Another System Build Thread -- $2000 for all round entertainment...

njc

Gawd
Joined
Apr 30, 2002
Messages
581
So it's that time again... been 4 years since my last major system overhaul, and i'm tired of piece-meal upgrades... time to do the whole thing. i'll be starting law school next year, and i'm going to try to reassert the PC desktop's role in my life, as the macbook pro has been hogging more and more of the spotlight. this will be primarily for TV, music, gaming, and basic internet usage. pretty standard stuff. i have an HDTV, so i'll need a video card that can deliver good looking video content to the TV, as well as a 24" dell widescreen LCD i intend to get ... i want to run vista, so everything needs to be compatible.

i've been out of the game so to speak for a while, so i'm not up to date on the standards as far as cpu/mobo/ram combos, but here's what i've got so far:

$2000 budget:

LIAN LI PC-6070Bplus II Black Aluminum ATX Mid Tower Computer Case - Retail

Thermaltake W0093RU ATX 12V 2.0 Version 500W Power Supply - Retail

Intel Core 2 Duo E6700 Conroe 2.66GHz LGA 775 Processor Model BX80557E6700 - Retail

Western Digital Caviar RE WD3200YS 320GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM

Western Digital Raptor WD360ADFD 36GB 10,000 RPM Serial ATA150 Hard Drive - OEM

ASUS EN7950GT/HTDP/512M GeForce 7950GT GDDR3 PCI Express x16 HDCP Splendid Video Card - Retail

Creative 70SB046A00000 7.1 Channels PCI Interface Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series - Retail

2X LITE-ON 20X DVD±R DVD Burner with LightScribe Black SATA Model LH-20A1L-05 - OEM

Microsoft Windows Vista 32-Bit Ultimate for System Builders Single Pack DVD - OEM

So, I'm pretty sure all I'm missing is the motherboard and RAM. i'm not really sure what direction or model to go at all with the motherboard... any recommendations? i don't really intend to be overclocking, so does this proc run stock at 667? any recommendations for brand of RAM?

also, at this stage in the planning of system builds i tend to make some silly oversights... anything missing? any compatibility issues? i'm looking to go vista, so i need to make sure all my hardware is compatible. is there a way to check? a compatibility list for vista? any suggested swaps to make? any advice is appreciated.
 
Is there some reason you *must* have vista? It sounds like you just want things to *work*, period.

Get seagate hard drives and scrap the raptor.

You can get a more powerful video card, ala the 8800gts for about the same price as the 7950.

also, you'll be wanting your generic e6600/asus p5b (or gigabyte ds3)/your choice of ridiculously cheap corsair/ocz/whatever ram.
 
Don't go too low on power supply, even though your choice is enough, but more power = more headroom for other things like overclock and stability etc. And since you got a pretty good budget, you can buy a nvidia 8800 series card and still have nuff $ for 2407WFP... and assuming you gonna squeeze some more juice from ur E6700, get a good cpu cooler like thermalright ultra xtreme or just get a tuniq tower...


- OCZ GameXstream 700W - $101.99 @ zipzoomfly
- EVGA's 8800 GTS 320MB or higher model (make no mistake, evga's life time warranty+step up is a steal)

Mobo:
- EVGA's 680i base mobo A1 - $224.99 @ newegg (lifetime warranty on A1)
or
- Asus P5W DH Deluxe/WIFI (I personally love the remote to death lol)

RAM:
- 2x 1GB G.Skill DDR2 800 HZ RAM - $154.99+ship @ newegg
or
- 2x 1GB G.Skill DDR2 1000 HZ RAM - $229.99 +ship @ newegg

I just did a quick caluclation if u were to choose my suggestion for psu, mobo, ram, video card... total will be around $1775
 
Not a bad start...

