Army Veteran Says CoD Marketing Is "Tasteless"

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I can totally understand that some people believe video games "trivialize and sanitize" war but, I don't think blaming an ad that makes fun of FPS n00bs is the best way to make your point.

It begins with two Hollywood buffoons in (for whatever reason) MultiCam taking heavy fire during an apparent New York City terrorist attack. The men calmly walk into a hailstorm of bullets, and return fire with rifles, pistols, and submachine guns. On some level—perhaps it’s the intensity of the actors—the commercial wants its action to be taken seriously.
 
The army vet is looking for an association between FPS gaming and actual war. This is the flaw.
 
Yanno I often respect those who put their lives on the line... actually correction, I respect those who get their lives put on the line (its often silly to think they have much of any choice in the matter).

But for being these "brave" people, they sure can be pussies sometimes. They want to be the muslims of the west, where everything is sacred and it has to be run by them first!

As an astronomy/physics teacher it offends me greatly to see movies like Deep Impact or Armageddon make such light of how realistic it is to stop an asteroid from hitting the Earth... ok it doesn't, it's entertainment, the end.
 
People need to relax..I love this commercial..Should be evolution of a noob..lol
 
It's all a matter of perspective. I see DB Grady's point as well as the gamers perspective. Usually attitudes change in a heartbeat when real life fire is directed at you. A game, no matter how realistic, can ever be confused with that. Unfortunately, the services also play upon the gamer mentality. Ever see the controls for a drone or M1-A?
 
He didn't say anything about the game really. He was making commentary on how it's sold and marketed to the public, which understandably is offensive to some combat veterans.
 
Ever see the controls for a drone or M1-A?

The controls aren't aiming at a certain "mentality" per se, but at familiarity. If soldiers already understand and user an XBox controller, why reinvent the wheel when we can just reuse something with minimal training?
 
The controls aren't aiming at a certain "mentality" per se, but at familiarity. If soldiers already understand and user an XBox controller, why reinvent the wheel when we can just reuse something with minimal training?

One day they will be pwned by chinese drones using kb/m. :p
 
I liked the commercial and I serve ... People need to re learn what reality is sometime. Believe me COD it's extremely popular in the military and so is this commercial.
 
There is nothing serious or realistic about CoD and the commercials associated with it. The marketing of it bothers you? Yea, well most marketing is pretty stupid.
 
I'd like to point out that anyone who touts that they were a "paratrooper with Special Operations Command" most likely means that they sat behind a desk. All of the infantry, engineers, medics and commo guys earned their SF tab if they're with SOCOM. I guess he didn't want to admit he was a PAC clerk or other support MOS. "War veteran" doesn't mean someone actually engaged the enemy either, just means they were in country when a war was going on. (Conversely, there are guys I know that engaged the enemy, but aren't war veterans.)

Anyways, COD commercials and the actual games have always had ridiculous/unrealistic plots. C'mon, the last commercial had Jimmy Kimmel fall down after shooting an RPG. Sorry, rockets don't have recoil.

Anyone believing that COD is realistic is an idiot.
 
I knew there were a bunch of morons in this country the day I saw the Modern Warfare Edition Jeep being sold.

There is definately a culture in place that cheers war like they were cheering for their favorite football team.
 
Yanno I often respect those who put their lives on the line... actually correction, I respect those who get their lives put on the line (its often silly to think they have much of any choice in the matter).
... because clearly, those who volunteer to join the Armed Forces had no choice in the matter. :rolleyes:

He didn't say anything about the game really. He was making commentary on how it's sold and marketed to the public, which understandably is offensive to some combat veterans.
I have a hard time to believe this to be true. Violence has been glorified in the entertainment industry since they started to make silent movies in black & white. Often that glorification was done for dramatic or humorous effect. I would expect some Quaker religious zealots to get offended by glorification of violence but not combat vets.

By the same logic combat vets would be offended by the 2nd amendment because they have seen up close what happens when you give guns to the general (civilian) population.
 
The controls aren't aiming at a certain "mentality" per se, but at familiarity. If soldiers already understand and user an XBox controller, why reinvent the wheel when we can just reuse something with minimal training?

I understand the argument but, I reject it. As an old 'observer' I know that the best way to turn farmers into fighters is by giving them the a different perspective on the situation they find themselves facing. The easiest, fastest and (listen up pentagon) cheapest way to do this is by isolating them from all that's familiar and immersing them in the trivialities of how to function as a military unit. People have been fighting wars since there were people. Being successful at fighting wars requires acknowledging the artificial and unique trade of the professional soldier. Silly controllers don't have much of an impact really anymore than having a stock stamped with "Made by Mattel" did in the bad old days. It just irritates me. :)
 
The controls aren't aiming at a certain "mentality" per se, but at familiarity. If soldiers already understand and user an XBox controller, why reinvent the wheel when we can just reuse something with minimal training?

