Atari Sues Over Video Game Review

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Atari has filed a lawsuit against a website over a review of Alone in the Dark. While the review was negative, Atari claims they are not suing because of that, they are suing because the reviewer allegedly used a pirated version of the game for the review. Hit the link for the full scoop.

Atari has filed suit against German gaming website 4Players for publishing a negative pre-release review of Alone in the Dark, alleging that it was written based on an illegally obtained copy of the game.
 
Atari is probably going under since they were sort of using this game as a brand "reboot". It's not doing so hot as far as the reviews go, which is a shame.

Bye bye Atari.
 
Atari is probably going under since they were sort of using this game as a brand "reboot". It's not doing so hot as far as the reviews go, which is a shame.

Bye bye Atari.

Yeah I think they just need to lay the Atari brand name to rest. The original company forever changed video gaming and the post meltdown company made some great arcade games (Motha Fuckin Race Drivin' anyone?) :) After that the company really ceased to exist and was just a brand name. Sad.
 
You know the only reason why they are doing this is because the review was bad, if they didn't make such crappy games, they probably would not have minded.

E.T. comes to mind
 
Yeah I think they just need to lay the Atari brand name to rest. The original company forever changed video gaming and the post meltdown company made some great arcade games (Motha Fuckin Race Drivin' anyone?) :) After that the company really ceased to exist and was just a brand name. Sad.

I still have Race Drivin' on my original Gameboy. Grey scale FTW!
 
If they really did review the game on a pirated copy, then I think they should be sued.
 
I read somewhere that the suit was because they wrote the review on leaked code, and thus it would also be an earlier build of the game not entirely representative of the final release.
 
Nothing like suing the people who write bad reviews to make people listen to the bad reviews. Dumbasses.
 
From the article said:
Update: Gamer.nl staffer Erwin Bergervoet has informed Shacknews that Atari also asked the Dutch gaming site to pull its 5/10 review of Alone in the Dark posted Thursday, a day before the game's official European street date.

"Within an hour [after posting], Atari called to have the review pulled off, claiming there was an embargo till Friday," Bergervoet said in a comment to Shacknews. "Our review copy was sent directly to us by Atari and [was] not a pirated copy. They explicitly told [Gamer.nl] that they only let high scoring reviews break the post-release embargo date."

If this is true, Atari won't be much of a name any longer, one way or the other.
 
You know the only reason why they are doing this is because the review was bad, if they didn't make such crappy games, they probably would not have minded.

E.T. comes to mind

etcartridge.jpg
 
Its not because the review was bad, its because the game isn't out yet and the review was based off of a pirated copy. They should sue them.
 
Its not because the review was bad, its because the game isn't out yet and the review was based off of a pirated copy. They should sue them.

Would you per chance be interested in investing in a business venture selling battery operated igloo defrosters to Eskimos?
 
Thats great. Either way this is a lose, lose situtation for Atari. One on hand either the company is telling the truth and were given the game by Atari then told that only positive reviews were allowed before the release of the game. Which would show that they knew the game was a piece of shit and tried to trick people into buying it by having it only have positive reviews. On the other, they are lieing and did steal the game and even with the game being free they thought it was a piece of shit meaning that Atari has a crappy game on their hands.

If the first one happens to be true, then the company could turn around and sue them for slander by claiming that they are doing reviews with prirated games. Thus hurting Atari even more.
 
Its not because the review was bad, its because the game isn't out yet and the review was based off of a pirated copy. They should sue them.

Huh? How are pirates supposed to know how good a pirated copy is if the review isn't done off of the pirated copy???

I mean, if a review is done off of version 1.2, and the pirated copy is 0.92Alpha, the review might not mention missing textures, poor framerates, poor optimization, and glaring instability.

Dunno, after five BSODs, I might just give up... Never realizing this crappy performance was normal for the version I pirated...

Isn't finding the most current cracked copy part of the game anyway?


then again, maybe they should sue... Considering how bad the retail release of Crysis was, can you image how God awful a 0.92Alpha may have been?
 
there was a review site not long ago that almost entirely used pirated copies to review.. can't remember the name of the site but it was shut down a long time ago, and had pretty close ties to the "scene"

if the review site in question is using pirated copies it should also be shut down, which i think its pretty bad journalism to imply they are sueing because of a bad review.. they are sueing because of a pirated copy (they didn't think Atari wouldn't know who they've given review copies too?)..

the title should read..

Atari sues over review of pirated game..
 
You know the only reason why they are doing this is because the review was bad, if they didn't make such crappy games, they probably would not have minded.

E.T. comes to mind

Wrong Atari there guy :D

This is from buying the company Atari, then renaming their company from infogrames (which ironically came right after that train wreck of a game Masters of Orion 3), which was originally Hasbro Interactive/Microprose/etc.

Anyways, re-read the story, there's an update, now the claim is there is no pirated copy, it was a legit copy sent directly by Atari, but they're being pissy because they had a rule that only high scores could be published before the release date.
 
Update: Gamer.nl staffer Erwin Bergervoet has informed Shacknews that Atari also asked the Dutch gaming site to pull its 5/10 review of Alone in the Dark posted Thursday, a day before the game's official European street date.

"Within an hour [after posting], Atari called to have the review pulled off, claiming there was an embargo till Friday," Bergervoet said in a comment to Shacknews. "Our review copy was sent directly to us by Atari and [was] not a pirated copy. They explicitly told [Gamer.nl] that they only let high scoring reviews break the post-release embargo date."
Another case of "oh no piracy is destroying our company/sales/pink fuzzy unicorn dreams"
 
It's common practice to let review sites who give favorable reviews the go before release. Hello IGN and gamespot. If they pirated the game, shame on them. Right now there's no proof either way.

The question remains though, has a review site ever used a pirated copy of a game before and gave good reviews and then was sued for it? I bet if they gave this crummy game (be honest, we all knew it was going to be crummy) a good score they would have looked the other way. Justify pirating the game? No. But a double standard that I'm sure exists.
 
I was going to purchase this game on launch day sight unseen. NOW, I am going to download the "unoffical demo" to see if it is bad 1st. If they screwed up this game ..... Arrrggghhh. I have been looking forward to a new Alone for a long time. Man I loved the 1st one in. HArd to believe that was back in 1992.. Wow... Ya know what sucks ? in 92 I was legal drinking age so now I am old... Waaaaaaaaaaaaa...
 
Wasn't Witcher also published by Atari in western countries ?

Anyway from what was in other news apparently only those with below 7/10 score are using "pirated" versions :D

And those sites which haven't received games from Atari claim to get them from shops.
 
BaH! No matter which way you cut this stinky turd its still a turd.
 
the title should read..

Atari sues over review of pirated game..
Only if you believe Atari, who has no evidence, and think that everyone else is lying. A couple of the sites say they got the game from Atari, another one said they got the game when a store released it early.

I'm going to believe the review sites, at least until there is some evidence to the contrary.
 
They could not have done it on a pirated copy as the game hasnt been cracked yet..
 
Back
Top