AMD Wants to Retake the Datacenter

“Retake”? LOL
Never had it to begin with. I wish they WOULD take it from intel. I would LOVE it if Epyc spread en masse.
HPE and Cisco say their biggest threat is AWS/Azure, yet the prices on their latest server offerings are DOUBLE of 4 years ago. I cannot believe how expensive compute has gotten. Sure Skylake has more cores and lots of memory, but like for like, natural progression from just a few gens ago is 2x the cost.
They are driving people to cloud because of their asinine prices. Enterprise SAN and scale-out NAS is getting cheaper and faster while compute skyrocketed.
The way-above poster nailed it - they’re pushing hard away from traditional rack compute into either HCI or just plain making it extremely difficult financially. Urging you away from rack servers n such.
And it happened in basically 1-2 server generations. Big boys is right. It’s getting tough to stay in the game if budgets are flat or shrinking.
 
“Retake”? LOL
Never had it to begin with. I wish they WOULD take it from intel. I would LOVE it if Epyc spread en masse.
HPE and Cisco say their biggest threat is AWS/Azure, yet the prices on their latest server offerings are DOUBLE of 4 years ago. I cannot believe how expensive compute has gotten. Sure Skylake has more cores and lots of memory, but like for like, natural progression from just a few gens ago is 2x the cost.
They are driving people to cloud because of their asinine prices. Enterprise SAN and scale-out NAS is getting cheaper and faster while compute skyrocketed.
The way-above poster nailed it - they’re pushing hard away from traditional rack compute into either HCI or just plain making it extremely difficult financially. Urging you away from rack servers n such.
And it happened in basically 1-2 server generations. Big boys is right. It’s getting tough to stay in the game if budgets are flat or shrinking.

I love the cloud bait-and-switch.

It's cheaper *now*. Get on board, make your infrastructure depend on it... and you're their bitch. The hassle of moving stuff around will make eating price increases a "lesser evil", and off it goes.

Every-friggin'-body is taking their piece out of that cake. Hardware providers have demand from both sides, so they just smile to everyone. Then you tell them to #*(*$% off, go to the cloud, and... well, we'll see.
 
I love the cloud bait-and-switch.

It's cheaper *now*. Get on board, make your infrastructure depend on it... and you're their bitch. The hassle of moving stuff around will make eating price increases a "lesser evil", and off it goes.

Every-friggin'-body is taking their piece out of that cake. Hardware providers have demand from both sides, so they just smile to everyone. Then you tell them to #*(*$% off, go to the cloud, and... well, we'll see.
Every cost-analysis I’ve done actually show there is NOTHING cheap about getting in. Once you dial in the performance your workloads actually require with right-sizing, it is so much more expensive it’s ridiculous. All egress traffic billed by the second, I/O billed by the second etc. The people who had no long term sense are now scrambling trying to pull workloads back on-prem as fast as possible. Certain workloads can make sense. But use prudence and go in slow.
 
Every cost-analysis I’ve done actually show there is NOTHING cheap about getting in. Once you dial in the performance your workloads actually require with right-sizing, it is so much more expensive it’s ridiculous. All egress traffic billed by the second, I/O billed by the second etc. The people who had no long term sense are now scrambling trying to pull workloads back on-prem as fast as possible. Certain workloads can make sense. But use prudence and go in slow.

For those who have it more expensive from the get-go, it's even worse.

But hoorah for buzzwords, I guess. Being a rational and honest salesman makes you a boring one.
 
For AMD to be competitive they need to get their whole box price down more. Memory prices are making them not be competitive on a dollars scale.
 
in the enthusiast community it's 50/50.. in the idiot world of people that don't know anything AMD still doesn't exist to them.. you ever want to see how uninformed people are, go into a best buy or fry's in the prebuild desktop/laptop area and mention AMD around them, they won't have a clue what you're talking about.

Let's be realistic here, you walk into any of those places, and odds are you are talking to the guy that normally sells washing machines or A/V equipment. it's not like the have schools they send the minimum wage sales staff to. to educate them in the difference between an I7 and a Ryzen 7.
 
