Apple’s Announcements

They just want you to buy more of their crap - Oh, here we have FW adapters for $50! Come and get them!
 
lol waits for the dreaded nvidia chipset instabilities to surface.........lol
 
So a craptacular trackpad + 2 mouse buttons > every trackpad apple has ever released ever. :p (no, but seriously Apple, one button mice are clearly fail, get over it already, yeesh)

First off, multibutton mice have worked in OS X with no drivers ever since I started using it. My first Mac in 2002 was used with a five button Intellimouse Explorer 3.0, no drivers, just plugged it in right out of the box. Just because they package a one button mouse in the box doesn't mean you have to use it (mine was never unwrapped), or that the software can't support it (it can).

As for the trackpad, its called multitouch, look into it. One finger and a click is left click, two fingers and a click is right click, has been for a while. It works great. The only difference now is that instead of being restricted to clicking with your thumb, you can just do it with your finger. Or if you really want to thumb click out of habit you can still click the bottom of the trackpad just like you used to, same difference since the whole thing is a button. Hell, I just saw in a screenshot showing that you can even assign a corner of the trackpad to act as right click if you want. If you really want right click where your "craptacular trackpad" has it and for some ridiculous reason you just hate the idea of multitouch, just assign right click it to the lower right corner and your done.

Programmable multitouch trackpads have a lot of advantages. Pinching can resize photos and text, three finger swipes act as backwards and forwards in web browsers and other applications like Finder or whatever, and now four finger swipes activate expose and the alt-tab application switcher, depending on the motion. Most of this stuff even works in Vista thanks to the Boot Camp drivers, its really cool.

Sorry dude, once again you fail. The multitouch trackpad is actually one of the best thing about those notebooks, leaves every other trackpad interface in the dust.
 
lol waits for the dreaded nvidia chipset instabilities to surface.........lol

Dude, no kidding. Every nvidia mobo I've had has been nvidia ever since they came out (best AMD boards for a long time, remember the VIA?) and I've had no problems, but I feel like I've dodged a bullet all this time. We'll see how these all shake out with the new notebooks.
 
Disgusting ....

Pros to Macbook:
LED
nVidia
Penryn
DDR3 (although minor)

Cons:
No firewire????
$200 MORE????

The four changes above are completely evolutionary. Evolutionary changes in this day and age shouldn't raise the price. The Macbook has been scarcely upgraded at all since its release. The new body style shouldn't be accompanied by a ridiculous hike in price. I am impressed with the nice looking LED screens, but they take away your firewire port and don't even replace it with a third USB.

I'm skipping this generation for sure. I love my Macbook, but if it died right now I certainly wouldn't be replacing it with one of these new expensive ones. I'm not impressed. The Penryn and DDR3 can't be costing Apple enough to justify a $200 price hike. That's not the way the computer business works. I honestly hope people don't buy them until the price comes down.

Fail. (sorry if I sound a bit harsh ... long day at work!)
 
Heh a cheap 24" thats still more than 2 times the price of a store bought 24"

Yeah you can buy a 24" monitor for about $300 these days but it won't perform anywhere as well (Nor look half as good I should add). It's like saying I can buy a 4 door Civic for $15k, why does this 4 door M3 cost $60k? They serve different purposes and perform much differently. I doubt anyone can confirm this yet but in all likelihood it uses the same beautiful H-IPS panel as the 24" Imac, which uses the same panel as the $1k NEC 24". It also has a glossy screen which no other high quality 24" in the U.S. currently uses to my knowledge. The only other decent glossy 24" I know of is the Hazro and it isn't a USDM product. I know some professional imagers frown upon glossy screens but in my experience it doesn't alter saturation enough on the Imacs to warrant any major problems while printing (Nothing beyond a few tweaks, which you'd have to do anyway since no LCD I've ever used has ever displayed colors as they are printed) so I doubt it will with this monitor either. It'll just look gorgeous as the Imac does. I'm not a huge fan of Apple's normal price gouging but this monitor is actually a pretty good deal compared to the competition right now.
 
Disgusting ....

Pros to Macbook:
LED
nVidia
Penryn
DDR3 (although minor)

Cons:
No firewire????
$200 MORE????

Add two pros: backlit keyboard and multitouch trackpad. Aluminum case instead of plastic is a subjective pro.

Subract one big pro: you need to knock Penryn off that list since those were added earlier this year.

