AMD Says PhysX Will Die

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
During an interview with Bit-Tech, AMD’s Director of Technical Marketing for the Graphics Product Group said that PhysX will die if it remains a closed and proprietary standard.

"There is no plan for closed and proprietary standards like PhysX," said Cheng. "As we have emphasised with our support for OpenCL and DX11, closed and proprietary standards will die."
 
I don't think physx will last either. Most gamers aren't going to go out and buy a second card or lose a ton of fps just for a little eye candy
 
They are probably right. I turn it off on my SLI setup. All it does is slow the game down at the expense of physics eye candy. In other words it's not doing anything for me in the game play department. I welcome a industry standard that works across all platforms or better yet puts my quad core CPU to use.
 
PhysX is not eye candy. Most developers were simply not using it to its full potential because:
- They lack creativity.
- They don't actually understand much physics themselves.
- Most importantly, it is not worth spending that amount of time on something a very, very small group of users will actually see. This is different now; one could say that at least half of all PC gamers can use PhysX (if we assume half of PC gamers use Geforce 8 series and newer NV cards). Expect to see "The Way It's Meant To Be Played" partners to start using PhysX in their games, even if only for eye candy as you said.

I am truly hoping that devs and game companies will smarten up, because proper physics simulation is something I have been waiting for for a long, long time.
 
PhysX was never a very good API. Even hardware accelerated, it always looked weird and behaved badly.
 
Says the person who doesn't have the majority of descrete graphics card sales and who doesn't own the standard.

Oh, someone better go tell EA about this. :rolleyes:
 
PhysX is not eye candy. Most developers were simply not using it to its full potential because:
- They lack creativity.
- They don't actually understand much physics themselves.
- Most importantly, it is not worth spending that amount of time on something a very, very small group of users will actually see. This is different now; one could say that at least half of all PC gamers can use PhysX (if we assume half of PC gamers use Geforce 8 series and newer NV cards). Expect to see "The Way It's Meant To Be Played" partners to start using PhysX in their games, even if only for eye candy as you said.

I am truly hoping that devs and game companies will smarten up, because proper physics simulation is something I have been waiting for for a long, long time.

I agree. Physics add a hell of a lot more to a game than graphics. I would take the graphics hit for better physics as that actually adds to the game play, better looking textures don't.
 
physics is great in games. just extreme physics are not working well because of the huge calculations it requires.

Half-life 2 uses physics in game to do certain stuff. There are many use for physics and it will make a game more life like because there is physics in real life.


If physics forumlas can be calculated quicker with hardware than use it.

I think amd ati is just mad that their competitors is being ahead of them in certain fields.
 
PhysX will die if there are no good games to support it. Ageia failed with PhysX because there are not enough good games supporting the API. Nothing has changed much since then except for a new game with curtains in it. ;)
 
"As we have emphasised with our support for OpenCL and DX11, closed and proprietary standards will die."

Ummm.
 
Sour grapes said ATI.
There is no standard physics API in the horizon. OpenCL and DX11 are not it.
One day it will come, but even then, it will probably look something like PhysX, and NVIDIA will have a gigantic head start on driver and optimizations.
Exactly same scenario with CUDA and OpenCL/DX11 Compute.
ATI's strategy of waiting for years until standardizing groups get their shit together is a huge mistake.
 
They are probably right. I turn it off on my SLI setup. All it does is slow the game down at the expense of physics eye candy. In other words it's not doing anything for me in the game play department. I welcome a industry standard that works across all platforms or better yet puts my quad core CPU to use.

This has been mentioned before by another user somewhere else so credit goes to him here.

CPU is no where as capable as a dedicated PPU, or in this case, a GPU. You can have 8 or 16 cores if you want, it still can't beat a single graphic card which have massive parallel processing units, which is exactly what physics simulation needs.

It will always run much slower on a normal general purpose CPU.

Even if there's a standard like DX type, it will still use GPU (as Ageia has shown that a dedicated PPU is not a popular choice), so the argument that takes up graphic processing power will still apply to whatever AMD wish to adopt in the future :). That's not the problem just specific to nVidia, if its a problem at all

Most people would be more than glad to stick in their older card for physics processing, all we need is more game support
 
I consider myself to be a big supporter or physics acceleration including PhysX however...

PhysX is a lot like Glide was...
It works,
It's good,
It's fast,
It's proprietary.

Physics acceleration won't die, but if PhysX is not widely adopted it (the API) most likely will. I love what physics acceleration brings to the table and I stand behind it. However I'm not close minded to the fact there could be better API's to accelerate it.

