Android vs. Windows 7: What’s Better for your Netbook?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
eWeek compared Google Android and Microsoft Windows 7 Starter Edition from a netbook perspective and liked what they saw from Google. Acer recently announced that 3Q09 will see an Android-powered netbook join their product line and will provide a quick litmus test on whether the OS is ready for the next level.

"Netbooks are designed to be compact in size and easy to connect to the Internet wherever you go," Jim Wong, Acer’s president of IT products, said in a statement. "The Android operating system offers incredibly fast wireless connection to the Internet. For this reason, Acer has decided to develop Android Netbooks for added convenience to our customers."
 
Windows: Can run any existing Windows app.
Android: Can run any app in the last year or so since inception, programmed for Android.


Ummmm, yea... I'll keep Windows, thanks.
 
No for the truth!:D Windows 7 runs like a whore chasing a john down that owes her money on my Asus EeePC 1000H.

as much I like 7 (I am going to it as soon as I get the official release) they are talking net books and "lite" version of 7. I doubt its as fast as google's or as feature rich. I will be interested to see just how this pans out.
 
as much I like 7 (I am going to it as soon as I get the official release) they are talking net books and "lite" version of 7. I doubt its as fast as google's or as feature rich. I will be interested to see just how this pans out.

Windows 7 Ultimate RC runs very very well on my Dell Mini 9 with an 8GB SSD and 2GB of ram, it runs much better than Windows XP Home that came on the Dell.

I would like to see a lite version of 7 since the full version takes almost 7gigs for an install.
 
Even Vista ran okay on netbooks if you tweaked it a bit, Win7 just runs better w/minimal tweaking... Android's gonna have to provide a big tangible benefit other than possibly running a lil' faster on the same hardware, because netbooks are getting faster and otherwise it's gonna face all the same issues that regular flavors of Linux usually face on any desktop/laptop platform.
 
Seriously why Android? I see a novelty to it, but as a main OS no thanks. There is plenty of various Linux distributions that up to the task. And with Moblin v2 (final) around the corner would make a much wiser choice of an alternative OS.

Keep Android to what it does best, as a phone stack.
Win7 not even interested.
 
Seriously why Android? I see a novelty to it, but as a main OS no thanks. There is plenty of various Linux distributions that up to the task.

This.

Ubuntu is great on netbooks.

If you want as light as possible... DSL is pretty good :D
 
I'm running Windows 7 Ultimate on my Asus Eee 1000HE. It came with XP, but Windows 7 seems to be running WAY smoother. Even with the default config of 1gb RAM and slow 160gb drive, it was much snappier. I went ahead and added some Crucial 2gb and a Seagate 500gb, and it's running like a champ. Even with Windows 7 ULTIMATE, much less some netbook edition. I have all the eye candy turned on with Aero Peek, the Flip3d, and all that jazz. I like the fact I don't need to load k-lite codec pack anymnore either. Media Player plays all my xvid rips just fine and without any hiccups. Hulu works great in normal mode, but full screen HD seems to take a dive and get a little choppy. Windows 7 also found EVERY component on load...802.11n wireless, NIC, built in camera, graphics, etc. My external Verizon Wireless card also worked without a hitch.

It's better in RC than Vista after 2 service packs. Oh well, better late than never. And this frikkin Asus gets 9.5 hours battery life with a 6 cell. I watched Cars, Kung Fu Panda, and TinkerBell (I got a baby, get off me) all back to back and still have 60% battery left. Wow.
 
I think the Linux camp missed it's chance at greatness on netbooks to an extent, the crippled Linux distros that were present in many of the early netbooks were far too limiting... And rather that try something else most manufacturers simply went to WinXP as soon as most netbooks moved from SSDs to regular HDDs (cheap SSDs w/buggy controllers were the main performance bottleneck, not the Atom or 1GB of RAM). I dunno why Android would fare any better at this point.
 
