but without the growth limitations of a NAS. With unRaid, if you lose one drive, you lose no data, if you lose two, you only lose the data on those drives. With Raid5 - if you lose two, you probably lose the entire array.

Whatever you decide on, you absolutely need periodic backups of the most critical files, preferably off-site. Do not depend on hard drive protected storage as your sole means to stay out of divorce court.
 
Set up a WHS with offsite backup to a server at your girlfriend's house.

You could be safe while still living life on the edge! :D
 
What I recommend for you:

- WHS (with duplication turned on for the more important files) to store everything.
- External drive for backups of the really important data (like those home videos, pictures but not the gigs of music)
- Another external drive (to backup the backup external drive) to store it offsite (anywhere but your home like your GF's house :D or in-laws house or parent's house or neighbors or friend's etc.)
- An online service like Mozy, Carbonite, or AmazonS3. for the REALLY important info.

If you really want to be careful, store the external hard drive in a fire-proof safe.
 
Set up a WHS with offsite backup to a server at your girlfriend's house.

You could be safe while still living life on the edge! :D

Wish I had thought of that option! Must be my age and marital status ... :D
 
this is my recommendation::

get a mate, persuade him how good a htpc will be and say if you'll make it for free and he can have all of your movies etc for free.
 
unRaid Server Pro definitely seems appealing for me!

So let me get this straight, the OS works in that it achieves "redundancy" through a single parity drive, much like RAID 4, and it also offers fault tolerance in the sense that if more than one disk (NOT the parity disk) were the fail, it would only take out the data of the drives involved, not necessarily the whole array.

After all my drama with OCE and full RAID 5 risk rather than segmented and compartmentalized damage, I'm seriously thinking about ditching the stripe performance of RAID 5 for something simpler and easier - the quick capacity expansion that unRaid features is definitely appealing to me.

Can anyone think of any opposition to going towards unRaid Server Professional, aside from the performance loss by essentially doing a JBOD with a parity disk? Is the parity disk the weak link in this setup?
 
Syntax - that is correct, unRaid is "Raid4-like" in that it uses a single parity drive. If you lose two drives, you only lose the data on those drives. If one of those is the parity drive, then the only data lost is that on the other drive. I would not classify the parity drive as the wink link, cuz if you lose that, you've lost nothing other than your real-time protection. Once you replace it and rebuild parity, your good.

lime-technology has a future version in the works to protect against a two-drive failure. I bet we'll see that in less than a year.

I had a drive fail on me last year - while it was failed, I actually saved a recorded show to that drive, then watched it... all the while that drive was failed. I got a replacement, swapped it out, and unRaid rebuilt the data.

The file system is not proprietary, so even if your motherboard fried, you can pull those drives and get at them from another machine. There is a freeware utility out there that will let you read those files directly from a Windows machine if you were to pull an unRaid drive out and install it in a Windows box. So unlike Drobo for example, if you have a serious hardware failure, you can still get at your data without a recovery service or buying additional hardware.

unRaid boots from a flash drive, so you don't use up a drive for the OS, another factor that makes it more storage efficient that most alternatives. Although WHS, FlexRaid and Raid5 are thought of as competitors, unRaid is closer to being a NAS on steroids as it is problematic to dual purpose an unRaid server, but it also administers like a NAS, making it fairly hands-off. Its linux based, but unless your are modding the OS, you won't use any linux with it.

unRaid basic which supports 3 drives (2 data, 1 parity) is free. I highly recommend trying that out first to get a feel for it. When I first tried unRaid, I just disconnected my regular Windows drives from my PC, got a couple old (one ide, one sata drives), built the unRaid flash OS, booted it up, and within 15min could use unRaid on my home network.
 
As I place more and more of these memories on my machine (and the kids download 100 songs a day) I realize I need more storage asap.

Specifically, I need a significant storage that will GUARANTEE these memories are safe or I will end up in Divorce Court. I will need to access from my main computer and a HTPC someday.


Oh you will have memories alright... memories of you getting your computer infected by a file from all the downloading, or memories of the agencies ceasing your computer and server, or perhaps memories of a nice lawsuit from some recording agency.


Anyways, I recommend WHS as always.
 
Syntax - that is correct, unRaid is "Raid4-like" in that it uses a single parity drive. If you lose two drives, you only lose the data on those drives. If one of those is the parity drive, then the only data lost is that on the other drive. I would not classify the parity drive as the wink link, cuz if you lose that, you've lost nothing other than your real-time protection. Once you replace it and rebuild parity, your good.

lime-technology has a future version in the works to protect against a two-drive failure. I bet we'll see that in less than a year.

I had a drive fail on me last year - while it was failed, I actually saved a recorded show to that drive, then watched it... all the while that drive was failed. I got a replacement, swapped it out, and unRaid rebuilt the data.

The file system is not proprietary, so even if your motherboard fried, you can pull those drives and get at them from another machine. There is a freeware utility out there that will let you read those files directly from a Windows machine if you were to pull an unRaid drive out and install it in a Windows box. So unlike Drobo for example, if you have a serious hardware failure, you can still get at your data without a recovery service or buying additional hardware.

unRaid boots from a flash drive, so you don't use up a drive for the OS, another factor that makes it more storage efficient that most alternatives. Although WHS, FlexRaid and Raid5 are thought of as competitors, unRaid is closer to being a NAS on steroids as it is problematic to dual purpose an unRaid server, but it also administers like a NAS, making it fairly hands-off. Its linux based, but unless your are modding the OS, you won't use any linux with it.

unRaid basic which supports 3 drives (2 data, 1 parity) is free. I highly recommend trying that out first to get a feel for it. When I first tried unRaid, I just disconnected my regular Windows drives from my PC, got a couple old (one ide, one sata drives), built the unRaid flash OS, booted it up, and within 15min could use unRaid on my home network.

