Best choice for me now

inotocracy

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jul 25, 2004
Messages
5,625
Was wanting to hop on the i7 train but money is tight, but I still want a new chip to compliment my new 260. With my current board/memory what would be the best jump up? Been away from the CPU game for a while so I'm sure the [H] will be able to make more of an informed decision than myself currently. :cool:

Current:

Intel C2D E4500 @2.9ghz (11x265)
4GB DDR2 800 @880mhz
Gigabyte P35-DS3L

edit: my ideal budget would be between $100 and $150, but if its close to that I can probably do it.
 
Get a i7 920, whatever gigabyte board has the features you want (check out newegg), and 6gbs of whatever ddr3 ram you like/can afford (you'll need a 64-bit OS or you'll only be able to use ~3GBs of ram.)

I like Asus mobos, but you may feel more comfortable with a gigabyte since that's what you currently have. The p6t deluxe is nice though, having used it for about 6 months now, I really like it. Should be well under your budget (assuming you meant $1500 not $150...)
 
Whoops I misread your post, I thought you WANTED a core i7. sorry bout that.
 
The one CPU upgrade within that budget that would actually be worth it would be to go with a reasonably-priced quad-core like a Q8400 or Q9400 and then overclock it. That would give you the most increase in overall performance that you can expect without spending a lot more money. You should be able to find one of those chips for under $200. Anything less wouldn't be worth it in my opinion.
 
Thanks for the recommendation. Would a quad core be better than an e8400? Looks like a decent chip for the money, and not much out there right now really takes advantage of 4 cores (is there anything that actually does that I'd use, gaming wise?).
 
I believe SCom does. For gaming 8400 was way better than the 9400 I had.
 
If you ran your timings at 1:1 and overclocked with a median range 400fsb, here are the multipliers for these chips mentioned in your price range;

Core 2 Duo's -
E8400 @ 9x400 = 3.6ghz @ $167.99
E8500 @ 9.5x400 = 3.8ghz @ $189.99

Core 2 Quad's -
Q8200 @ 7x400 = 2.8ghz @ $167.99
Q8400 @ 8x400 = 3.2ghz @ $184.99

and just for reference if you were to really consider a quad this is currently the hottest deal on the core 2 quad platform.
Q9550 @ 8.5x400 = 3.4ghz @ $229.99 with a whomping 12mb cache.

The Duo's of course with the higher clock speeds are going to be better for games (for now) if that is your primary goal for this purchase. But if you also want all around system multitasking performance the Quad's are a great way to go. You can play a game and do other things in the background at the same time, like encode vids, burn music, all sorts of things. Either way it's an upgrade because you'll be doubling to tripling your cache and going to the smaller 45nm more efficient chip.

You might also want to consider these for a quick, effective, and inexpensive fix. And say if you even ran them at 350fsb. The only major difference between the E7's and the E8's besides the native fsb and multipliers, is the 7's have 3mb cache and the 8's have 6mb.

E7400 @ 10.5x350 = 3.6ghz @ $119.99
E7500 @ 11x350 = 3.8ghz @ $139.99
E7600 @ 11.5x350 = 4.0ghz @ $149.99
 
Last edited:
You the man rive22! I'll digest all this and let you guys know what I decide. I'm leaning more towards the E8400 right now since I don't see a use for the quads just yet (IMO).
 
hahaha no problem man! yeah definitely bro that E8400 is a pretty sweet little chip with lots of potential, ya can't go wrong. :)
 
Id say get an E7400 if you have a Microcenter around you, since they are only $100 there. Q9400 is a decent option at $160 at MC as well.

An E8400/E8500 would be fastest obviously, just not sure its worth the money.

Duals are faster in gaming, but there is less overall core load with quad cores, and therefor, less heat. Ive had a Q9450 and E8400 at one point, and compaired them both. Q9450 tied the E8400 in Crysis at 3.4 with the E8400 at 4.2, and ran a couple degrees cooler because the stress was spread over all four cores.


Im thinking for a budget chip, E7x00 would be best. Or sell what you have, get an open box x58 for ~$150, a 920 from MC for $230, and 3gb of OCZ 1333 Platinums. I did that and spent $400 even, got 4.2Ghz HT air cooled, ram was able to run at 1700Mhz, and was happy till I got board with it lol.
 
