AMD/ ATI Open Stereo 3D Initiative

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
[H] reader Jimmy F. sent along this image from 2010 in San Francisco that says the company will be announcing its Open Stereo 3D Initiative soon. See the slide for all the info.
 
I, for one, have had my fill of "3D".

When will this shit end?
 
Yeah, I'm willing to give it a try, but I just don't see it myself. Wasn't excited when Nvidia announced it, and I'm not excited now. I'm quite certain this is only coming as a response to Nvidia making such a big deal about it with Fermi.
 
I, for one, have had my fill of "3D".

When will this **** end?

Competition competition, though I've heard a lot more interest about bluray 3D, the ability to watch 3D movies at home instead of just at the theater.
 
Is this 'open' as in able to run on all GPU's? I sure hope so because ATI is doing the right thing with their open physics system. Nvidia's proprietary stuff can suck it.
 
I was a 3D fan before it was Nvidia. I assume they just bought the right to it. When I first got a kit it was $50-100 at compusa/circuit city and it didnt matter what card you used. It used an external adapter and glasses.
 
I, for one, have had my fill of "3D".

When will this shit end?

About the same time the Eyefinity bullsh*t ends. That'll be right about when 4k displays come out, so about 2 years? (for affordability)

3D Vision (and 3D Vision Stereo), AMD 3D, and Eyefinity can all suck it. I'll take a 55" seamless 4k screen please and thank you.
 
Why would 4K be any kind of threat to eyefinity? Eyefinity is used for getting larger aspect ratios so you can see more of the game world. 4k resolutions barely if at all extends beyond the aspect ratio of 16:9 monitors at 1080p. It depends a bit as the number of vertical pixels change with respect to whether the content is 2.35:1, 16:9, etc.

Still...Eyefinity is not about ultra-high resolution standard-aspect ratio. Its about ultra high resolution expanded aspect ratios. 4k's best advantage is really that you can expand the screen sizes to say 100" and still have the clarity in pixels per inch as you had with 1080p at 50". That being said, that would require the same or more processing power than eyefinity, for the same aspect ratio, same image, just blown up to bigger screen sizes. I think within reason, 3x27" monitors is a great mix of screensize + aspect ratio that 1-100" monitor wouldn't really beat. Especially if the 100" monitor costed 5x the price of the 3x27" monitors, gave you a smaller aspect ratio and required more pixels per second to be pushed to drive it.

That's akin to saying "Once the PCs get a tiny bit better(4k tvs), PDAs are dust!(portable media players)" which just isn't true since they both serve different purposes.
 
I, for one, have had my fill of "3D".

When will this shit end?

Cool story bro. I haven't. Myself and a 10-20 million or more people enjoyed Avatar in 3D. I'm looking forward to seeing more movies in 3D where its used to a positive benefit and helps give an extra sense of depth. I can't wait to see Clash of the Titans in 3D in theatres when that comes out since one of my childhood movies was the original Titans movie(Something Kirken?) and other greek-adventure/mythology classics.
 
Same, im all for having more options

Maybe i wont 3d all the time... but its sure nice to be able to
 
Cool story bro. I haven't. Myself and a 10-20 million or more people enjoyed Avatar in 3D. I'm looking forward to seeing more movies in 3D where its used to a positive benefit and helps give an extra sense of depth. I can't wait to see Clash of the Titans in 3D in theatres when that comes out since one of my childhood movies was the original Titans movie(Something Kirken?) and other greek-adventure/mythology classics.

I agree, I enjoyed the latest 3D flicks as well. It seems like the public is becoming very responsive to the entire idea of 3D content and I'd bet my left nut that it will go even more mainstream within a couple of years
 
k anyone remember when NVIDIA had this out..oh 10 years ago with the TNT? I had a set of these shutter glasses..and OMG the headaches, the lack of support, it was ridiculous. Games would only work on certain res, you could only be like 3 feet away from the computer cause the cable plugged into the video card and was a passthrough. These were awful.
 
Why would 4K be any kind of threat to eyefinity? Eyefinity is used for getting larger aspect ratios so you can see more of the game world. 4k resolutions barely if at all extends beyond the aspect ratio of 16:9 monitors at 1080p. It depends a bit as the number of vertical pixels change with respect to whether the content is 2.35:1, 16:9, etc.

Still...Eyefinity is not about ultra-high resolution standard-aspect ratio. Its about ultra high resolution expanded aspect ratios. 4k's best advantage is really that you can expand the screen sizes to say 100" and still have the clarity in pixels per inch as you had with 1080p at 50". That being said, that would require the same or more processing power than eyefinity, for the same aspect ratio, same image, just blown up to bigger screen sizes. I think within reason, 3x27" monitors is a great mix of screensize + aspect ratio that 1-100" monitor wouldn't really beat. Especially if the 100" monitor costed 5x the price of the 3x27" monitors, gave you a smaller aspect ratio and required more pixels per second to be pushed to drive it.

