Antec Earthwatts or Neopower?

haadij404

2[H]4U
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
2,280
My trusty old Antec SP-500 finally bit the dust the other day... with one month left on the warranty too :D woo just made it in.

anyways since Antec doesn't make that psu anymore so they offer either the Earthwatts 500w or the Neopower 500w (which is modular and a big plus). Which one do you think is better? I read that the earthwatts were made by seasonic so thats a big plus but still its not modular. The neo does have 3 12v rails(51A) vs the EW's 2 (44v). So yeah the neo seems a bit more robust and has modular cables so i am leaning towards it.

Newegg reviews rated the Earthwatts pretty well but the neo didnt get such glowing reviews. But you know how newegg reviews... take them with pound of salt.

The PSU will be powering the computer in my sig.

so what would you reccomend between the two?

thanks
 
anyways since Antec doesn't make that psu anymore so they offer either the Earthwatts 500w or the Neopower 500w (which is modular and a big plus). Which one do you think is better? I read that the earthwatts were made by seasonic so thats a big plus but still its not modular. The neo does have 3 12v rails(51A) vs the EW's 2 (44v). So yeah the neo seems a bit more robust and has modular cables so i am leaning towards it.

The Earthwatts EA500 is now made by Delta, not Seasonic. IN addition, that is not how you determine the total amperage on the +12V rail for a PSU. You determine the amperage on the +12V rails by first finding out what's the total combined, max load, combined or max wattage set aside for the +12V rails/section alone. Then divide that total by 12 and you get how much amps the PSU has on the +12V rail.

That's the correct way to find out how much amps a power supply has. Don't add up the amps on the +12V rail to figure out the amperage. Doesn't work that way. If the total combined or max wattage can't be found on the power supply, check the manufacturer's page for that PSU for that info. If the manufacturer doesn't provide that information, it's generally a good sign for you to drop that power supply from consideration.

So the Antec EA500 has 34A on the +12V rail while the Neopower 500 has 38A on the +12V rail. I'd recommend the Neopower.
 
So the Antec EA500 has 34A on the +12V rail while the Neopower 500 has 38A on the +12V rail. I'd recommend the Neopower.

ahh damn i shouldn't have assumed it was so simple! thanks for correcting me.

so since the EA-500 isn't made by seasonic anymore, has less Amps and isn't modular I think the neopower is looking quite a bit more attractive.

so what you think?
 
so since the EA-500 isn't made by seasonic anymore, has less Amps and isn't modular I think the neopower is looking quite a bit more attractive.

so what you think?

In this case, it does not matter who made the PSU as the Earthwatts and Neopower PSUs are about the same quality wise. But the Neopower is the better choice due to its modular cables and 4A more.
 
In this case, it does not matter who made the PSU as the Earthwatts and Neopower PSUs are about the same quality wise. But the Neopower is the better choice due to its modular cables and 4A more.

Yeah, I am feeling the same way. The modular cables are a big plus... especially in smaller cases.

Thanks for the advice. Appreciate it.
 
The Neopower 500W is a very good PSU. I have one running in a secondary system. It would work great for your needs.
 
my sp-500 just died as well,after i fill out the rma request and click submit it loads the antec main page,and now its been 3 days and no response. they say allow 24 hrs,I just wonder if the form even went through?
 
hmm i got my rma # within a few hours of submitting it. you can call them up... they are pretty good over the phone.
 
a little update.

pretty impressed so far with Antec RMA and turn around time. They recieved my old SP-500 last friday (coast to coast shipping). They shipped out the new one Tuesday. Should get it by Friday. Not too bad at all.
 
Personally I would go with the neo. I got an antec modular psu and I love it!
 
ahh damn i shouldn't have assumed it was so simple! thanks for correcting me.

so since the EA-500 isn't made by seasonic anymore, has less Amps and isn't modular I think the neopower is looking quite a bit more attractive.

so what you think?

also just because the EA500 isn't made by seasonic anymore doesn't mean its a bad thing. Delta makes great units, they're the ones who make Antecs top of the line Signature units. the build quality inside the EA unit looks absolutely fantastic. but yeah, the modular design and more amperage on the Neopower units make it a little more attractive
 
well i just got my neopower from antec today. i shipped my dead sp500 on the 20th and i got the replacement today. not too bad at all.

impressed by how simple and efficient the whole process was. they were very quick in issuing an rma number and emailing the shipping info. i messed up filling out which replacement i wanted so i emailed the rma department letting them know i wanted to change it. i got an email back within 30 minutes letting me know the change was made.

just impressive all around. they did good by me and i think its only fair to share this positive experience with you all :D
 
Antec has always been a good company to deal with.Glad your happy and oc it just to burn it in good.
 
Back
Top