AMD To Unleash A 5GHz Processor?

meh.. it's just probably a binned 8350 with a water cooler.


(I have an fx8350 system at 4.7Ghz)
 
Part of this is a catch22. I mean software developers can not design their software to require 8 cores since not 95% of their target audience does not have an 8 core cpu.

That and many software developers have not seen any benefit in certain applications in going to multi-threaded applications. It's not just that the market doesn't have more than 4 cores, it's just that there is a diminishing return on investment going over 4 cores.

If it was something like video encoding or 3D rendering or server software, then there is a benefit of more than 4 cores. But, something like Microsoft Word or your instant messenger program or other programs day-to-day see no benefit going more than one core. There are very few games that see benefit of 4 or more cores, but it's absolutely rare. Majority of the games are dual core maximum.

Even some of the programmers on [H] have commented similarly-- majority of the programs we use day-to-day do not see any benefit beyond one or two cores. What can Word or Skype or Thunderbird do with more than two cores? If there is a way to efficiently split tasks between cores such as checking email on one core, browsing a web page on the second core, and so on, then maybe that would push for the need of multi-threaded/multi-core processors. But, it's not happening.

I'm hoping with the PS4 and Xbox 720/NEXT that it'd push the need for more than 4 cores on the computer seeing that console games tend to be ported over to the PC anyway.
 
I love you more than intel amd but no i will not buy an faildozer at 5ghz but i will take a haswell E@ 5ghz
:D
 
"Don't be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed. The ability to destroy a heat sink is insignificant next to the power draw of The FX."
 
I dont get it?

I have 2 8320's running at 4.6 Ghz on air on Asus Sabretooth boards. Rumor has it the 8300 can do a bit better, so why is it even "a thing" that they could crank out hand selected chips that can do 5.0Ghz? :rolleyes:
 
I dont get it?

I have 2 8320's running at the 4.6 Ghz on air on Asus Sabretooth boards. Rumor has it the 8300 can do a bit better, so why is it even "a thing" that they could crank out hand selected chips that can do 5.0Ghz? :rolleyes:

Because the best you're going to get with a 8300 is 4.8 and most don't get that. A 8350 that'll not only do 5 GHz but do it while running cool enough for air, that is a pretty big deal. Not $800 big but still pretty cool.
 
Did I read that right? $795? That sounds more like a G34 socket chip than an AM3+
 
Whatever.

If it's the same arch as the FX-8350, even at 5Ghz, it will be beaten by a stock i7-3770 in per core performance.

they would need to bump the clock to ~6.5Ghz in order to beat the turbo clock of 3.9Ghz on the 3770 in core for core performance.

By all means AMD, please release higher clocked models, but giving them a racy name like centurion when they aren't even coming close to measuring up to the competition just makes you look silly.
 
AMD still makes processors for something other than garbage laptops? News to me. I've been AMD free for like 15 years now.
 
So factory overclocked chips that will have little to no additional OC headroom (and might even see problems reaching their advertised clock like some stock OC'd GFX cards have) for about the same price you could buy a 6 core i7 for that overclocks to about the same clock speed and performs about 50% better for most every task...

Neat.
 
way to many are biased to Intel, and mostly not for good reasons, and yes I read far far to many reviews, Intel chips faster, by all means, but generally 500Mhz difference not no 1Ghz+ performance differential, I think sir you need to read more reviews.

Example 2500k at stock FX8100 stock are approx same performance level
http://www.hardwaresecrets.com/arti...re-i5-2500K-and-Core-i7-2600K-CPU-Review/1402
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/434?vs=288
stock for 8150 3.9/4.2 turbo
2500k as you are aware 3.3/3.7 turbo

I am not saying they are "comparable" I am simply stating there is an approximate 500Mhz performance difference at all clocks, Intel case and point is far more energy efficient as it simply does not "need" to clock up to get its performance boosted, FX chips more or less have to(they are not crappy, they just are not as fast)

Anyways, you want to be Intel lover AMD hater, be the way you will, however, you should not be throwing very false information out without at least posting some reasonable data to back it, like I said, at least all I have read is exactly what my opinion is, AMD still does have good cpu and have for years, Intel clock for clock is faster however at the resolution that most of us play games at it means next to nothing for most games/tasks.

You are not going to have something that is magically fully smooth and playable on system 1 and something that is crap glitching out unplayable on system 2, f using appropriate hardware with good driver sets.

And Haswell will be updating their graphics and they will be quite powerfull compared to what they have now, however, the top chip which will use the best version GT3 is also going to be brutal expensive compared to the rest of the lineup and at least from early benchmarks will be comparable to AMD offerings but not quite matching the graphics performance of said top offering from AMD.

So, pay a lot for a wicked fast cpu with so so graphics OR get a decent cpu at a decent price with very capable graphics(considering its marketplace) if all else if holy folks would look at both sides before making bad opinions. But yeh, I do not agree with AMD doing this, I think their time could be better done and resources better spent then binning top FX chips for insane clockers BUT it may very well give them the $ they need to do what they feel needs to be done :)
 
Part of this is a catch22. I mean software developers can not design their software to require 8 cores since not 95% of their target audience does not have an 8 core cpu.

Just because a program is multithreaded does not mean it requires a certain number of cores to run.

Go ahead and look in task manager under the performance tab. My work laptop currently has ~1400 threads running.

Some of the real reasons that programs do not support more threading are:

1. It is harder to program well for multithreading. I suspect a lot of programmers don't see the need to multithread their programs because systems are so fast. But, they fail to take into account that their software is probably not going to be the only thing running on the systems in question.

2. Some tasks will not benefit from multithreading. That being said, things like games should be able to run a whole bunch of threads no problem. Running on only 1-2 threads is just lazy on the developer's part as you should be able to easily break down things so the load will be spread across more CPU cores.

Graphics, sound, AI, I/O, logic should be able to all be seperated if done properly. Running everything in only 1-2 threads is just retarded.

Games/programs with a huge number of simulations should have a huge number of threads running if you really want to get the most out of a system.
 
Did I read that right? $795? That sounds more like a G34 socket chip than an AM3+

I know, one could buy a Xeon processor for that cost and have far high performance in single-threaded and SMP applications.
wtf is AMD thinking...
 
Graphics, sound, AI, I/O, logic should be able to all be seperated if done properly. Running everything in only 1-2 threads is just retarded.
The problem is that AI and other game logic is highly-dependent on game state. AIs need to know about not only the environment, but they need to know how to react to players (and there could be more than one) and how to 'mingle' with other AIs. They have to talk to each other, and that incurs overhead. There are similar problems in physics: objects need to know about other objects in order to interact (usually collide) with them.

It's easy to throw certain things into their own threads, pass them some messages and let them do things which don't affect anything else. But when you have things that are stateful, it becomes very difficult to effectively parallelize them. That isn't really a completely solved problem at this point.

To that end, gigahertz still matters. I have to wonder, though, whether a rumored 5 GHz AMD processor is actually any better than any high-end Intel at a much lower frequency, and what the power profile on that will be. Frequency is a super-magic-yay-single-threaded-performance thing, and that's great, but it's also a oh-shit-power-consumption thing, and that isn't so great.
 
This really isn't a clock speed race. While that might be true in home computing, pretty much everything sitting in a server rack benefits from and can use a multitude of lower clocked cores in a more power efficient manner than a smaller number of faster cores.
 
Yes, to the former.

The problem with the later...is that when Intel doesn't have any competition, we consumers get underwhelming generational performance increases.

Not to mention a hefty price tag, as you have no choice.

I will personally be glad if they do produce the CPU, and it actually performs well. My first build was an AMD Athlon at a time when they were better than Intel (until the Dual cores showed up). Should be able to build a new system by the time it actually hits the shelves.
 
AMD still makes processors for something other than garbage laptops? News to me. I've been AMD free for like 15 years now.

AMD absolutely owned Intel in both performance and value from the release of the socket 754 Athlon 64 up until Core 2 came along... I mean, the Athlon 64 3000 ran at 1.8 GHz and was comparable to the 3GHz Pentium 4 Northwood chips. Say what you will about AMD's current architecture, but they aren't that far behind in performance compared to Intel's 'netburst' garbage.

The 8320 is priced to compete with the i5, and IMO it is a good value there. You get i7-level multi-threaded performance and it's single-core performance is plenty fast for gaming (though if you're pushing multiple GPUs/super-high resolutions an i7 would be the best choice). Power consumption is higher if you OC, but we're talking tens of dollars worth of electricity over several years.

Please tell me they aren't using liquid nitrogen to achieve this:rolleyes:

Go back and read the first post.
 
This 5ghz cpu might run at stock voltage like other FX cpus. If it does then it might overclock to 6ghz with ease. Have to see. :)
 
This 5ghz cpu might run at stock voltage like other FX cpus. If it does then it might overclock to 6ghz with ease. Have to see. :)

Are they going to include a free 1600W PSU if that's the case?
 
server sided stuff is also "hand built" if you will to take advantage of the multi-processing of todays chips, more threads, more concurrency, more memory etc, they are built to truly tap out what is put into them while still being efficient.

Desktop or general consumer stuff is meant to be adaptable, not a one trick pony.

There is a big difference between many cores and many threads and high clock speeds or efficiency at those clocks, Athlon Vs Pentium showed benefit of tight programming at lower clock speeds and also showed the disadvantage and advantage of high clock speeds but loose per clock performance, something apparently AMD forgot, but something Intel had seen and did their damndest to get away from, Intel builds their chips with efficiency first and foremost these days with a good clock speed but the biggest thing is the tuning of them that they truly can take advantage of the per core performance regardless of the clocks they are at(or so it seems)

AMD did a mistake with bulldozer which will not truly be sorted out till steam roller, they did a different arch multi-thread approach which was a wicked neat design, however, the chip does not break down the instructions itself or it truly would do wonders, like Intel HT approach, if AMD could have gotten their chips to act in that way the performance would be jaw dropping, instead it relies on devs/coders to do the threading via OS least that's the way I understand it, so the performance is not where it should be a) and b) the chips were built to hit high clock speeds but not tuned to really take advantage of that clock speed on a per core basis their cache is to latent, their "mistakes" take to much out of the processing workflow to really let the design come to life.

SR will apparently make a large difference in multiple ways that AMD made a blunder with bulldozer, its just a shame it has to come at such a price to them to get there. I think if they can manage to fix the single threaded as well as per core performance while still keeping a high clock speed but at reduced power/temps AMD will make one hell of a chip, AMD overall has made some stellar designs over the years, they just need to figure out how to get them all together and they will be a force to be reckoned with, multi-core they got it, and graphics they got it, just a couple "tricks" they need to sort out me thinks, shrinking and possible latency fixes as well as boiling in micro instructions to help the chip "digest" the threading instead of relying on the OS to do it all would help big time.

I think for this chip, one may need a mini nuke or at least very specific motherboards, or it has been binned like crazy to find an ultra high speed but low leakage chip, an overclockers wet dream :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1039792579 said:
Whatever.

If it's the same arch as the FX-8350, even at 5Ghz, it will be beaten by a stock i7-3770 in per core performance.

they would need to bump the clock to ~6.5Ghz in order to beat the turbo clock of 3.9Ghz on the 3770 in core for core performance.

By all means AMD, please release higher clocked models, but giving them a racy name like centurion when they aren't even coming close to measuring up to the competition just makes you look silly.

The trick is where you want to go on what numbers on what applications , there already benchmarks which show that AMD beat or get near it. If you running applications on top of eachother like fraps and certain games guess what...

And if you want to fool people start the 4 core vs 8 cores , and you would have to disable HT , goodluck with that one...
 
The trick is where you want to go on what numbers on what applications , there already benchmarks which show that AMD beat or get near it. If you running applications on top of eachother like fraps and certain games guess what...

