Android Market Pulls Popular Emulators

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Bowing to pressure from game maker Sega, Google has abruptly pulled some of its most popular paid emulator apps from its Android Market. Google has also pulled the developer’s privileges from the Market.

We got in touch with yongzh (or Yong Zhang, as he's known in real life) to discuss the matter, and he confirms that his developer account has been removed and his apps pulled without warning --
 
Some of the comments say the apps weren't Yong Zhang's to sell anyways. He took someone else's code and made an Android port. Even if Sega hadn't complained, something tells me Zhang's days were numbered anyways.
 
Some of the comments say the apps weren't Yong Zhang's to sell anyways. He took someone else's code and made an Android port. Even if Sega hadn't complained, something tells me Zhang's days were numbered anyways.

yep, stealing GPL code, then profiting without even having the decency to release the sourcde code of said stolen code = nono
 
Android market is a haven for pirates and thieves.

Google has been too lax for too long. Just do a search for emulators and you will find dozens of programs stolen and republished on the market. There are scam devs out there taking advantage of googles shitty policies.

There is no protection for the devs and little for the consumer. The 15 minute refund policy is a JOKE. 24 hours was barely enough, 15 minutes is an insult.

Here is a good example of what i mean. This person took a good emulator and repackaged it as his own and has flooded the android market with it under many different names.
 
Android market is a haven for pirates and thieves.

Google has been too lax for too long. Just do a search for emulators and you will find dozens of programs stolen and republished on the market. There are scam devs out there taking advantage of googles shitty policies.

There is no protection for the devs and little for the consumer. The 15 minute refund policy is a JOKE. 24 hours was barely enough, 15 minutes is an insult.

Here is a good example of what i mean. This person took a good emulator and repackaged it as his own and has flooded the android market with it under many different names.

Anything to artificially inflate the android marketplace numbers to make a competitive comparison to the app store, huh? ;)
 
Anything to artificially inflate the android marketplace numbers to make a competitive comparison to the app store, huh? ;)


Sure but who gives a damn how many apps there are? Most people will have 15-20 apps on their device they use. So I don't think anything about the "we have more apps" race.
 
Charging for emulators based on Open Source is wrong, and I could see them being pulled for breach of that license, but If they didn't contain any ROMs then I don't see where Sega has any legs to stand on.
 
Sure but who gives a damn how many apps there are? Most people will have 15-20 apps on their device they use. So I don't think anything about the "we have more apps" race.

Granted, but the number of apps increases the likelihood of finding what you need.
 
Android fans once believed (and perhaps still do, to some degree) that the hands-off approach Google took was good for the ecosystem, and that the hands-on-very-much-on, curated approach Apple took was evil, anti-developer and anti-consumer. I suspect that the more we see Google tightening their grip, the more we'll see Android fans embracing Google's newfound sense of control.
 
The Snes9x port says in its description that his snes emulator is based off snes9x which prohibits anyone using the source to profit, be it from ads or direct payments.

So I'm guessing his emulators are ports that go against this
 
Granted, but the number of apps increases the likelihood of finding what you need.


I disagree. You could have 10,000 apps like big boobies 15 and sexy wallpapers 26 and it doesn't help anyone. I am an Android supporter but it doesn't mean I agree with everything they do. I just ignore the ignorant fluff on the market. I assume most people are intelligent enough to search for what they want.
 
I disagree. You could have 10,000 apps like big boobies 15 and sexy wallpapers 26 and it doesn't help anyone. I am an Android supporter but it doesn't mean I agree with everything they do. I just ignore the ignorant fluff on the market. I assume most people are intelligent enough to search for what they want.

of course that doesn't mean that 10,000 apps about big boobies is necessiarily a bad thing.
 
The Snes9x port says in its description that his snes emulator is based off snes9x which prohibits anyone using the source to profit, be it from ads or direct payments.

So I'm guessing his emulators are ports that go against this

Yeah. I don't have any sympathy for people profiting off of someone else's hard work.

Grabbing something GPL'd and repackaging it for profit and violating the GPL is lame.
 
I disagree. You could have 10,000 apps like big boobies 15 and sexy wallpapers 26 and it doesn't help anyone. I am an Android supporter but it doesn't mean I agree with everything they do. I just ignore the ignorant fluff on the market. I assume most people are intelligent enough to search for what they want.

He said the likelihood, not the absolute certainty of finding what you're looking for.

Lets say you have 2 stores, one holds about 100,000 items and another that holds 50,000. And they are geared towards the same sales... it's more likle you'll find it at the 100,00 store than the 50,000 store. Is it possible to get it at both? yes, is it possible to get it at the smaller, and not the bigger? yes, but is it more likely to get it at the bigger store because they have a bigger selection? yes.
 
