Putting a computer together

Stefan

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 27, 2003
Messages
266
Hey, I'm building a computer, wondering if I can get some insight on some of the hardware I've selected, and looking for suggestions on other hardware...
(THIS IS STRICTLY A GAMING RIG, NO GRAPHICS OR AUDIO EDITING)
Alright, so...

CPU: Intel Core 2 DUOE6600 2.4 GHZ - Good?

HD: Seagate Barracuda 320 GB

Memory: OCZ Platinum XTC 2 1 gb sticks DDR2-800 (What's difference between this and gold? And is there faster / better memory for gaming?)

Video Card: EVGA E-GEFORCE 8600 GTS SuperClocked (I've heard negative things about this card, should I go straight to the 8800 and stomach the extra cash? the 8800 is 640mb, this is 256, curious if this will have a huge effect... anddd, is it worth going to superclocked, or should I just get the typical 8600 gts ... I've also always been a fan of ATI, but I've heard negative things about their current gen cards... insight?)

Tower: Antec Sonata II Black ATX 16IN Mid Tower Quiet Case 3X5.25 2X3.5 4X3.5IN 450W Air Duct 120MM Fan (Now I don't know too much about towers, this seems to be the most popular on www.ncix.com - and has the most reviews... It comes with a PSU, wondering if this will be sufficient for what i'm looking for, or does anyone have any recomendations for towers.)

Mainboard: ASUS P5B ATX LGA775 Conroe 965P DDR2 PCI-E16 3PCI-E1 3PCI 6 SATA2 Sound Motherboard (Again, not too familiar with Motherboards, curious if this will support everything I'm looking to purchase. From what I read, it will, but I might have missed something. Any insight would be terrific, and perhaps suggestions.)

PSU: Relative to the tower of course, do I need something more powerful than the one provided?

Physics Card: Is this even necassary at this point? I've heard negative things about them.

Sound Card: I currently have a Creative Soundblaster Audigy 2 7.1, it's clearly dated, HOWEVER, I've really never had any problems with it, and only use some Icemat headphones, that has its own external soundcard. Should I invest in a better soundcard, or just continue with this?

Cooling: Should I get some extra fans or anything? My old CPU got fried, I really dont want that, just any suggestions on it would be great.

DVD/CD drives: Someone told me that the new mobo's don't support that many of the older drives, never heard anything at all about this, but I have one dvd writer, and one cd writer currently, wondering if everything will be gravy when I get a new mobo.

Heatsink: Necassary? (Probably not going to overclock, might... mildly...)

Finally, monitor.
I have a good 19" crt right now, is it worth upgrading to an LCD right now? Just some suggestions would be great.
Thanks all in advance. I know im asking quite a bit, so just any little bits of info would be great.
 
that cpu is great for oc'ing

as far as hdd.... i think you should cough up some extra dough for a 150gb raptor. use the raptor for your os and games and the seagate for your media files. if you want a strict gaming rig go with the 640mb 8800 gts. the performance will be leaps and bounds better. the tower looks just fine but im not sure about the psu. i dont know much about psu's. you will probably be just fine with the stock cooling you have in your case if you dont plan on oc'ing. If you do then you need to get aftermarket cpu cooling.
 
I know this is a great community, any insight at all ladies and gents, any at all!
 
that cpu is great for oc'ing

as far as hdd.... i think you should cough up some extra dough for a 150gb raptor. use the raptor for your os and games and the seagate for your media files. if you want a strict gaming rig go with the 640mb 8800 gts. the performance will be leaps and bounds better. the tower looks just fine but im not sure about the psu. i dont know much about psu's. you will probably be just fine with the stock cooling you have in your case if you dont plan on oc'ing. If you do then you need to get aftermarket cpu cooling.

no, he shouldn't because the 7200.10 drives from seagate are just as fast. the raptor drives never were *that* much faster anyway. Doesn't matter one bit for gaming.


