Athlon II X4 Take 2

Zachstar

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Sep 27, 2005
Messages
1,407
Ok obviously the 620 was rather silly unless you had the means and the will to unlock its L3. AMD finally admitted to using deneb cores initially http://www.fudzilla.com/content/view/15514/1/ which really did not help them in my view as it gave it poor performance for the power draw.

On the 16th the 640 will be let loose. This in my opinion looks to be a true Propus core because at the same 95W TDP It manages to get 3.0 Ghz rather than the yucky 2.6 Ghz the one with the deneb core had.

The official brand is Athlon II X4 640 and this baby will run at 3.0GHz and will only have 4x512KB L2 cache, and no L3. There is still a chance that some of these CPUs will actually be Denebs and that some hack might let you enable the hidden L3 cache. We will look into this one.

I highly doubt this will be deneb based. They were VERY quick to pull down the 620 after people flocked to buy it to unlock the L3. I doubt they will make that mistake again.


So the question is price? Your thoughts? My guess is the same 125 USD. As they want to keep the sub 100 USD for the 65W and 45W versions.
 
I am really interested to see further reviews on this chip. Well any of the X4 Athlon II's. I have seen a couple different ones. In overclocking it seems that people are finding these chips to oc on air a lot better than the Phenom II's and they think that the L3 cache may hurt oc ability and without it the X4 Athlon II cpu's oc better. http://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/2922/amd_athlon_ii_x4_620_processor_review_quad_core_for_mainstream/index.html

That is a 620 review.

People the 620 is a deneb with a switch thrown just to turn off the L3 the L3 is still there and can be unlocked that is why they rushed to pull it off newegg once the unlockers flocked to it.

The 630 and 640 being likely true propus cores will be FAR better with no L3 hogging power.
 
More info is out people and MAN is this confusing!

http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=3638

What is the 620 doing back? Are you honestly telling me AMD that you are going to have 2 different versions of the same model? People are going to seriously wonder what in the world is going on when one review has different results from the other if this "new" 620 at 99USD is a true Propus.

Today we get two models: the Athlon II X4 630 and the Athlon II X4 620, priced at $122 and $99 respectively. The only difference between the two is clock speed; the 630 runs at 2.8GHz while the 620 runs at 2.6GHz. These are both AM3 chips meaning they'll work in AM3 motherboards with DDR3 memory or AM2+ boards with DDR2 memory.
 
Easy: AMD is reusing the product name and phasing in the newer, better Propus version.

Also, that is the review I read (didn't even release, mostly cause I didn't care, that AMD already released a 620). That is the 620 I'm interest in getting.
 
Sounds reckless to me. Likely to cause boatloads of confusion. All the reviews so far talk of the Deneb based 620. Unlockers will flock to the 620 again after reading the reviews talking about L3 unlocking and chaos will result.
 
What is the 620 doing back? Are you honestly telling me AMD that you are going to have 2 different versions of the same model?

it's been done before, on s754 there were two different 3400+ models (2.2 + 1mb l2, 2.4 + 512k l2), both had different dies (clawhammer/newcastle), the newcastle 3000+ on s754 was replaced by a venice 3000+ (130/90nm), on s939 the same things happened.. (hell, on socket A there were model numbers used for both barton and thouroughbred, then even FSB speeds were different)

in that light these two versions are very similar, if the cpu is taken as a black box, without unlocking tricks, the only tip off would be the power usage
 
But the "unlocking tricks" made the 620 an overnight stampede once word got out it could be unlocked Newegg could not take it down fast enough.

The lack of unlocking is going to make some people angry. Chaos will result. Maybe not on Hardforum where I have been badmouthing the 620 for days but on other forums where topics don't linger as long.

Yes AMD ought to be congratulated on being the first 99USD quad yet to be honest I am more interested in the 65W and 45W versions and how they can handle such as TF2 and Star Wars The Old Republic.
 
Like Freezed said, AMD has done this before. It's not a big deal.

While I wish it was a 65w part, most of the time it's probably going to be right around that mark until you really stress all four cores.
 
Like Freezed said, AMD has done this before. It's not a big deal.

While I wish it was a 65w part, most of the time it's probably going to be right around that mark until you really stress all four cores.

I can easily stress all 3 of my cores and I have L3. When planning cooling it tends to be better if you plan for the peak. Only exception being HTPC where you can test and find out what works best for what video software or whatnot. Just about any modern game will want to peg your cores even if its not that graphically insane.

Nothing on the C3 topic about a 65W yet but then again 45Ws are already selling across the pond. I would not be surprised to see a 90s USD range 2.5-2.6 65watter within a week.
 
mAJORD on XS delidded a Propus and found the new die underneath:
http://www.xtremesystems.org/Forums/showthread.php?t=234305

Compare that to the larger 940 die:
http://www.xtremesystems.org/Forums/showthread.php?t=234325

The only 800 series chip available so far is the 810 and that is selling at a tiny fraction of the rate the 900/700/500 series is if you can trust the Newegg review rate - 117 vs 3323 (total). I take that and the fact that 810's can also unlock the full 6MB L3 with ACC enabled that either almost no Deneb cores have a bad L3, almost all Deneb cores with a bad L3 are also defective in other ways and thus recycled without laving the fab plant, or some combination of the above.
 
in that light these two versions are very similar, if the cpu is taken as a black box, without unlocking tricks, the only tip off would be the power usage

Yeah, to the vast majority of AMD's customers... OEMs and 99% of those who buy boxed CPUs, it doesn't matter whether it's a castrated Deneb core or a Propus. They will just install the CPU, put on the stock heatsink and be done with it. No unlocking, no overclocking.

If they really care about power draw, most online stores list the TDP right next to the other data like clock speed and L2 cache size. There are already both 95W and 125W versions of some CPUs with identical clock speeds and model numbers, so this is nothing new. It will be the same with the Athlon II X4's - some will be 95W, others 65W. People will think of the new CPU in terms of the wattage, not as the "Deneb" or "Propus". Those are just codenames that are used by engineers and geeks.
 
Well looks like it is the new Propus after all. Smart move as you don't want to sell to just unlockers trying to find a cheap CPU to Unlock to a Phenom II

Reviews arent half bad for the 620 either. And so far no riots have appeared :p

Now if they can just hurry up and get the 640 out and a 65W version.
 
cool this might end up going into a system for a relative, as they have a m-atx board that recommends nothing more than 95w, would be a great addition especially if they come stock clocks or 2.8 to 3.0.
 
Really thinking of putting the 620 in my file server/vm box. Though I'm not sure because I want this to be as power efficient as I can make it.

620 / 780G
or
X3 705e / 780G

or wait for the 600e? These AMD chips easy to underclock to maybe save some power?
 
Really thinking of putting the 620 in my file server/vm box. Though I'm not sure because I want this to be as power efficient as I can make it.

620 / 780G
or
X3 705e / 780G

or wait for the 600e? These AMD chips easy to underclock to maybe save some power?

underclocking is easy, just drop the multiplier (for instance, if you want to target the comming 45w tdp chips, drop the multi to 11x), and then gradually lower the Vcore untill it crashes your stress tests, and then back it up one notch.

Also keep in mind, all amd chips have cool and quiet, under low stress any phenom II will drop down to 800 mhz and ~0.8v
 
620 is not as power efficient as the 630

I would wait for a good Athlon X3 in the 65W range to come out. Tho 65W quad are soon to arrive as well.
 
Simple. 630 is a higher quality part thus can be clocked faster before failing at the same vcore

i'm thinking that the 620 in the anandtech might have been a deneb die, which would sip some extra juice as well.. off course the small Vcore fluctuations per chip will have a significant impact as well
 
i'm thinking that the 620 in the anandtech might have been a deneb die, which would sip some extra juice as well.. off course the small Vcore fluctuations per chip will have a significant impact as well

The "Old" 620 was a harvested deneb. The new one they got was propus and is the real deal. Its just the weaker of the two.

Alot more will be made known when they get more models out.
 
exactly what difference does it make if it it's the real deal, or a l3 disabled denab? I don't understand why you're complaining, buy it, unlock it, and have a $99 Phenom 2 920
 
45 Watts WOW, so now the inefficiency of a 600w PSU becomes the biggest energy hog in the system. My Phenom II dual-core 550BE with AM3 mobo idles using 52 Watts at the wall, the Athlon does even better?
 
exactly what difference does it make if it it's the real deal, or a l3 disabled denab? I don't understand why you're complaining, buy it, unlock it, and have a $99 Phenom 2 920

I sure hope a bunch of unlockers try that and are unable to return it due to neweggs new CPU return policies.
 
They have been at Newegg since last night or yesterday afternoon. Ordered the 620 at like 3 in the moning.
 
I want to see how well the 640 gets to 4Ghz :)

People are saying that the lack of L3 is helping overclocking by no small amount so you may be in luck. However at 45nm the heat produced will be very much real.
 
Back
Top