I agree with the above posts regarding the video card. You definitely want to get an 8800 series card for a 24inch monitor. (I'd even go for the top-of-the-line 8800 GTX if you can afford it... To make room you can drop the proc to an E6600, and realize almost no performance decrease, even at the different stock speeds.) The 7950GX2 is last year's overpriced tech, and not worth it on a system w/ your budget.

Mark.
 
with the potential of EVERY core2duo processor, it would be a waste not to overclock. true, the price of the e6700 is down to a bit over $300, but that's only running at 2.66 ghz. for around $300, you can have a motherboard and a cpu that will overclock to 3.0ghz on the stock intel HSF.

one example - gigabyte ds3 ($120) & e6420 cpu $190 = $310

with memory prices at rock bottom these days, you can easily pick up 2 gigs of pc6400 for slightly more ($10-$20) than its slower paced brethren.

please give it some thought.
 
Drop the thermaltake PSU. A good quality 500W+ is more than enough for a single 8800GTX and a couple hard drives. Go for the Corsair 520W from buy.com and use google checkout... it should come out to $70AR/AC. The Corsair is a much better PSU than that Tt POS. Don't buy a Tt unless its a toughpower, but even then, there are better choices for the price. The GXS700 has ripple... which kills your components over time.

For the mobo, I'd suggest the Asus P5B-E or Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3. Both are great boards whether your overclocking or not. The intel chipset runs cooler than the NVIDIA chipset, and is rock stable, even if you are overclocking.

Vista drivers are terrible right now. So if you have XP, run that for now. Since you're buying everything new, everything should be compatible with Vista. You'll just need to wait for the manufacturers to fix their drivers (NVIDIA, Creative, etc).

I'd drop down from the E6700 to the E6600, as the higher multiplier/stock speed of the E6700 shouldn't cost ~$90. Its rather simple to OC these Core2Duos, and you could do so even with the stock HSF on stock voltage. Stock voltage will most definately let you reach the same speed as the E6700 with the E6600: 9 * 296 = 2.6Ghz, just set your FSB to 296 and you should be set.

Stock speed on all Core2Duos is based off of the 266Mhz FSB. So with an E6600, the multiplier is 9:
9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz clock speed, 2 * 266 = DDR2-533 ram speed ... now OC it a bit...
9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz clock speed, 2 * 333 = DDR2-667 ram speed ... which is easily attainable

So, if you'd like that modest OC of 3Ghz, go for some DDR2-667. Theres some Super Talent sticks at the egg that are rather cheap (2GB DDR2-667 for $85). If you can find some DDR2-800 sticks for a similar price, then go for them. Of course, if you don't want to OC at all and stick with the E6700, then all you need is DDR2-533 -- just be sure to get the cheapest of the three speeds (533/667/800).

I agree, go with an 8800GTX for a 24" LCD. You need the horsepower.
 
thanks for the useful replies folks... i've adjusted my shopping cart...

i'm going to order the 700W OCZ PSU from zipzoomfly, so that's not on this list ..

i'm confused as to why one poster said to ditch the raptor for seagate drives... do they offer a 10k RPM drive (that i'd use for windows and base applications)? last time i was in deep with current hardware/gaming system trends, that was a common choice to make, a high speed smaller drive for OS/apps, and a bigger drive for data... is there a better solution? perhaps 2 bigger drives running in raid 0?

i went with the kingston RAM, as i'm always afraid of failure, so i tend to go with the bigger name brands. decided to go with 4 GB, as it falls well within my budget.

took your advice for the video card, upgraded that guy.

took your advice regarding the motherboard, went with the P5W DH Deluxe

took your advice and docked the proc down to the 6600, will overclock to 3.0

sound the same, double dvd burners the same

so i guess my two remaining questions are about the hard drive choice, and what type of RAM i should go with... would 4 X 1 GB be better (it's more expensive right?) than 2 X 2 GB? is there a reliable and cheaper brand i should go for? what's the difference between PC25300 and PC2 5400?

thanks again guys
 
Remember that if you go with four gigs of RAM, you will need to run 64 bit XP or 64-bit Vista in order to use it all. Otherwise you will be limited to 3.2 Gigabytes of RAM at most (the actual number will depend upon how much component memory you have. So if you get a GTS 640 or GTX video card, the amount you'll be able to use may be less.)