CPU: Intel Core 2 DUOE6600 2.4 GHZ - Good? yep

HD: Seagate Barracuda 320 GB yep

Memory: OCZ Platinum XTC 2 1 gb sticks DDR2-800 (What's difference between this and gold? And is there faster / better memory for gaming?) just get whatever is cheapest with 4-4-4 timings and ddr2 800. OCZ is a good brand

Video Card: EVGA E-GEFORCE 8600 GTS SuperClocked (I've heard negative things about this card, should I go straight to the 8800 and stomach the extra cash? the 8800 is 640mb, this is 256, curious if this will have a huge effect... anddd, is it worth going to superclocked, or should I just get the typical 8600 gts ... I've also always been a fan of ATI, but I've heard negative things about their current gen cards... insight?) go for the 8800, or wait a couple of weeks for what looks to be an impressive ati linup

Tower: Antec Sonata II Black ATX 16IN Mid Tower Quiet Case 3X5.25 2X3.5 4X3.5IN 450W Air Duct 120MM Fan (Now I don't know too much about towers, this seems to be the most popular on www.ncix.com - and has the most reviews... It comes with a PSU, wondering if this will be sufficient for what i'm looking for, or does anyone have any recomendations for towers.) If you like it, thats what matters. You'd ideally like to have 120mm exhaust and intake, at least

Mainboard: ASUS P5B ATX LGA775 Conroe 965P DDR2 PCI-E16 3PCI-E1 3PCI 6 SATA2 Sound Motherboard (Again, not too familiar with Motherboards, curious if this will support everything I'm looking to purchase. From what I read, it will, but I might have missed something. Any insight would be terrific, and perhaps suggestions.) will be fine

PSU: Relative to the tower of course, do I need something more powerful than the one provided? yes check the psu forum for recs

Physics Card: Is this even necassary at this point? I've heard negative things about them. no

Sound Card: I currently have a Creative Soundblaster Audigy 2 7.1, it's clearly dated, HOWEVER, I've really never had any problems with it, and only use some Icemat headphones, that has its own external soundcard. Should I invest in a better soundcard, or just continue with this? wait, what? Thats a good card, man.

Cooling: Should I get some extra fans or anything? My old CPU got fried, I really dont want that, just any suggestions on it would be great. scythe ninja, tuniq tower, zalman 9700 (they look so cool!) are all very good, solid cpu coolers. If your case doesn't come with case fans for its slots, get some.

DVD/CD drives: Someone told me that the new mobo's don't support that many of the older drives, never heard anything at all about this, but I have one dvd writer, and one cd writer currently, wondering if everything will be gravy when I get a new mobo. perhaps they were talking about modern mobos only having one IDE channel, meaning that you can only fit two IDE devices in your pc. everything else has to be SATA. if thats the case, IDE->SATA adapters are cheaply available. Just make sure your HDS have SATA interfaces and you'll be fine

Heatsink: Necassary? (Probably not going to overclock, might... mildly...) necessary, yes lol. Whether or not you want anything better than stock cpu cooler depends on you. Like I said, the tuniq/zalman/sycthe are all good


good luck
 
Video Card: Ditch the 8600GTS and go with the 8800GTS for around $270 if you shop around. Or better yet wait a couple of weeks to see what ATI's lineup of DX10 cards. Right now the price of the 8600GTS (around $200 or so) isn't very attractive and it's performance is roughly equal to current $150 DX9 cards.

Tower: Cases are a metter of personal choice. Just choose whatever case you want and can live with. But FYI, the PSU that comes with the Sonata II is a pretty decent PSU but I dunno if it can power an 8800GTS. It should be able to though.

PSU: If you happen to ditch the Sonata II and gone with another case that may not come with a power supply, then I recommend the XClio 460W Stablepower PSU or the XClio 500W Goodpower PSU. Either one will be fine for your setup.

Other than that, you got a solid build. Oh and be sure to pay attention to Thrawn's advice.
 
Awesome, thanks guys.
So the new ATI will be out shortly eh?
Wont the first version ATIs have problems though?
I've been using a 9500 pro oc'd to a 9700 pro and it's done wonders for me, but I've been told by a lot of sources that the Geforce 8800 is where it's at right now...
 
Some sites are reporting that ATI's lineup of DX10 cards are going to be released around May 14th. Dunno if there's going to be any teething problem with the ATis but most of those problems should be resolved soon after launch. Yes right now the 8800GTS is where its at but since ATI's cards are so close to launch, it's best to wait and see what ATI brings to the table. Although if you feel that you can't wait two weeks for the new cards, then go for an 8800GTS 320MB card.
 
