Are NAS systems slower than DIY system?

junfan

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
238
I'm currently running a WHS in a spare PC. I'm finding out it's not really what I want, I'm looking into possibly getting a prebuilt NAS system, possibly with drives, running RAID 5 most likely.

All I have on my WHS is movies and TV shows, I'm not backing up any data to it, though I occasionally will use it to put some files on it, but usually only temporarily. Basically I really only need a streaming server or HTPC, something really quiet and very low power to be on only when I plan on watching something.

I was looking at some reviews of NAS systems and many of them said they are very slow, one noting 10MB a sec, my WHS box usually gets 50-70MB a sec, speed isn't a huge issue but some of the files I'm copying over can get up to 15GB, and many times I'm copying over a large number of files at a time.

Are NAS systems usually slower than spare PC/DIY systems? I really can't imagine why they would be, is it a driver issue or substandard NIC? Any NAS I pick up will be connected the same way as my WHS, via gigabit.
 
Yes they are slower. That's just the way it is. Inefficient transfer protocols, cheap components, and bottlenecked by low powered CPUs.

Pay to play!
 
A consumer NAS will be slower. You gotta spend 400+ to get anything like cheap system speeds...
 
I have the Promise SmartStor 4300 (original) and I average 7 MB/s. I used to have a DIY system but opted for a NAS because of how extremely simple it is to setup and maintain. Yes, the performance sucks but I knew that before purchasing. I wanted the small form factor and ease of use the NAS provides. Now that my NAS is running out of space (4 250gb HDs in RAID 5) I am thinking about going back to a DIY system running WHS and using the NAS as backup.

I guess if you already have a WHS server why not make that your primary server or get a NAS to stream files and your current box can manage the backups. This way you don't really need RAID on your NAS because you will have backups.
 
Yeah, I like smallnetbuilder.com for networking and NAS info. Ended up just getting an Atom powered nettop for my server box, just had to find one that had a gigabit NIC on it.
 
Why are you unhappy with your current WHS setup? Too big/noisy or something like that? If that's the case, it shouldn't be hard to remedy...
 
Why are you unhappy with your current WHS setup? Too big/noisy or something like that? If that's the case, it shouldn't be hard to remedy...

I like WHS, but for my usage it really is overkill, I'm looking for something lean and mean, I always leaned towards a lean NAS OS, something like NASLite or FreeNAS but decided to go with WHS since they have such a long free trial. I really like the idea of a unified control panel that most NAS OS's use.

I've been running WHS for close to 6 months, my biggest gripes are -
-long startup time, I don't leave it on 24/7 as really I only use it to stream media
-loudness, I know I could fix this easily but it rolls into the next gripe
-size of case, to remedy this I would have to change hardware
-messing with drivers and frequent updates, it is a windows box after all

One of my biggest gripes, they advertise it as "headless" and for the most part it is, but if something goes wrong you have to throw a videocard in and fix it through the server itself, this happened a few times more than I like, but it is unusual.

I'm looking at the new QNAP TS-410, since I already have two caviar black 1TB drives I'll probably just buy the QNAP and 2 more drives to fill it. QNAP seems to be the top tier brand and in the price range i'm looking at all the top tier companies have very similar offerings, usually a connection or two is different, but the main differences seems to be software and physical appearance, both of which Iook excellent for the QNAP.

ZtTxA.jpg
 
Gotcha, altho for the same price you could consider some of the pre-built WHS rigs as well (into which you could just throw your existing drives too). I've no idea how fast those NAS boxes boot up but the HP WHS I've dealt with boots pretty fast and is pretty inaudible (altho it was sitting next to a large Xerox machine so that might've overshadowed any noise I could've picked up from it :p ). I was surprised at how fast it rebooted when I installed updates on it...

OTOH I imagine if something goes wrong w/those HP boxes it becomes even more of a chore troubleshoot it, but hardware failure is possible w/a NAS box as well and AFAIK migrating drives that were involved in a RAID config from one such device to another can be much trickier than moving WHS drives around.
 
Are NAS systems usually slower than spare PC/DIY systems? I really can't imagine why they would be, is it a driver issue or substandard NIC? Any NAS I pick up will be connected the same way as my WHS, via gigabit.

I think you can take a look at the xtreamer eTrayz. It has great spec and have what you ask for. I don't have have etrayz yet, but I have their xtreamer and it is simply the best network mediaplayer I ever had.

etrayz:

http://www.xtreamer.net/etrayz/specs.aspx

xtreamer network media player:

http://www.xtreamer.net/xtreamer/overview.aspx
 
One of my biggest gripes, they advertise it as "headless" and for the most part it is, but if something goes wrong you have to throw a videocard in and fix it

Why can't you use remote desktop?

Another solution could be to just get a hardware raid card, run windows 7, and just use the machine directly as your HTPC media center. If the purpose is just storage for watching videos and stuff then all you really need from WHS is raid. If you only care about it being on when you want to use it then putting your storage on the HTPC machine directly would make sense.

Also if you care about case size you could get an external SAS enclosure to house your disks and use a normal case for the pc itself. SAS raid controllers can be somewhat expensive but this setup would be very fast. It's a shame theres no workable software raid 5/6 implementation with windows.
 
Have you tried using FreeNAS/OpenFiler on your existing WHS hardware? Size and 'you don't have to build it' are the only real advantages of prebuilt NAS boxes, and you pay a lot for them in performance, money, flexibility or all 3.
 
Fast. Good. Cheep. Pick two. Thats the rule for NAS. I have yet to find a good compromise, but I'm leaning toward QNAP atm.

*subscribed*
 
Back
Top