Apple TV Selling Itself Short?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Apple TV is having a problem enlisting the support of Warner Bros, due to being too ‘cheap’. Apple set its rate at $.99 per TV show, a figure not comfortable for Warner.

"We think the rest of the studios will see the light and get on board pretty fast," Apple Chief Executive Steve Jobs said during his keynote address earlier this month.
 
There's a lot more going on with the new Apple TV than people might realize. In time, it'll become a big big thing for Apple, so if the TV studios don't pay attention and get on board right now even in spite of somewhat reduced pricing, they're going to find themselves missing out on a shitload of potential revenue very soon indeed.
 
Its Steve Jobs posturing. If they made the iPhone $50 bucks and cut his proft margins 80% he'd be crying too. He just wants his product to sell and will let other people make the sacrifice to make it happen.

Its not potential revenue. Its basically saying eat shit because that's all we'll let you eat from Apple's standpoint. Now if apple got a real cut of the profits they'd love to charge $5 bucks an episode.
 
Windows Media Center. Ceton CableCard tuner (if I ever get mine!). The ultimate TV.
 
lol how can they complain about $1 per episode when it's free on TV?

They wonder why people download...
 
Well, For the price to "rent" a TV show I say fuck Apple and go buy the DVD/BD Season and watch it next week should you not be able to get around to watching that episode within 24 hours. And then re-sell later and make part if not most of your initial investment back.
 
That does not make any sense... Think about all the shows that come in on your Cable TV service yet you don't pay anywhere near .99 each for those. Who the hell would you buy one show anyway!? Who watches only 1 episode of a series!?

The only thing I have ever purchased on iTunes was the last season of Stargate SG1 (for $30) and that was a purchase not a rental. They would post new episodes the day after they were aired.
 
Warner didn't have a been with just the pricing... they didn't like entire rental business model and I don't blame them.

The whole idea behind having TV shows on tap is that you can watch them whenever you wish. Paying $0.99 every single time you want to watch an episode per 24 hours is just plain stupid. The option to buy the episode outright and watch it whenever you wish would've been better.

With media boxes like the Xbox360, Apple TV just doesn't make sense.
 
lol how can they complain about $1 per episode when it's free on TV?

They wonder why people download...

Well it isn't about what you pay for it but I suspect what they are actually getting, remember that you may not pay directly for it on TV but someone does where as I suspect Apple is trying to squeeze the majors and out of that $0.99 they don't like the amount they are getting.
 
I still don't have much faith in AppleTV. It is going straight up against the vastly popular Xbox360, which already has a very well established user base, can play DVD's, can play games, has the zuneplace which imo has just as much product as iTunes, has access to Netflix, which no matter what Steve "do what i say" Jobs say will never be replaced.

What does AppleTV give me the 360 cannot?
 
Free on TV with advertising.

... that people pay to watch since it's on cable or satellite anymore on top of all that. Who the hell has a TV actually pulling OTA content, if anyone... nobody I know that's for sure.
 
I still don't have much faith in AppleTV. It is going straight up against the vastly popular Xbox360, which already has a very well established user base, can play DVD's, can play games, has the zuneplace which imo has just as much product as iTunes, has access to Netflix, which no matter what Steve "do what i say" Jobs say will never be replaced.

What does AppleTV give me the 360 cannot?

It can cost only $100. You are correct in that gamers, geeks, and the like won't be fawning over AppleTV. That being said, my parents want an easy way to stream netflix and listening to my mom's iTunes collection, and the AppleTV is right up their alley.

Would I trade my HTPC for AppleTV? Not in a million years. Is the average consumer willing to sacrifice capability for a lower entry point an ease of use? Time will tell, but I'm guessing yes.

Roku, AppleTV, GoogleTV, these are the future. The tech companies want a piece of the cable TV pie. More people are going without cable, and Apple is trying to pick up some of these people with the rentals. If you only watch 5-10 shows a month that aren't on the networks, the rentals become more attractive.
 
... that people pay to watch since it's on cable or satellite anymore on top of all that. Who the hell has a TV actually pulling OTA content, if anyone... nobody I know that's for sure.

My LCD has the following inputs: Custom HTPC, Wii, and Bunny Ears for OTA TV
 
I still don't have much faith in AppleTV. It is going straight up against the vastly popular Xbox360, which already has a very well established user base, can play DVD's, can play games, has the zuneplace which imo has just as much product as iTunes, has access to Netflix, which no matter what Steve "do what i say" Jobs say will never be replaced.

What does AppleTV give me the 360 cannot?


not a damn thing. Stick with 360.

I have a ps3 and a 360, thats all I need. Thought about getting one of these for the bed room but its really not worth it to me.
 
It can cost only $100. You are correct in that gamers, geeks, and the like won't be fawning over AppleTV. That being said, my parents want an easy way to stream netflix and listening to my mom's iTunes collection, and the AppleTV is right up their alley.

Would I trade my HTPC for AppleTV? Not in a million years. Is the average consumer willing to sacrifice capability for a lower entry point an ease of use? Time will tell, but I'm guessing yes.