And yeah, I agree, everything is all mid and high range now while the bottom end is represented by the old Macbook with a measly $100 price drop. Crappy. Compared to the value you usually get with a product refresh (hell, the aluminum iMacs were introduced last year as $200-$400 cheaper across the board than the prior plastic ones), this was pretty disappointing. I understand that going all carved aluminum and glass and everything isn't cheap, but it leaves no room for the low end. I'd have been a bit happier if they at least knocked the old Macbook an additional $100 or so.
 
Add two pros: backlit keyboard and multitouch trackpad. Aluminum case instead of plastic is a subjective pro.

Subract one big pro: you need to knock Penryn off that list since those were added earlier this year.

And yeah, I agree, everything is all mid and high range now while the bottom end is represented by the old Macbook with a measly $100 price drop. Crappy. Compared to the value you usually get with a product refresh (hell, the aluminum iMacs were introduced last year as $200-$400 cheaper across the board than the prior plastic ones), this was pretty disappointing. I understand that going all carved aluminum and glass and everything isn't cheap, but it leaves no room for the low end. I'd have been a bit happier if they at least knocked the old Macbook an additional $100 or so.

Exactly! I don't know what their deal is. The $1099 Macbook has never been worth more than $850. Look at what you sacrifice when you drop from the old $1299 Macbook to the $1099 Macbook:

$1299 (old)
2.4GHz
2GB DDR2
160GB HD
DVD/RW

$1099 (old)
2.1GHz (300MHz 12.5% slower)
1GB DDR2 (half)
120GB HD (33% less)
DVD reader CD Burner (no dvd burning on an ELEVEN HUNDRED DOLLAR LAPTOP?? WTF!!!)

$850. They should never have charged more than that. Any Windows notebook over $400 can at least burn a DVD. How the crap are you going to burn all those movies you made in iMovie without a DVD burner?? And when you backup your 30GB iTunes music library, what are you supposed to put that on ... CDs? Let's see ... 45 CD's later (which would probably wear out the drive by then) your iTunes library is backed up. Oh, and you're going to have to get an external HD for any movies you bought via the iTunes store. They won't fit on a CD ...

Isn't it magnanimous of Apple to reduce the price by $100. I hope you guys all go out and by this "value-priced" Mac. It's a steal now.
 
They have to keep the ~40% profit margin they've maintained since roughly 1984 with the intro of the first Mac... nothing new to see here folks, move along... move along...
 
They have to keep the ~40% profit margin they've maintained since roughly 1984 with the intro of the first Mac... nothing new to see here folks, move along... move along...

Obama should consider deploying windfall taxes on Apple :p
 
Lol, I'm actually disappointed then. I thought the Fleshlight should at least have something to do with X-Rays.
 

It does have a DVD burner. Otherwise I agree with your post. Hopefully they get a decent option to fill in the bottom end with the refresh next year, because they left that way behind with this last round of updates. Its much closer to the old 12" Powerbook than a Macbook that should really run in price between $1000-$1200. I guess sales are good enough where it does matter, but it sucks that they're leaving such a big hole there (not as sucky as entirely cutting out matte screens on the MBP though!)
 
It does have a DVD burner. Otherwise I agree with your post. Hopefully they get a decent option to fill in the bottom end with the refresh next year, because they left that way behind with this last round of updates. Its much closer to the old 12" Powerbook than a Macbook that should really run in price between $1000-$1200. I guess sales are good enough where it does matter, but it sucks that they're leaving such a big hole there (not as sucky as entirely cutting out matte screens on the MBP though!)

"SuperDrive 8x (DVD±R DL/DVD±RW/CD-RW)"

You're right. Finally. Two years late, and still too expensive.

I sure am soured on the lack of a firewire port, too. I would rather buy the $1000 one and upgrade the crap out of it just to have firewire. I like the new looks, but only two USBs.

This is freaking 2008. Has Apple ever heard of eSATA?

What the elf?? Apple = "teh suck"

(and this is coming from an Apple fan with a Macbook, three iPods, and an iMac I recently sold to a friend!!!)
 
"SuperDrive 8x (DVD±R DL/DVD±RW/CD-RW)"

You're right. Finally. Two years late, and still too expensive.

I sure am soured on the lack of a firewire port, too. I would rather buy the $1000 one and upgrade the crap out of it just to have firewire. I like the new looks, but only two USBs.

