Best defrag utility for Home Server?

MaxBurn

[H]ard|Gawd
2FA
Joined
Nov 14, 2004
Messages
1,134
Having some real performance issues lately, thinking it has to be fragmentation related. Demegrator does nothing on this score right?

I can't think of a real reason why I couldn't just defragement each drive individually, can I?

I know there are some paid apps available, are they any good?
 
I recommend mydefrag on all current windows versions. Its free and lets you organize your data the way you want it. Don't be worried about reliability considering this is a free produce. The reason not to worry is that all defrag programs use the same reliable Microsoft api to actually move the data.

www.mydefrag.com
 
That should work since WHS is W2k3 based. However I do not use WHS so I have not tested that. I do run mydefrag on Win2k3 server and workstation however.
 
Looking deeper it only lists drive D: "data" in my computer. I can't help but think it is a really bad idea to hit defrag on drive D: "data" on home server, especially when they tell you NOT to do things like that every time you log into the server.

Looking at the disk info for that spanned volume it lists 6TB and some garbage charachters in there, it plainly doesn't recognize that the volume is 16+TB and consists of 11 drives.

Back to my original question I know there are several defrag utilities for home server out there? Anyone try them?
 
If it's not a specific WHS defrag program you'll be shooting yourself in the head if you try it.

IIRC there's only two made for WHS, I've tried them both, and WHS has been such a major PITA that I couldn't tell you if they worked or not.

I'm just hopefull that a bare bones WHS will be reliable enough to count on when it actually matters.

Maybe someone else with a better WHS experience can provide more insight. :)
 
I am sorry I expected the Microsoft Defragmentation API to be the same for WHS as every other windows OS since 2000. I guess with its unique file system stuff it has to be different..
 
Last edited:
I second that. Although I don't use WHS myself, I recall that when it was released, MS officially advised against the use of the windows native defrag utility. Something to do with a shadow copy service - defrag conflict IIRC. So be careful, and use only a WHS compliant defrag utility (there are only 2 on the market anyway).

I too hope that WHS V2 turns out to be something easy and stable enough for the home user to manage. I was very excited when V1 first came out, but that soon turned to disappointment as the horror stories emerged. It put me off from building a WHS box then.

I would still like to build one, but not at the cost of time and sweat in getting it to run properly. Unlike years past, my inclination towards tweaking and fiddling with computers is slowly declining...I want/expect stuff to 'just work' with minimal setting up (as it should be, for home usage) :/
 
I too hope that WHS V2 turns out to be something easy and stable enough for the home user to manage.
V2 has a whole new file system.......
no longer are the drives NTFS formatted with the files spread among them, rather now they’re using a custom format that only WHS v2 can currently read.
.

That just fills me with confidence. :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top