Also, no sympathy here as well, profiting off of other's hard work is just wrong.
 
Android fans once believed (and perhaps still do, to some degree) that the hands-off approach Google took was good for the ecosystem, and that the hands-on-very-much-on, curated approach Apple took was evil, anti-developer and anti-consumer. I suspect that the more we see Google tightening their grip, the more we'll see Android fans embracing Google's newfound sense of control.

Just because it works that way for you, your Stockholm Syndrome with Apple, doesn't mean it works that way for everyone else.

We still have side loading. Enjoy being restricted only to the App Store unless you jailbreak your phone.
 
Android fans once believed (and perhaps still do, to some degree) that the hands-off approach Google took was good for the ecosystem, and that the hands-on-very-much-on, curated approach Apple took was evil, anti-developer and anti-consumer. I suspect that the more we see Google tightening their grip, the more we'll see Android fans embracing Google's newfound sense of control.

Depends on how that control is worked out.

The hands-off approach has its merits, as does the iron-fisted approach. But with merits come flaws, and they both have approaches that make sense for different reasons despite those flaws.

If it becomes an iron-fist approach, I won't be embracing it. I will be seeking alternatives if there are any.

If it becomes a little bit more well handled, as in Google actually reviewing code to make sure it is not malicious at the very least, I can handle something like that. I actually agree with that, as well as the removal of copycats out to make money on code they didn't actually make themselves. Things like that make sense.

What doesn't make sense to me is that on iTunes you can get R-rated movies (which CAN contain nudity) and music that gets Parental Advisory warnings, yet you can't get an app with similar "objectional content", even if it's from the author of said objectional content. I don't know if this is still the case, but stuff like that in the link is part of why I refuse to use iTunes or an iPhone. Don't tell me I can't get objectional content yet offer it anyway, just in a different form. It's stupid, hypocritical, and a total turn-off. I refuse to buy CDs or movies from Wal-Mart for this very reason no matter what the price is and happily pay the markup at Best Buy or Fry's whenever I want to own a copy of the album/movie in question. Yeah I may pay more, but at least the cases don't look like they've been run over by a pallet jack.
 
The hands-off approach has its merits, as does the iron-fisted approach. But with merits come flaws, and they both have approaches that make sense for different reasons despite those flaws.
I think there's a good middle ground. The Android Marketplace is essentially a free-for-all while the App Store is a censored walled garden, and I think somewhere in-between is where the Marketplace might eventually end up. Google taking a cautious hands-on approach could improve the overall experience without really shutting anyone out (given the Marketplace isn't the only game in town), and to me that makes sense.
 
the dude was profiting off other people's work, don't see an issue.. now I wonder if google will give me a refund? (I actually purchased one of his apps)
 
Charging for emulators based on Open Source is wrong, and I could see them being pulled for breach of that license, but If they didn't contain any ROMs then I don't see where Sega has any legs to stand on.

I mentioned this a while ago on XDA-developers in the G1 section. The fact that this guy released perfectly working emulators on his own is what struck me suspicious. It took Snes9x nearly a decade to work perfectly, and N64 emulators still don't work 100% to this day. Then suddenly this guy was able to do this on his own? It was obvious that he was taking code from open source emulators, and charging for it.

Now if these emulators were removed so Sega can get more sales for reselling their old games, then shame on Sega. I bought the game once, and once is enough.
 
I think there's a good middle ground. The Android Marketplace is essentially a free-for-all while the App Store is a censored walled garden, and I think somewhere in-between is where the Marketplace might eventually end up. Google taking a cautious hands-on approach could improve the overall experience without really shutting anyone out (given the Marketplace isn't the only game in town), and to me that makes sense.

I agree. That would make sense as well.
 
meh just download it off demonoid or such, or off another android store of some type...meh enough said
 
the dude was profiting off other people's work, don't see an issue.. now I wonder if google will give me a refund? (I actually purchased one of his apps)

I mentioned this a while ago on XDA-developers in the G1 section. The fact that this guy released perfectly working emulators on his own is what struck me suspicious. It took Snes9x nearly a decade to work perfectly, and N64 emulators still don't work 100% to this day. Then suddenly this guy was able to do this on his own? It was obvious that he was taking code from open source emulators, and charging for it.

Now if these emulators were removed so Sega can get more sales for reselling their old games, then shame on Sega. I bought the game once, and once is enough.

That's exactly why I never bought his emulators. He basically wrote a Java wrapper and stole the actual emulator code. That's why the apps were removed. If they had been written from the ground up I'm willing to bet the emulators would still be on the market. Honestly, they should have been removed a long time ago, but I'm guessing Sega and Nintendo didn't make a big enough stink early on. Even Sony allowed the PSX emulator to be on the market until the Xperia Play was announced.
 
Back
Top