Right,
An example of this would be the Sherman tank from WWII. It was built to be driven (control wise) like a tractor, so anyone with experience with tractors could drive a Sherman tank with little to no training. And with many of the solders being drafts/ recruits, it makes sense to make the controls something they would be used to.
 
He didn't say anything about the game really. He was making commentary on how it's sold and marketed to the public, which understandably is offensive to some combat veterans.

That' just it, if he had an issue with war games, I can see that.

He is taking issue with a parody / joke ad because he doesn't know it is a joke. Every FPS player on the planet knows "the n00b," has been stuck with them on their team, lost matches because of them, team killed by them etc. etc....so the ad was funny to us.

The author of this article talked about the ad like it was serious:

There is a television advertisement for a video game called Modern Warfare 3 that is so base and strident that it’s hard to believe that it’s not deliberately offensive. It begins with two Hollywood buffoons in (for whatever reason) MultiCam taking heavy fire during an apparent New York City terrorist attack. The men calmly walk into a hailstorm of bullets, and return fire with rifles, pistols, and submachine guns. Most disturbing is that the depicted maelstrom seems designed to carefully hover in the uncanny zone. Clearly it’s not Black Hawk Down, but neither is it Starship Troopers. On some level—perhaps it’s the intensity of the actors—the commercial wants its action to be taken seriously.

How can you actually tell if someone is a noob in CoD!? :confused:

Never played? Doesn't neccessarily have to be CoD either, the noobs can be spotted a mile away...especially if they are on your team (see above) ;) The ad is not funny at all if you've never encountered "the n00b" while playing.
 
I understand the argument but, I reject it. As an old 'observer' I know that the best way to turn farmers into fighters is by giving them the a different perspective on the situation they find themselves facing. The easiest, fastest and (listen up pentagon) cheapest way to do this is by isolating them from all that's familiar and immersing them in the trivialities of how to function as a military unit. People have been fighting wars since there were people. Being successful at fighting wars requires acknowledging the artificial and unique trade of the professional soldier. Silly controllers don't have much of an impact really anymore than having a stock stamped with "Made by Mattel" did in the bad old days. It just irritates me. :)

I see your point, but I think you are going to broad in your thinking. I have been hunting a fair amount in my life. As such I have been used to handling a gun. Most guns in a basic level are similar; you have a safety, trigger, stock... A military gun is going to have the same basic parts and understanding, even though they might be different in many ways. Does this mean if I ever become a soldier, I will have a hard time feeling like I am a solider because I am familiar from guns already?
Furthermore you’re right about people fighting wars sense forever… But they have been fighting with weapons they usually had at home, or what they found on the battlefield. Was a soldier from the American Revolutionary war (where guns from home where common), any less of a solider. Granted they were not a professional as a British solider at the time. Being familiar with the land and the weapons the where using was and advantage at the time. By being at home and fighting in familiar land and weapons makes it harder from them becomes a military unit?
Your point is right, but when it comes to everyday items it doesn’t need to change. Giving them a uniform, working like a unit, living in dorms, that’s the time of stuff that’s going to bring about the change you are wanting. What we are dealing with here I a basic everyday device that people are becoming increasing familiar with.
 
... because clearly, those who volunteer to join the Armed Forces had no choice in the matter. :rolleyes:

You missed the point, they might choose to go into the Armed Forces. But have many actually choose to go Iraq. Further more, how many choose to go in the front lines. You normally don't have an say in the matter.
 
Your point is right, but when it comes to everyday items it doesn’t need to change. Giving them a uniform, working like a unit, living in dorms, that’s the time of stuff that’s going to bring about the change you are wanting. What we are dealing with here I a basic everyday device that people are becoming increasing familiar with.

You're correct, it's just my geezerness coming through. I just have a hard time acknowledging game controllers "as a basic everyday device." :D
 
Never played? Doesn't neccessarily have to be CoD either, the noobs can be spotted a mile away...especially if they are on your team (see above) ;) The ad is not funny at all if you've never encountered "the n00b" while playing.

But in a game its practically impossible to miss (grenades)...and requires 0 skill...noobs get hard to spot! :D
 
I liked the commercial and I serve ... People need to re learn what reality is sometime. Believe me COD it's extremely popular in the military and so is this commercial.

