Benchmark Performance SSD Testing: AHCI vs IDE

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ryan and the gang at PC Perspective put together a rather informative SSD performance article today that could help enthusiasts avoid making a mistake when tweaking SSD drive settings.

"The overclocking crowd goes nuts to squeeze every possible bit of performance out of their hardware. Those reading the Benchmark Reviews article are likely to waste countless hours going for those few percentage points in single-threaded benchmarks, only to find their *real* (multi-threaded) performance has suffered significantly. I urge those system tweakers out there to do some additional research before dropping your personal systems back down to IDE mode."
 
I guess this should put an end to the debate of whether to go AHCI or IDE for an SSD.
 
AHCI does seem like a no-brainer for SSDs, although I wonder how much queuing is really going on on my non-server (non-SSD) box, here.

Note that the editorial gives props to anandtech, legitreviews, and hardocp for their storage reviews.
 
Meh, I can't use AHCI unless I use an older JMicron controller on this MB, so I'm using IDE.

Who was the moron he was so pointedly saying their review sucked?
 
Who was the moron he was so pointedly saying their review sucked?
It was linked on the first line of the article: Benchmark Reviews. Note that they have redone the tests using new tools that show AHCI is superior in most cases.

And here is another website refuting the validity of their claims: http://www.pcper.com/article.php?aid=901 So we just need a website that does more than run one ill-suited benchmark to do this comparison and see what's what.
??? That's the original editorial from Steve. They have added a note about Benchmark Reviews' updated tests.

If there's one thing we've learned from all of this, it's that HDTune sucks.
 
lol, ok I guess I was confused about what we were talking about. Anyway it seems that 'SSD is better on IDE' is not really true.
 
lol, ok I guess I was confused about what we were talking about. Anyway it seems that 'SSD is better on IDE' is not really true.
Yeah, the Benchmark Reviews writer tries to save face by using the analogy of a cargo ship (speed vs. cargo capacity) but it doesn't really fly.
 
Yeah, it's not as if any other hardware review site has ever made any dumb technical errors in their articles...
 
Yeah, it's not as if any other hardware review site has ever made any dumb technical errors in their articles...
This was a bit beyond forgetting to carry the 1. The whole article was a technical error. Wrong benchmarking tool, wrong conclusions, wrong recommendations. From a site thats all about benchmarking.
 
I never said it wasn't.

But as someone who's written hundreds of reviews and articles over the years, including some for BmR, I can tell you that no matter how technically astute you may be (I've been a professional programmer since 1986), if you write a lot, some day you're going to make a really dumb technical error. You might even write an entire article based on a bad premise. I've done it, and I imagine most of the current big names have as well.

And when you do, you can be assured that there will be people ready to fall on you like rabid wolverines. Allyn Malventano's original article wasn't just a technical rebuttal; it was a rather nasty attack, although I see that some of the more egregious passages have since been edited or removed.

Savaging someone online is easy and fun, if you've the kind of personality that delights in that.
 
Back
Top