Arrest Made in Wikileaks Video Probe

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
An Army intelligence analyst that bragged online about leaking classified Army documents to Wikileaks has been arrested. Former hacker Adrian Lamo spilled the beans to the authorities after this guy spilled the beans to him about spilling the beans on classified documents. Damn, you just can’t trust hackers with beans these days. :D

Manning came to the attention of the FBI and Army investigators after he contacted former hacker Adrian Lamo late last month over instant messenger and e-mail. Lamo had just been the subject of a Wired.com article. Very quickly in his exchange with the ex-hacker, Manning claimed to be the Wikileaks video leaker.
 
Sort of kills any sense of nobility he might have earned for trying to blow the whistle on military cover-ups. I guess everybody has to get their 15 minutes. Pathetic.
 
a previously unreported breach consisting of 260,000 classified U.S. diplomatic cables that Manning described as exposing “almost criminal political back dealings.”

“Hillary Clinton, and several thousand diplomats around the world are going to have a heart attack when they wake up one morning, and find an entire repository of classified foreign policy is available, in searchable format, to the public,” Manning wrote.

I wonder how much longer they'll allow Wikileaks to exist. Surely if Wikileaks actually posts that stuff and upsets politicians around the world they won't be able to find any country they can be hosted from.
 
I wonder how much longer they'll allow Wikileaks to exist. Surely if Wikileaks actually posts that stuff and upsets politicians around the world they won't be able to find any country they can be hosted from.

As someone who's known Lamo for around 15 years, I'd say he did the ethical thing.

Re: Wikileaks, it seems TPB still exists so as long as sites like TPB exist then Wikileaks will have no trouble.
 
I can understand Lamo's claimed motivation for outing Manning as the Colateral Murder video leaker. If the other classified information he leaked does indeed put lives at risk then there should be consequences for that.

Though I have to give kudos to Manning for leaking the colateral murder video. Even though what he did was clearly illegal, it was definitely necessary to get it out in the open.
 
Re: Wikileaks, it seems TPB still exists so as long as sites like TPB exist then Wikileaks will have no trouble.

The Pirate Bay violates copyrights - sure it upsets the media companies, but that is not in the same league as a site that apparently could post things the leaker says could expose near criminal behavior between a major politician (Hillary Clinton) and thousands of diplomats around the world. THAT they'd fight a lot harder to close down.
 
more like if they make a pest of themselves, everytime they bring up a server, a NSA Dos attack shuts it down....
 
The Pirate Bay violates copyrights - sure it upsets the media companies, but that is not in the same league as a site that apparently could post things the leaker says could expose near criminal behavior between a major politician (Hillary Clinton) and thousands of diplomats around the world. THAT they'd fight a lot harder to close down.

But a site like Wikileaks needs a source to post such information. A source with such information is more important to stop then the site they would be providing the information too.

Simply put, it is now out in the open and everyone knows about it, closing Wikileaks right now would be the same as pouring salt on the wound at this point.
 
Sort of kills any sense of nobility he might have earned for trying to blow the whistle on military cover-ups. I guess everybody has to get their 15 minutes. Pathetic.

thats what the military has been itching to do for years, hell they made an entire report specifically about wikileaks and how to destroy its credibility and make examples of people to destroy wikileaks
 
Thanks Mr Lamo. Ethics are not a bad thing.

Wikileaks is doing what they are supposed to do. I may not agree with them all the time but, I understand how they can be/are necessary. This doesn't give the government a right to shut them down. Especially the U.S. goverment. Freedom of the press anyone? These guys leak/report shit you won't see from the bought and paid for media. It's war. Horrible shit happens every day. Wikileaks just showed people a little of that. Kinda falls in there job description if you ask me. Not unethical imo.

As for the Army Spc......rot in jail dick. I hope you have grey hair when you get out. I fuckin hate traitors. I doubt there are few soldiers anywhere in "any" army that will disagree with me. If manning were a taliban infiltraitor I'd actually have more respect for him however, he's not. He's just some punk looking to be famous.
 