If you want to do some mild overclocking, look into the P5B-E instead of the P5B vanilla. Other good choices would be the GA-965P-DS3, or the MSI P6N SLI-FI.

Raptors are great, but are more of a luxury than a necessity. My raptor gets about 78MB/s avg transfer rate, while my 7200.10 gets about 65MB/s -- thats some damn good speed for much less cost.

As far as ram goes, you really won't notice the difference between CL4 and CL5 @ DDR2-800 speeds. And if you're not OC'ing, or only OC'ing mildly, stick with some DDR2-667 sticks if they're cheaper for you. The good thing with the DDR2-800 CL5 sticks is that you should be able to lower the timings for the lower speeds. If you won't be OC'ing or only OC'ing mildly, you'll most likely be running at a lower speed. Stock settings for the E6600 will be 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, which is DDR2-533. A mild OC to 3Ghz is possible on the stock intel cooler, which would require the following settings: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667. If you want a really good OC, you'll need a better CPU HSF, as suggested by thrawn86... with which you could reach 3.6Ghz (9*400; DDR2-800).

As for the PSU, keep in mind Antec had a bad run of PSU's sometime last year, and old stock is still in the wild... so you may need to RMA that puppy. However, that 450W is rather weak on the +12v rails, so if you want a better one, check out the two that Danny recommended. I don't know if they're available at ncix, though. Check out jonnyguru.com's forums for more suggestions.

The R600 should be out pretty soon, which should push prices down on the current DX10 cards... for the sake of competition. I don't know if they'll have problems, but I'm sure if they do, you could always RMA it for a stable version. All new hardware has issues... hell, look at the errata list for the Core (2) Duo's, lol. The GF 8800 is where its at right now cuz you have no other choice. So, take Danny's advice.
 
no, he shouldn't because the 7200.10 drives from seagate are just as fast. the raptor drives never were *that* much faster anyway. Doesn't matter one bit for gaming.

tomshardware.com

look at the hdd charts. raptor out performs the seagate in almost every category. just as fast? i dont think so.
 
tomshardware.com

look at the hdd charts. raptor out performs the seagate in almost every category. just as fast? i dont think so.

Honestly you really won't notice the difference between the two. From tomshardware, the Seagate Barracuda trails behind the Raptor by 5-10 point. While the Raptors does outperform the Seagate, it doesn't lead it by much. Considering that the 36Gb and 150GB Raptor costs around $100 and $200 respectivey, it's a better choice to get the Seagate 320GB drive that costs around $80 and provides much more storage.

Though if a person has money to burn, then by all means, go for the Raptor.
 
tomshardware.com

look at the hdd charts. raptor out performs the seagate in almost every category. just as fast? i dont think so.

no, not as fast... but pretty damn close for a lot less money...

ST3320620AS: 65MB/s - $80
WD1500ADFD: 78MB/s - $205... difference: 18% performance increase for 2.5x the price.

Sure, uh huh, thats worth it... :rolleyes:

FYI, my raptor was hooked up ;) So I didnt pay that huge price premium, lol. Definately a nice drive, but not for the price. For the price of the seagate and the performance you get, its definately worth it over the Raptor. The Raptor is a luxury... so only get one if you have extra money to spend and don't want to deal with RAID and/or SAS.
 
Honestly you really won't notice the difference between the two. From tomshardware, the Seagate Barracuda trails behind the Raptor by 5-10 point. While the Raptors does outperform the Seagate, it doesn't lead it by much. Considering that the 36Gb and 150GB Raptor costs around $100 and $200 respectivey, it's a better choice to get the Seagate 320GB drive that costs around $80 and provides much more storage.

Though if a person has money to burn, then by all means, go for the Raptor.

k, so the barracudas have more than 4 times the storage space and at least 1.5x transfer rate as the raptor, but the raptor has lower seek times. how much difference would that make in rl? would u please link me to a review? thx in advance

brilliant minds coincide :)
i was talking about 2 320gb seagates in RAID0
 
(THIS IS STRICTLY A GAMING RIG, NO GRAPHICS OR AUDIO EDITING)

brilliant minds coincide :)
i was talking about 2 320gb seagates in RAID0

But even a single 'cuda is good enough for gaming. You won't really notice any huge improvements from a RAID0 array, nor a Raptor, while gaming. So your game levels load faster... a couple seconds here, a few seconds there... is it really worth the extra price? only if you have money to burn.
 