$400 is a bit more than $160 ;) With the E8400 I think I'd be able to keep the chip a bit longer than an E7X00 and I don't really plan on overclocking too much, at least not for a while, so heat shouldn't be a major concern. I'd think a quad would kick out more heat than a dual, no? More squished on the same chip would require more power and more heat..
 
Get a quad core, a stock intel e8400 @ 3.0ghz will be a good improvement over your E4XXX @ 2.9ghz, but it's not big enough to justify spending 150+ for a small upgrade.

Q9550 would last you for a while. Stock speeds would be fast and then later down the line you should be easily able to oc the cpu to 3.6ghz+ and have it last a while.
 
$400 is a bit more than $160 ;) With the E8400 I think I'd be able to keep the chip a bit longer than an E7X00 and I don't really plan on overclocking too much, at least not for a while, so heat shouldn't be a major concern. I'd think a quad would kick out more heat than a dual, no? More squished on the same chip would require more power and more heat..

After you sell your stuff, your should be over $300 though, making it very worth considering ;)

The heat depends on the load. At idle the difference is minimal. At semi load (playing a game), there is less load on the quad. Crysis would be around 40% on 3 cores, 25% on the fourth, averaging 36% load. On the E8400 it was 80% for both cores, which is more then double the load, making up for half the cores.
 
Well if it was me and I was going with a dual it would be purely for the reason of trying to get the highest oc out of it. I would want to run that thing stable in the 4.0-.4.5ghz range (on air) ;). That would be a screaming beast for your games. :D Otherwise if you don't plan to oc much, you can have pretty much the same clock speed with a Q8400 only costing $17-20 bucks more. Figure a pizza and a couple liters of pop and you got yourself a nice little multitasking machine. You won't notice that much of a difference from 4mb-6mb cache unless you are doing heavy crunching tasks but then in that case the quad would make up for the slack.

But all talk aside the one that is itching at you the most is usually the one you are meant to get. :cool:
 
Last edited:
Great advice guys, love the [H]. I'll continue to mull this over. I got a week until I get paid so that should be plenty of time to debate between the two. Thanks again!
 
Sorry to jump in, but is it worth it for me to continue upgrading what I currently have?

Im thinking about buying the Q9550, and 2x2gb gskill pc8500

Would it be worth investing that $350 to what i currently have? Thanks
 
If it were my money, I'd look for a E6850 for $80-$85. Ebay your E4500, and recoup most of your $$. you could hit 3.6ghz, and double you cache for less than $40 (approx)
 
If you are considering a quadcore and have $350, imo your best bet would be to part your system and go i7. I don't see the powersupply that you have, ask for specific reccomendations in the PS forums.
 
Yeah it depends on what you use your system for. If you multitask then it's worth the upgrade without a doubt. If you plan to audio/video encode then another $150 will get you the I7 system.

I7 chip at microcenter for $229
MSI mATX mobo for $169
6 Gigs OCZ Platinum DDR3 RAM $99

And you're good to go and yes like said depending on your power supply.

But ask yourself, do you feel your system bottlenecking? And in what tasks? You might find with your setup you'd be happier getting DUAL SSD Raid 0 for your boot/os drive.
 
Well when you think about it. If you sold your mobo and chip for the difference it would cost you the same 350 or so out of your pocket and you could get the I7 instead. A short time ago it would have been a little different but prices have come down on all 3 of the major components.
 
+1 for C2D's for gaming....+1 i7 for benching.
E8500 does 4.2 on air in its sleep and looses no ground
to quads unless you have more of a workload than games.
 
the thing is Romdominance. The Q9550 is selling for $250 and the E 8500 is $262 (ncix)

This is the dilemma really. I mean yes I have 3.8ghz on my E6850 and Its great. But just notice with all backround applications running and all that. It gets a bit slow at times.

Either choice would be good but I mean for roughly the same price (cheaper) I can get twice the cache.

Thanks for the imput so far people. highly appreciated.
 
the thing is Romdominance. The Q9550 is selling for $250 and the E 8500 is $262 (ncix)

This is the dilemma really. I mean yes I have 3.8ghz on my E6850 and Its great. But just notice with all backround applications running and all that. It gets a bit slow at times.

Either choice would be good but I mean for roughly the same price (cheaper) I can get twice the cache.

Thanks for the imput so far people. highly appreciated.
Do you overclock? If so, get the Q9550. The additional overclocking headroom that you might get from the E8500 won't give you a particularly significant amount of performance over a Q9550 overclocked to 4GHz or so, which is doable with an E0 chip (all Q9550s currently sold are E0 chips). Considering the quad is cheaper as well, I don't see any advantage to going with the dual-core.
 