The reason some people suggest not buying the Raptor is because they believe a 10,000 RPM drive is not worth the price premium and space sacrifice for the marginal performance improvement experienced in everyday use. The suggestion to buy the Seagate drive is a suggestion to buy a speedy, reliable, and well received 7,200 RPM drive. Whether or not 10,000 RPM drives are useful is a contested debate subject. I fall into the camp suggesting that it's a waste of money and too much of a space sacrifice. I'd very well go with a fast, large 7,200 RPM drive for less money. Others, however, may disagree.

(Note that the Raptor brand is the only 10,000 RPM Sata drive on the market.)

Good luck,

Mark.
 
i'm going to order the 700W OCZ PSU from zipzoomfly, so that's not on this list ..

i'm confused as to why one poster said to ditch the raptor for seagate drives... do they offer a 10k RPM drive (that i'd use for windows and base applications)? last time i was in deep with current hardware/gaming system trends, that was a common choice to make, a high speed smaller drive for OS/apps, and a bigger drive for data... is there a better solution? perhaps 2 bigger drives running in raid 0?

so i guess my two remaining questions are about the hard drive choice, and what type of RAM i should go with... would 4 X 1 GB be better (it's more expensive right?) than 2 X 2 GB? is there a reliable and cheaper brand i should go for?

I hope you're not planning on using all 700W of that OCZ PSU. Again, here's why: http://jonnyguru.com/forums/showthread.php?t=442
I'd go for the Corsair 620W from ZZF instead. Here's jonnyguru's review.

here's my opinion on the raptor...
tomshardware.com

look at the hdd charts. raptor out performs the seagate in almost every category. just as fast? i dont think so.

no, not as fast... but pretty damn close for a lot less money...

ST3320620AS: 65MB/s - $80
WD1500ADFD: 78MB/s - $205... difference: 18% performance increase for 2.5x the price.

Sure, uh huh, thats worth it... :rolleyes:

FYI, my raptor was hooked up ;) So I didnt pay that huge price premium, lol. Definately a nice drive, but not for the price. For the price of the seagate and the performance you get, its definately worth it over the Raptor. The Raptor is a luxury... so only get one if you have extra money to spend and don't want to deal with RAID and/or SAS.

Two Seagate.10 drives in RAID0 is certainly more cost effective, and would also have a higher avg transfer rate. But, if you don't want to deal with RAID but want the fastes possible single non-scsi drive, then the Raptor is it.

what's the difference between PC25300 and PC2 5400?

Same DDR2 speed rating... difference of mathematical opinions...
DDR2-667 => 333 * 2 = 667, 667 * 8 = 5336 ... correct rounding: PC2-5300
DDR2-667 => 333 * 2 = 667, 667 * 8 = 5336 ... ambitious rounding: PC2-5400
 
regarding the PSU, i read that thread, and a 'ripple' seems like bad news... i don't think what i have listed component-wise would get me close to pushing that 700W even close to it's limit, but regardless, i want the most reliable components possible; after working in a computer shop and doing builds, i hate RMA-ing things more than anything else in the world (besides building systems in shitty cases) ... i'll go with that corsair.

i'm interested in running 2 seagates in Raid 0. how hard is it to configure onboard RAID? i've never done it before on a personal machine, and the only time i did it when i worked was under the guidance of my supervisor when we were building a server (and i think that was 0+1, not 0) ... i'd imagine that if it's onboard, it's relatively simple and well-documented in the ASUS documentation?
 