Right now if you want good physics you need something that can run PhysX (Just like you pretty much HAD to run 3DFX a long time ago). However just like 3DFX... just because you’re the only kid on the field now, doesn't mean you're the best
 
Physx is actually used in alot of modern big name titles, people just confuse Physx in a game as something that is hardware required and causes a huge hit and is expensive and stupid. Obviously this is not true. Now that Nvidia got Physx and redid the API, its actually quite nice. Developers are using Physx now as a way to not have to animate every little thing on a model ( jiggly and hair for example) and it makes interactions with the world easier. I cant even begin to name all the big titles that use Physx. Everyone just hears Physx and associates it with hardware. Its no differant that Havok except it will kick Havoks ass if you have HW that will use it, and a shitload of gamers now have that HW.

Why all the hate on Physx? Ive been a fan for a while, but not a fanboy. Id bet that there is atleast one title you play/just finished that used Physx. Id bet 3/4 of H could say that.
 
no edit damnit....
Plus Im not sure what the practice is now, but it was possible to get Physx API for your game for free upfront, and then pay royalties. This was a huge bonus for dev's and beat the hell out of Havok upfront cost plus royalties. Smaller titles could even be 100% free if you had certain spash screens. Physx was really Dev friendly, we were so close to using it in college when I was still going for Video game programming ( Since changed to Cisco Network Admin with minor in Network Security )
 
What modern big name titles? Mirror's Edge, Mass Effect, GoW, GRAW, what else?
 
I thought physx was free to use for developers, and nvidia offered ATi free help to make it work with there GPUs? I mean yeah its proprietary as in nvidia has the only rights to change the code and what not, but I thought cost of entry was free thanks to NV?

Sounds like ATi is jealous.
 
Anything that uses UnrealEngine and many more. And its not just about Physx per say, its about physics in games, and Physx currently offers the best deal in that area.

And between the franchises you listed alone, you dont think thats enough money to justify it hanging around long enough to be used for more things? The longer it is around the more things it will be used in as the user base will be larger. Remember tho, Physx runs on anything, it just runs best on Nv. Havok just runs, on anything, nothing but the same old Havok no matter what you do. Physx gives us a chance to get more, and isnt that why we are here? We all have insane computers anyways...

No games use it? Howabout your own and a few others you left out. Mirror's Edge, Mass Effect, GoW 1&2, GRAW 1&2, New MoH games (Airborne included), Gundam Games (huge in Japan), Any of the last 6 Tom Clancy games, UT3, AoE, BoS, The awaited Huxley, Backbreaker, GRID, BiA HH, and the Gamebryo engine has it too ( Oblivion and Fallout 3 ) And again the Unreal3 engine too. Plus MANY more, and shitloads of smaller fun titles too

Not to mention that now all EA studios, 2K games studios, and a few other smaller names are getting and using it, Cheaper than Havok and better results = good business.

Im sure you've played or wanted to play one of those games/series??
 
Hrmmm... I've actually been looking at getting one of the 1x PCI-E PhysX cards since they have come down in price quite a lot.

It would go very nicely with a 4850 or 4870... leaning more towards a 4870 1GB.
 
GRAW and Cellfactor are how old, and PhysX implementations have evolved and improved how much between then and the not yet released but recently demoed PC Mirror's Edge?

As long as it remains as optional like special maps, eyecandy, something that doesn't improve the game, be it by performance or general gameplay experience, it's only going where Nvidias money orders it to, ie not very far. Just look at that list of PhysX games people like to pass around, see how many you've actually seen in stores. See how many were released at all, or worth caring about.


Havok just turned ten years, when we finally get Intel/ATI hardware acceleration of that we're not going to notice anything but a smoother framerate, perhaps better performace overall, because the physics are always there. Imagine that, future Source titles, Diablo 3 with perfect framerate even under heavy physics-accelerated scenes? I don't recall any Havok title going sluggish on me during physics filled scenes though, and so far it has done more than "HAY GUYS YOU CAN SHOOT CLOTH", shooting bricks and playing with rubber ducks in water have for me.


PhysX needs something huge to impress and show it's worth with. A disgustingly realistic racing game using PhysX to accurately simulate every moving part in a car? That would be a good start to make up for the hype dollars spent.

I'd settle for PhysX giving me nonshit framerates in GTA4 PC.
 
I don't get it... AMD says they have no plan for PhysX since its a closed standard.... but will support DX11 instead. DX isn't exactly an open stadard is it???
 
never had an interest and honestly don't care...I just find it amusing that someone from AMD would be so critical on a competitor...kind of like the pot calling the kettle black
 
Anything that uses UnrealEngine and many more. And its not just about Physx per say, its about physics in games, and Physx currently offers the best deal in that area.