This. My brother is infantry and we talk sometimes about the games we're going to play together with the rest of our family when he gets back from Afghanistan - he saw the modern warfare commercial and while he hates how commercials like that depict combat as some sort of Serious Sam affair, he thought it was hilariously bad in a good way.

Modern Warfare 3 isn't something we play, but some of his favorite games are Battlefield 3 and Arma - if an active duty soldier who sees combat and loses comrades loves these games, maybe the article is looking at this in the wrong way? After all, we've been trivializing war for a long time now - how many people can honestly say that they've sacrificed for the current set of conflicts America, or any other first world country, has found itself embroiled in? The war might as well be as distant as a fictionalized account of a videogame; only those who actually fight it seem to actually care about it.

I think I understand what he's trying to say, but it's far too late for that. The damage to the national psyche was done long before videogames were invented, let alone these commercials surfaced.
 
It's an advert for a game making fun of 2 different types of players found IN the game. If you read anything more in to than that you need step away from the computer or TV and go play in the ball pit.
 
Thank god they did not have the advert show a griefer. dear god can you imagine the knee jerk response article to that?
 
A lot of the guys I play BF3 with are ex-military, many of them war vets, with a few who are still active service or are private contractors and one of the many thing's they share in common is a lack of appreciation for CoD.
 
I understand the argument but, I reject it. As an old 'observer' I know that the best way to turn farmers into fighters is by giving them the a different perspective on the situation they find themselves facing. The easiest, fastest and (listen up pentagon) cheapest way to do this is by isolating them from all that's familiar and immersing them in the trivialities of how to function as a military unit. People have been fighting wars since there were people. Being successful at fighting wars requires acknowledging the artificial and unique trade of the professional soldier. Silly controllers don't have much of an impact really anymore than having a stock stamped with "Made by Mattel" did in the bad old days. It just irritates me. :)

They're way ahead of you.

http://www.americasarmy.com/
 
While I'm all about Vets and there rights this is just dumb. Its a video game , many forms of media glorify violence/war and blaming one game ad as completely pointless.

There are far more important things Vets should be worried about , like there huge suicide rates , the fact that most of them don't have any money or work when they get back home from years in a combat situation , the fact they have poor benefits and that they are vastly underpaid (politicians should be forced to switch salaries with them). There are just so many other issues with Vets that would be worth the national attention this one ad will get because of this complaint....


How sad.
 
I knew there were a bunch of morons in this country the day I saw the Modern Warfare Edition Jeep being sold.

There is definately a culture in place that cheers war like they were cheering for their favorite football team.

How is that any different than Eddie Bauer, Harley Davidson, or the plethora of other "special" edition vehicles ever sold or given away as prizes?
 
I liked the commercial and I serve ... People need to re learn what reality is sometime. Believe me COD it's extremely popular in the military and so is this commercial.

I was in the air force. When I saw this commercial I LOVED it. I thought it was genius and actually showed a great image of the military.
 
Yes it's tasteless, that's the freaking point.

Funny too... Once you wash the Iraqi sand out of your vagina.


You missed the point, they might choose to go into the Armed Forces. But have many actually choose to go Iraq. Further more, how many choose to go in the front lines. You normally don't have an say in the matter.

Soldier first. That's the deal. You sign up for the meager pittance, on the off chance that you will be part of the small percent in harms way.
 
Meh, I know many Vets that play CoD. If I recall correctly, CoD is actually a popular time waster for troops overseas too. The issue here (once again) is someone trying to equate a video game to real life. This is really no different than when people try to claim that GTA caused some kid to commit a crime IMO.
 
I think the author of the article should have been pissed they let the douchey fat kid from super bad portray a military member.... that's the real travesty here.. His tubby ass would get a whole 50 feet before having a massive coronary.
 
I think the author of the article should have been pissed they let the douchey fat kid from super bad portray a military member.... that's the real travesty here.. His tubby ass would get a whole 50 feet before having a massive coronary.
"You're a disgusting fat body, Pvt. Pyle!!! You're ass looks like 50 lbs. of chewed bubble gum!!!"
 
I tend to think things through and parallel them with reality of whats actually going on in the world. To me I visualized the real life version where the mine blows the soldiers head into bits and he doesn't comeback to play again. Or where there is some family in the top floor of that building that gets shredded by gunfire. Even though I play the game, I fully understand where the guy is coming from and felt it was an unnecessary to involve real people in comparison to actual game footer. Sort of inching the line ever bit closer.
 
Back
Top