Apple Forces Largest-Ever Kickstarter Refund

Let me break this down for you :

1.I own physical property
2.My rights of ownership over that physical property give me the natural right to arrange that physical property in any way I see fit so long as it does not aggress upon another person (e.g. building a spotlight and shining it on your neighbors property).
3.Imaginary property is a violation of physical property rights. How can one truly claim to own physical property when simply arranging that physical property in a certain fashion subjects you to government-sanctioned violence and property seizure?
4.However hard someone worked on something is irrelevant. That is a utilitarian argument in which you are trying to justify an inherently unethical action (the act of committing violence against someone for arranging their property in a certain manner) on the basis that the consequences of the action are somehow beneficial.

The situation, obviously, is not that simple.
 
Let me break this down for you :

1.I own physical property
2.My rights of ownership over that physical property give me the natural right to arrange that physical property in any way I see fit so long as it does not aggress upon another person (e.g. building a spotlight and shining it on your neighbors property).
3.Imaginary property is a violation of physical property rights. How can one truly claim to own physical property when simply arranging that physical property in a certain fashion subjects you to government-sanctioned violence and property seizure?
4.However hard someone worked on something is irrelevant. That is a utilitarian argument in which you are trying to justify an inherently unethical action (the act of committing violence against someone for arranging their property in a certain manner) on the basis that the consequences of the action are somehow beneficial.

Let me break this down for you

1.Has no bearing on the subject.
2.You can arrange it in anyway you so choose. If you want to develop and use your own charger or interface yourself, you are perfectly within your rights to do so. You simply cannot sell it to others.
3.There is no 'imginary' property. A design is not 'imaginary'. It is very real, and very real work and time was put into it. As well as the efforts to design the manufacturing for it. As well as collecting the materials and producing it.
4.No, it is not at all irrelevant, in fact it is the epitome of relevance. Your argument against it is even more ridiculous than your other claims. Violence has nothing to do with 'hard work'. That is about the dumbest attempt at correlation you could have made. Why someone may work hard at violence, one is not directly related to the other. Also how much one gets paid for how hard they work is subjective. The fact that someone worked hard to design something, is not. They designed it, fact. They made a product from that design, fact. They patented that product, fact. There is a system in place to define 'ownership' for patented designs, fact.
 
Over $100k to develop a charging station? I see that kind of thing on sale in Fry's all the time for $7.

Connectors...check
Voltage regulators...check
White cylinder to hold stuff...check

Not seeing the $100k part yet.
 
Let me break this down for you

1.Has no bearing on the subject.
2.You can arrange it in anyway you so choose. If you want to develop and use your own charger or interface yourself, you are perfectly within your rights to do so. You simply cannot sell it to others.
3.There is no 'imginary' property. A design is not 'imaginary'. It is very real, and very real work and time was put into it. As well as the efforts to design the manufacturing for it. As well as collecting the materials and producing it.
4.No, it is not at all irrelevant, in fact it is the epitome of relevance. Your argument against it is even more ridiculous than your other claims. Violence has nothing to do with 'hard work'. That is about the dumbest attempt at correlation you could have made. Why someone may work hard at violence, one is not directly related to the other. Also how much one gets paid for how hard they work is subjective. The fact that someone worked hard to design something, is not. They designed it, fact. They made a product from that design, fact. They patented that product, fact. There is a system in place to define 'ownership' for patented designs, fact.

1.It absolutely does.
2.Then I can't use it in anyway I chose, now can I? Part of owning physical property is the ability to sell it to other people.
3.The amount of time put into it does nothing to justify the act of aggression upon another person. Property rights derive from scarcity; an idea is not scarce because it can be instantiated and copied without depriving the original creator of the idea of the use of that idea. By contrast, if I take your car, you no longer have the use of that car.
4.It is violence because the state forcibly takes your property and will forcibly lock you up (sending thugs with guns after you) if you refuse to hand it over.
5.Rights do not come from the state; simply because the state says something does not make it right or correct. The only reason the state (another organized crime ring) stays in power is because they have more guns and more weapons of mass destruction and can rule by fear, intimidation and threat of violence.
 
Please, tell me in what way the Xbox is NOT the most open of all the game consoles?

Direct X?

Direct X is proprietary. It's bolted to Windows and the Windows libraries that support it. It's not cross-platform. OpenGL runs on iOS, Linux and Windows. It is "open" hence the name.
 
For the love of all things holy, would SOMEONE, somewhere PLEASE make a Win 8 RT device the size of my ipod 4g so I can get rid of this thing?
W3rd.

Although there's no reason why an Atom SoC device would cost any more to build than a similar ARM device, PC manufacturers need to protect existing lines. Any x86 == competition for bread and butter systems. So while an Atom Win8 (or Win7 or Linux or whatever) handheld would be quite useful, it's unlikely to happen at anywhere near iPod Touch prices.

Plus Windows is a bloated pig and the OS takes up many, many gee-bees. And it grows without limit for pretty dumb legacy decisions (WinSxS "solved" DLL-Hell, however inefficiently). You need lots of Flash/SSD storage and that's a main price differentiator in the handheld segment. Adding 8GB or 16GB = $100-$200 price increase over lower model. Moronic.

If I had a small touchscreen x86 handheld the size of the iPod Touch, even with a low netbook-like resolution of 1024x600, I'd be pretty happy (as long as it had some kind of digital video out).
 
Actually no, this is factually incorrect. Far less companies use proprietary standards these days. And mentioning the Xbox is funny, since it is the most open of all the game consoles. Also, it is particularly funny that you single out Microsoft, who made their money on opening up their OS to many standards and put money into developing industry standards. That is why the PC is so open while the Mac is so closed. But even Apple had to start adopting some of the standards that Microsoft helped fund, because of public demand.

Also, since the majority of the smart phone market belongs now to Android, and Android is essentially an open platform, I would disagree with your assertion. It is factually accurate for me to say that more companies produce Android based devices than produce iPhone and iPad devices...
What are you talking about?

The only royalty-free things on a modern PC are USB and DisplayPort.
All of the things that make a PC a "PC" are proprietary and that's certainly not what makes a "PC so open while the Mac is so closed" aside from the fact that PC's aren't particularly open. Other than the fact that OSX isn't supposed to be operated on non-Apple hardware and there are less aftermarket options for the Apple buying consumer the general public isn't even impacted by their so-called closed system.

But where it matters most, media consumption, games, production software DRM/activations, and every single device either soldered to your board, slotted, or plugged in there is a license fee being assessed for the "right" to do so.

In terms of android being open or not, I'm not aware of a single non-proprietary platform that uses it.


There are tons of posts in this thread that indicate people simply don't even know what goes on in behind the scenes and when they talk about open or closed systems they must be referring to how hard or easy it is to find a cheap knock-off product that works as well as the expensive one...although that's not saying much for the premium product rather than being a ringing endorsement of it in my opinion.
 
Direct X?

Direct X is proprietary. It's bolted to Windows and the Windows libraries that support it. It's not cross-platform. OpenGL runs on iOS, Linux and Windows. It is "open" hence the name.

Lol, how did I know this old argument was going to come up? Yes, Xbox does not support OpenGL currently. But find me the games that are designed solely off of OpenGL verse all the games that are designed off of DirectX. Also, contrary to many revisionist history buffs, Microsoft did not develop DirectX to kill OpenGL. DirectX was funded by Microsoft and designed to create an industry standard that all game developers and hardware developers could use a common tool. It was being developed at the same time as OpenGL and was meant to be a companion to it. Microsoft could have scrapped the DirectX initiative and gone with OpenGL, but DirectX was easier for game developers at the time, and hindsight is 20/20. So while yes, DirectX is proprietary in that Microsoft developed it as a standard, it wasn't developed to kill anything else. Of course nowadays it certainly is being leveraged in a battle against OpenGL. All that said, this case is completely different, considering it is free to incorporate and use DirectX. You as a consumer are not paying for it, game developers are not paying for it, and to my knowledge hardware manufacturers do not pay any license related to DirectX either. So I fail to see how this has any real bearing on the conversation?
 
What are you talking about?

The only royalty-free things on a modern PC are USB and DisplayPort.

But where it matters most, media consumption, games, production software DRM/activations, and every single device either soldered to your board, slotted, or plugged in there is a license fee being assessed for the "right" to do so.

Actually this is not true at all. There are tons of things in Windows that are freely licensed. There are plenty of open source projects within Windows as well. And it is fact that the real reason Windows won out over Apple is that Windows was a more open platform allowing many hardware vendors to make their own hardware to work with Windows. Certainly there were proprietary drivers, and certainly there are licenses, but in actuality far fewer licenses are paid for than offered for free within Windows. Note above where I talk about DirectX, which is licensed for free. Also note that many of the things you are listing as slotted or plugged in are developed by other companies other than Microsoft. And there are many reciprocal agreements between those companies and other companies to do "cross" licensing allowing those companies to use each other's technology for free as well.
 
Apple's actions are clearly monopolistic and anti-competitive. Before gutting by Republicans we used to have anti-trust and anti-competition laws.

Apple has been pulling the same shit for decades. I wanted to get into making addons for the Mac long ago, but Apple required a $100,000 fee up front before they would allow a 3rd party business to do that, Daystar at the time was the only small business with the extra cake to afford it, and hence the only 3rd party supplier of accelerators for example.

As far as I'm concerned Apple should have been prosecuted 100's of times for these violations, and Microsoft sitting in the holding cell with them. Imagine the progress in technology that has been thwarted by their conduct over the years in such matters.
 
Let me break this down for you :

1.I own physical property
2.My rights of ownership over that physical property give me the natural right to arrange that physical property in any way I see fit so long as it does not aggress upon another person (e.g. building a spotlight and shining it on your neighbors property).
3.Imaginary property is a violation of physical property rights. How can one truly claim to own physical property when simply arranging that physical property in a certain fashion subjects you to government-sanctioned violence and property seizure?
4.However hard someone worked on something is irrelevant. That is a utilitarian argument in which you are trying to justify an inherently unethical action (the act of committing violence against someone for arranging their property in a certain manner) on the basis that the consequences of the action are somehow beneficial.


Sorry but you're wrong. Just because you can buy a physical device, does not mean you have the rights to duplicate/produce copies and sell them for profit. Apple spent the time/money to design and implement a new connector for their next gen of devices. There is nothing imaginary about that.

The new connecor has a security chip to show it's a legit cable. Other companies shouldn't be able to purchase/use that chip without licensing it from apple (Clones coming out from China don't count). Apple has complete control over show they license to, and what the requirements are. So there is nothing wrong with what apple is doing, it's just shit policy to fuck the consumers and get more $.
 
DirectX was funded by Microsoft and designed to create an industry standard that all game developers and hardware developers could use a common tool.
The goal of DirectX was to make Windows a more viable gaming platform. From DirectX co-creator Alex St. John:
I realized that a major part of my job was to figure out how to use technology control to create economic force, or leverage, such that money and business flowed in Microsoft's direction, and people had to go [to them].
 
Apple's actions are clearly monopolistic and anti-competitive. Before gutting by Republicans we used to have anti-trust and anti-competition laws.

Btw, I hate to bring up facts, but antitrust laws were sponsored by Republicans to begin with. The exemptions (Unions, Banks, Insurance) to those laws have been sponsored by Democrats. But the whole ins and outs of who, what and why are actually fairly convoluted. Neither side is specifically against antitrust itself. So trying to pin antitrust and anti-competition on the Republicans is patently false.
 
Sorry but you're wrong. Just because you can buy a physical device, does not mean you have the rights to duplicate/produce copies and sell them for profit. Apple spent the time/money to design and implement a new connector for their next gen of devices. There is nothing imaginary about that.

The new connecor has a security chip to show it's a legit cable. Other companies shouldn't be able to purchase/use that chip without licensing it from apple (Clones coming out from China don't count). Apple has complete control over show they license to, and what the requirements are. So there is nothing wrong with what apple is doing, it's just shit policy to fuck the consumers and get more $.

The chip is bullshit, and its there for no fucking reason

The fact this guy could bypass it easily is proof of that.

A lightning USB cable costs $20, micro USB, which you can buy -ANYWHERE- for $2

It was fucking bad enough that you can't even charge cell phones via computer USB anymore and needed a charging dock, but this shit takes the cake

Glad they won't be relevant in 3 years
 
Sorry but you're wrong. Just because you can buy a physical device, does not mean you have the rights to duplicate/produce copies and sell them for profit. Apple spent the time/money to design and implement a new connector for their next gen of devices. There is nothing imaginary about that.

The new connecor has a security chip to show it's a legit cable. Other companies shouldn't be able to purchase/use that chip without licensing it from apple (Clones coming out from China don't count). Apple has complete control over show they license to, and what the requirements are. So there is nothing wrong with what apple is doing, it's just shit policy to fuck the consumers and get more $.

I don't recognize the state as the arbiter of rights (they are, after all, the biggest rights violator of them all).

The problem with utilitarian arguments is how easily they are twisted and how inconsistent they are.

To Wit :

1.Person A spends a lot of time devising a plan to break into an art museum and steal its paintings.
2.Person A invests a lot of money into the purchase of the equipment needed to pull off the aforementioned caper.
3.Person A successfully pulls off the robbery and is therefore entitled to take the property of the art museum because of the time and effort they spent coming up with and implementing a set of ideas to rob the museum.
 
The goal of DirectX was to make Windows a more viable gaming platform. From DirectX co-creator Alex St. John:

Nice quote, good job of linking the source as well. Btw, if you want to do more research, Alex St. John has said many conflicting remarks about the true purpose of DirectX. In fact in an interview for Joystiq he also said that it wasn't at all for gaming:

http://www.firingsquad.com/features/alexstjohn/

But from many hardware developers, game developers and Microsoft developers at the time that I talked with, the biggest problem was no industry standard to develop from. There were a number of different development platforms being used at the time, including Glide if anyone remembers that. Which while being developed based on OpenGL, was actually quite different enough to be its own trademarked proprietary offering.

But yes, absolutely Microsoft's goal to create DirectX was to make Windows a more viable gaming platform, and the way to do that was to make it easier for everyone to develop on it. Just like with any other company out there trying to make money. Remember also that much of Linux and things designed for it is 'proprietary' and yet it can be used with attribution. I think people too often get the idea of something being proprietary confused. USB is proprietary. HDMI is proprietary. DVI is proprietary. But all of these are common industry standards adopted and used by many companies. The apple connector is not.
 
To be honest, it's their own dumb fault for pushing a kickstarter fund without securing licensing permission from the owner of the tech. I actually have no love for apple, but their proprietary connector required some amount of investment to engineer--as a business, they deserve to recoup those costs through their own sales, or licensing (if they so choose to license it at some point--if not, too bad for those who want to use it). But don't expect to use the tech. without licensing it--that's pretty much business 101, and one of the reasons why I hate hearing about kickstarter projects (most of the technology-related ones are half-brained or ill-conceived).

That being said, I detest Apple and the way they do business. They stifle true advancement of technology wherever they can while at the same time crying out that they are the true innovators.
 
But yes, absolutely Microsoft's goal to create DirectX was to make Windows a more viable gaming platform, and the way to do that was to make it easier for everyone to develop on it.
I've bolded the important part. You originally stated that DirectX was "designed to create an industry standard that all game developers and hardware developers could use a common tool". All game developers and hardware developers cannot use DirectX as a common tool, as DirectX is exclusive to a very limited number of proprietary Microsoft platforms.
 
I've bolded the important part. You originally stated that DirectX was "designed to create an industry standard that all game developers and hardware developers could use a common tool". All game developers and hardware developers cannot use DirectX as a common tool, as DirectX is exclusive to a very limited number of proprietary Microsoft platforms.

I am sorry, limited how? Also DirectX is not just limited to Windows, it can and has been ported to other systems as well.
 
Over $100k to develop a charging station? I see that kind of thing on sale in Fry's all the time for $7.

Connectors...check
Voltage regulators...check
White cylinder to hold stuff...check

Not seeing the $100k part yet.

Manufacturing is not free.
 