And between the franchises you listed alone, you dont think thats enough money to justify it hanging around long enough to be used for more things? The longer it is around the more things it will be used in as the user base will be larger. Remember tho, Physx runs on anything, it just runs best on Nv. Havok just runs, on anything, nothing but the same old Havok no matter what you do. Physx gives us a chance to get more, and isnt that why we are here? We all have insane computers anyways...

No games use it? Howabout your own and a few others you left out. Mirror's Edge, Mass Effect, GoW 1&2, GRAW 1&2, New MoH games (Airborne included), Gundam Games (huge in Japan), Any of the last 6 Tom Clancy games, UT3, AoE, BoS, The awaited Huxley, Backbreaker, GRID, BiA HH, and the Gamebryo engine has it too ( Oblivion and Fallout 3 ) And again the Unreal3 engine too. Plus MANY more, and shitloads of smaller fun titles too

Not to mention that now all EA studios, 2K games studios, and a few other smaller names are getting and using it, Cheaper than Havok and better results = good business.

Im sure you've played or wanted to play one of those games/series??
You are spreading FUD, GRID doesn't support PhysX, Fallout 3 uses Havok, so does Oblivion.

PhysX titles:
http://www.nzone.com/object/nzone_physxgames_home.html

Havok titles:
http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/29/73/
http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/37/78/
http://www.havok.com/content/blogcategory/44/84/

Famous PC games that support Havok:
Alone in the Dark
Assassin's Creed
BioShock
F.E.A.R.
Guitar Hero III
Half-Life 2: The Orange Box
Hellgate: London
Lost Planet: Extreme Condition
Spore
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
Alan Wake
Diablo III
Fallout3
 
physx has so much potential, its just as it was said earlier.. they lack creativity.
I would much prefer to see difference such as:

1) With PhysX ragdoll physics is much more realistic.

2) Volumetric water behaves realistic and can be manipulated. i.e. Throw a barrell into a pool and water splashes out and water level drops. (Can make for some interesting puzzle games)

3) Projectiles (bullets, knives, etc) behave more realistically. Weight, speed, inertia alter their impact upon an object. (Brick, wood, drywall)


Many of the capabilities of physics in games would not be eye candy and this is where NVIDIA loses their path. A company dedicated to eye candy is trying to implement something fundamentally designed to deal with behavior, not eye candy.

It is the behavior of the world that would add immersion and the benefit is it "should" not impact framerate performance. The only problem (for NVIDIA) is not knowing how to market something that has nothing to do with their core business.

This is what is needed. and it's definitely possible with hardware acceleration. all projectiles affected by wind, gravity, distance? what about splashing water on materials and changing their properties?

gpu's are so much more parallel than cpus.
 
on the other hand, cpu's have begun to hit the wall with speed, so it seems the direction taken now are architecture and more cores. in addition, most games are being bottlenecked by the gpu already.
 
for those asking DX11 is closed but is not proprietary. Closed source and developed by microsoft. Open to any vendor willing to implement it on their hardware. DX11 will run on cards from Nvidia, Ati, and intel.
 
I thought physx was free to use for developers, and nvidia offered ATi free help to make it work with there GPUs? I mean yeah its proprietary as in nvidia has the only rights to change the code and what not, but I thought cost of entry was free thanks to NV?

Sounds like ATi is jealous.

Ati has a vested interest in the death of the PhysX api. They will not be able to compete with Nv using a Nv controlled api. Nv has a vested interest in the success of PhysX as an api. Nv's "offer" to Ati, basically amounted to a,"please use this so that our api does not die, and is eventually required to play all games. So we can later insure that we always keep you 6 months behind us on hardware." Nv having control of the api could, and most likely would, insure that Ati's solution using it never rivaled their own. They would almost certainly alter the api to best suit their own hardware. Ati said no thanks to that, of course.

As it sits, PhysX hardware support is NOT currently being used in any earth shattering way in games. Because Ati and Intel are not on board. Many games have some hardware support for it, but usually it is just included as a kicker, or after thought, or because it was already built into the engine, or just because Nv paid us or did it for us. It does not really change or enhance the game play enough that people are just clamoring to get it.

Hardware accelerated physics is the future imho. I just don't think the PhysX api is going to be the winner unless they open source it and hand it over to a standards body. Nv, should remember what happened to Glide. PhysX as an api could very easily die in ayear or two if they are not careful. Don't wait till MS includes something similar in DX or an open version, like OGL in the past, becomes wide spread in it's use. Open source it while it is still relevant.
 
