Are Google Maps Good or Evil?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What do you guys think? Are Google Maps (Street View) good, bad or neither? Are you concerned that anyone on the internet can see your house, cars and family via Street View?

On the other side was the announcement of CriminalSearches.com, a new service from PeopleFinders.com that said it shows where "sex offenders...thieves, violent offenders, murderers, or con artists" live in your neighborhood. The site shows people icons on a Google map; clicking an icon shows a person's photo, description, address, and criminal history.
 
Privacy wise? HORRIBLE. I can't stand it. Blows me away how close people can get to you and find where you live. AMAZING some people have the balls to do something like this!

If *I* am looking for someplace? Awesome. Thanks for the help! :)

I like the whole sex offenders thing. VERY VERY Welcome in my book. The more people know where these people are, the better.

Personally, I'd like to see the streetviews done only in business area's, rather than residential. It can be helpful, but I'm not really looking up how to get directions to my MySpace stalked 9th grader...
 
What is worse, somebody using Street View to take a look at things or someone physically going to your residence?
 
Hmmmm, someone is taking public records, making a database, and letting you know if your neighbor was convicted of murder. I like it. If Streetview was updated by the hour, yeah i would have a prblem with it.
 
Whatever it's just a picture. It's not like Google is spying on you. If someone wants to know what your house looks like, or find out where you live, if they have your address then they'll find out anyway. If they dont have your address, it's not like they are going to print out a picture book of the united states and take a magnifying glass and try to find you based on your picture.
Basically, it's much more helpful than hurtful. People just like to make a big deal out of it because it's easier to take a stand on an internet company taking pictures of your street for navigation purposes than it is to take a stand on more important, touchy issues.
 
Didn't read the article because no matter what I support Google taking over as much of the Internet and any related technologies as possible in as little time as possible. Can't wait until I can fire up Googlefox and double-click Googlenet, type in "my neighbour's wife naked" and get a live cam feed from their shower.
 
I'm all for it. It's a very useful tool in the sense that you can "know before you go". It's not that big of a privacy concern to me, because it's not doing anything that a person is unable to do. If I have an address, and a GPS unit, I can find my way to a house and take a look. They aquired the photos by means of a car, which is something you and I could do as well.

It's not evil.
 
People are so paranoid... they most likley dont know but your home pictures can be found years before even google existed... it's called the realestate market, adjusting, and tax agencies.

Anyways, maps have existed centuries before google

And sattelite imagery decades before google (years for the consumers)

All google did was bring these things together and make it a big deal... and now everyone is all up in arms about it as if this is some whole new concept.
 
just like everything else, it's a double edged sword, including a single edged sword.

hahah...

ANYWAY, it's great when finding people's houses since you would know what it look like and not have to find the number plate somewhere on the house. like when you use craigslist

it's also useful to see how the place look generally. It's very helpful to have extra information like this when going into places i havent been before.
 
I can't see the problem with a year-old picture of what people can see FROM THE STREET.

What on earth would give you the idea that something that can be seen from the street would be private?
 
People decry Google for invading their privacy, yet are totally complacent about some of the laws that have been put in place to essentially ensure that we will NOT have any privacy and can legally do nothing about it.

W. T. F. Is all I have to say to that. At least Google is trying to improve how you can figure out where you're going.
 
I'm confused as to how someone can consider this an invasion of privacy. Barring the Google van trespassing onto private property, there is nothing seen on street view that couldn't be seen...wait for it...FROM THE STREET.

If you want something to be private, here's a thought...make sure it's actually private, and don't do it/display it in view of passing motorists. Because it's just as easy for a random kid with a camera phone to post a picture of whatever it is you consider "private" should they happen to see it as they drive by.
 
I have no qualms with Street View. Like many others have said, they're not doing anything any other person couldn't do, anyone could walk by houses, take pics and post them. Besides, plenty of people have made their case with Google and had their residences removed from Street View, it's not as if they are unwilling to respect people's requests for what they perceive as privacy.
 
I do not have a problem with their "Street View", but they need to fix their directions. I've used it on multiple occasions where one or two steps were left out. Never had this problem with MapQuest or Yahoo Maps. Anyone else have this problem?
 
Street view has helped me quite a bit finding places I need to go. However, google maps can kiss my ass! It got me lost so baldy that I got tired of it and bought a GPS...
 
Google Maps with the hybrid view? Great for finding places. Streetview? Even better.

I used it to find the closest parking garage to the Downtown Chicago Apple store when I went down to get my new iPhone. Right around the corner from the Apple store.

Do I care about the privacy issues related to Streetview? No...it doesn't show anything someone can't see by driving by my house...so what's the big deal?

That criminal background check is interesting...especially the neighborhood watch...lots of minor offenses...most people don't have more than 1 or 2 items listed. Occasionally you find one with a listing longer than hell. Of course it all depends on where you live.
 
If someone can drive down that public street and see it for themselves in real life. Then tell me how the f-bomb is Google at large a problem?!
 
