Asrock x570 boards?

Jeff G

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Nov 2, 2017
Messages
245
Between Phantom Gaming 4, Pro4, Steel Legend, and Extreme4, is there any major reason to spend the extra money from one to another?
Phantom Gaming 4 @ $155
Pro 4 @ $170
Steel Legend @ $200
Extreme4 @ $239
Besides the added rgbness and different color layouts, is there any actual performance benefit to the pricier boards?
This will be going in a large, windowless case so the aesthetics will matter very little.
I plan to run a r5 3600 or r7 3700x (undecided currently) with 3600/c15 memory, cpu being overclocked if possible with a full water loop.
 
Every generation is different and it sounds like the X570 boards across the product spectrum have beefier VRMs, but I can say that the old X470 Fatal1ty Gaming K4 board was terrible compared to the CH7 and Strix X470-F I used, so I don't know that I'd trust the super budget board. It had significantly worse memory compatibility.

But every generation is different, so they might not be that bad.
 
Every generation is different and it sounds like the X570 boards across the product spectrum have beefier VRMs, but I can say that the old X470 Fatal1ty Gaming K4 board was terrible compared to the CH7 and Strix X470-F I used, so I don't know that I'd trust the super budget board. It had significantly worse memory compatibility.

But every generation is different, so they might not be that bad.

Steel Legend Vs Extreme4 - Extreme 4 has front usb-c, Steel Legend has Displayport rear - Same pcb.

Phantom Gaming 4 and Pro4 are identical - Difference is Pro4 has M2 cooler and USB-C out in the rear. - Same pcb

CPU VRM I believe is identical, but I'm a proponent that it's highly overstated requirement that being said, extreme4 and pro4's heatsink is a bit meh, but it should be fine even with 12 core.
SOC vrm between steel\extreme4 and pg4\pro4 seems a bit different. - SL\Extreme4 has cooler on SOC atleast.
 
Steel Legend Vs Extreme4 - Extreme 4 has front usb-c, Steel Legend has Displayport rear - Same pcb.

Phantom Gaming 4 and Pro4 are identical - Difference is Pro4 has M2 cooler and USB-C out in the rear. - Same pcb

CPU VRM I believe is identical, but I'm a proponent that it's highly overstated requirement that being said, extreme4 and pro4's heatsink is a bit meh, but it should be fine even with 12 core.
SOC vrm between steel\extreme4 and pg4\pro4 seems a bit different. - SL\Extreme4 has cooler on SOC atleast.

With a r5 3600 and 3600/c15 ram, am I going to see any performance difference between any of that stuff? Is the better components in the SL enough to justify an additional $35 over the pg4? Seems like a small amount to pay if it's a much better board, but I dont want to pay the extra $35 if it's not going to get me anything.
 
With a r5 3600 and 3600/c15 ram, am I going to see any performance difference between any of that stuff? Is the better components in the SL enough to justify an additional $35 over the pg4? Seems like a small amount to pay if it's a much better board, but I dont want to pay the extra $35 if it's not going to get me anything.
Performance wise for a 3600 no. Higher end boards will have better power delivery but will be more important pushing the 12 and upcoming 16 core cpu. It should be good enough for 3600 overclocking.
 
IMO in their X570 lineup only the Taichi and above are worth going for unless you are limited budget. Unless you really really want mATX & 4.0 since its the only one period or want to go with the ITX (ships next week maybe? on newegg) to get thunderbolt ports in SFF.

If you can find one in-stock at MC (good luck) the Taichi is $250 bought with a cpu.

If you are limited budget get a good deal on a nice X370/X470 board with good bios support instead...which still means Taichi or above. Their mass-market sub-taichi boards are worlds apart unfortunately.

I think similar logic can be applied to many of the other vendors: if you aren't getting the nicer models, you will get more bang for your buck with deals on previous gen premium boards.
 
Last edited:
I'm not going with a x370 board. I had too many issues with too many of them trying to get high speed memory to work.
When it comes to x470 boards, good ones are the same price as mid-tier x570 boards.
The x470-f is still $189, barely less than the plethora of mid-tier x570 boards at $199. C7H is $285, well in to the territory of decent x570 boards. Seems like it's not a great investment to buy the last gen boards at current gen prices. If they drop a bit in price, maybe.
And even still, with the very limited amount of OC potential in the Ryzen 3000 chips, I dont know if I even need a high end board for the 3600 (which I guess is my root question).
What will I gain going with a x470 Taichi over a x570 SL at the same price?
 
I just took a brief tour at Newegg of X470 and X570 options, and a comparison to Z390- whoah.

I can't say that I could recommend anything without further external validation.

What struck me as interesting is that the features are pretty difficult to deal with. The basic stuff is available everywhere, but any hint of using add-in cards or wanting more than two M.2 slots and you'd want to really consider X570.

Another thing that stood out on some, especially the MSI boards, was the use of Realtek LAN. I'm not sure I would accept that on a premium board line (which every X570 is, versus the expected B550 and so on). I do see Intel controllers on ASRock boards, so that's a plus.
 
I just took a brief tour at Newegg of X470 and X570 options, and a comparison to Z390- whoah.

I can't say that I could recommend anything without further external validation.

What struck me as interesting is that the features are pretty difficult to deal with. The basic stuff is available everywhere, but any hint of using add-in cards or wanting more than two M.2 slots and you'd want to really consider X570.

Another thing that stood out on some, especially the MSI boards, was the use of Realtek LAN. I'm not sure I would accept that on a premium board line (which every X570 is, versus the expected B550 and so on). I do see Intel controllers on ASRock boards, so that's a plus.

Which Realtek LAN? I mean my CH8 has an INTEL 1GB LAN and a Realtek 2.5GB LAN.
 
Which Realtek LAN? I mean my CH8 has an INTEL 1GB LAN and a Realtek 2.5GB LAN.

I'm seeing 8111's on some boards. I didn't take notes, was just going through what I could find, and that's something that I watch out for.

[I'll also say that I have a 10Gbit switch, but I'm a pretty rare case there- so far as I know, Aquantia is the only current producer of 10Gbase-T NICs, with Intel's being out of production- and I'm quite leary of Realtek's >1Gbit tech as well...]
 
I'm seeing 8111's on some boards. I didn't take notes, was just going through what I could find, and that's something that I watch out for.

[I'll also say that I have a 10Gbit switch, but I'm a pretty rare case there- so far as I know, Aquantia is the only current producer of 10Gbase-T NICs, with Intel's being out of production- and I'm quite leary of Realtek's >1Gbit tech as well...]

Good thing I didn't buy it for the Realtek LAN (I don't even think I have my ethernet plugged into that port). It just seems like an odd move for MSI to put Realtek GbE only except as maybe a 2nd controller.
 
Good thing I didn't buy it for the Realtek LAN (I don't even think I have my ethernet plugged into that port). It just seems like an odd move for MSI to put Realtek GbE only except as maybe a 2nd controller.

Yeah, I'd only accept a Realtek controller if it were for IPMI (which most are). But that's far from a desktop feature. And that's not that I consider Realtek to be a problem in general or even specifically with network controllers- it's that Intel parts are available for what appears to be zero end-user cost over the Realtek parts, and the Intel controllers are bulletproof and supported by any OS you'd want to throw at it.
 
Back
Top