Amino Acid Found in Comet Tail

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
The amino acid glycine, the most common of the 20 amino acids on proteins found on Earth, was detected in microscopic amounts from a sample of comet Wild 2’s tail. It took a few years to confirm that the sample was not contaminated and astrobiologists now feel confident enough to announce that the sample is indeed extraterrestrial. Did we come to Earth a long time ago from a galaxy far, far away? Are these remnants of Cylons? Did a Stargate explode somewhere? (Insert bad sci-fi analogy here) :D

The latest findings add credence to the notion that extraterrestrial objects such as meteorites and comets may have seeded ancient Earth, and other planets, with the raw materials of life that formed elsewhere in the cosmos.
 
Damn, didn't you watch that episode of Star Trek TNG where they explain where all life came from? It was this race 4 billion years ago that went around seeding planets with the basic building blocks of intelligent life. This comet is just one of their projects let loose to wander the galaxy. Mystery solved.

http://sttng.epguides.info/?ID=320
 
I'm gonna love reading this thread as the night goes on. I anticipate that my sci-Q will go up. :)
 
Damn, didn't you watch that episode of Star Trek TNG where they explain where all life came from? It was this race 4 billion years ago that went around seeding planets with the basic building blocks of intelligent life. This comet is just one of their projects let loose to wander the galaxy. Mystery solved.

http://sttng.epguides.info/?ID=320

So these aliens went willy-nilly all over the Universe jizzing the "seeds" of life everywhere? :eek:
 
looking at it from a strictly math point of view, the probability that there is life out there is damn near 100%. As to whether its super advanced or simple bacteria who knows.

If you look at our galaxy alone -- billions of stars each with hoever many planets, multiply that times the billions/trillions of galaxies and you will have something pop up.
 
The amino acid glycine, the most common of the 20 amino acids on proteins found on Earth, was detected in microscopic amounts from a sample of comet Wild 2’s tail. It took a few years to confirm that the sample was not contaminated and astrobiologists now feel confident enough to announce that the sample is indeed extraterrestrial. Did we come to Earth a long time ago from a galaxy far, far away? Are these remnants of Cylons? Did a Stargate explode somewhere? (Insert bad sci-fi analogy here) :D

stargate isnt' bad :p lol
 
Yeah, the chance of life having ever existed over the entire course other than on Earth is really high. However, humans have only been around for a speck of time compared to 15 billion years of time. So, it can be argued that the chance of an intelligent species to evolve interstellar travel or even just communication at the exact moment in time that we do is a lot lower.

Not to mention that other life might be less advanced so we can't detect them as easily or they are too advanced so they don't notice us or they're too far away for us to communicate before humans get wiped out.
 
I've seen "The Andromeda Strain"!
I've seen how these things work! We're doomed! hehe
 
Yeah, the chance of life having ever existed over the entire course other than on Earth is really high. However, humans have only been around for a speck of time compared to 15 billion years of time. So, it can be argued that the chance of an intelligent species to evolve interstellar travel or even just communication at the exact moment in time that we do is a lot lower.

Not to mention that other life might be less advanced so we can't detect them as easily or they are too advanced so they don't notice us or they're too far away for us to communicate before humans get wiped out.

On the other hand with hundreds of billions of galaxies, each with hundreds of billions of stars, there is also a ver good chance that there are billions of inhabited planets, so it could be argued that there should be at least a few thousand around our general level.

Though, given the size of the universe, it would be tough to ever find them anyway.
 
Noooo! We came from Mars! Martians knew their planet was about to lose its magnetic field (thus space would erode its atmosphere), so they packed up, settled on Earth, killed the dinosaurs, and started from scratch!
 
if you can get a picture of the comet with an [h] they will post it on hardocp

lol
 
I'm not sure why it is a big deal or why people need to believe that most of the organic material on Earth came from comets or other extra-terrestrial bodies. Some of it could have, but it seems just as likely that most of that organic material would have been destroyed upon entry into the atmosphere or after the colossal impact which followed.