Let's be realistic here, you walk into any of those places, and odds are you are talking to the guy that normally sells washing machines or A/V equipment. it's not like the have schools they send the minimum wage sales staff to. to educate them in the difference between an I7 and a Ryzen 7.

I think that goes for sales people in every industry, especially in retail.

It doesn't matter what I am shopping for, computers, cars, lawn mowers, snow blowers... You name it.

By the time I am in a store looking to buy something I've already done my research, and I know WAY more than any sales person I've ever encountered. I'd prefer the sales people just leave me alone. "No, you can't help me"
 
Let's be realistic here, you walk into any of those places, and odds are you are talking to the guy that normally sells washing machines or A/V equipment. it's not like the have schools they send the minimum wage sales staff to. to educate them in the difference between an I7 and a Ryzen 7.

i was referring to average customers, i already know how useless the employee's are so trying to talk to them about anything they're suppose to be experts at is about as useful as talking to a brick wall (disclaimer: i've worked at fry's and was a manager at bestbuy)
 
As a Microsoft developer, Hyper-V is free for us. They give us enough free production licenses for me to run the office.
Going with ESXi would be a huge expense compared to free.

I can already create a virtual test environment inside Hyper-V, so I don't need VMWare for that either.

As for power usage, I've already dropped it significantly when I got rid of our older servers by virtualizing them. The newer severs draw much less power over the day, even though they are running multiple virtual servers. Besides, we don't get a separate power bill as it's included in our lease. :D


See, it's all about the use case.
 
HPE and Cisco say their biggest threat is AWS/Azure, yet the prices on their latest server offerings are DOUBLE of 4 years ago. I cannot believe how expensive compute has gotten. Sure Skylake has more cores and lots of memory, but like for like, natural progression from just a few gens ago is 2x the cost.
They are driving people to cloud because of their asinine prices. Enterprise SAN and scale-out NAS is getting cheaper and faster while compute skyrocketed.
The way-above poster nailed it - they’re pushing hard away from traditional rack compute into either HCI or just plain making it extremely difficult financially. Urging you away from rack servers n such.
And it happened in basically 1-2 server generations. Big boys is right. It’s getting tough to stay in the game if budgets are flat or shrinking.

Which is why many of my servers are 5-6 years old and I have no plans on replacing them in the near term.

There are plenty of cheap used CPU's and memory to upgrade older servers.
I've upgrade a few of my servers from dual 2.4 quad core Xeons to dual 2.8 10 core Xeon and upgraded the memory to 128GB and even 256GB ram for a fraction of what a new server with similar specs would have cost.
3rd party drives like the WD gold line are also much cheaper than the vendors drives. Pulling out some old 1TB drive and replacing them with new 4TB drives also gives a performance boost. With the price of server level SSD's coming down, I've even started upgrading some to SSD's (I use the same Intel drives that Dell repackages at 3 times the price).

As long as I don't have a major hardware failure, my existing servers should be good for another few years.
 
For AMD to be competitive they need to get their whole box price down more. Memory prices are making them not be competitive on a dollars scale.

Unless I am missing something, both AMD and Intel's server parts use the same Registered ECC DDR4, so they should cost pretty much the same.

I agree, RAM prices are what are keeping me from upgrading my server, but that would be the same whether I were getting a new AMD or Intel system.
 
Give me a minute I want you all to see what I am seeing here on Dell's server build site. Maybe I am way off base.

Now that is interesting.

Compare the two builds I just did.


The V2 I JUST quoted... has 768 gig of ram. AND is 3k Cheaper than an nearly identical build last week with 512gb of ram. SERIOUSLY DELL?? WTF?? So the same build now is about 3k cheaper to go AMD. x 12 servers that's a good chunk of change.
 

Attachments

  • 2u R7425 VM host AMD CPU.pdf
    1.9 MB · Views: 0
  • 2u R7425 VM host AMD CPU v 2.pdf
    1.9 MB · Views: 0
Back
Top