AMD Managers Copied Confidential Files Before Joining NVIDIA

Probably nothing, unless someone can show that :
1) Nvidia had a part of the theft (AMD is not accusing Nvidia of this)
2) Nvidia received the documents and did not reject those (again, I don't see this accusation)

I do wonder what the 4 employees will face. If copied for their own use, they may be ordered to destroy the documents, and may face civil penalties. But the most useful thing, and I think why AMD is doing this so publicly, is to raise a stink and dirty up as many people (who deserve it if the accusation is true) and a competitor as possible. ;)

So why would the employees steal the data? You can almost guarantee they would of tried to use it as leverage to get hired by Nvidia, which means Nvidia hired them knowing they had stolen secrets from AMD. So Nvidia either A) hired the thieves and did not accept the information, or B) hired the thieves and accepted the documents.

Stealing that much information just to sit on it makes no sense at all, especially when all four got hired by Nvidia.
 
Stealing that much information just to sit on it makes no sense at all, especially when all four got hired by Nvidia.

It does if they just used it to "come up with ideas" while being employed in the same industry. For all we know these people could have invented this stuff. Still, it doesn't seem like theres the whole story here.
 
what's wrong with them doing that? It's comparable to kids at a lemonade stand copying their recipe of lemons, sugar and water before starting a job with cocacola.

/amdfanboybait
 
Some of this really does not make sense.

One why would Feldstein steal doc for Nvidia if he just worked so hard to get all the major consoles to use AMD solutions? Why would he go back to work for Nvidia?

Why did accessing anything he was not supposed to have not trigger an audit by IT?

Did they delete some tech doc and that is what AMD really wants back?

Is AMD able to deliver on the chips they have agree to to, or is this a way to get back Feldstein if he setup AMD to fail?

Last if AMD can not prove they did it, can the SEC investigate AMD for trying to mess with nvidia's stock price?
 
You would think Nvidia would be hunting for better quality employees from rival companies. Better quality meaning employees technical enough to get away with something like that.

100,000 confidential documents are not exactly easy to hide.

AMD has a fantastic engineering group , the only weak point for them is that there software division needs a serious slap across the face , AMD drivers for their GPU's are a nightmare to deal with compared to the smooth and painless experience Nvidia provides with their drivers.

It really doesn't matter that the employee's took the documents so much as it matters that Nvidia took those documents and likely used them against AMD competitively. I wouldn't be surprised that after these 4 are prosecuted that AMD doesn't go after Nvidia directly for participating in such a practice.

AMD can no longer hold a candle to Intel when it comes to CPU's but their GPU's often stay competitive with Nvidia in every regard.
 
Yea, the one-time payments didn't amount to much, but with the Nintendo Wii console they made money on royalties (each console sold) and it amounted to a big sum over the life of the console. If it's the latter, they could potentially have a pretty big sum of money depending on the sales figures and the arrangements with Sony, MS, and Nintendo.

As to the topic, this is pretty bad for both parties. nVidia ends up looking like tools for hiring AMD's former employees that (allegedly) stole sensitive information, and AMD looks more and more of a leaky ship.

+1!
 
The one console that doesn't look like it's going to go AMD appears to be the SteamBox. Gabe has already been pretty buddy-buddy with nVidia there and that looks to continue with talks of "post-Kepler". I think it's a case of nVidia realizing that they can't piss off the big console makers and still make a killing, because in the end it's inevitably going to bite you in the ass. I have a feeling that nVidia is going to be bending over backwards to get Gabe's approval going forward after learning the hard way that you can't treat the console makers like trash and expect them to come crawling back. This way they at least get a single potentially major next-gen console

Well, the current offerings from that company that Valve invested in and is reportedly developing Steam box prototypes with, based on those current offerings, are using AMD Trinity.
 
So why would the employees steal the data? You can almost guarantee they would of tried to use it as leverage to get hired by Nvidia, which means Nvidia hired them knowing they had stolen secrets from AMD.
1) because (current/older) documents make handy references if you're still working in the field. Even great employees can't remember everything.

2) that's a gigantic stretch, and something AMD hasn't even claimed.

I do think that AMD would rather have those 4 employables not working for either company, which is another reason to make this so public without even civil action filed against those 4 former employees (yet).
 
NVIDIA already wrote that book, years ago!
Not to get all flame-y, but my AMD tablet dying 6 months ago was kind of a blessing. I want to be open to as many options as possible, but graphics drivers (Windows and Linux) are a big reason why I'd scratch an AMD laptop with AMD graphics off the list for now. I have a Quadro in my Lenovo laptop and I can't believe I put up with AMD driver problems for so long.
 
AMD has a fantastic engineering group , the only weak point for them is that there software division needs a serious slap across the face , AMD drivers for their GPU's are a nightmare to deal with compared to the smooth and painless experience Nvidia provides with their drivers.

Tell that to people who had their NV GPU's burn out and die on them due to faulty drivers/hardware.

While I slightly agree that NV has had better drivers overall, the fact remains that both camps have issues from time to time.

It is laughable though to hope for AMD's demise. A duopoly is bad enough, imagine NV in a monopoly situation, and that's where a lot of ignorant people show their stupidity.

If true I hope AMD takes these ex-employees and NV (if involved) to the bank, for some bank.
 
Back
Top