paradoxical
Limp Gawd
- Joined
- May 5, 2013
- Messages
- 320
You aren't going to get the exact same dimensions with the macbook because most aren't going with the same screen aspect ratio as apple. the 15" XPS lineup differs from the 14" macbook by 0.1", 0.2" and 1.2" and that sounds pretty comparable to me given you can find those kinds of discrepancies between different non apple manufacturers for the same size category. The real difference is weight, mainly because of cooling needs. As for ports, even apple cut back on the thunderbolt ports to offer more variety of built in ports. And I don't think they are wrong for doing that.
There's always trade offs. Like the apple trackpad is just the best track pad implementation out there and there's no arguing with that. You use it a lot and it is front and center. You WILL notice it. On the other hand, osx multi monitor support is a hot steaming pile aggravated by trying to turn basic functionality into a tiered option. If you are doing hoteling or hybrid work, you are going to notice that... a lot. Things will vary. I think a LOT of people will have a hard time finding the value proposition in $6k laptop.
I'm not sure what you are talking about with multi-monitor support in OSX, it's absolutely wonderful - and window management is a joy with tools like BetterSnapTool. I have three primary work locations: my desk on floor 2, my desk on floor 3, and my home office. At each desk I have identical setups:
Samsung G9 Neo 49in ultrawide on an ergotron arm
Alienware 34in OLED ultrawide on ergotron arm to the right of the G9 Neo (I regret these monitors BTW, text sucks)
iPad Pro front and center beneath the G9 NEO
Caldigit Thunderbolt 4 dock
The G9 Neo serves as my primary monitor. On the left side of the screen I have my company Notion with my to-do list. On the middle of the screen I have my main work browser/excel/Premiere/whatever window, which is wider than the side windows. On the right of the screen I have my inbox.
On the Alienware I have Slack, facebook messenger, and apple messenger which handles all of my comms. Then I have two browser windows with my ecommerce dashboards visible at all times.
The iPad Pro is a third monitor which works awesome with Apple's native integration and has my daily calendar view front and center.
This an incredibly productive workflow and all of this is connected to my MBP with a single thunderbolt 4 cable. I can seamlessly get up and walk to any of my desks, plug in, and all of my windows even snap right to their defined locations I set with BetterSnapTool.
Further, when I am traveling for work I bring the iPad Pro 12.9 with me and always have a second monitor wherever I am that seamlessly is integrated into my workflow. It's incredibly powerful, and nothing on Windows is as seamlessly integrated.
I don't know who would spend $6k on a MacBook Pro. The reality is that the M2 Max with 32GB of ram and the base 1TB is enough for like 99% of people unless you're that specific person in very specific industries where you basically need the 96GB of RAM for the GPU. If you need more storage upgrading the internal NVME doesn't make much sense anyways. You'll just have a thunderbolt drive, network storage, etc.
When you look at the price of basically the base M2 Max build it's actually pretty competitive compared to the PC market choices, and of course is far more portable and useable on battery.
Of course, if you do actually have the money to blow the max RAM/storage spec MacBook Pro offers a far more impressive package that is actually portable & useable on battery compared to anything on the PC laptop side. No PC laptop is going to have 96GB of RAM for the GPU, and be able to work at full-tilt for a reasonable period of time on only battery.
The reason I always go for the 8TB SSD is because that allows me to keep my entire company's Dropbox local on my machine and not on the cloud. The only thing I don't have locally is our 20TB of specialty engineering data. Having everything stored locally (all marketing videos, production media, photos, etc) allows me to be much more productive on airplanes or in hotels with shit internet.
Last edited: