Apache Patch to Override IE 10’s Do Not Track Setting

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The ‘Do Not Track’ feature that will be turned on by default in Internet Explorer 10, now has an override patch developed by one of the authors of the DNT standard. The patch, applied for Apache, will override the default Microsoft setting.

“The only reason DNT exists is to express a non-default option. That's all it does. [...] It does not protect anyone's privacy unless the recipients believe it was set by a real human being, with a real preference for privacy over personalization.”
 
User agents should be eliminated and should have never been created to begin with. It encourages sloppy web design and targeting websites towards specific browsers at the exclusion of others.

If Microsoft wants to win brownie points with me, they should include an ad blocker by default. Contract out with the Adblock Plus guy to write an adblocker for Windows 8; it would have the plus side (for Microsoft) of hurting Google since Google makes far more from advertising than Microsoft does.
 
User agents should be eliminated and should have never been created to begin with. It encourages sloppy web design and targeting websites towards specific browsers at the exclusion of others.

If Microsoft wants to win brownie points with me, they should include an ad blocker by default. Contract out with the Adblock Plus guy to write an adblocker for Windows 8; it would have the plus side (for Microsoft) of hurting Google since Google makes far more from advertising than Microsoft does.
you must hate mobile sites.
 
What the hell is the point of DNT if it's overrideable in the first place?

This is a clusterfuck from the get go.
 
So me choosing to use a browser that has it on by default isn't the same thing as me clicking on a button to turn it on? Just sounds like they are looking for an excuse to ignore it.
 
What the hell is the point of DNT if it's overrideable in the first place?

This is a clusterfuck from the get go.

It seems one good thing that MS did for us with regards to DNT is that they exposed to everyone that its not that reliable and can be easily defeated by the people who created the standard. now that's a deal breaker :D
 
So me choosing to use a browser that has it on by default isn't the same thing as me clicking on a button to turn it on? Just sounds like they are looking for an excuse to ignore it.

This.
 
So me choosing to use a browser that has it on by default isn't the same thing as me clicking on a button to turn it on?

Yes, correct. *YOU* may choose to use IE10 because it defaults in to DNT, but for the millions of people where IE10 is simply the default on their computer they did not make such a choice.

The only way DNT can possibly work is if you have to manually go enable it - that makes it crystal clear exactly what you want. I'm pretty sure the IE team just wants to watch the world burn. It's the only way to explain ActiveX, IE6, IE7, IE8, and now IE10's DNT.

What the hell is the point of DNT if it's overrideable in the first place?

DNT isn't "overridable" - it is merely a *request* to the server that you would prefer to not be tracked. It requires engineering resources on the server side to actually respect it. Google & others have to actually support DNT in the first place. By itself it doesn't do squat.

User agents should be eliminated and should have never been created to begin with. It encourages sloppy web design and targeting websites towards specific browsers at the exclusion of others.

It also allows for sites to work around browser bugs or for sites to deploy bleeding edge features on browsers that support them. A world without user agents would be a clusterfuck - it simply doesn't work.

If Microsoft wants to win brownie points with me, they should include an ad blocker by default. Contract out with the Adblock Plus guy to write an adblocker for Windows 8; it would have the plus side (for Microsoft) of hurting Google since Google makes far more from advertising than Microsoft does.

Because you hate supporting the sites you go to why, exactly? Do you think Kyle is running a non-profit here or something? Have you mailed him a check for the content you've consumed without viewing ads?
 
...........people where IE10 is simply the default on their computer they did not make such a choice.

yes they did, they choose to use IE10 and not another browser... no one forced them to do anything ?
 
yes they did, they choose to use IE10 and not another browser... no one forced them to do anything ?

People like me and you come from another time. These days, unless Balmer comes to your door and gives you a personalized version of Windows based on extensive interviewing of your needs and wants, you're being forced to do something.
 
The amount of ignorance in here baffles me.

These are from spec:
We do not specify how that preference is enabled: each implementation is responsible for determining the user experience by which this preference is enabled.

and


the user might ... make a choice for privacy that then implicitly includes a tracking preference

and


... the expectation will be that their chosen user agent and personal preferences regarding Web site behavior will not be altered by the network environment

and


Key to that notion of expression is that it must reflect the user's preference, not the preference of some institutional or network-imposed mechanism outside the user's control.

And this is how IE "defaults" to DNT:yes, by explicit user choice.

Express_Settings_Win8RTM.jpg


Mr. Roy is abusing his powers in apache github with his political issues. It is simple as that.
 
Yes, correct. *YOU* may choose to use IE10 because it defaults in to DNT, but for the millions of people where IE10 is simply the default on their computer they did not make such a choice.

The only way DNT can possibly work is if you have to manually go enable it - that makes it crystal clear exactly what you want. I'm pretty sure the IE team just wants to watch the world burn. It's the only way to explain ActiveX, IE6, IE7, IE8, and now IE10's DNT.



DNT isn't "overridable" - it is merely a *request* to the server that you would prefer to not be tracked. It requires engineering resources on the server side to actually respect it. Google & others have to actually support DNT in the first place. By itself it doesn't do squat.



It also allows for sites to work around browser bugs or for sites to deploy bleeding edge features on browsers that support them. A world without user agents would be a clusterfuck - it simply doesn't work.



Because you hate supporting the sites you go to why, exactly? Do you think Kyle is running a non-profit here or something? Have you mailed him a check for the content you've consumed without viewing ads?



It goes both ways. The ads here arent intrusiveand I don't mind seeing them. In fact they are so obscure I don't even notice them 90% of the time. Same can't be said for alot of other sites. But I also subscribe to genmay, so they've gotten money out of me.
 
What the hell is the point of DNT if it's overrideable in the first place?

This is a clusterfuck from the get go.

There is no point of DNT until it is enforced by global, worldwide legislative. DNT is just a header in a request from your web browser to the web server, that "hey you, application on the server, please be a good boy and do not track this user because that is what he would like". And the server application can choose if it will use that flag or not.

It is exactly like a "beginner" sign on your car - it just signs that you are sorry, but you are clumsy because you just started driving - it doesn't stop others from cursing at you and using the horn.
 
People like me and you come from another time. These days, unless Balmer comes to your door and gives you a personalized version of Windows based on extensive interviewing of your needs and wants, you're being forced to do something.

Quoted for truth :(.
 
The amount of ignorance in here baffles me.

These are from spec:


And this is how IE "defaults" to DNT:yes, by explicit user choice.

http://www.computerworld.com/common/images/site/features/2012/08/Express_Settings_Win8RTM.jpg

Mr. Roy is abusing his powers in apache github with his political issues. It is simple as that.

Uh, that's not explicit user choice. You just posted a screenshot showing IE10 defaulting to DNT on.

IE10 is defaulting to DNT because of course Microsoft won't respect that setting and will still track you with Bing - if it's built into the browser it doesn't count, obviously. But they know that Google will actually respect DNT, and will thus be hurt by the huge marketshare IE has. Microsoft is just fighting dirty here, in the process they are poising a spec, *and* they are getting ignorant tech fools to root for them. Totally a win-win-win for them.

yes they did, they choose to use IE10 and not another browser... no one forced them to do anything ?

Who said anything about forced? Also, your argument is horseshit and you know it. Go buy a PC and don't make any decisions about what web browser to use and you will end up with IE10. The default for the majority of users will be IE10. They did not make any decision other than buying a computer.

Although with that said, you *are* forced to use IE10 on Windows RT, so there's always that.
 
Back
Top