On board RAID is usually quite simple. In all cases of Onboard RAID i've used (Intel's ICH5/6R and nVidia MediaShield for 680i,) configuration was done on the RAID controller's stand-alone CMOS screen, which can be accessed during the RAID post right after the system post. Most high-end, modern motherboards support RAID 0, 1, 0+1, and 5. Older and simpler motherboards may only support RAID 0 and 1.

I've never had any problem using on-board RAID, except that on my last computer I could never find native Linux drivers for the ICH5R chip (not a big deal since I hardly ever use Linux.) Just be sure to always backup your data if you do RAID-0, as RAID-0 arrays do increase the chance of drive failure.

Mark.
 
If I had $2000, here's what I'd do - it comes out to $2180, and doesn't include an optical drive (add $30 for your run of the mill DVD burner), but here goes:

Antec Nine Hundred Case - $139.99

One of my old roommates had a Lian-Li midtower...it was loud. Antec cases are usually nice and quiet. This one has huge fans, so cooling won't be an issue either.

Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3250820AS 250GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM - $67.99 * 2

I'm of the opinion that Raptors aren't worth the extra money, whereas extra cores or a better GPU is. This is a nice half a terabyte, should be plenty to get you started ;)

EVGA 768-P2-N835-AR GeForce 8800GTX 768MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16 SUPERCLOCKED HDCP Video Card - Retail - $599

The best of the best. You've got a big monitor, so you're going to need it. Plus, it'll last you longer than one of the less expensive models. I'm still happily gaming on my "venerable" 7800GTX. Two years, sheesh. I'm getting old.

Creative 70SB046A00000 7.1 Channels PCI Interface Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series - Retail - $129.99

WTF happened to Creative's decent midrange offerings? I was about to blast you for choosing such an expensive sound card, but this looks like the only option that isn't on some crappy half-height PCB. Sheesh. Yeah, the X-Fi should serve you well. I'm basing that opinion on how the bitching about the X-Fi and Vista has stopped in the OS forum for the most part.

Antec NeoPower NeoHE 550 ATX12V 550W Power Supply - Retail - $109.99

Never skimp on your PSU. I'm using a NeoHE 500 now with great success, so I'm just going with what I know. I've also heard good things about the Enermax Liberty, if you have anything against Antec.

G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory Model F2-6400PHU2-2GBNR - Retail - $114.99 * 2

Overclocking RAM has never seemed to be worth the money to me, since overclocks are never garuanteed...better to go with 4 GB. Vista will love you for it. Also, G.Skill is a brand I've had great experience with.

MSI 975X Platinum V.2 LGA 775 Intel 975X ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $150

I'll admit I know nothing about Core2 motherboards. I like my current MSI board, and see little value in SLi, so this seemed like a good choice. There was a 975X board from ABIT that was only $109, but I'm guessing it's only that cheap because it doesn't overclock well.

Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz LGA 775 Processor Model BX80562Q6600 - Retail - $535.00

IMHO, two more cores > 200 more MHz, especially since you can make that up in overclocking.

Microsoft Windows Vista 64-Bit Business for System Builders Single Pack DVD - OEM - $150

If you need MCE, go Home Premium. If you need Remote Desktop, go Business. If you need both, go Ultimate. Otherwise, Ultimate is not worth it in and of itself, unless a video desktop is worth ~$50 to you.

Total: $2180. I know it's $180 over budget. If I absolutely had to, I'd drop the extra HDD and wait slightly longer to make the ~$120 extra I needed. Actually, if I was buying this, I'd probably re-use my PSU, case, HDDs, and optical drives, so that's several hundred dollars right there.
 
If I had $2000, here's what I'd do - it comes out to $2180, and doesn't include an optical drive (add $30 for your run of the mill DVD burner), but here goes:

Antec Nine Hundred Case - $139.99

One of my old roommates had a Lian-Li midtower...it was loud. Antec cases are usually nice and quiet. This one has huge fans, so cooling won't be an issue either.

Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 ST3250820AS 250GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - OEM - $67.99 * 2

I'm of the opinion that Raptors aren't worth the extra money, whereas extra cores or a better GPU is. This is a nice half a terabyte, should be plenty to get you started ;)

EVGA 768-P2-N835-AR GeForce 8800GTX 768MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16 SUPERCLOCKED HDCP Video Card - Retail - $599

The best of the best. You've got a big monitor, so you're going to need it. Plus, it'll last you longer than one of the less expensive models. I'm still happily gaming on my "venerable" 7800GTX. Two years, sheesh. I'm getting old.

Creative 70SB046A00000 7.1 Channels PCI Interface Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Professional Series - Retail - $129.99

WTF happened to Creative's decent midrange offerings? I was about to blast you for choosing such an expensive sound card, but this looks like the only option that isn't on some crappy half-height PCB. Sheesh. Yeah, the X-Fi should serve you well. I'm basing that opinion on how the bitching about the X-Fi and Vista has stopped in the OS forum for the most part.

Antec NeoPower NeoHE 550 ATX12V 550W Power Supply - Retail - $109.99

Never skimp on your PSU. I'm using a NeoHE 500 now with great success, so I'm just going with what I know. I've also heard good things about the Enermax Liberty, if you have anything against Antec.

G.SKILL 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800 (PC2 6400) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory Model F2-6400PHU2-2GBNR - Retail - $114.99 * 2

Overclocking RAM has never seemed to be worth the money to me, since overclocks are never garuanteed...better to go with 4 GB. Vista will love you for it. Also, G.Skill is a brand I've had great experience with.

MSI 975X Platinum V.2 LGA 775 Intel 975X ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $150

I'll admit I know nothing about Core2 motherboards. I like my current MSI board, and see little value in SLi, so this seemed like a good choice. There was a 975X board from ABIT that was only $109, but I'm guessing it's only that cheap because it doesn't overclock well.

Intel Core 2 Quad Q6600 Kentsfield 2.4GHz LGA 775 Processor Model BX80562Q6600 - Retail - $535.00

IMHO, two more cores > 200 more MHz, especially since you can make that up in overclocking.

Microsoft Windows Vista 64-Bit Business for System Builders Single Pack DVD - OEM - $150

If you need MCE, go Home Premium. If you need Remote Desktop, go Business. If you need both, go Ultimate. Otherwise, Ultimate is not worth it in and of itself, unless a video desktop is worth ~$50 to you.

Total: $2180. I know it's $180 over budget. If I absolutely had to, I'd drop the extra HDD and wait slightly longer to make the ~$120 extra I needed. Actually, if I was buying this, I'd probably re-use my PSU, case, HDDs, and optical drives, so that's several hundred dollars right there.

This actually looks like a good build in itself... Maybe you should consider some of this.


About the X-Fi though: I have an X-Fi and Vista, and while I was lucky enough to never have any crippling problems with it (sound has always worked well in all games and apps,) I know that the driver situation hasn't improved,and Creative still hasn't said anything about what it's doing to fix everyone's problems. Perhaps the reason people aren't complaining about the X-Fi as much anymore is that people are tired of complaining for so long... but the situation hasn't improved yet. You can certainly get one if you want, but you should be fine with on board sound, and if you want to save money, a quad core is a much better purchase than the X-Fi

Just my thoughts. Oh, and if you do get the GTX and four gigs, as I said before, you WILL want 64-bit Vista.

Regards,

Mark.
 
so i guess my two remaining questions are about the hard drive choice, and what type of RAM i should go with... would 4 X 1 GB be better (it's more expensive right?) than 2 X 2 GB? is there a reliable and cheaper brand i should go for? what's the difference between PC25300 and PC2 5400?

thanks again guys

Going 4 x 1 GB is the cheaper solution, but you'll have to sell them later if you want more memory. Going 2 x 2 GB will allow you the opportunity to upgrade right away, but it is more expensive. Last I checked, 2 x 1 pair were going for $105 for ddr2-800. The 2 x 2gb pair were going for $280

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231112
 
Never skimp on your PSU. I'm using a NeoHE 500 now with great success, so I'm just going with what I know. I've also heard good things about the Enermax Liberty, if you have anything against Antec.