But just notice with all backround applications running and all that. It gets a bit slow at times.

These are the magic words I was waiting for. The people that will benefit from a quad+ usually know that's what they need before hand. Where as others like the OP seem to be doing just fine with the likes of a C2D.

As noted though you could toss that baby in for $229, grab 2 more gigs of ram and you'll be solid. You'll have cash left over. :) With what you said I wouldn't even consider another dual especially considering the prices.
 
Last edited:
the thing is Romdominance. The Q9550 is selling for $250 and the E 8500 is $262 (ncix)

This is the dilemma really. I mean yes I have 3.8ghz on my E6850 and Its great. But just notice with all backround applications running and all that. It gets a bit slow at times.

Either choice would be good but I mean for roughly the same price (cheaper) I can get twice the cache.

Thanks for the imput so far people. highly appreciated.

Looks like you need to learn to shop around then. The E8600 is that price, the E8500 $80-$100 less.
 
can you please link ? and (ncix.ca) Since I am in Canada.

I never use NCIX, and did not see you were in Canada. Sorry about that.
However, Im sure you can find a used E8x00 for $100 or so. I know Ive sold 3 E8400s in the last year for $115 or less each in the states.

Maybe you can have someone buy one, and ship it to you as a gift so you dont have to pay custom's fees?
 
How are we cooling this? If its on air, there is no way that a quad is goin to stay cooler than a c2d. Your probably talking 400-600MHz difference in oc at similar heat level. In most apps, thats a 15% gain in processor speed, and if its a cpu bottleneck to the gpus, that can be huge.
 
Your probably talking 400-600MHz difference in oc at similar heat level. In most apps, thats a 15% gain in processor speed, and if its a cpu bottleneck to the gpus, that can be huge.
He's running an 8800 Ultra. A Q9550 at 4GHz will not bottleneck his GPU.
 
How are we cooling this? If its on air, there is no way that a quad is goin to stay cooler than a c2d. Your probably talking 400-600MHz difference in oc at similar heat level. In most apps, thats a 15% gain in processor speed, and if its a cpu bottleneck to the gpus, that can be huge.

As stated in my Tag, Water cooled.

both cpu and gpu are in the loop.


so far a lot of people are "for" the Q9550; thanks for your responses everyone .
 
These are the magic words I was waiting for. The people that will benefit from a quad+ usually know that's what they need before hand. Where as others like the OP seem to be doing just fine with the likes of a C2D.

As noted though you could toss that baby in for $229, grab 2 more gigs of ram and you'll be solid. You'll have cash left over. :) With what you said I wouldn't even consider another dual especially considering the prices.

and yes i was going to also get 2x2gb pc8500 to go along with the cpu upgrade. Or should i get 2x2 and 2x2 giving me 8gb of ram? I have money so dont worry about that being the issue. just wanting it to be beneficial :)

just wanting to make sure the Q9550 was the way to go :)
 
Last edited:
Well I would tell the op that I went from a QX9650 at 4-4.2GHz to an e8600 at 4.5-4.7GHz and would never switch back. It was on a 790i ultra all wc'd and 3xgtx280hc's. Before goin i7, the c2d was the fastest setup out there for benchin/gaming, period.
 
The q9x50 is no slouch, even when compared to the i7. It has plenty of power even to satisfy a hardcore enthusiast. Anyways, my machine is mostly for gaming and I run an e8500 at 4.2 and it is fantastic paired with my 4870x2. If I were going to upgrade soon though, I'd much rather get a q9550 or 9650 and overclock than get an i7. I'll make the switch when I actually need it...and thats the thing, how many people on this board actually NEED an i7? If you heavily multitask and do other shit that's really CPU intensive and you're coming up from a pentium 4 or athlon x2 939 then it's a no brainer, and perhaps you can justify it, but most people here can't, no offense. I believe it's all hype mostly. I can game with my system next to someone who has an i7 at 4ghz and with the same graphisc card and guess what? ...the experience will be the same. I DARE you to see the difference.

OP, if gaming is your thing, get an e8400 or e8500, and overclock the shit out of it. Since money is an issue, that is your safest and quickest bet. If you're willing to be computerless for a while and shop around to keep costs at a minimum, get an i7. Personally, I wouldn't.
 
Q6600 is good. very powerful and popular. good reviews. not expensive at all
 
Back
Top