Any problems with USB Hard Drive connected 24/7?

multiplexed

Weaksauce
Joined
Mar 8, 2003
Messages
88
I have a desktop computer. I'd like to attach a USB hard drive to the desktop for backup purposes.

My question is, are there any problems with having a USB hard drive attached pretty much 24/7. For example, are there any problems during reboots and normal day to day activities?
 
No problems whatsoever, other than the obvious fact that if some type of malware were to invade your system it could (potentially) screw with your backups, I think it's pretty unlikely ('specially if you're doing image backups which usually create compressed/proprietary files) but it's a possibility.

I leave mine on all the time, mostly out of laziness, I do try to turn it off occasionally to give it a rest but my backups are automated and I don't wanna be bothered to have to remember to turn it on during the days when the backup jobs are set to run. I've got off-site backup of my personal stuff that I update every 6 months anyway.

The only other problem would be the drive overheating if you've got a poorly vented/built enclosure... Even if it's properly built most enclosures tend to have a limited lifespan... I've killed two enclosures over the last 5-6 years and the drives that were inside 'em are still working perfectly fine. Has nothing to do w/brand or quality, one was a pre-built external enclosure from WD (250GB drive I still use, in a TiVo, it was a royal PITA to rip the dead enclosure open tho), the other was an AMS enclosure I bought to pair with my own drive (it was built out of aluminum and had a fan).

Last enclosure I bought for my external backup drive is an Ultra (seems like they're CompUSA/Tigerdirect's quasi-house brand now)...

Doesn't have a fan but it's all solid aluminum and the drive attaches directly to it (unlike my AMS enclosure, where the drive resided on a plastic sled), that means heat is conducted directly thru the entire surface of the enclosure (like a heatsink), since HDs actually radiate the most heat around the sides (some of the chips on the underside do get hot tho). It has USB and e-SATA, my AMS enclosure did as well tho I ran that one off USB for the longest time since my previous mobo didn't have e-SATA.

If you plan to build your own you're probably better off using one of the Green WD drives or w/e reduce power draw & heat output, tho I've always put standard 7,200 RPM drives into mine w/no issues so if speed is a priority don't sweat it.
 
Are you talking about a standard, external USB hard drive, or are you talking about a custom enclosure?

Thanks
 
What do you mean by custom enclosure? The enclosures that you buy (into which you can place your own drive) are really no different than the pre-made external USB drives you get from WD or Seagate, other than the fact that they're easier to open and service. I was talking about either or both of those in my post.

This is what I'm using right now for backups (over e-SATA) w/a 500GB WD drive I bought about a year ago. It gets fairly warm around the sides so you know it's radiating heat off the HD to the exterior (a good thing). Based on the good experience I've had with that one (and the price) I just bought this one yesterday. I'm gonna put my netbook's 160GB HD inside it since I'm upgrading it to a 40GB SSD.

The warranties are one thing to keep in mind if you're trying to decide between a pre-made one from whomever or grabbing one of those plus your own HD... Many of the pre-made external hard drives now come with 3-5 year warranties, but a lot of them still have 2 or even 1 year warranties. If the drive or the enclosure die after warranty you pay to replace the whole thing yourself.

Whereas it's relatively easy to grab a WD Black drive or w/e with a 5 year warranty and put it into the enclosure of your choice, if it dies you can RMA it and if the enclosure dies you can get a new one fast for $20-30 (I believe those Ultra ones have a 3 yr warranty as well tho); so it's cheaper in the long run and you have more control over the drive/capacity.
 
What do you mean by custom enclosure? The enclosures that you buy (into which you can place your own drive) are really no different than the pre-made external USB drives you get from WD or Seagate, other than the fact that they're easier to open and service. I was talking about either or both of those in my post.

This is what I'm using right now for backups (over e-SATA) w/a 500GB WD drive I bought about a year ago. It gets fairly warm around the sides so you know it's radiating heat off the HD to the exterior (a good thing). Based on the good experience I've had with that one (and the price) I just bought this one yesterday. I'm gonna put my netbook's 160GB HD inside it since I'm upgrading it to a 40GB SSD.

