best onboard sound?

polonyc2

Fully [H]
2FA
Joined
Oct 25, 2004
Messages
30,631
can anyone tell me which onboard sound solution is considered the very best...meaning as close in quality to a dedicated sound card...I have an Auzentech X-Fi Prelude PCI sound card and its getting harder and harder to find a motherboard which fits a dedicated sound card along with 2 video cards...most board layouts are terrible in this regard

I'm a heavy gamer but also enjoy listening to music/movies on my PC...is there a high end onboard sound solution?
 
speaking from the AMD side, the Asus Crosshair III is good, its got an X-FI(though not a true one as ive read) that give me great sound, and its PCIe slot is above the 1st slot for GFX
 
A couple of the MSI boards did. Not sure which ones off the top of my head. I just never had good luck with MSI, so I stopped buying their boards.
 
If you have a 5.1 and up receiver, I recommend going digital via optical out on the MB or Dolby Digital Live via 3rd party card, USB audio w/ digital out or HDMI on the GPU. The decoding is done on the receiver side and is superior to any thing you can do in your PC. Con is the need for a receiver and external speakers. Though you can get cheap or used sets for $200up. I'm using an old 1st gen Sony 5.1 receiver (5-6 years old) with Cervin Vega Satellites after I upgraded my main HT receiver.

I'm in the same boat as you after upgrading to a MSI x58 pro-e board. One of the 2 PCI slots was covered by a GPU. I kept my HDTV tuner and took out my Montego DDL card. I'm now using the onboard audio via optical out. Sadly that means only 2 channel sound unless when watching movies. For gaming (mainly FPS) I use a headset anyway.

I'm currently looking into PCIe HDTV tuners since there is a free slot to the right if the 1st PCIe x16 slot. On the sound card side I've heard these cards have DDL and one has DTS connect.

  • Xonar DX: fine map practically everything has what I want, reliable drivers without fummelei, unfortunately, no DTS Connect / NEO
  • Xonar D2X: everything, besides, what one needs, unfortunately, a little bit expensive
  • X Fi Titanium: also no DTS, apparently frequent driver Probs
  • X-Fi™ Forte 7.1 DTS connect
Did some googling and see that there are X58 motherboards with DTS connect. http://benchmarkreviews.com/index.p...sk=view&id=263&Itemid=69&limit=1&limitstart=8

Also found a USB DTS connect audio solution. This might be the way to go and skip the whole space issue completely. Only concerns would be if USB2 has enough bandwidth to handle audio data between PC and card and what the CPU utilization would be.

Sondigo AUZ-CALLISTO 5.1 Channels USB Interface Callisto Home Theatre adapter
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16829272001
 
Last edited:
The ASUS Xonar DX is pretty much so rock solid. The sound quality over on-board audio is night and day difference! Only issue is the need to disable advanced settings like DS3D 2.0 for Windows Media Center/Netflix. Other than that its bitchin!
 
Back
Top