Apple Slams Proposed E-Book Settlement

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
To say Apple is "not pleased" with the Justice Department's proposed settlement would be an understatement.

The proposed settlement -- with Lagardere SCA's Hachette Book Group, News Corp.'s HarperCollins Publishers, and Simon & Schuster (owned by CBS, which publishes CNET) -- requires the three e-book publishers to terminate their existing contracts with Apple. Apple, which denied the Justice Department's allegations, said the publishers' settlement unfairly impacts Apple and would be "irreversible."
 
Apple may be in the right on this one. Granted, what amounts to artificially inflating the prices was pretty anti consumer, what company isn't these days, but the way the DOJ went about this is pretty strong arm. "Let the courts figure this one out." or that is what I would say if we were able to find a judge that is not bought and paid for.
 
Apple, which denied the Justice Department's allegations, said the publishers' settlement unfairly impacts Apple and would be "irreversible."

Poor Apple, doesn't like surface rot. :(
 
I find it funny that Apple is whining about being on the other end of their tactics.

I get their point, losing contract rights aka fees/penalties they would collect if contract was broken with out government intervention. Also that other companies deals effect Apple (though this is hypocrisy on Apple's part).

Yet this is essentially what Apple did when they got the publishers on the Agency Model (well except for the contract loss part). They got the publishers to negate and renegotiate any contracts with ALL other vendors. Apple swung their power stick just as much as Amazon.

Individually and by themselves both the Agency and Wholesale models are decent models, each has upsides and downsides. Apple imo manipulated the market to position themselves better then their competitors and negated any market benefit of Amazon for being "first" and "cheapest".

Everyone talks about Amazon's power and monopoly in the ebook business, but yet seem to ignore Apple's power as well. Apple was able to get all the big publisher to negate their contracts (what ever they were) with Amazon and others and switch to the Agency deal. That is power, considering the publishers probably aren't making much more after then before.

Apple operates on a high profit margin, they don't do loss leaders, or small margins. 30% is probably near the bottom of acceptable profit margin for Apple. So instead of competing with Amazon, which they could easily have done. They arranged the deal with the publishers to protect their 30% and force everyone else to play the same game.

Look at the numbers...

9.99 was the general price of a book at Amazon before Agency pricing... Very common assumption that Amazon was selling at cost or slightly below. Thus we may assume the wholesale price was ~9.99 on average.

Those same books are now 12.99, which what do you know is essentially 30% more, hmmm for some reason is odd that this is roughly 30% more. Is it coincidence that Apple generally collects 30%.

So the publishers probably didn't get more per book (maybe a bit), and Amazon was restricted from selling at cost (price is their "thing") and have to compete directly with Apple with the same price.

Hmmm how is this NOT Apple manipulating the market?
 
Apple may be in the right on this one. Granted, what amounts to artificially inflating the prices was pretty anti consumer, what company isn't these days, but the way the DOJ went about this is pretty strong arm. "Let the courts figure this one out." or that is what I would say if we were able to find a judge that is not bought and paid for.

Actually, Apple is guilty of something called "price-fixing", which is, in fact, a crime.
 
unfairly impacts Apple? So kind of like any settlement that gets struck against you?
 
Everytime Apple gets pissy it brings a tear to my eye. A tear of joy. But only one. I want to be crying with chears, though.
 
Jobsuckers conspicuously missing from this thread...
 
Apple can go cry me a river.

The government came down on them like a bag of $50 hammers for price fixing.

Apple is NOT the aggrieved party here.
 
Actually, Apple is guilty of something called "price-fixing", which is, in fact, a crime.

First, I don't question your post. I agree with it (but not the usual Apple is Evil bullshit that usually comes up in these threads).

So is the entire industry, but one seems to question when the cost of Gas, by all companies, goes up at the same time and costs the same.

Or when all the Cereal companies raise prices by the same amount at the same time.

Or, and I love this one, when companies like Microsoft, HP, And Apple, and seemingly half the other companies out there have MAP pricing (Minimum Advertised Pricing) they force their re-sellers to abide by or lose marketing funds as punishment.

There is SO much price fixing in this country, if everyone was sued it would take decades to even make a dent in it.
 
Apple's contracts can be negated as part of a settlement because they're accused of price fixing. If 3 of 5 publishers want to settle with DOJ they're perfectly able to do so. Apple may scream and yell about it but there's really nothing they can do about it.

