AMD Says PhysX Will Die

Says the person who doesn't have the majority of descrete graphics card sales and who doesn't own the standard.

Oh, someone better go tell EA about this. :rolleyes:

This is no different that 3dfx and Glide..

i've been saying all along that PhysX's problem is they came out trying to sell hardware, instead it should have been a software solution to begin with (like Havok).. and when and only when does the software take off, add the hardware solution for it.


The problem now is, developers can add it, but only with a special piece of hardware (including a 2nd Nvidia card) can someone really experience the full force of it.. and that is the problem with a closed system, too few users with the hardware specific to run it.
 
Gimme a break, look at your sigs look at all the cash you guys have spent on your PC only to hear you cry about buying another card? please.....
 
PhysX will die if there are no good games to support it. Ageia failed with PhysX because there are not enough good games supporting the API. Nothing has changed much since then except for a new game with curtains in it. ;)

those were some ugly colors in that game as well
 
The problem now is, developers can add it, but only with a special piece of hardware (including a 2nd Nvidia card) can someone really experience the full force of it...

Dont you get it? It offers you everything Havok does on any system you use it on. It rewards you with EVEN BETTER effects when you have the hardware, but you are not losing anything, just gaining more. Its like playing on a 8600GT and a GTX 260, its the same thing on both cards, you arent "losing" anything but you get a better image on the gtx. Physx will survive because it has a direct link to a grfx company ( Havok is supported by ATI, but NV owns Physx, so it cant really go away ) and it does everything havoc does on any platform for MUCH cheaper/ free. As a bonus, it does extra things on its owners platform.

And dont give me its gonna die cause its eye candy. The grfx market is so damn fast because of that eye candy. Especially here I dont want to hear people bitch about its only eye candy. And its not just eye candy anyways, but some of you dont want to see that its just an API just like yalls beloved havok. In a business world, if you have one product that for 10 years hasnt done anything exciting except cost more, and along comes a new player, offering all the same things but for Free/Cheap AND it has some industry firsts ( PPUs and now Ohysx on GPUs ) AND it now is owned by the same company that is sponsoring the game your making with TWIMTBP money, everything points to Physx, strictly business.

ATI is still claiming havok hardware support is coming, why doesnt anyone jump them for blowing smoke up our asses for 3-4 years? Dont be pissed cause Nv and Ageia jumped on a good idea
 
Accelerated Physics will happen, period. The GPU companies have 2 choices:
1) Sit and wait for years until khronos or whoever finally put out a standard API spec.
2) Make your own API, optimize your drivers and HW, use it to influence the eventual standard.

#2 is obviously the better choice.
NV bought Ageia and Intel bought Havok. ATI is screwed and spilling out FUD.
 
- Physics APIs in games have been used for ages already, either homebrewn or commercial libs.
- PhysX and Havok are both good physics APIs.
- Physics are becoming more and more important in games to add realism.
- PhysX is hardware-accelerated, Havok won't be for the foreseeable future.
- Hardware acceleration gives a huge boost with physics animations.

Why are people using Havok again? Is AMD just covering up the fact that it made a big mistake by turning down nVidia's offer to freely use the PhysX API and such a while ago? Is AMD a sore loser? :)

Disclaimer: I'm a game developer and we use PhysX exclusively with our games ;)
 
I hope they are right. I like open standards better.

Problem is that there are only two main physics APIs, Havok and PhysX.
There is no open standard for physics, and neither OpenCL nor DX11 will deliver that.
They will simply create an open standard for GPGPU. But that doesn't guarantee any open physics library. In fact, it's perfectly possible to create a closed physics API on top of OpenCL or DX11.

Until there's some kind of open standard (which AMD is not actively working on either), PhysX is the only way to get hardware accelerated physics. And that's the reality that AMD will have to face.
 
Plus Im not sure what the practice is now, but it was possible to get Physx API for your game for free upfront, and then pay royalties. This was a huge bonus for dev's and beat the hell out of Havok upfront cost plus royalties. Smaller titles could even be 100% free if you had certain spash screens.

Last I looked, you can use the binary version of PhysX for free, as long as you put up splash screens, logo's and make references to PhysX in promotional material and such.

A full license costs US$50k per application. This gives you access to the sourcecode and
the right to change it at will.
 
Physx will survive because it has a direct link to a grfx company ( Havok is supported by ATI, but NV owns Physx, so it cant really go away )

Havok is owned by Intel. Intel technically is a graphics company aswell, being the largest supplier of IGPs. Also, they plan to release a discrete graphics card codenamed Larrabee next year.
So I doubt that Havok will go away.
 