Lol, how did I know this old argument was going to come up? Yes, Xbox does not support OpenGL currently. But find me the games that are designed solely off of OpenGL verse all the games that are designed off of DirectX. Also, contrary to many revisionist history buffs, Microsoft did not develop DirectX to kill OpenGL. DirectX was funded by Microsoft and designed to create an industry standard that all game developers and hardware developers could use a common tool. It was being developed at the same time as OpenGL and was meant to be a companion to it. Microsoft could have scrapped the DirectX initiative and gone with OpenGL, but DirectX was easier for game developers at the time, and hindsight is 20/20. So while yes, DirectX is proprietary in that Microsoft developed it as a standard, it wasn't developed to kill anything else. Of course nowadays it certainly is being leveraged in a battle against OpenGL. All that said, this case is completely different, considering it is free to incorporate and use DirectX. You as a consumer are not paying for it, game developers are not paying for it, and to my knowledge hardware manufacturers do not pay any license related to DirectX either. So I fail to see how this has any real bearing on the conversation?

That's a nice deflection. You said the Xbox and hence Direct X was open. It's not. It's proprietary.
 
Over $100k to develop a charging station? I see that kind of thing on sale in Fry's all the time for $7.

Connectors...check
Voltage regulators...check
White cylinder to hold stuff...check

Not seeing the $100k part yet.

A fabricated injection mold for the plastic can cost 100k by itself. Then you need to buy thousands of units to bring the price down. So if you are a small guy just starting few plants will front the cost for you on a whim, you will have to pay for it all upfront.

This is alot of why you see products from many companies use the same plastic shape.
 
That's a nice deflection. You said the Xbox and hence Direct X was open. It's not. It's proprietary.

Actually no, my claim was that of all the gaming consoles out now (Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft consoles), the Xbox is the most open. I never ever claimed that DirectX was open, or made any correlation whatsoever between Xbox and DirectX. But nice try there bud.
 
To a limited number of Microsoft platforms.


Yes. To a limited number of Microsoft platforms.

I am sorry what limited number? Continuing to say it is so does not make it so. Also your argument in no way reflects how Xbox is less open than other platforms. You have only mentioned one way in which Xbox uses a proprietary solution that is generally only found on Microsoft products. However, if we want to go further, what does it take to develop games for Xbox and what does it take to develop for PS3 or Nintendo? The Xbox also offers more device connectivity to it. It also has methods to sync more information between it and other devices you have. In addition, the Kinect, which is an add-on component for it, has its own SDK available for use with multiple other platforms. There is tons of projects out there alone that use the Kinect. And while you may argue, "that's the Kinect, not the Xbox". The Kinect was developed for the Xbox within the Xbox organization. None of the other game console makers have opened up their devices for such purposes.
 
Ars just posted an article that Apple has reversed a specification in the "Made for iPod" design guide to allow both 30-pin and Lightning connectors to be used on the same charging device.

Still doesn't change my original points, but Apple does seem to have reasonably responded to the situation.
 
plus apple always finds a way to spin it, I mean half the apple people think they are the small guy, you know the eccentric, if you did something bad to a kickstarter that would mean your the big bad company. So apple just goes, oh well you can include our old adapter, but I bet you cannot include other more standard adapters.
 
And yet this will be defended by the apologists. Funny how everyone rails against every single other manufacturer went it comes to proprietary cables, but somehow apple is exempt.

Your story may be true in an Apple forum but it is quite the opposite around here.
 
apple chokes cock. only a matter of time before people wise up (I hope)

They've been doing it for at least 25 years... and people have been slurping up their kool-aid all that time. There's no reason to expect anything will change anytime soon.
 
They've been doing it for at least 25 years... and people have been slurping up their kool-aid all that time. There's no reason to expect anything will change anytime soon.

Hasn't Apple been in their upswing since 99? I wonder what their last run was back in the 80's. Their current one is still going strong but it is no where near as long as what MS had up until a few years ago.
 
Because it's their proprietary interface. If you want to license the tech, you have to play by Apple's rules.

The main impetus for Apple in creating the lightning connector was one of control: China and friends knocking off the old connector for 99cents wasn't making Apple any money. So in typical Apple fashion they require no less than total control so they chipped both ends of the lightning connector to make knockoffs infinitely harder and once again control the supply end to end.

Funny I just got done reading another thread here (re: Steve Jobs estate "stiffing" the guy that built a boat for Steve) and one guy was squirting tears over what seemed to him like a larger pattern of Apple "bashing" site wide. Then seeing this thread next was good for a laugh. Apple sure knows how to make friends,
 
They have to keep their exclusive club status. Can't have Apple devices mixing with the commoners....

I hate Apple.
 
Back
Top