I'll admit I know nothing about Core2 motherboards. I like my current MSI board, and see little value in SLi, so this seemed like a good choice. There was a 975X board from ABIT that was only $109, but I'm guessing it's only that cheap because it doesn't overclock well.

IMHO, two more cores > 200 more MHz, especially since you can make that up in overclocking.

The NeoHE is made by Seasonic now, but is of much lesser quality than the Corsair. So stick with the Corsair.

The P5W DH Dlx is actually a bit better than the MSI 975x plat. It basically comes down to which chipset you need. If you have cash to burn, need SLI + OC'ing, and don't mind dealing with a couple issues, then get the 680i. If you want a cheaper version of SLI since no setup needs dual 16x SLI anyhow, then the 650i SLI is good. If you need Crossfire, the 975X is your only choice aside from the DFI Radeon Xpress. If you don't need a dual card setup, the P965 Express overclocks better than the rest, and is pretty damn stable. The high end dual card chipsets are better with CPUs with high multipliers, because they can't reach as high of an FSB as the 650i and P965 Express.

While 2 more cores is better than 200Mhz, its harder to OC quad-core CPUs than dual-cores. However, the Q6600 can reach 3Ghz. Compare that to the Conroe, and its a bit slower, seeing as how Conroes easily reach 3.6Ghz -- which would be faster than 4 cores for 99% of the applications out there, currently. I don't think a quad core will be necessary until at least a year from now.
 
The P5W DH Dlx is actually a bit better than the MSI 975x plat. It basically comes down to which chipset you need. If you have cash to burn, need SLI + OC'ing, and don't mind dealing with a couple issues, then get the 680i. If you want a cheaper version of SLI since no setup needs dual 16x SLI anyhow, then the 650i SLI is good. If you need Crossfire, the 975X is your only choice aside from the DFI Radeon Xpress. If you don't need a dual card setup, the P965 Express overclocks better than the rest, and is pretty damn stable. The high end dual card chipsets are better with CPUs with high multipliers, because they can't reach as high of an FSB as the 650i and P965 Express.
Good to know :) I figured it was like the 865/875 days, where all the cool kids had 875s and all the cheap kids bent over backwards trying to get their 865s to work as fast as the 875s...iirc there was little overclocking difference between the two chipsets, since ther were pretty much the same in the first place.

While 2 more cores is better than 200Mhz, its harder to OC quad-core CPUs than dual-cores. However, the Q6600 can reach 3Ghz. Compare that to the Conroe, and its a bit slower, seeing as how Conroes easily reach 3.6Ghz -- which would be faster than 4 cores for 99% of the applications out there, currently. I don't think a quad core will be necessary until at least a year from now.
Note that this guy's last system lasted him four years. Some people are of the mind to over-build now, and sit on it until you can't use it anymore. Having 2x the number of cores will go a long way to increasing the lifespan of a PC, especially with apps getting more and more multithreaded.
 
Note that this guy's last system lasted him four years. Some people are of the mind to over-build now, and sit on it until you can't use it anymore. Having 2x the number of cores will go a long way to increasing the lifespan of a PC, especially with apps getting more and more multithreaded.

It may, but the price premium is too high. A CPU who's price drops in half within ~6 months is a waste, imo, no matter how long you keep a PC. You'll get a spare dual core, and a quad core, for the same price half a year later... you could even sell the dual core to help offset the cost.
 
If he waits that long he might as well wait for Barcelona, and if he waits for Barcelona he might as well wait for Penryn, and if he waits for Penryn he might as well wait for Nehalem...