PhysX was nothing before, but now it's owned by NVIDIA. Whole new ballgame.


 
nothing about AMD position, but I'll show how PhysX SDK is widespread for real (those list at none is absolete)
http://physx.cwx.ru/

Yet another list that shows that Fallout 3 & Oblivion not being listed as using PhysX.

Sorry Vaulter98c, but it is you that are looking like the smart ass there. :(
 
PhysX was nothing before, but now it's owned by NVIDIA. Whole new ballgame.

PhysX wasn't exactly 'nothing'.
Before it had PPU support and was renamed PhysX, it was known as NovodeX, a multiplatform, multithreaded, optimized physics library. Quite a few titles made use of it, especially on PS3 and XBox.
Ofcourse, with the widespread GPU acceleration suppor that nVidia has now given to PhysX, it indeed is a new ballgame, but they didn't start from 'nothing'.
 
Exavior
Yet another list that shows that Fallout 3 & Oblivion not being listed as using PhysX
And they must ?)

Scali2
efore it had PPU support and was renamed PhysX, it was known as NovodeX
Before that, NovodeX was also merged with another physics engine known as Meqon)
 
PhysX wasn't exactly 'nothing'.
Before it had PPU support and was renamed PhysX, it was known as NovodeX, a multiplatform, multithreaded, optimized physics library. Quite a few titles made use of it, especially on PS3 and XBox.
Ofcourse, with the widespread GPU acceleration suppor that nVidia has now given to PhysX, it indeed is a new ballgame, but they didn't start from 'nothing'.

Fair enough. How about we say nothing on the PC then?




 
I've done some reading, and Nvidias offer to ATI is always open, they could pick it up tomorrow if they wanted, but they're as doubtful as the rest of us about the future of PhysX and for now refuse to do it. Would be fun to play with the eyecandy physics for a while.

If we don't see some excess Intel/AMD/ATI computational power go towards Havok calculations before 2010 they're too late with it. HL2 Ep3 Havok hardware acceleration, get on it, guys!
 
but they're as doubtful as the rest of us about the future of PhysX and for now refuse to do it.

They just pretend to be doubtful, trying to steer developers away from using it, it's a tactic called 'damage control'.
 
On the other hand, I really, really hope to see PhysX in a future PC GTA game so that we once and for all can get away from RockStar physics.

I backed up onto a railing at like 5 mph and went flying. At ten frames per seconds.
 
Still not true. Various multiplatform engines such as Unreal Engine used NovodeX on PC aswell.

A couple of engines is nothing. I stand by my original post. In a few years we'll check back and compare what PhysX was before the NVIDIA acquisition to what it became after and say it was essentially nothing in comparison.


 
A couple of engines is nothing. I stand by my original post. In a few years we'll check back and compare what PhysX was before the NVIDIA acquisition to what it became after and say it was essentially nothing in comparison.

Perhaps, perhaps not.
Physics just isn't a big thing in games yet. Although Havok has been around longer, it doesn't have a huge list of successful games behind its name either.
nVidia is promoting PhysX vigorously, but we will have to see what it leads to in the end.
If they can't get a significant marketshare quickly enough, another hardware-accelerated physics API might move in, and PhysX will be nothing but a memory a few years from now.
 
Physics is the next big thing, its only when is the issue.

we all remember when first 3D was the thing, then everyone was 3D, then multiplayer was the thing, everyone had multiplayer then, then surround sound, then amazing textures and grfx. Now, we have true to life LOOKING worlds, they SOUND real, and you can move about them in 3D with MANY PEOPLE, the last step is to make them ACT/FEEL real. Physics will be the next big wave ( we can already see early attempts like half life 2 and others, but sooner or later everyone will jump on the bandwagon and currently Physx offers a better choice than Havok for jumping on that wagon.

Beyond a new source of control/input, I really dont know where we are going after physics is in most games, and not knowing whats next for games is awesome, because we wont see it coming!
 
see the problem is havok is rewriting their whole physics engine to be able to have hardware hooks thats why it is taking forever. PhysX took havok by surprise because there was nothing better than havok before and now there is. Also for old games that uses havok engine would most likely not be updated with a new havok engine that has the hardware support that are not a year or two old.