This is freaking 2008. Has Apple ever heard of eSATA?

What the elf?? Apple = "teh suck"

(and this is coming from an Apple fan with a Macbook, three iPods, and an iMac I recently sold to a friend!!!)

I got my hands on them today and its weird, the Macbook isn't so much a "low end" Mac notebook as it is the successor to the 12" Powerbook that was discontinued a while ago. Same deal as before: it matches the Macbook Pro features like the aluminum case, the multitouch trackpad, backlit keyboard, and a GPU that can do more than just drive a desktop. In this respect it isn't that bad, in that the much demanded 12" Powerbook has in fact finally returned (and cheaper than the ~$1700 those machines were), they just decided to call it a Macbook.

For a true low-end Mac notebook to fit the sub $1300 range though, its kind of a mess.

Seeing them in person kind of confirmed my initial thoughts, which is that they left the low end far behind in this refresh. That said, I can easily see a fair number of people willing to drop an additional $200 or so for the physical extras you get. The real kick in the balls though is that the $1000 Macbook has Firewire and the new one doesn't, which is hilarious since you can actually run Final Cut Studio on the new Macbook now! Hilarious, that would have been such an ideal pro rig alternative for so many people.

At the very least, the $2500 Macbook Pro from before Tuesday's keynote now sells for $1500 new (get them while they last). IMO it is well worth it, especially since you get a matte screen option, the ability to run Final Cut/Photoshop/Lightroom/3D games/whatever for a lot less money, and you get a machine that is only marginally slower than the new models that were just introduced. As much as I really love the new trackpad (the new gestures are great, and you can assign a corner for right click on top of the old "two fingers for right click" move), it isn't nearly enough for me to sell my MBP that is only six months old. I'll be keeping it for a long while.

Now that I think about it, my next machine in two years will probably be something more along the lines of the Macbook Air. After checking out the machines today it hit me that it really is the form factor that I want the most. Something with the power of the current Macbook Pros but in a 3lb sheet of aluminum. Considering how far GPUs and subnotebook storage will be by then, I think it'll happen. Its great because honestly, I'm over hauling "big" notebooks around. I put big in quotes because the Macbook Pro and Macbooks are lightweights compared to most other laptops out there, but man, I can't wait until I'm not even aware that I'm carrying that thing in my bag. If I wasn't so power/storage hungry I'd just get an Air now and be done with it.

On a side note, the new trackpad feels nothing like I was expecting it to. I was expecting a slick surface like the iPhone but it actually feels exactly like the old trackpad, same friction and grip and everything. I guess the long term advantage of making it glass is that you get none of the wear on it like you would most other plastic trackpads after several years of use. Makes sense for long term durability.

Anyhoo, yeah, pricing is definitely in a weird place right now.
 
And to go completely off topic, ALL YOU FOOLS NEED TO BE PLAYING DEAD SPACE.

HOLY CRAP.
 
I agree with Serpico here. JUMP on the older Macbook Pros. I own the 2.5 ghz 15" model. I dropped 2000 EU (I live in Germany as an opera singer), and I went over and picked one up for my wife refurbed for $1643 SHIPPED. She will have a MBP now and is quite happy. We have family in Texas (I am from Fort Worth) and her new beauty will be waiting for her in Nov-Dec when she visits for the holidays. I have performances so I won't see America till April :(

I find the refresh to be much ado about nothing for the MBP, and the MB is a little overpriced for what you get. The Macbook Air is MUCH more interesting with a 9400M in it. It actually packs quite a punch for it's size (both power wise, and to your wallet;)). Still, this refresh makes me that much happier I bought my MBP two months ago.

On a side note, as a formal Apple basher, this thing is gorgeous. It is so light, so well laid out, and when adding up features is really only a couple hundred more than an equivalently equipped Notebook. Plus, being able to run Windows simultaneously in VMWare or separately from my Boot Camp Partition makes this the Swiss Amy knife of notebooks. Well worth the money in my opinion.
 
I got my hands on them today and its weird, the Macbook isn't so much a "low end" Mac notebook as it is the successor to the 12" Powerbook that was discontinued a while ago. Same deal as before: it matches the Macbook Pro features like the aluminum case, the multitouch trackpad, backlit keyboard, and a GPU that can do more than just drive a desktop. In this respect it isn't that bad, in that the much demanded 12" Powerbook has in fact finally returned (and cheaper than the ~$1700 those machines were), they just decided to call it a Macbook.

