AT&T Deflecting Defectors

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
AT&T is running a bit scared these days, fearing the worst about their customers. The fact is, Verizon is in a very good position to tempt AT&T’s customers away from them. So what does a company do in this situation? The answer to that is simple: you bribe them with shiny electronic devices. :D

There are few catches that come along with the deal, though. For one, customers who choose to accept the $200 device must stay on board with AT&T for another 12 months.
 
I guess offering competitive plans/services are out of the question.
 
I have a prepaid ATT phone, I wonder if I can get in on this deal... pay $100 for another year of service and get a $200 device to ebay... sounds like a great deal to me ;) :D
 
You know an industry has you by the short and curlies when companies give you lots of incentive to join them, but no loyalty rewards for staying with them.

Things seem to be swinging back toward real competition, which is nice.
 
My G2 connects directly to wi-fi access points without additional equipment, why is AT&T spending money on these devices when software can do the same job?
 
My G2 connects directly to wi-fi access points without additional equipment, why is AT&T spending money on these devices when software can do the same job?
Hmm. Explain to customer the software options OR give away some bling and score a 12-month contract extension. I'm thinking the latter is the more lucrative way to ensure customer retention.
 
Goes to show how over priced AT&T is, why not just reduce the price of their package by $17.00. for the next 12 months. or the toy in question is also overpriced.
 
Still waiting for 3G from AT&T here, also still have over a year of contract left before being able to switch. Mainly stayed with AT&T the last few years because of the rollover minutes. Finally got 3G in a neighboring town in late December but still a few miles away. Had some AT&T workers running around a couple of weeks checking the line conditions for Uverse service, but no idea of a timeline on the availability of that either.
 
so they get you to renew the contract for a year or more in order to have your device connect via 3G to this device which connects to your broadband...as opposed to your phone connecting to your broadband for free with no contract extension or equipment.....LOL :confused:
 
There's plenty of other ways to take advantage of the Verizon iphone thing. People have been getting secret unlimited data plans out of AT&T, or just getting huge discounts in general on their bills.

My mom came by tonight and was telling me that a phone rep she talked to earlier today gave her nearly $100 of her most recent bill.

If you're not in contract with AT&T right now, you can demand all kinds of crazy stuff and get most of what you want.
 
ATT is prematurely overreacting.

some will switch, but most won't.

ATT is a bitch. They will never lower the price on anything.

I have ATT dsl and phone service, and they hiked the price on both recently.
 
I don't know if AT&T has a big advertising budget or if they are just really trying hard to get more customers but they are the ONLY carrier that advertises repeatedly on all of the radio stations I listen to. I wish they would give it up.
 
For a company that's supposed to be all that worried about defections to Verizon, you'd think maybe they wouldn't price Atrix the laptop dock for the cost of a full laptop when all it is is a keyboard, screen and battery.

They had the golden goose in the Atrix...but decided that rather than reap the golden eggs, they'd hit it in the head with a shovel so they could take the down for a pillow. That single phone could potentially have made up for a good many of the defections with people coming the other way from other carriers.

But not now.
 
If Verizon would offer an unlimited plan similar to sprints for $69.99/month on the iPhone I would jump ship.
 
If Verizon would offer an unlimited plan similar to sprints for $69.99/month on the iPhone I would jump ship.

Verizon offers it for appropriately more than Sprint when you take into account the service quality.......to put it another way, if you could get the same coverage from Sprint that you get from Verizon then Sprint should charge more. Which do you want, the cheapest or the best service? Cant have both. Making the network as large and reliable as VZW has costs big bucks. Sprint has not invested in their network nearly as much and it is reflected in their pricing and shows in everyday use.
 
For a company that's supposed to be all that worried about defections to Verizon, you'd think maybe they wouldn't price Atrix the laptop dock for the cost of a full laptop when all it is is a keyboard, screen and battery.
They had the golden goose in the Atrix...but decided that rather than reap the golden eggs, they'd hit it in the head with a shovel so they could take the down for a pillow. That single phone could potentially have made up for a good many of the defections with people coming the other way from other carriers.
But not now.

I dissagree, there was a similar device a while back (I want to say the red-something or something-red) that was also just a screen/KB "dock" for WM devices and it bellied up, of course with modern hardware a lot of the percieved shortcommings (it didnt multitask well because of the phone's hardware, interface was laggy because of the hardware, etc) there might be more interest, but since netbooks can be had for $100 or less...

If Verizon would offer an unlimited plan similar to sprints for $69.99/month on the iPhone I would jump ship.

If it were the same "contract" that Sprint has it's not worth it, "unlimited" means 4gb/month and 300mb of data-roaming, Minutes are soft-capped at 2000 per account iirc as well. Not to mention extra charges for 4G ($10/month) and most Android Phones (another $10/month)... I'm on the old "SERO" plan and I'm paying the same thing now thanks to these and other "Additional charges" --- dont think iPhone wouldn't also have these same hidden costs

Also keep in mind verizon is officially the most expensive carrier in the USA, beating out even AT&T! dont hold your breath waiting for a price-drop...
 
You know an industry has you by the short and curlies when companies give you lots of incentive to join them, but no loyalty rewards for staying with them.

Things seem to be swinging back toward real competition, which is nice.

Except that too many "competing" plans still end up with money going to the same company. Case in point... Virgin Mobile, Boost, Cricket and Sprint.

While Cricket also uses MetroPCS towers, in my area, there's no service with MetroPCS, so you're using nothing but Sprint towers here.

I'm on Sprint now. My contract is up in about a month. I will not be renewing.

Virgin Mobile PAYG has the best deal right now. $40/mo, taxes and fees included, 1200 monthly minutes, unlimited data and text. (This is workable for me as I peaked at 790 minutes in one month, including nights and weekends and is the foundation of my math later on)

My plan with Sprint right now is $51/mo, 400 minutes with nights and weekends, 300 text messages and no data. To add data to this would cost me about another $30/mo.

Boost also beats Sprint. $50/mo, unlimited everything. After 6 months of on time payments, it drops by $5 to go as low as $35/mo for service after 18 months.

Sprint's "Everything Data" is more expensive than both of these plans. $70 a month with limited minutes and the taxes/fees are not inclusive.

I called Sprint up and spoke with cancellation. I couldn't even get them to take my existing plan, sans data, and adjust the price with contract to be $40/mo. I gave up on trying to haggle and asked the woman outright, "Are you going to give me anything better than what a new customer would get if I were to renew my contract?" She said "No." I laid out my argument...

I've been with Sprint for 6 years.

Virgin and Boost are both entirely serviced by and/or owned by Sprint.

For the same phone, the Samsung Intercept... you pay $40/mo over 2 years: $960 on Virgin, $1920 over 2 years on Sprint. Right now the Intercept is free at Sprint with 2 year contract, so $1920 over two years. Right now the Intercept is $200 up front with no contract on Virgin, so $1160 over 2 years.

Exactly what benefit am I getting with signing a contract in this case? Completely eliminate the up front phone cost and go by plans only... there is no phone worth paying an extra $960 for just to use... and the phones that you can only get on Sprint (aside from the Intercept) all have up front costs WITH a contract. So, basically, you pay $1000 for the phone for the same amount of service, regardless.

Virgin does have an unlimited minutes plan. $60/mo flat. Sprint's equivalent? $99.99/mo plus taxes and fees. So the math looks even worse if you stick to truly unlimited plans. (Reminder: Boost unlimited, wholly owned by Sprint, is $50/mo flat and drops to $35/mo after 18 months.)

I pointed all this out to the cancellation rep as well and asked her why she couldn't give me a better deal. I actually stunned her into silence before she admitted that "maybe renewing your contract isn't right for you."

I ended up buying the Samsung Intercept on Virgin when it was on sale. It's actually a damn nice phone. Android really leveled out the playing field for when it comes to "midrange" to "high end" in features. Some people want a larger, higher resolution screen. I want a phone I can keep in my pocket when I sit down. ;)

It's all so very strange to me right now. What passes for competition in this case, though, is still money in Sprint's pocket. What I don't understand is how they can't compete with THEMSELVES for the same service. The only difference is what phones you can get for the tradeoff of paying more and having a contract. Hardly seems like a deal anymore.
 
Addendum: My above argument/math doesn't even include the mandatory $10 add-on if you contract a 4G enabled phone.
 
And that's why I like Japanese mobile companies. The longer you stay with them, the lower your bills become. Not to mention, you collect points that you can use to purchase a new phone.

Credit cards give you cash back. Airlines give you miles. Mobile companies just take crap away.
 
Addendum: My above argument/math doesn't even include the mandatory $10 add-on if you contract a 4G enabled phone.

I'm suprised they didnt tell you about the $10 additional charge for having an android phone (or maybe they're just sticking it to us SERO users, since it brings us within sight of their 69.99 unlimited everything plan) and no I did NOT say $10 for "premium data" (4G --- which I wouldnt mind paying IF IT WERE AVALIBLE! I have to drive 2 hours[/b] to get 4G), it comes to $20 additional charges (I'll see if I can find the exact name of the charge on my bill later)

Though in my defence I think I paid $100 for the HTC EVO after discounts and rebates, which was a damn good deal (though I'd rather have paid the $300 and them knocked off the $10/month charge since unless things go waaaaay south I plan to renue my contract AGAIN in 2 years (will be the 4th time)

I dont get it, every time I call CS they give me the rundown perfectly on any problem (and if they cant fix it give me a free replacement), any plan questions, etc... I seem to be the only one that has ZERO complains with the Sprint CS department, hell they even happily UNLOCKED my Intrepid (currently running a GoPhone SIM*) when I switched to the EVO!

Also dont bank too heavily on Vergin/Boost Data. Sprint customers get "tower priority" when the cellular slots fill up. A close friend of my mother's said he went from 1.X Mbps down to 120Kbps on Vergin and when he calls was politely told that Spring users all got priority on the towers over Vergin/Boost users.


*(yes I know ATT is GSM and Sprint is CDMA, The Intrepid is a world-band phone supporting BOTH radios)
 
Back
Top