The warranties are one thing to keep in mind if you're trying to decide between a pre-made one from whomever or grabbing one of those plus your own HD... Many of the pre-made external hard drives now come with 3-5 year warranties, but a lot of them still have 2 or even 1 year warranties. If the drive or the enclosure die after warranty you pay to replace the whole thing yourself.

Whereas it's relatively easy to grab a WD Black drive or w/e with a 5 year warranty and put it into the enclosure of your choice, if it dies you can RMA it and if the enclosure dies you can get a new one fast for $20-30 (I believe those Ultra ones have a 3 yr warranty as well tho); so it's cheaper in the long run and you have more control over the drive/capacity.

Actually I think most DIY enclosures lack the power managment of the pre-made external enclosure. At least any enclosure I've ever used.

My seagate freeagent go 500GB spins down when not in use however, as do most pre-made external drives now.
 
I dont think Ive come across a DIY enclosure that has any power management features. It would make sense that the pre-built enclosures from the big name manufacturers (Seagate, WD) would have power management. However, on my old WD external drive, the spin down time was set very low. The drive would spin down after only 10 minutes of inactivity...which really wasnt feasible since everytime you tried to go into the explorer to save a file, windows would read from the drive and spin it up again. In a typical 8 hr work day, the drive would probably spin up an down 20+ times.
 
Code:
# dismount the device
umount $DEST && {
 /usr/bin/sdparm --command=stop $DEVICE
} || echo Unmount Failed !

That is a line from my nightly backup script on my home file/webserver. I have an older 120gb WD Passport(a 2.5" portable USB external) connected to it. It's a headless ubuntu server and I back up everything to the Passport every night.

Obviously I had to figure out a way to keep the drive from spinning all the time, as these things don't have much of a lifespan. The 'sdparm --command=stop' line shuts the drive down. I don't know much about the command, but the little power LED on the drive shuts off when I run that command, and the drive spins down and doesn't come back on unitl I mount it again(or my script runs.)

Obviously the command isn't very helpful to anyone running windows, but multiplexed did not specify his OS. Maybe someone more knowledgeable than myself can find some similar means in Windows?
 
I dont think Ive come across a DIY enclosure that has any power management features. It would make sense that the pre-built enclosures from the big name manufacturers (Seagate, WD) would have power management. However, on my old WD external drive, the spin down time was set very low. The drive would spin down after only 10 minutes of inactivity...which really wasnt feasible since everytime you tried to go into the explorer to save a file, windows would read from the drive and spin it up again. In a typical 8 hr work day, the drive would probably spin up an down 20+ times.

Huh. My seagate only spins up when I read/write to it, it also doesnt spin up when I access the root folder of the drive, it spins up if I go into any subfolders though.

Its been idle for the last day or so.
 
My 750GB WD is a royal pain in the ass sometimes (Mybook enclosure). Some programs (OUTLOOK!) are absolutely convinced they should spin up that drive before doing things, giving me random 10 second delays during normal desktop usage.

I think it's because that drive has the most free space, but I am not 100% sure.
 
My 750GB WD is a royal pain in the ass sometimes (Mybook enclosure). Some programs (OUTLOOK!) are absolutely convinced they should spin up that drive before doing things, giving me random 10 second delays during normal desktop usage.

I think it's because that drive has the most free space, but I am not 100% sure.

Windows update on XP used to write to whatever drive had the most free space, that annoyed the crap out of me.
 
I could've swore my last DIY enclosure would spin the drive down, might've been my imagination, haven't really noticed or checked on the new one I got from Ultra tbh (no fan so it's quiet, and it's solid/thick aluminum so it dulls the sound of the drive pretty well). I wonder if e-SATA enclosures are able to do that any easier than USB ones can.
 
Back
Top