For a true low-end Mac notebook to fit the sub $1300 range though, its kind of a mess.

Seeing them in person kind of confirmed my initial thoughts, which is that they left the low end far behind in this refresh. That said, I can easily see a fair number of people willing to drop an additional $200 or so for the physical extras you get. The real kick in the balls though is that the $1000 Macbook has Firewire and the new one doesn't, which is hilarious since you can actually run Final Cut Studio on the new Macbook now! Hilarious, that would have been such an ideal pro rig alternative for so many people.

At the very least, the $2500 Macbook Pro from before Tuesday's keynote now sells for $1500 new (get them while they last). IMO it is well worth it, especially since you get a matte screen option, the ability to run Final Cut/Photoshop/Lightroom/3D games/whatever for a lot less money, and you get a machine that is only marginally slower than the new models that were just introduced. As much as I really love the new trackpad (the new gestures are great, and you can assign a corner for right click on top of the old "two fingers for right click" move), it isn't nearly enough for me to sell my MBP that is only six months old. I'll be keeping it for a long while.

Now that I think about it, my next machine in two years will probably be something more along the lines of the Macbook Air. After checking out the machines today it hit me that it really is the form factor that I want the most. Something with the power of the current Macbook Pros but in a 3lb sheet of aluminum. Considering how far GPUs and subnotebook storage will be by then, I think it'll happen. Its great because honestly, I'm over hauling "big" notebooks around. I put big in quotes because the Macbook Pro and Macbooks are lightweights compared to most other laptops out there, but man, I can't wait until I'm not even aware that I'm carrying that thing in my bag. If I wasn't so power/storage hungry I'd just get an Air now and be done with it.

On a side note, the new trackpad feels nothing like I was expecting it to. I was expecting a slick surface like the iPhone but it actually feels exactly like the old trackpad, same friction and grip and everything. I guess the long term advantage of making it glass is that you get none of the wear on it like you would most other plastic trackpads after several years of use. Makes sense for long term durability.

Anyhoo, yeah, pricing is definitely in a weird place right now.

Good input. That's exactly what I'd do right now if my Macbook died. I would nab one of those MBP's for the reduced price. We'll still be able to get refurbs for sometime, because they'll get them back for repairs and such. I don't know if this Macbook will die. Now that the keyboard has been replaced (back when it was new) along with a few other internal parts, the battery, and the optical drive, it seems pretty solid. If it doesn't die, yay. It's a good little laptop for school.

Yeah, I agree with Serpico on this one.
 
I'd rather have a 2408WFP then one of those Apple 24", cheaper with more features. $899 for a 24" seems a tad...ridiculous, but then again I guess that Dell won't have the Apple logo :D

On the surface, it does seem that way. However, if you ever have a chance to look at one of the Apple Cinema Displays next to another monitor you will notice a difference.

And I own three 24" Dell's....
 
I think this time round the Macbook is the clear winner in terms of value regardless of having a poorer screen and lack of FW. The Pros are for pros but everyone else could use a MB. Once the MB ages a bit and drops in price or the old style one gets bumped off at that price point and replaced with the new its value will show. Until then, buy the MBP from the refurb store.
 
The backlighting on the Dell 24's I have are noticably uneven. It gets the job done, but I definitely see the value going Apple + LED backlight.
 
The backlighting on the Dell 24's I have are noticably uneven. It gets the job done, but I definitely see the value going Apple + LED backlight.

That and it uses a P-MVA panel, comes with inverse ghosting and other artifacts, all sorts of fun stuff.
 
Apple had the perfect opportunity to introduce better ACDs. Instead, they leave us with a singular, over-priced, typical one-way-or-the-highway SMUG Apple product.

Idiots.
 
Apple had the perfect opportunity to introduce better ACDs. Instead, they leave us with a singular, over-priced, typical one-way-or-the-highway SMUG Apple product.

Idiots.

Assuming that it is using the same H-IPS panel in the NEC 2490WUXi and the 24" iMac, its actually an ok deal considering that the NEC runs $1100, plus it has a webcam/speakers/mic built in.

Considering that most people will be comparing its price with other MVA or TN panels out there, I don't know if it will matter much though.
 
Back
Top