As for the Army Spc......rot in jail dick. I hope you have grey hair when you get out. I fuckin hate traitors. I doubt there are few soldiers anywhere in "any" army that will disagree with me. If manning were a taliban infiltraitor I'd actually have more respect for him however, he's not. He's just some punk looking to be famous.

I don't think he wanted to be famous at all, he just didn't know how to keep his mouth shut. I can't fault him for getting that video out in the open; The other stuff, I'm not so sure about yet.
 
Whats the big deal about the Colateral Murder video? Somebody explain to my why I should be upset over us killing some ragheads that are trying to kill our soldiers?
 
“I would come in with music on a CD-RW labeled with something like ‘Lady Gaga,’ erase the music then write a compressed split file,” he wrote. “No one suspected a thing and, odds are, they never will.”

“ listened and lip-synced to Lady Gaga’s ‘Telephone’ while exfiltrating possibly the largest data spillage in American history,” he added later. ”Weak servers, weak logging, weak physical security, weak counter-intelligence, inattentive signal analysis … a perfect storm.”

I laughed.
 
Whats the big deal about the Colateral Murder video? Somebody explain to my why I should be upset over us killing some ragheads that are trying to kill our soldiers?

Well... no one was trying to kill the soldiers. It was a group of reuters reporters.
 
I feel that oversight and independent review of military actions should happen as a matter of policy. Sure, the guy broke the rules, but he did what he felt was right. If current military law is arranged in such a way that horrors can be swept under the rug, maybe military law needs to be reviewed.

We are not (or at least should not be) bloodthirsty barbarians with fancy gadgets.
 
I'm as conflicted as Lamo. That's a lot of dispatches indiscriminately disclosed. Still, I trust the organization he leaked them to and their due diligence in deciding what to make public.
Which you can clearly see a weapon in the video. They were mingling with "terrorists."
EVERYONE has a weapon in Baghdad. You were correct to put "terrorists" in quotes, anyway. That way it includes the kids in the minivan.
 
Whats the big deal about the Colateral Murder video? Somebody explain to my why I should be upset over us killing some ragheads that are trying to kill our soldiers?


I like racists :rolleyes:

like I love gay fat burger munching Americans - you see ?
 
EVERYONE has a weapon in Baghdad. You were correct to put "terrorists" in quotes, anyway. That way it includes the kids in the minivan.

Yes. Because everyone was able to use their xray goggles to see into the van while they thought they were engaging a bunch of guys with guns. Sounds to me that if you want to not have to worry about getting wasted by the military, you shouldn't walk openly carrying guns. Or, you know, hang out with guys who are carrying guns.
 
Yes. Because everyone was able to use their xray goggles to see into the van while they thought they were engaging a bunch of guys with guns. Sounds to me that if you want to not have to worry about getting wasted by the military, you shouldn't walk openly carrying guns. Or, you know, hang out with guys who are carrying guns.

It's their country. It's legal for them to walk around carrying weapons. You know, like here in the U.S.A.
 
It's their country. It's legal for them to walk around carrying weapons. You know, like here in the U.S.A.

Yes. And if you decided to walk down the sidewalk in suburban America with a loaded AR-15 slung across your back, you lose all right to complain if the cops show up and shit hits the fan. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
If you're going to walk around an active warzone, crouch behind cover and take pictures of our military forces using cameras that you've been repeatably warned might look like RPG's in the 2 seconds that a soldier has to make a threat assessment, you shouldn't be surprised, much less outraged when you get your face rearranged.
 
Yes. And if you decided to walk down the sidewalk in suburban America with a loaded AR-15 slung across your back, you lose all right to complain if the cops show up and shit hits the fan. Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
If you're going to walk around an active warzone, crouch behind cover and take pictures of our military forces using cameras that you've been repeatably warned might look like RPG's in the 2 seconds that a soldier has to make a threat assessment, you shouldn't be surprised, much less outraged when you get your face rearranged.

Just because a person is walking around with a loaded assault does not give anyone, not the police nor the military, to arbitrarilly kill you. Unless you have threatened somebody or pointed that weapon at somebody or yourself you are free to walk around with that assault weapon. Just because you think nobody should doesn't give you the right to just kill anybody who does.
 
What? It's not like they were skipping through a field of flowers hand in hand and the mean military showed up and ruined the party. There were guys holding guns standing with other guys ducking around the corner of a building, pointing something dark and cylindrical at a helicopter, in an active war zone. Ground troops were approaching, a decision had to be made. In retrospect, it was a bad one that, although I don't fully condone, I understand why it was made. We can either roll around on the floor kicking and screaming about an imaginary coverup, or we can take steps to ensure it doesn't happen again. Putting smarter journalists who can pick better company would be a good start. Pulsing IR beacons would be better. Finding a way to keep the military informed of journalists locations, groupsize, composition, and dress would be the best.
 
The reason why no one cares about the dead Reuters photographers is that they themselves are Iraqi, they are not important in the eyes of most Americans. Imagine the fallout it was Americans or Europeans killed. It's racism, plain and simple. At the same time, they are definitely not the first civilians killed in the illegal and unjust invasion, and at the same time you can wonder why they consider us to be occupiers.
 
The reason why no one cares about the dead Reuters photographers is that they themselves are Iraqi, they are not important in the eyes of most Americans. Imagine the fallout it was Americans or Europeans killed. It's racism, plain and simple. At the same time, they are definitely not the first civilians killed in the illegal and unjust invasion, and at the same time you can wonder why they consider us to be occupiers.

an illegal and unjust invasion? what the hell are you smoking? ask the widows of all the dead Kurds, hell, ask the survivors of the murdering bastards that killed thousands of other Iraqis, Kuwatis, and an entire generation of Iranians in a truly unjust war for oil.

This discussion is like the people that try to claim the Holocaust didn't happen. lots of convenient "facts" get brought out to try and prove that we caused all the problems in Iraq. Iraq has been one festering wound since before the Ottoman empire imploded.
 
The reason why no one cares about the dead Reuters photographers is that they themselves are Iraqi, they are not important in the eyes of most Americans. Imagine the fallout it was Americans or Europeans killed. It's racism, plain and simple. At the same time, they are definitely not the first civilians killed in the illegal and unjust invasion, and at the same time you can wonder why they consider us to be occupiers.

After all, the video tells the whole story, right? :rolleyes: Who's to say they weren't passing information to the dirtbags they were with? Can you say with absolute certainty that there were no exchanges of fire or mortar barrages originating in the area prior to the video being shot? Everyone's pissing and moaning about innocents being killed, but shit happens in a war zone. I take it everyone would prefer the WW2 days of just carpet-bombing the crap out of an area?

The only ones innocent in that attack were the kids in the minivan, but nobody's blaming the tard responsible for "Bring your kids to war" day.
 
What? It's not like they were skipping through a field of flowers hand in hand and the mean military showed up and ruined the party. There were guys holding guns standing with other guys ducking around the corner of a building, pointing something dark and cylindrical at a helicopter, in an active war zone. Ground troops were approaching, a decision had to be made. In retrospect, it was a bad one that, although I don't fully condone, I understand why it was made. We can either roll around on the floor kicking and screaming about an imaginary coverup, or we can take steps to ensure it doesn't happen again. Putting smarter journalists who can pick better company would be a good start. Pulsing IR beacons would be better. Finding a way to keep the military informed of journalists locations, groupsize, composition, and dress would be the best.