Roku, AppleTV, GoogleTV, these are the future. The tech companies want a piece of the cable TV pie. More people are going without cable, and Apple is trying to pick up some of these people with the rentals. If you only watch 5-10 shows a month that aren't on the networks, the rentals become more attractive.

Ok, so you claim the ease of use and lower entry point will be the key selling points. But I will tell you this that you won't see much of these "ease of use" buyers come your way with out a way of playing a simple DVD player. Alot of these buyers who want easy use also want to play alot of their DVD's too with out adding another peice of hardware.

Plus is the 360 really that hard to use? My mom can even guide herself through it which is nothing short of a miracle.
 
not a damn thing. Stick with 360.

I have a ps3 and a 360, thats all I need. Thought about getting one of these for the bed room but its really not worth it to me.

haha I did find this responce pretty funny. The key thing for the AppleTV is it IS smaller and has a lower entry point.

I think with all the extra money through subscriptions someone might find themselves paying a boat load to use the AppleTV.
 
$0.99 is too 'cheap' .. for a rental. Really? These guys just overvalue themselves way too much. I'd might pay 0.50 for a purchase but only 0.25 for a rental, tops. The IP folks just keep pricing themselves out of the market then cry when there is so much 'infringement'. Either they are greedy or stupid, but my money is on both.
 
How much do cable companies pay for their materials? And on top of that, how much revenue do they get out of the commercials?
 
Warner didn't have a been with just the pricing... they didn't like entire rental business model and I don't blame them.

The whole idea behind having TV shows on tap is that you can watch them whenever you wish. Paying $0.99 every single time you want to watch an episode per 24 hours is just plain stupid. The option to buy the episode outright and watch it whenever you wish would've been better.

With media boxes like the Xbox360, Apple TV just doesn't make sense.

Realistically, what proportion of consumers watch the same episode of a TV Series, more than once? A rental model makes much more sense. You can catch up on a few episodes of a show or series that you missed out on, for very little cost and then carry on watching it live.

Personally, I will save quite a bit when iTunes moves over to a TV rental model in the UK.
 
I am an OTA user, as well. I'll give them my money when I can watch what I want, when I want. The ads don't bother me, its the having to wait until a specific time on a specific date that bothers me.
 
Subscription or GTFO. I'd pay $50/mo to watch all my shows on demand in HD, but they'd have to offer at least a two season backlog.
 
The whole idea behind having TV shows on tap is that you can watch them whenever you wish. Paying $0.99 every single time you want to watch an episode per 24 hours is just plain stupid. The option to buy the episode outright and watch it whenever you wish would've been better.
.

The exact same week Apple announced .99 cent ABC/FOX TV ep rentals from iTMS ....Amazon started *selling* their Video on Demand ABC/Fox/BBC library for .99 each? I picked the latest seasons of Lost and Futurama, in 720p for $1.00 per episode. It's in my "Video Library" cloud and I can access them anytime I want via the web, BD player or Roku.

IMO, buying an AppleTV is a sucker bet and I think Warner Bros knows it.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
it more or less sounds like apple coming and trying to grab any content they can, they know they're already beat by other suppliers, if they get their hands on anything they will drown out the other subscribors with advertising.
 
I might be the only person here who finds the new AppleTV appealing. I don't have a 360 or PS3, I game only on PC. While I have a HDMI cable ran to my tv, I can't dedicate the TV and PC to one task, all the time.
I want Netflix on my tv, and to stream video files.. that's it. The AppleTV is the ONLY device at $100 or less that streams Netflix and local content from your PC. Albeit in H246 MP4s only.

The other options are a Roku box, which does not do local streaming, and the WD Live TV Plus, which is $120 on Amazon. Unless Roku adds local streaming, for someone like me, the WD box and the AppleTv are the only decent options. The iTunes store, and Apple integration is nothing to spit at, and I believe there is a lot more going on in the future with this device than people know.

I don't care about having a Bluray or DVD player. I rip all my current movies from their discs. I'm not too anal about having Bluray quality either.. but I'm in the definite minority with my friends on that issue. I also dislike TV in general and only enjoy movies, while most of my friends MUST have the latest episodes immediately, I have no problem waiting for the season to be over and getting the DVD or streaming it on Netflix.

One thing is for sure, I refuse to pay for cable or satellite when the programming is so stupid and brain dead. I do like a GOOD sitcom or movie, but overall I think time is better spent reading a book to enhance my mind's ability to function.

Nothing wrong with having fun but I think people need to step back and focus less on the media swirl of tv/movies coming at them and spend more time investing in themselves. Once you do that, the AppleTV is plenty of entertainment. Most of my friends are far too obsessed with shows on TV, and honestly I think it's dumbed them down as people. The average person will laugh at a really, really stupid joke on a very mediocre sitcom (and no, I'm not entirely humorless). :) We really do need less TV and media in our lives and hopefully a combination of the collapse + high prices will push people that way. The library is free!
 
Back
Top