That's akin to saying "Once the PCs get a tiny bit better(4k tvs), PDAs are dust!(portable media players)" which just isn't true since they both serve different purposes.

Because gaming on a 55" (or even 42") 4K display (4096×3072 pixels) would be more fun, because it's seamless. Ultra-high resolution reduces the need for AA and other effects (if you don't believe me, go read some [H] articles) and yes, it actually requires more horsepower, but life sucks sometimes. Are you telling me it won't take anymore horsepower to run a game on 3 monitors rather than 1? I certainly hope not.

I remember people saying that 22" or 24" or even 30" monitors would be big enough. Pah! Anyone saying that hasn't played on a 96" screen. No it's not as high resolution as a 30" (yet) but there's something incredibly entertaining about it. The characters and backdrop are seamless and BIG.

FYI, here's a test:

Take your Eyefinity rig, and run a game on it. I don't care which, just any game (I use Supreme Commander, Eve Online, WoW, CoD: MW as examples myself) you like. Now go out and put it on a 55" Samsung (which a savvy shopper should be able to pick up for less than US$1400) and play it on there through a receiver w/ decent speakers. 5.1 isn't necessary, but admittedly is nicer. Now tell me which is cooler / more fun to play with. The 3 - 22" / 24" which have a higher horizontal resolution (but less vertical), or the seamless thumping of the large display. Now move it up to a 4k display, so that the 3 (even 27" monitors) have a slightly higher resolution, but a much tinier picture. Oh wait, you're at a vertical resolution disadvantage now! (Meh)

I'll give you a hint, an honest person admits the TV is far more fun to play on. No the resolution isn't there (yet) to say it thumps Eyefinity (or 3D Vision Surround) yet.

Then again I am biased. I've been running off of a large TV display since computers were able to output video to HDMI (even without sound) and my friend does play on a nice 1080p projection right now. I can no longer tolerate bezels in my display chopping up the picture. I'm chomping at the bit for 4k and higher displays. Small monitor gaming is not nearly as exciting anymore.

Aspect ratio? I hear this one trotted out way too often. If that's you're real worry, you'll want 3 - 4k displays as that would make the aspect ratio even awesomerrrr. I remember game center in Cali that had "pro" teams come in to play. They would always give those guys some free time on the unit because they wanted to link cool factor I guess. Funny thing, it didn't seem to help the guy on it vs his opposing teammates. Something about "skill" I think.

In short, this is personal preference. Then again, anyone doing it would probably end up with a 22 / 24" on their desk and a 50 / 60"+ on the wall to play on. PC monitors won't go away, but without a higher resolution, they will lose the gaming market unless you're going to stack six of those things together. This will NOT help you in a game. This is about fun factor. 3 displays and ultra-cool "aspect ratio" marketing jingoism mean sh*t. Take two relatively equal players and they'll be relatively equal regardless of Eyefinity (or 3D Vision Surround) come the end of the game. Take two slightly unequal players and give the worse of the two the awesomerrr display. He'll still lose. That's it.

Eyefinity (and 3D Vision Surround) are marketing eye candy. They've been puffed beyond their real importance (which is to point out they may drive the need for larger displays) by many. Fun factor rules, and Eyefinity (et al) pales in comparison to a larger, higher resolution, display.
 
Been gaming in Stereo3D for years.. I am so happy to hear ATI trying to push "Open Stereo 3D". I hope ATI succeeds with this, but at the same time, I hope that ATI will not slack off with actively participating/developing/supporting the technology. Remember TruForm? ATI set out to support it quite a bit and then gave up on it. We had to wait several years for "practical" tessellation to become a reality, and ATI actually had to wait until DX11 because ATI does not have such an active involvement in the community like Nvidia does with their TWIMTBP program.

Honestly, I think 1080p with at least 4xAA would suffice with 3D. The AA is nearly doubled to 8x AA because both left and right images are being anti-aliased on their own and then combined. It makes the screen feel at least twice as big (my 24" CRT feels like 50" when it's turned into 3D with great depth). The resolution is actually 1920x1200x10000 or something like that, since the depth goes just as far as the stereo separation goes (the depth layers are virtually unlimited).

About the headaches, I share my sympathies for those who did not properly adjust the convergence settings in order to make the 3D image feel natural enough so that it does not eventually cause headaches. All of my friends and brothers/wife/family who played it on my rigs never complained of headaches--not even after playing for several hours.