I have watched that video many times and just rewatched it again. The Iraqis were at no point threathening. Nobody in their right mind would be planning an ambush out in the open. The fact that ground troops were approaching should have given them more reason to hold fire. Heck they could have called the local soldiers and had them check. Instead the pilots were in a rush to get the order to engage. They could barely even wait to get the go-ahead cursing to be let to engage the "enemy". Listening to and reading the pilot conversation you can easily tell they just wanted their kills in. They were even laughing and begging the injured to "just touch a weapon" so they can shoot again.

And who is to decide who reporters should be company with. Who are these better company you're talking about, the U.S. soldiers? The same ones that non-chalantly blew them out of the ground and then ran their bodies over with a Bradley and laughed about it?
 
Untitled.png


Because it'd be absolutely impossible to mistake that for anything other than a guy with a camera.
In all honesty, if I was a photographer in a war zone where the enemies attack one of the most powerful armies in the world by dressing like civilians and walking around with guns, and I just happened to be surrounded by guys dressed like civilians, who happened to be carrying guns at the exact moment a pair of Apache's started circling me, I'd shit my pants.
I mean, at any point before they went out for the day, do you think they went over what they'd do if they ran into the Americans? The choppers were circling, the guys on the ground knew that they were there, why didn't they drop their rifles and wave a shirt or something? Seriously. If they all threw down their guns and waived at the pilot, I guarantee that the outcome would have been different.
Yes, the pilots wanted to get it over with. Once again, they're in a warzone where the enemy wears civilian clothes, carries guns, and can make things go from perfectly relaxed to uber violent in a heartbeat. They're circling a bunch of guys who fit the bill and are aware that the choppers are there. Would you have preferred them to sit around and wait until someone tags them with a heat-seeker? God knows that we poured enough of them into the region in the 80's. There are more than a few scenario's that this incident could have fallen under.
Oh, and logic should dictate who you surround yourself with in an active warzone. At the top of the list of who you shouldn't associate with, people that could be easily mistaken for enemies. Someone wearing some sort of easily identifiable uniform would be ideal.
 
Untitled.png


Because it'd be absolutely impossible to mistake that for anything other than a guy with a camera.
In all honesty, if I was a photographer in a war zone where the enemies attack one of the most powerful armies in the world by dressing like civilians and walking around with guns, and I just happened to be surrounded by guys dressed like civilians, who happened to be carrying guns at the exact moment a pair of Apache's started circling me, I'd shit my pants.
I mean, at any point before they went out for the day, do you think they went over what they'd do if they ran into the Americans? The choppers were circling, the guys on the ground knew that they were there, why didn't they drop their rifles and wave a shirt or something? Seriously. If they all threw down their guns and waived at the pilot, I guarantee that the outcome would have been different.
Yes, the pilots wanted to get it over with. Once again, they're in a warzone where the enemy wears civilian clothes, carries guns, and can make things go from perfectly relaxed to uber violent in a heartbeat. They're circling a bunch of guys who fit the bill and are aware that the choppers are there. Would you have preferred them to sit around and wait until someone tags them with a heat-seeker? God knows that we poured enough of them into the region in the 80's. There are more than a few scenario's that this incident could have fallen under.
Oh, and logic should dictate who you surround yourself with in an active warzone. At the top of the list of who you shouldn't associate with, people that could be easily mistaken for enemies. Someone wearing some sort of easily identifiable uniform would be ideal.

pic.jpg


Iraqi's at a street corner in an Iraqi town. Iraqi law allows them to carry weapons. They have not shot at anybody. One pilot thought he saw a weapon aimed. He did not try to confirm. He did not wait to see if what they were going to do. Like I said, who plans an ambush out in the open. If they really knew the gunships were there do you really think they would be milling out in the open like that. Really? As far as they were concerned they were a bunch of Iraqis at an Iraqi street corner in an Iraqi town. Why should they have to get permission from American soldiers to walk around their town. If the military wants to know what Iraqis are doing wherever at what time then they should just declare martial law in Iraq and stop all pretensions democracy.
 
