AMD or Intel route advice please

CruzCtrl

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
247
OK I am ready to start a new system but as you can see from the specs of my current system in my sig, I have not stayed in the hardware loop at all.
I am trying to build a very mild gaming rig (FPS's mostly not usually very current ie: COD 2, Source based games, and NFS series or other racers) that is as future proof as possible for my budget of $600. I am not locked into either camp nor am I stuck on these choices listed below but if they are good choices I will go with them (please feel free to suggest any thing you think is better while staying near my budget).

Items not needed will be reused from my current rig ie: hard drive, monitor(2007wfp), keyboard, mouse, case, etc).

Intel route:
ASUS P5N-E SLI LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 650i SLI
Intel Core 2 Duo E6300 Conroe 1.86GHz LGA 775


AMD route:
ASUS M2N-E Socket AM2 NVIDIA nForce 570 Ultra MCP
AMD Athlon 64 X2 3800+(65W) Windsor 2.0GHz Socket AM2


Common items:
CORSAIR XMS2 1GB (2 x 512MB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 800
BFG Tech BFGR76256GTOCE GeForce 7600GT 256MB GDDR3
Thermaltake W0093RU ATX 12V 2.0 Version 500W Power Supply (I listed this because I didn't think that my current power supply would be adequate).

There is about a $100 difference between the two above systems with the AMD being the cheaper, if going with the AMD and spending the extra on something to make it better initially is an option, feel free to make a suggestion there as well.

Thank you for any help here.
 
Go with the Core 2 Duo setup. The E6300 will beat the X2 3800+ in most apps and games.

However, the power supply you chose is crap. Thermaltake PSUs are generally considered to be of dubious quality. Anyway, I suggest you get this power supply: XCLIO GOODPOWER 500W ATX 500W Power Supply - $51.99

You can save $10 by going with this video card: eVGA 256-P2-N615-TX GeForce 7600GT 256MB PCI-Express - $129.99. You can overclock this card to the BFG card's speed if you want to.

Quick question though: are you planning to overclock this system?
 
Intel. It'll eat a kitten.

IF you can swing a bit more for a PSU, try the Corsair HX 520 at www.buy.com for well under $100 shipped.
 
Seasonic supplies Corsair's 520W and 620W PSUs. They also supply Antec's NeoHE line of PSUs. This is a good deal on a good psu:
$50 - Antec Neo HE 550W Supply ($80 - $30MIR)

You already know that the Core2Duo will outperform any AM2 CPU. If you're doing strictly gaming, and want to save that $100, the AM2 route will be fine for your uses. However, just know that there are new Core2Duos coming out (E4300 and E4400) that will be much cheaper in Q2'07, and will definately outperform any AM2 CPU once overclocked.

http://dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=5414

http://anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2903

The E4300 is currently the same price as the E6300, but is easier to OC because of its higher stock multiplier. So, my suggestion would be: If you can, wait until the E4300 is at its target Q2'07 price ($113) instead of its debut price ($189); which should be by the end of march, or earlier, hopefully.
 
I went with the BFG because it has a $50 rebate until the 31 of January making it around a $90 card.

And yes, I would like to try my hand at overclocking this time around.

It would seem that there is an issue verified by Antec regarding Asus motherboards and the HE line not getting along very well. Doing research on other P/S choices.

As for the new E4300, I won't be waiting for the price to fall (although I would like one) and I'm somewhat disgusted that it is being released by retailers at a price equal to or greater than the E6300. On that note, would I be better off overclocking wise to get the E4300?
 
heh, sorry, i didnt notice your mobo choices, i was looking at the cpus only, hehe (its late, i need sleep, lol). jonnyguru.com is a great resource for psu reviews. he has a recommended list in his forum. the psu subforum here also has a good list of recommended psus.
 
Both setups are fine, the Intel will give you a lot more CPU headroom in the future.
As far as I know on the 22nd of this month there should be a price cut on AMD Cpus, so maybe waiting till then is a good call.
BTW that M2N-E mobo is no good for overclocking!,but its very stable under heavy loads at stock.
I would take the AMD rig and use the 100$ to either jump up to a 7900 class GPU or X1950 Class GPU, the 7600 is really a sorry fish in the buyers pond today.
For a bit less then $200 you can get an X1950 Pro or a 7900Gs - they both RAPE the 7600GT in any game.
I would use the rest of the spare cash for more memory - 1GB is not enough for all of todays games (Examples are BF2, F.E.A.R). I don't know how much further the extra cash will take you, but more memory and a faster GPU will earn you more game play then a Core2Duo over an AMD64 X2. At these specs - the bottleneck is still in the GPU and ram.
Good Luck!
Oh, as for the PSU's I've always found Enermax to be great ones even over long periods of time, so any one above 450W of their series should be fine (Liberty series is more "case friendly" if you can afford it).
 
Great help from all who responded, my thanks goes out to you.

If I decide to go the Intel route, what M/B would you guys recommend (price and overclockability is a consideration)?
 
I'd recommend the Gigabyte GA-965P-DS3. Pretty damn good overclocking mobo for about $150 I believe.

But if your budget is a little tighter, then go with the Gigabyte GA-965P-S3. The low cost version of the GA-965P-DS3 but still a decent overclocker for about $110.
 
Back
Top