Hey, I'm building a computer, wondering if I can get some insight on some of the hardware I've selected, and looking for suggestions on other hardware...
(THIS IS STRICTLY A GAMING RIG, NO GRAPHICS OR AUDIO EDITING)
Alright, so...

CPU: Intel Core 2 DUOE6600 2.4 GHZ - Good?

Sure

HD: Seagate Barracuda 320 GB

Nice HDD. Never had any problems with any of my seagate drives.

Memory: OCZ Platinum XTC 2 1 gb sticks DDR2-800 (What's difference between this and gold? And is there faster / better memory for gaming?)

Video Card: EVGA E-GEFORCE 8600 GTS SuperClocked (I've heard negative things about this card, should I go straight to the 8800 and stomach the extra cash? the 8800 is 640mb, this is 256, curious if this will have a huge effect... anddd, is it worth going to superclocked, or should I just get the typical 8600 gts ... I've also always been a fan of ATI, but I've heard negative things about their current gen cards... insight?)

Tower: Antec Sonata II Black ATX 16IN Mid Tower Quiet Case 3X5.25 2X3.5 4X3.5IN 450W Air Duct 120MM Fan (Now I don't know too much about towers, this seems to be the most popular on www.ncix.com - and has the most reviews... It comes with a PSU, wondering if this will be sufficient for what i'm looking for, or does anyone have any recomendations for towers.)

Mainboard: ASUS P5B ATX LGA775 Conroe 965P DDR2 PCI-E16 3PCI-E1 3PCI 6 SATA2 Sound Motherboard (Again, not too familiar with Motherboards, curious if this will support everything I'm looking to purchase. From what I read, it will, but I might have missed something. Any insight would be terrific, and perhaps suggestions.)

PSU: Relative to the tower of course, do I need something more powerful than the one provided?

No you don't. All these 800+watt PSU's are a joke IMO. There not needed at all. I'm using a 350watt enermax that I bought almost 5 years ago now on a 3.4 prescott 24 pin using it as a 20 pin. OC'd to 4GHz no problems with power. Please don't be fooled by all the guys running out and buying 1000watt power supplies. They obviously don't know jack shit about what is really needed in PC's.

Physics Card: Is this even necassary at this point? I've heard negative things about them.

If you got the cash why not? It won't be bad for your gaming system.

Sound Card: I currently have a Creative Soundblaster Audigy 2 7.1, it's clearly dated, HOWEVER, I've really never had any problems with it, and only use some Icemat headphones, that has its own external soundcard. Should I invest in a better soundcard, or just continue with this?

I would stick with it as it is a decent souind card.

Cooling: Should I get some extra fans or anything? My old CPU got fried, I really dont want that, just any suggestions on it would be great.

DVD/CD drives: Someone told me that the new mobo's don't support that many of the older drives, never heard anything at all about this, but I have one dvd writer, and one cd writer currently, wondering if everything will be gravy when I get a new mobo.

Heatsink: Necassary? (Probably not going to overclock, might... mildly...)

Finally, monitor.
I have a good 19" crt right now, is it worth upgrading to an LCD right now? Just some suggestions would be great.
Thanks all in advance. I know im asking quite a bit, so just any little bits of info would be great.

Only thing to think about by going LCD is by going LCD you will usually more offten then not be forced into using the native res that comes with you LCD. That means high end video cards only.

I screwed up the quote I replied in your quote sorry...
 
no, not as fast... but pretty damn close for a lot less money...

ST3320620AS: 65MB/s - $80
WD1500ADFD: 78MB/s - $205... difference: 18% performance increase for 2.5x the price.

Sure, uh huh, thats worth it... :rolleyes:

FYI, my raptor was hooked up ;) So I didnt pay that huge price premium, lol. Definately a nice drive, but not for the price. For the price of the seagate and the performance you get, its definately worth it over the Raptor. The Raptor is a luxury... so only get one if you have extra money to spend and don't want to deal with RAID and/or SAS.

agreed. ill concede that point. I had the money to spend so thats why I got one. I just wanna get rid of this 320gb wd I have. Its...meh.
 
Back
Top