Thanks for the informative post; is it possible by any chance to run unRaid on Hyper-V in Windows Server 2008 to configure the system? Or is it possible to boot into the flash disk for unRaid only for the purposes of setting up the initial drives? Reason being is that I plan on using my server for more than just NAS file serving (light stuff, like a game server and HTPC as well), so I was wondering if I can have the program flexibility that I'm used to on my Server 2008 setup. :)
 
Thanks for the informative post; is it possible by any chance to run unRaid on Hyper-V in Windows Server 2008 to configure the system? Or is it possible to boot into the flash disk for unRaid only for the purposes of setting up the initial drives? Reason being is that I plan on using my server for more than just NAS file serving (light stuff, like a game server and HTPC as well), so I was wondering if I can have the program flexibility that I'm used to on my Server 2008 setup. :)

I can't say. A few folks have configured unRaid to run as a VM (and others to host), but not with Hyper-V that I know of. Grab unRaid basic (free) and give it a try. The most obvious challenge I can see is making sure unRaid only sees the drives it should see and that Server 2008 leaves those drives alone.

You've really got me curious with this idea - I've got a full MSDN subscription, so I've got Server '08. mmm....

Edited to add: Found a relaed thread on the unRaid forums. http://lime-technology.com/forum/index.php?topic=1831.0
 
Thanks for the informative post; is it possible by any chance to run unRaid on Hyper-V in Windows Server 2008 to configure the system? Or is it possible to boot into the flash disk for unRaid only for the purposes of setting up the initial drives? Reason being is that I plan on using my server for more than just NAS file serving (light stuff, like a game server and HTPC as well), so I was wondering if I can have the program flexibility that I'm used to on my Server 2008 setup. :)

I'm not sure if you would be able to do that or not. It is probably a question that could be asked on the unRaid Forum and they could help you out.

My initial guess would be no… or at least it could not be done easily. If it can be i would be very surprised. I know that some of the people on the unRaid forum run unRaid on a full slackware distribution.

There is one person who has created an "addon" for unRaid that provides more functionality. He goes by the name bubbaQ and his addition to unRaid is called BubbaRaid. I use BubbaRaid 90% of the time as it has a rtorrent/wtorrent, slimserver, nbzget, and a few other things built into it. Do some searching in the User Customizations section of the forum and you will find it.

UnRaid is not as flexible as Server 2008, but it does make a very good media server.
 
Alright, barring that, is it possible to run an unRaid server headless? As in, once I setup the initial storage pool through the unRaid interface and setup initially through a thumb drive, could I then boot into my actual OS disk for my server with Server 2008 and start running applications and such in the background with the unRaid array "seen" as a large logical storage volume, maintaining and monitoring the array through unRaid's browser interface?

If that's possible, I may very well be sold with unRaid for my future storage solution. :)
 
Update: I just posted a thread in the unRAID forums; if anyone's curious as to my storage dilemma and would like to pitch in here (or there), I'd greatly appreciate your opinions!
 
I use Windows 2003 with a Highpoint RAID controller doing RAID 5. Backup is two different external USB drives (upgrading to 2TB soon).

If all you need is storage, a NAS or WHS might work, but I use my server for other things too.
 
Thanks for the informative post; is it possible by any chance to run unRaid on Hyper-V in Windows Server 2008 to configure the system? Or is it possible to boot into the flash disk for unRaid only for the purposes of setting up the initial drives? Reason being is that I plan on using my server for more than just NAS file serving (light stuff, like a game server and HTPC as well), so I was wondering if I can have the program flexibility that I'm used to on my Server 2008 setup. :)

I'm researching this myself. The problem with unraid is that it HAS to have access to the usb stick that its licensed for or else it doesn't work. Plus, you need raw disk access. I don't want to use virtual disks for a large storage server, i want raw disk access so in case of a big cock-up i can rip the drives out and access them on any other box.

ESX 4 supports usb pass-through and raw disk, however the usb feature is broken which may be fixed in the mysterious Update 1. I was reading about win2k8r2 /hyper-v and it appears that it does suppport usb storage devices and raw disk assess.

As soon as I get some x64 hardware I'm going to get win2k8 up and do some testing.
 
What I recommend for you:

- WHS (with duplication turned on for the more important files) to store everything.
- External drive for backups of the really important data (like those home videos, pictures but not the gigs of music)
- Another external drive (to backup the backup external drive) to store it offsite (anywhere but your home like your GF's house :D or in-laws house or parent's house or neighbors or friend's etc.)
- An online service like Mozy, Carbonite, or AmazonS3. for the REALLY important info.

If you really want to be careful, store the external hard drive in a fire-proof safe.

+++++

redundant home-brew storage solution + 99.9% uptime guarantee by a paid service like Amazons3/JungleDisk .......is hard to beat.

I would trust Amazon/S3/JungleDisk over an offsite solution actually.
 
except how slow upload and downloads are for large files.... so this works for a small music library, small photo library and documents.... not really all that great if it takes 2 months to download all your backups....
 
Back
Top