They've done plenty of experiments showing that organic compounds - the "seeds of life" - could have easily formed under the conditions in the primordial soup which was our ancient oceans. From there, it is a bigger step from inert compounds to actual life, but it obviously happened, since we are here. It seems more likely to me that life formed and evolved on this planet, rather than being formed and evolved on other planets and somehow making it's way here. Either way, you are faced with the question of life from non-life.

The idea of an advanced race "seeding" the galaxy has been around for a long time and is a classic idea of science fiction. It was just reproduced in ST:TNG and Stargate, but has been a lot of other places as well.
 
Great... we were born from the gasses shooting out of the tail of a comet.... niiiiiice.

God does have a sense of humor it seems
 
Astrochemists have detected several amino acids in interstellar space. There are many chemical processes that can form them in that environment. Seeding of the earth of amino acids from space is one of the stronger theories for how they got on earth in the first place.
 
The "seeding" ideas, if proven correct, don't get us any closer to the origins of life. They simply move the origins from here to there. How did the amino acid form in the comet? Where did the 4 billion old race come from?

These are lateral findings. In other words: why care?
 
people that say stuff like we are alone in the universe and we did not evolve we were created in gods image and the earth is only 6,000 years old etc etc need to kill themselves... no duh there is life out there... and its really sad when I think about how truly small we all are on this tiny planet :(
 
people that say stuff like we are alone in the universe and we did not evolve we were created in gods image and the earth is only 6,000 years old etc etc need to kill themselves... no duh there is life out there... and its really sad when I think about how truly small we all are on this tiny planet :(

That's pretty harsh.

Where would the likes of Faux News be without their misinformed,mouth-breathing, creationist dittoheads?

Everyone deserves a chance at life, even the really, really stupid people.
 
yeah :( I'm a little bitter towards those people. I grew up with a catholic step mom. haha. I hated that bitch
 
The confirmation is nice. I don't know what happened to my skeptism--I just assumed we knew this to be true.

I'd be more excited if they'd found midi-chlorians, though.
 
That's pretty harsh.

Where would the likes of Faux News be without their misinformed,mouth-breathing, creationist dittoheads?

Everyone deserves a chance at life, even the really, really stupid people.

I love when creationists ask me for proof of evolution. I am a paleontologist, and I carry a USB stick that has my MS thesis on it, for backup. All I need to do is plug it in and boom: 500mb of jpg images of a succesion of fossil plankton from a Cretaceous limestone, one gradually evolving into another. Shuts 'em the. fuck. up.
 
In a mixture containing the necessary elements, bombarded with cosmic radiation over thousands and thousands of years, I'd be far more surprised if we didn't find any. Glycine is a simple enough molecule that you'd expect trace amounts to form by random chance.
 
I love when creationists ask me for proof of evolution. I am a paleontologist, and I carry a USB stick that has my MS thesis on it, for backup. All I need to do is plug it in and boom: 500mb of jpg images of a succesion of fossil plankton from a Cretaceous limestone, one gradually evolving into another. Shuts 'em the. fuck. up.

Uhm, correct me if I'm wrong but you won't have a successful evolutionary transition within one sedimentary layer. Now during the cretacious you did have a lot of oceanic anoxic events, but still it would require multiple epochs to show a gradual evolution of the plankton, at least that is what I think I remember.

But anyways, you know creationist really aren't the "enemy", most of them really aren't educated enough to know better or feel that if they agree with "evolutionists" they are denying their belief structure. My Dad is a die hard creationist and to me it doesn't matter. There are so many variables in the scriptures but no where does it say that the Earth is 6,000 years old, but many people belive Ussher's time table for whatever reason. The hostility displayed against people with differing opinions has always fascinated me, but scientists are generally some of the most antagonistic and hard headed group of people I've had the pleasure of working with.
 
They've done plenty of experiments showing that organic compounds - the "seeds of life" - could have easily formed under the conditions in the primordial soup which was our ancient oceans. From there, it is a bigger step from inert compounds to actual life, but it obviously happened, since we are here. It seems more likely to me that life formed and evolved on this planet, rather than being formed and evolved on other planets and somehow making it's way here. Either way, you are faced with the question of life from non-life.
IMO, it doesn't matter whether the amino acids formed in the primordial soup on earth or were seeded here. The mere fact that amino acids can be seeded only increases the chances that life exists elsewhere.
 