Dude people can only see your house if you give out your address.
 
Don't have a problem with the Street View. In fact, I have a bigger issue with the CriminalSearch. Where are the flags for people convicted of speeding, DWI, or wife-beaters?

I know, I'm weird compared to most people because I don't feel that it is my right to know my neighbor's criminal history. If they have done time and are out of jail, then they've "paid their penance" in the eyes of the law and should be view as any other citizen.... Otherwise, they need to fix the criminal system instead of putting out personal information for anyone to see and start denying people the right to live in certain communities, which is happening more often then I like.
 
As with most things, everything has a good and bad side. In itself, Street View is great.. but there are instances where things should not be in Street View, for example, clear shots through someone's windows, or if my wife's sunbathing in the yard.
 
Awesome! Apparently there are 143 sex offenders in my area. They actually show PICTURES of the people too...

I do agree however that if a person pays their sentence by law, they shouldn't have to be subject to something like this, unless they're a repeat offender
 
Reminds me of an inlaw who loathes Google. She hates them because anyone can search on her name or number and find everything about her. I tried to tell her that that is because it is all public information and you can get it through any search engine. "But, Google makes it too easy!".

Streets are the same thing. You have no right to privacy from the road. So what if people can see your house; they can drive by themselves and get more details than they can from Google Maps.

Plus, there's the hilarious Street View outtakes.
The flasher
[ur="http://googlesightseeing.com/2007/10/15/multi-vehicle-car-accident-captured-on-google-street-view/"]Car accident[/url]
Bicycle accident (with embarrassing play-by-play)

You'll note that on many of them, Google has actually REMOVED that portion of the road so that you can no longer see the images :(
 
No fuggen way! Dude.

My friend of mine on the list... had no idea. Bahahaha
 
Well, Scalia better go find that "Privacy" right in the constitution or this kind of shit can get way way out of hand.

Sounds funny at first, but the down side of big brother and all his private equivalent minions is way bad.
 
Love Google Maps, not a big fan of Streetview. Reason being-- sure, it's "public" in the sense that anyone driving by can see it, but there is a big difference between having to make the effort to be there in person (or send someone), versus just being able to look it up online at any time, from anywhere. I don't like the idea of Google having all of this information completely cross referenced-- not that there is anything particularly "private", but where is the line?

I think Streetview in commercial/industrial areas is a great idea. I think having it in residential areas is where the boundary starts getting pushed...

At the very least, Google should have to notify the area they're taking pictures of in advance. I live in LA and there are movie shooting notices all the time-- to inform people of possible traffic closures, and in residential areas, basically a "we're taking pictures of this area, so you might want to not sunbathe naked in the front yard that day" warning. I don't think holding Google to at LEAST that standard is too much to ask of a multi-billion dollar company.
 
Most of the arguments in this thread are fail.

Since it's "public" what's to stop Google from allowing realtime video feed of people's homes? Because according to almost anyone in this thread, such an invasion should be allowed because 'it is just like going to the house'. When in reality, in all realities, it is not.

It is not the same as going to someone's house and thus should not be treated the same.
 
Most of the arguments in this thread are fail.

Since it's "public" what's to stop Google from allowing realtime video feed of people's homes? Because according to almost anyone in this thread, such an invasion should be allowed because 'it is just like going to the house'. When in reality, in all realities, it is not.

It is not the same as going to someone's house and thus should not be treated the same.

I would like that very much, it would save me from buying a home security system as I an watch my home from work :D
 
Didn't read the article because no matter what I support Google taking over as much of the Internet and any related technologies as possible in as little time as possible. Can't wait until I can fire up Googlefox and double-click Googlenet, type in "my neighbour's wife naked" and get a live cam feed from their shower.

we can only dream :) LOLS
 
well im gonna paint a giant mural of a vacant lot and stick it in front of my house just to mess with the google guy when he drives past... :D
 
Love Google Maps, not a big fan of Streetview. Reason being-- sure, it's "public" in the sense that anyone driving by can see it, but there is a big difference between having to make the effort to be there in person (or send someone), versus just being able to look it up online at any time, from anywhere. I don't like the idea of Google having all of this information completely cross referenced-- not that there is anything particularly "private", but where is the line?

I think Streetview in commercial/industrial areas is a great idea. I think having it in residential areas is where the boundary starts getting pushed...

At the very least, Google should have to notify the area they're taking pictures of in advance. I live in LA and there are movie shooting notices all the time-- to inform people of possible traffic closures, and in residential areas, basically a "we're taking pictures of this area, so you might want to not sunbathe naked in the front yard that day" warning. I don't think holding Google to at LEAST that standard is too much to ask of a multi-billion dollar company.

I agree. I think streetview is fine how it is, but I believe this would be a "happy medium" to allow any people with legitimate concerns to "clean up their yard" before pics of it go on the intertubes for all to see.
 
Back
Top