Amazon's policy was that best sellers could be classified as "loss leaders". A loss leader is a policy where you price something at or below cost to get people in the door. A big box store will do this all the time. They have a big sale on something relatively minor to get people into the store. Once there, people purchase other things at the same time. The premise is that the other things they purchase are going to generate more profits than the loss they take on the sale items. Amazon would sell best-sellers at a loss or no profit on the basis that they would keep you in their ecosystem and you'd buy more books in the future at their normal price. Amazon, and others, also would have sales from time to time. If a new book came out by an author they could run a sale on other books by that author so instead of buying one you would buy 5-6 and read them all. I've picked up a few books from Kobo on sales like that at 2.99 and 3.99. Under the agency model you're not allowed to do that, ever, unless the publisher wants to let you and they rarely do.

As anyone involved in the tech industry knows, Apple rarely has sales or runs any sort of variation in its pricing. For them, the price is the price, period. If you don't like it go someplace else. Amazon was the dominant player and Apple's planned book store wasn't going to go anywhere if Amazon was selling its best sellers at a loss. No way is anyone going to show up and buy something in the iBook store if they can get it on Amazon for 30% less. Apple knew that and refused to enter into a market they knew they couldn't win. Only way around that was to change the market. They met with all the industry reps to come to an agreement that the agency model would be forced on everyone. After all, Apple would fail from the beginning if they tried to use agency pricing while Amazon continue to use retail pricing. Jobs himself admitted in public that everyone would be forced to use the same pricing. This is a big black mark on Apple's case because it proves that the CEO knew full well he was involved in price fixing across an entire industry.

Since three of the five publishers have agreed to settle with DOJ we can assume that they'll have no problems furnishing DOJ with any documents they want to prove the case against Apple and the two remaining publishers. That is, after all, usually a condition of a settlement even if you don't have to admit to any sort of public "guilt". Apple is being very vocal because I suspect it is trying to convince the three publishers to fight the DOJ and not settle. If they come to a settlement agreement then it is very bad for the case going forward for the remaining people (Apple included). Basically, this is not unlike a theft trial. If they offer your buddy a plea bargain and he takes it then you know your case is fucked because he'll be telling the jury everything you did. Apple has three of its five conspirators ready to side with the DOJ and spill the beans in court.
 
Apple's damages to the e-book market are "irreversible". They can go fuck off and I would be damned surprised to see even sheeple defending Apple in this matter considering their actions were highly anti-consumer in nature.
 
There's also the fact that Apple's (in their words) attempt to break Amazon's monopoly with agency pricing didn't actually work. Amazon is still the major player by far in the e-book market. They still control the lion's share of the sales despite the price fixing scheme attempt to end it. People like Amazon's ecosystem and that's that, no matter what others try to do to change it. Others (Barnes and Noble, Kobo, etc) have managed to cut their small percentage out of the market without having to fix prices at all. Apple was the only e-book seller that had to resort to price fixing to get their piece of the pie.
 
Apple has three of its five conspirators ready to side with the DOJ and spill the beans in court.

This is why Apple is throwing a fit. They though they where being clever enough to get around the price fixing laws, but they where wrong.

Apple has never been able to compete on price, so they either need a fixed market or a monopoly with high profit margins.
 
I hate those sneaky, screw-the-customer tactics. How long has Apple been playing that game? It reminds me of the sneaky pricing tactics by Ticketmaster... they should just include their "fees" in the ticket price...

in Apple's case though, maybe it should be the opposite, comparing costs with profit margin/fees. So the book costs 10$, plus Apple's 3$ convenience/service charge.
 
Oh please, like Apple is hurting financially.
I grew up really poor and now I have a problem with throwing things away, I can't stand to see someone throw food away, and no matter how much money I have stashed in the bank I feel and behave like I'm broke.

I think Apple was severely traumatized in the 90's when they nearly went bankrupt so they might have similar reactions no matter how much cash they stockpile. It's probably why they stockpile so much cash in the first place.
 
When a 10 year old book costs 7 dollars for the paperback and 16 dollars for the ebook there is a serious problem somewhere.
 
If the contract is terminated, surely that just means another fair deal? Unless they were doing something underhanded... Oh..
 
If anyone has noticed, on Amazon the books that have the price set by the publisher higher than what Amazon wants have a caveat on the price. It says "This price was set by the publisher". It is right below the publisher's name in the "Sold By" field. Nice little way for Amazon to say ... don't like it, complain to the publisher. The ones that don't have the same restrictions are sold by Amazon and the prices drop significantly.
 
When a 10 year old book costs 7 dollars for the paperback and 16 dollars for the ebook there is a serious problem somewhere.

99 cents - $2 on eBay, .50 cents for shipping even better :D

25 cents at a garage sale if you are lucky to find it at one!
 
Back
Top