The big problem I would see with this is that object + "Entering Orbit" = Fireball. It would burn up. Interesting find but doesn't amount to much when it cooks in the atmosphere. Granted there may not have been one at the time it happened. Then the other thing is time. Sure a planet teaming with life could have exploded but in the time it would have taken to get it here would have been plenty long and a lot of the acid's could have dried up, frozen etc...
It's like, we found something. What did we find? Not sure but it sounds neat. That is what a lot of these science news end up being.
 
Uhm, correct me if I'm wrong but you won't have a successful evolutionary transition within one sedimentary layer. Now during the cretacious you did have a lot of oceanic anoxic events, but still it would require multiple epochs to show a gradual evolution of the plankton, at least that is what I think I remember.

But anyways, you know creationist really aren't the "enemy", most of them really aren't educated enough to know better or feel that if they agree with "evolutionists" they are denying their belief structure. My Dad is a die hard creationist and to me it doesn't matter. There are so many variables in the scriptures but no where does it say that the Earth is 6,000 years old, but many people belive Ussher's time table for whatever reason. The hostility displayed against people with differing opinions has always fascinated me, but scientists are generally some of the most antagonistic and hard headed group of people I've had the pleasure of working with.

You're right. Mark me impressed. You'll never see transitions in a single bed, but I'm looking at an entire formation. And yes, there were several OAE's, and they did interact with the plankton assemblages (mostly by killing them off, lol -- I'm looking for OAE 2 the 'Bonarelli' event, fyi). But the evolutionary changes are often quite "rapid" on a geologic timescale, even when compared to a timeframe as small as an epoch -- it only takes probably a few hundred thousand years for speciation to occur.

The scientific community is quite rightly outraged by the creationist movement, because it is a community that inherently does not accept the scientific method. They draw their conclusion (that there is a creator) first, THEN try to find evidence to support that conclusion. It is not science, and it never will be science. That's why it has been shut down in the Supreme Court. Creationists use their agenda to spread dogma over reason, and to further their own non-secular political agendas. They have absolutely no regard for the honest and ethically-right pursuit of true knowledge, and have no business attempting to discredit good, solid science with disinformation. In no way should any individual who purports to honor the ethics of true and free scientific inquiry ever tolerate creationism
 
But anyways, you know creationist really aren't the "enemy", most of them really aren't educated enough to know better or feel that if they agree with "evolutionists" they are denying their belief structure. My Dad is a die hard creationist and to me it doesn't matter. There are so many variables in the scriptures but no where does it say that the Earth is 6,000 years old, but many people belive Ussher's time table for whatever reason. The hostility displayed against people with differing opinions has always fascinated me, but scientists are generally some of the most antagonistic and hard headed group of people I've had the pleasure of working with.

It isn't that creationists exist that is the issue.. It's that there is a certain vocal segment of them that want to force schools to teach it as fact that's the problem..
 
Because the creationists entire paradigm is centered around "conclusion, therefore evidence", they assume that scientists operate in the same manner, e.g. that they have their own evil atheist agendas for which they skew their "evidence." This is downright insulting to many scientists on a very personal level, and I think that's where a lot of the hostility comes from. Many scientists hold themselves to a very strict moral code of ethics, one of NEVER drawing preconceived conclusions, and ALWAYS keeping an open mind about the DATA (NOT "competing theories").
 
It isn't that creationists exist that is the issue.. It's that there is a certain vocal segment of them that want to force schools to teach it as fact that's the problem..

What can possibly be involved in teaching creationism - oh wait, I mean "intelligent design" - other than a big sign that says "God did it"?

Keep that shit in Kansas or Texas - wherever that silliness is rearing it's head right now.
 
Life here began out there. (Sorry, had to toss in a BSG reference.)

Guess that answers the question "What does God need with a starship?" :D
 
Back
Top