I agrees with "rogue" soldiers or cops leaking videos which they believe to wrong and needs the public attention. Even if its illegal, its a necessary evil if it can bring abuses and other wrong doings to the public's attention which would otherwise be swept under the carpet. But this guy should have just kept his mouth shut from the beginning.

I do hope Wikileaks will continue to operate though.
 
Or the troops can keep killing them until they start paying attention to how they appear to our military. It's not that difficult. If they insist on walking around with guns and no discernible uniform (I'm more than sure their police force could be beefed up a bit), they need to come up with a way to show that they're not a threat. Or they're just going to continue getting rearranged, and everyone is going to continue to bitch and whine about it. Personally, I prefer to come up with solutions.

Sorry, I had an actual response typed up and it got kicked by the login screen.
 
Yes. Because everyone was able to use their xray goggles to see into the van while they thought they were engaging a bunch of guys with guns. Sounds to me that if you want to not have to worry about getting wasted by the military, you shouldn't walk openly carrying guns. Or, you know, hang out with guys who are carrying guns.
Well, if you're a reporter in a war zone, you don't have much choice, do you? Good thing we've got rules of engagement for this sort of thing... which were violated. Multiple times.

I think we're all missing the part where this was covered up. Hence the importance of the leaked video.
 
Well, if you're a reporter in a war zone, you don't have much choice, do you? Good thing we've got rules of engagement for this sort of thing... which were violated. Multiple times.

I think we're all missing the part where this was covered up. Hence the importance of the leaked video.

Actually, if you're a reporter in a war zone, your general goal should be to be as neutral as possible. Hanging around with guys with guns is hardly neutral. Obviously they're carrying them to ward off terrorists who might otherwise use them as hostages or something, which is why I originally suggested something along the lines if an IR beacon. It's not like we don't have technology to at least try to minimize the risks.

How was it covered up? Seriously? The video just wasn't released. I'm sure the Pentagon has plenty of footage of helicopters flying over open desert that they haven't released, is that a cover up? That's kind of the definition of cover up. Something is actually covered up. They haven't tried to convince everyone that it was actually the Russians piloting the choppers. And I'm pretty sure they haven't tried to convince everyone that the journalists are actually weather balloons.
 
Can you guys tell me with a straight face that if your country was invaded by soldiers from far away, that don't speak your language, look like you, or understand your culture, you would just be as peaceful and not doing anything about it? What if these foreign soldiers labeled you a terrorist as soon as you picked up a gun, or broke into your house at night and scared your family? What if you saw your friends and neighbors getting killed, businesses being blown up, and being constantly bossed around by foreigners?

Iraqi's have lived under extremely stressful circumstances, especially between 2003-2007. That's four years of being kept up at night by explosions. That's four years of having to constantly watch your back. That's four years of having to duck and hide when you hear a gun shot. And what would be on your mind? You might blame the people that started all the violence in the first place, the Americans. Maybe that's not the most rational solution, but you might be so angry that you might want to kill the occupier.

America did a MUCH better job when they started to negotiate with the Sunni Extremists and actually got them to come on their side. Maybe sometimes it doesn't hurt to show RESPECT towards the people and culture of the country that you are occupying, and constantly calling them terrorists because they want you gone is not respecting them. Ironically, those guys that were killed in the video I bet would have been on our side two years later. There is a very good chance of that. They also could have been Shiite, but I don't really know, my point remains the same.

The hardest thing for me to understand about you people who say "kill em all, let god sort them out" is why you think that will actually work. Did killing millions of communists help the Nazi's win Stalingrad? Did slaughtering countless Vietcong help America win that war? There's no logic in that strategy, and it makes me dismiss you as a very simple minded person.

Now, thankfully we did get a very smart general named David Patraeus who made a counter-insurgency strategy that actually worked in Iraq, and it was far more complex than simply killing as many "terrorists" as possible. But that's what some of you still want to do, just kill people. That's half the reason why we had the war in the first place. Where is your logic?
 
Back
Top