If it is optional eye candy, GPU physics will not gain traction. The titles we have seen today with shattering glass and cloth waving in the wind is not integral to game play and the impact on the game's experience is minimal.

Until they all get their shit together and agree on a standard (or more likely Microsoft does it for them) we'll be stuck with optional eye candy. It's got nothing to do with the developers "not understanding physics", it's just nvidia and ati wasting time on their new pissing contest.
 
um gamebryo uses Physx for about half the calculations of regard to animation, Havok is the world physics, but Physx is there, look at the back of the box and read the engine sheet smart ass

I will say GRID is a bad call on my end, I was lead to believe that it uses Physx, my bad

But, yea, gamebryo has support and uses Physx API in the engine. There is a mod out to replace some of the Havok world physics with Physx Physics and I am using that now on my rig. Lovin it, make thing seem smoother and a little more real.

So dont go calling me fud because one game wasnt there. I personally loved Physx in Brothers in Arms HH and GRAW2 and Gears2 (not the game, but Physx made a much more in depth experience) and cant wait to get backbreaker. Physx has all these titles in just what, a year and a half to two years its been out? Havok is 10 years old and its list of good games isnt that much better one could argue.
 
um gamebryo uses Physx for about half the calculations of regard to animation, Havok is the world physics, but Physx is there, look at the back of the box and read the engine sheet smart ass

I will say GRID is a bad call on my end, I was lead to believe that it uses Physx, my bad

But, yea, gamebryo has support and uses Physx API in the engine. There is a mod out to replace some of the Havok world physics with Physx Physics and I am using that now on my rig. Lovin it, make thing seem smoother and a little more real.

So dont go calling me fud because one game wasnt there. I personally loved Physx in Brothers in Arms HH and GRAW2 and Gears2 (not the game, but Physx made a much more in depth experience) and cant wait to get backbreaker. Physx has all these titles in just what, a year and a half to two years its been out? Havok is 10 years old and its list of good games isnt that much better one could argue.

Umm, Gears 2 can't use PhysX because it's an Xbox 360 game.
 
"There is no plan for closed and proprietary standards like PhysX," said Cheng. "As we have emphasised with our support for OpenCL and DX11, closed and proprietary standards will die."
Wut?
 
Umm, Gears 2 can't use PhysX because it's an Xbox 360 game.


PhysX can also be run in software on the cpu(s) just like Havok is. It can be run without a hardware implementation like a PhysX card or 8xxx and up Nv graphics cards. However, hardware acceleration, or rather running PhysX on some hardware other than the cpu, is one of it's selling points.

I don't know, or even care, if PhysX is used in the 360 version of Gears 2 or not, but it is certainly possible.
 
um gamebryo uses Physx for about half the calculations of regard to animation, Havok is the world physics, but Physx is there, look at the back of the box and read the engine sheet smart ass

I will say GRID is a bad call on my end, I was lead to believe that it uses Physx, my bad

But, yea, gamebryo has support and uses Physx API in the engine. There is a mod out to replace some of the Havok world physics with Physx Physics and I am using that now on my rig. Lovin it, make thing seem smoother and a little more real.

So dont go calling me fud because one game wasnt there. I personally loved Physx in Brothers in Arms HH and GRAW2 and Gears2 (not the game, but Physx made a much more in depth experience) and cant wait to get backbreaker. Physx has all these titles in just what, a year and a half to two years its been out? Havok is 10 years old and its list of good games isnt that much better one could argue.

I hate to break it to you that Fallout 3 for the PC does not list PhysX anywhere, neither does Oblivion. They have the Havok symbol and mentions it in all the copywrite, but they don't list PhysX on either case.

Nvidia PhysX support was just added to the Gamebryo engine last month, although Ageia's PhysX processor support was added last year.

To be honest I can't find a single thing that list Oblivion or Fallout 3 as having PhysX support.
 
PhysX can also be run in software on the cpu(s) just like Havok is. It can be run without a hardware implementation like a PhysX card or 8xxx and up Nv graphics cards. However, hardware acceleration, or rather running PhysX on some hardware other than the cpu, is one of it's selling points.

I don't know, or even care, if PhysX is used in the 360 version of Gears 2 or not, but it is certainly possible.

http://www.unrealtechnology.com/features.php♥♥♥♥♥♥♥physics

Epic does say that the untreal engine uses PhysX
 
while i would believe this, xbox360 uses an ati card..?

thats the problem with Physx

eceryone just thinks its an NV card required thing. Its just the same as Havok, except that it has HW support, but it doesnt depend on HW. Its just capable of running way more things than Havok ever could because of that HW, but it is just the same...
 
Back
Top