There's always a price cut or better product coming down the pipe. No point in waiting forever.
 
If he waits that long he might as well wait for Barcelona, and if he waits for Barcelona he might as well wait for Penryn, and if he waits for Penryn he might as well wait for Nehalem...

There's always a price cut or better product coming down the pipe. No point in waiting forever.

I didnt say twiddle your thumbs and wait for a quad core. I suggested a dual core NOW. A dual core now is more practical than a quad core, especially because of the price premium. You get an E6600 now for $235, use it until the Q6600 drops to $266 as planned. When it drops to $266, u can sell the E6600 for at least $100, bringing the total cost down to $166 + $235, or keep it as a spare CPU in case you fry the Q6600 while trying to push it past 3.2Ghz, lol. If you keep it as a spare, you'll spend a total of $501, which is still less than $535 for the quad core now. If you sell it, you'll spend a total of $400 -- even better.

What applications/scenarios would benefit from quad core right now, on a desktop, single-user-at-a-time environment, to warrant the current $300 price premium?
 
Some people don't like to constantly upgrade their box. This guy has kept the same box for four years. He tells us he has a very large budget, and he's sick of upgrading. I provided the suggestion that doesn't involve a major upgrade in six months.

For all intents and purposes, dual core isn't "necessary" right now. Nor is 4 GB of RAM, or maybe even 2 GB for that matter. Nor is a DX10 capable video card. Tell me, what game out there now takes advantage of DX10? How many years will it be before we get DX10-only games? Why not just get a 7800GTX? That'll run most games out there now, right?

To answer your question, there are lots of applications right now that could benefit from a quad-core CPU. Apart from the qualitative gains (snappier OS, etc), a quad core CPU could effectively double his Folding@Home performance and shave a significant amount of time off of any video encoding. I find video encoding to be a likely scenario for this user, since he plans on using his box as an HTPC with an HDTV. Takes a lot of horsepower to efficiently crunch video, and even more to even *render* HD video. There are lots of apps which could benefit from more cores, just because you don't use any of them doesn't mean they aren't out there.
 
To answer your question, there are lots of applications right now that could benefit from a quad-core CPU. Apart from the qualitative gains (snappier OS, etc), a quad core CPU could effectively double his Folding@Home performance and shave a significant amount of time off of any video encoding. I find video encoding to be a likely scenario for this user, since he plans on using his box as an HTPC with an HDTV. Takes a lot of horsepower to efficiently crunch video, and even more to even *render* HD video. There are lots of apps which could benefit from more cores, just because you don't use any of them doesn't mean they aren't out there.

I use a quad-core everyday at work. Its not much faster for every day tasks than a dual core last gen cpu. At least not enough to warrant the price premium. It only shows its strength when several people are running sims simultaneously.

I don't think a CPU is a huge upgrade. While a dual core isn't a necessity for most people, it is more practical than a quad core. While 2GB of RAM isn't a necessity for most people, it is more practical. While all your points are valid, I'm merely stating whats practical. Yes, he has the budget for it, but for all intensive purposes, it isn't practical. Thats just my opinion. It all comes from first hand experience.

But you're telling me spending a little less time video encoding is worth $300? I guess, to some people.

@OP: So, if a little faster video encoding and folding@home is worth the $300 price premium, go for it! In fact, you'll probably need folding@home to put your money to good use.
 
ok, thanks for all the extra advice, but i had already ordered the machine bhy the time the 2nd half of the replies came in... i've got the system built, everything went smoothly, and i love the lian-li case... sleek & light

but, i'm having trouble getting Raid 0 ... i've never done this before, so i'm kind of hacking in the dark... any guidance (especially specific experience and advice for the P5W DH Deluxe or other Asus boards) would be greatly appreciated... i can get the 2x320 GBs to show up separately, but i'm having trouble instantiating the RAID array.

i started another thread in the motherboard forum:

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1031014858&postcount=1
 
Back
Top