I personally think the Atom core is holding all these netbooks back. You could likely clock down a near modern single core and get better performance for about the same power and money. Add in a better chipset like ATIs and you have a good system for Win7. With the current junk CPU and chipset I would say Android would likely be better with enough work on the UI.
 
i think the other thing you guys are not looking at is an android netbook probably wont be x86... probably will be less expensive hardware with better battery life... so that might make a whole new market for itself... a small, inexpensive internet machine with basic productivity tools powered by google apps and a large group of developers with a fairly open platform... dunno, i think it might turn out pretty cool if they play their cards right
 
Better battery life than the 6-8 hours some of the more current netbooks get? That'd be pretty amazing... If they go with an ARM processor or something else that might get interesting.
 
I think the Linux camp missed it's chance at greatness on netbooks to an extent, the crippled Linux distros that were present in many of the early netbooks were far too limiting... And rather that try something else most manufacturers simply went to WinXP as soon as most netbooks moved from SSDs to regular HDDs (cheap SSDs w/buggy controllers were the main performance bottleneck, not the Atom or 1GB of RAM). I dunno why Android would fare any better at this point.

It won't. It's just ANOTHER distro. Same shit, different name. Not to be a dick about it, but wake me up when the Linux community gets together and creates something I actually want to switch to. Until then, whatever. :eek:
 
I'm not entirely sure about Android it seems more to be for smartphones or mids, we'll what it will evolve into. I think it would compete more with Linux, than windows. Then again, for a netbook it could probably be okay.
 
All I can say is that it better not come with Chrome pre-loaded. That, of course, would make them a monopoly and anti-competitive and the EU would be forced to fine them millions of dollars. Isn't that right Mozilla and Opera?
 
All I can say is that it better not come with Chrome pre-loaded.

Pretty sure it does. If your company makes an operating system and a browser at the same time, what browser are you putting on your operating system?
 
All I can say is that it better not come with Chrome pre-loaded. That, of course, would make them a monopoly and anti-competitive and the EU would be forced to fine them millions of dollars. Isn't that right Mozilla and Opera?
If everything was a fair world, it'd work that way.
Except the Google-lovers will all drool at the mouths about this. It's only bad when Microsoft does it.

It won't. It's just ANOTHER distro. Same shit, different name. Not to be a dick about it, but wake me up when the Linux community gets together and creates something I actually want to switch to. Until then, whatever. :eek:
Linux's demise has been the same reason why people love it: So many variations.
Instead of concentrating efforts and support one one killer distro, everyone feels they have to go create their own flavor.
 
For a non-Windows netbook OS, Moblin 2.0 = win, Android = fail.
 
Instead of a netbook that can run Android, how about a phone which can run windows 7? We've gotta be pretty close by now.
 
My thoughts on the matter of what browser it uses are as follows if a operating system doesn't have a web browser how exactly are you supposed to get one on it? Think about it fresh windows install no web browser... how are you to go to the web and download firefox or opera or ie or "insert preferred browser here." Your not going to be able to since you cant go to the web and download one you would have to have the foresight to have it on a disk ahead of time. Everyone else does it so why does everyone jump down Microsofts throat about it...

linux usialy has firefox loaded
windows = ie
mac = safari
android should = chrome...

About the only way to make it fair to everyone else would be to make a web enabled wizard that runs during initial setup where you can pick from a list of the most popular browsers but then links to down load said browsers change not every one automatically has internet on boot and most users are dumb and wouldn't know which one they want anyway.

[/end rant]

I have wanted for some time a x86 distro of android to try out i hope google releases an image anyone can get like true linux...
 
My thoughts on the matter of what browser it uses are as follows if a operating system doesn't have a web browser how exactly are you supposed to get one on it?

That argument is true for desktops... But most people that own a smartphone own a computer too. They can download online from the internet.

I personally can care less if they package Chrome on here. It's just the pot calling the kettle black.
 
Back
Top