What PhysX did is a step to the future of physics in games. AMD does not want to support PhysX in their card becuase they are not willing to pay the money required. They say PhysX will die to cover their lame excuses that physics is not important enough to be hardware accelerated or havok is paying them some money to not support PhysX so they can catch up and have a hardware version.
 
funny thing is is that Nv offered ATI to help port Physx to ATI HW, they said no. They'd have to pay royalties im sure, but its got be less than all the R&D and whatnot going into the havok issue
 
funny thing is is that Nv offered ATI to help port Physx to ATI HW, they said no. They'd have to pay royalties im sure, but its got be less than all the R&D and whatnot going into the havok issue

I doubt Intel is going to let AMD use Havok for free either. In the end it seems AMD will end up with nothing, no acceleration for either physics API with their hardware. Making a 180 degrees turn at this point has got to be embarrassing, though.
 
Exavior

And they must ?)

Not sure if you are asking me if they must or if you are trying to be sarcastic there. If you are asking a question, I wasn't aiming my reply at you but was just pointing to your list. Yesterday Vaulter98c called somebody a smart ass when they stated that Fallout 3 and Oblivion use Havok and not PhysX and told them to look at the back of the case for proof. I had posted then saying how the PC case doesn't state it nor did the list i looked at yesterday. It doesn't show up on the one you listed and I was just point that out that yet another list did no't have the games listed. So if the physx engine is being used to some regards in either of them along side the Havok engine which they do list then it would be hard for somebody to know as it isn't listed anywhere. Thus his attack was uncalled for as it would appear that the opposite of what he stated is what we are seeing.
 
I hope PhysX does not die as think of all the games you've played with horrendously bad physics in them. Just think of a few games using the Havok engine and think of the improper things that happened when you shot them or killed them. ATI/AMD can use PhysX as well they just don't wish too as I believe Nvidia gets money from them if they do. Considering how badly AMD is currently doing this might seem better for them in the Short Term not to use PhysX even though large developers have opted to use PhysX, EA included.
 
I hope PhysX does not die as think of all the games you've played with horrendously bad physics in them. Just think of a few games using the Havok engine and think of the improper things that happened when you shot them or killed them. ATI/AMD can use PhysX as well they just don't wish too as I believe Nvidia gets money from them if they do. Considering how badly AMD is currently doing this might seem better for them in the Short Term not to use PhysX even though large developers have opted to use PhysX, EA included.


Are you saying PhysX is somehow more accurate than Havok? In a fully hardware accelerated environment PhysX allows for more calculations, more moving objects than is currently possible on cpu under Havok or no accelerated PhysX for that matter. So in a sense it would make the hardware accelerated version more accurate. Not that we have seen much of that "accuracy" actually implemented in games.

Besides, most of the physics inaccuracies you see are intentional and meant for effect, just like the movies. People don't really go flying when you shoot them at point blank range with a shotty, they just fall down and die. Personally I prefer my aliens, zombies, nazis, or what ever die with a little wiggle and dance to the bullets, flying backward through the air, rag doll, style.

As to Ati not getting on board with PhysX, others have said this already, and so have I back in post 30. Ati said no thanks, because Nv would have control of the API. Nv would, of course, cater future releases of the API to their own hardware. Insuring Ati was never able to truly rival Nv in hardware physics. Ati joining in would prolly insure hardware accelerated PhysX's future as an API. That would not benefit Ati in the slightest, and in fact, would hurt them down the road.
 
Are you saying PhysX is somehow more accurate than Havok? In a fully hardware accelerated environment PhysX allows for more calculations, more moving objects than is currently possible on cpu under Havok or no accelerated PhysX for that matter. So in a sense it would make the hardware accelerated version more accurate. Not that we have seen much of that "accuracy" actually implemented in games.

Besides, most of the physics inaccuracies you see are intentional and meant for effect, just like the movies. People don't really go flying when you shoot them at point blank range with a shotty, they just fall down and die. Personally I prefer my aliens, zombies, nazis, or what ever die with a little wiggle and dance to the bullets, flying backward through the air, rag doll, style.

As to Ati not getting on board with PhysX, others have said this already, and so have I back in post 30. Ati said no thanks, because Nv would have control of the API. Nv would, of course, cater future releases of the API to their own hardware. Insuring Ati was never able to truly rival Nv in hardware physics. Ati joining in would prolly insure hardware accelerated PhysX's future as an API. That would not benefit Ati in the slightest, and in fact, would hurt them down the road.

what this man said.
 
Back
Top