And if you want to fool people start the 4 core vs 8 cores , and you would have to disable HT , goodluck with that one...

But it's still an $800 BD that would get it's ass handed to it by a 3930K costing 1/3 less in heavily multi-threaded programs and benchmark, I'm willing to guess. No doubt with less power draw and heat output than this new AMD incarnation.
 
but then again with the new HD intel graphics im not sure how well the a8/a10 stacks up anymore, they seem to make for ok cheap laptops that can play some games, far from a gaming laptop, but so is the cost

See I get tired of this garbage (and it is garbage). Intel still isn't where AMD was a year ago and Richland is making the gap wider still.

When Intel came out with their HD4000 parts all of these big news sites were ranting and raving, "UNPRECEDENTED threat to Nvidia, AMD" or "Entry-level graphics card is dead" and NONE of those stupid fucking sites said a single thing when AMD came out with better integrated performance a year before.

No great proclamations were made either when AMD came out with Trinity despite A8/A10 parts darn near tripling the results the HD4000 managed in a number of games and simply doubling it in virtually every other game that wasn't CPU limited.

Intel has consistently promised the world and delivered half-baked turds in graphics, their IQ wasn't even close to competitive until Ivy Bridge and their performance is still garbage and priced far above what they deserve. I don't want to hear another thing about Intel integrated until they actually manage to put out a competitive GPU.
 
Not a bad idea on AMD's part IMHO. As a collector's edition, limited run, guaranteed 5ghz OC on air @ <1000$, people will buy the small batches of these readily.

At the rumored 800$, selling a limited run of 1000 of these will what, double their year over year income? :p
 
I'm placing my bet now. Even at 5GHZ, it still won't beat the IPC or perf/watt of a now 2 year old Sandy Bridge 2600k running stock with turbo on.
 
I've built a few a8 systems for family who want to surf, check email, have a small PC, and play bejeweled type games and other minimal demand type games that need something a little better than cheesy integrated graphics

but then again with the new HD intel graphics im not sure how well the a8/a10 stacks up anymore, they seem to make for ok cheap laptops that can play some games, far from a gaming laptop, but so is the cost

The A8 in my system exceeds the Propus 630 quad it replaced.

For people who think quadcore systems like the Trinity series of chips are good enough for playing "bejeweled type games" really speaks to how ignorant and out of touch people in these forums are.
 
Part of this is a catch22. I mean software developers can not design their software to require 8 cores since not 95% of their target audience does not have an 8 core cpu.

require <> use if available, its called scaling
 
LOL I paid $230 for my 5ghz 2700k, a 5ghz FX wouldnt touch it performance wise....

As much as I loved AMD in the past....Hell even paid $300 for a brand new Phenom II 940....The time has passed where they aren't relevant in the CPU segment when it comes to performance (Although I do LOVE there APU's).
 
I could see this price as worth it if it came with 6 or 8 pd modules....12-16 cores @ $800 @ 5ghz would be awesome.
 
require <> use if available, its called scaling

And scaling is not always perfect (its good in a lot of video processing algorithms but falls short in other types of algorithms). That is why in a lot of cases in the real world you need to optimize for a certain # cores.
 
I'm placing my bet now. Even at 5GHZ, it still won't beat the IPC or perf/watt of a now 2 year old Sandy Bridge 2600k running stock with turbo on.

There is absolutely no chance it will win either of those. As far as performance goes it should come close to a an ivy-bridge i7 chip with both chips at stock.
 
And a 5GHz FX would clearly win against an ivy-bridge i7 in applications that make good use of more than 4 threads.
 
Well look at it another way. This could well be the most powerful chip to be built for the AM3+ platform.

So you buy it now and in 5 years time there will be someone out there that wants the fastest chip for their old AM3+ setup and will pay $400 on Ebay for it.

Saw it happen for a while with the top of the line 939 chips a few years ago. Sold my Opty180 for more than I paid for it.
 
Back
Top