I'm itching to find a good DLP high-def television montior that supports Stereo3D. It's probably the only solution out there that offers absolutely zero ghosting with shutter glasses.
 
k anyone remember when NVIDIA had this out..oh 10 years ago with the TNT? I had a set of these shutter glasses..and OMG the headaches, the lack of support, it was ridiculous. Games would only work on certain res, you could only be like 3 feet away from the computer cause the cable plugged into the video card and was a passthrough. These were awful.

I do have to admit that 3D Vision is the first unit that doesn't give me a headache. That said, I still think it's a waste.
 
I, for one, have had my fill of "3D".

When will this shit end?

About the same time the Eyefinity bullsh*t ends. That'll be right about when 4k displays come out, so about 2 years? (for affordability)

3D Vision (and 3D Vision Stereo), AMD 3D, and Eyefinity can all suck it. I'll take a 55" seamless 4k screen please and thank you.

With all due respect, how is a 4K display going to benefit you now? You can have a 4K display now...for $60,000 or so. Even in two years, I doubt the price will have dropped enough to make it accessible for even a dedicated enthusiast to purchase.

Meanwhile, you can do 3D Vision and Eyefinity without breaking the bank...and both will get even more affordable. Both technologies are getting more advanced monitor and gaming setups in the hands of more people. Eyefinity and 3D Vision are also helping push PC gaming back into the spotlight. We should encourage and welcome these new technologies, not decry them.

As far as AMD's Open Stereo 3D Initiative...it's obviously an attempt to challenge NVIDIA's control of this growing market segment. However, as long as whatever final form the Open Stereo 3D Initiative doesn't conflict with or prevent NVIDIA's solution, I'm all for it. I can hope that NVIDIA would pick up on the Open Stereo 3D Initiative, but I won't hold my breath on it.
 
Fun factor rules, and Eyefinity (et al) pales in comparison to a larger, higher resolution, display.

If this were even vaguely close to the truth then people wouldn't be shelving their 30" 2560x1600 screens for 22-24" 3x1 Landscape setups.

After a few months trial with Eyefinity, I've already arranged to sell my 30". You can't compare BFBC2 in Eyefinity with a 16:10 or 16:9 setup. It's a completely different experience. I can't imagine ever going back to a single screen now. It would be like going back from 16:10 to 4:3 but even more pronounced. Would you go back to a 4:3 display if it had better resolution than 2560x1600?

If you don't like the idea of Eyefinity then fine, but don't make out like it's bunkum on a forum of people that have experience of it.
 
Hopefully third party glasses are 50-75$.

At that price I would probably grab a pair since I've already got a 120hz lcd...
 
If this were even vaguely close to the truth then people wouldn't be shelving their 30" 2560x1600 screens for 22-24" 3x1 Landscape setups.

After a few months trial with Eyefinity, I've already arranged to sell my 30". You can't compare BFBC2 in Eyefinity with a 16:10 or 16:9 setup. It's a completely different experience. I can't imagine ever going back to a single screen now. It would be like going back from 16:10 to 4:3 but even more pronounced. Would you go back to a 4:3 display if it had better resolution than 2560x1600?

If you don't like the idea of Eyefinity then fine, but don't make out like it's bunkum on a forum of people that have experience of it.

It is hard to see his point of view after trying Eyefinity myself, but different people have different opinions.

This is simply AMD's ways of offering 3d without having to do much work or risk development dollars on it. An open framework for third parties. Though my guess is that most of the companies that take advantage of this, will be ones that make Bluray playback software.
 
Avatar in 3D really turned me on to 3D again. No sign of a headache what-so-over and it was a really good experience. I'd like to see Blu-Ray playback in 3D. Only problem is that I'd have to replace all three of my monitors with more expensive 120hz ones. That is the major sticking point for me. I understand why we need 120hz monitors, but I'm not interested in spending a bunch of money replacing my current monitors right now.
 
For f*cks sake! Please make it an open standard! 3D glasses aren't supposed to be expensive! It's just a couple of half inch mono LCD's and an alternating circuit!

And regarding the 120hz displays. The max my CRT could run back then was 70Hz. 60Hz isn't gonna be an issue for me.

I wasn't getting headaches btw.
 
What? 120Hz is the minimum requirement for the 3D vision. Next thing you're gonna tell me you want to use the Red-Blue glasses
 
What? 120Hz is the minimum requirement for the 3D vision. Next thing you're gonna tell me you want to use the Red-Blue glasses

You could present stereoscopic content at 60Hz, which would still allow 30fps for games/videos which is acceptable (if only barely). The problem is that the flickering from the shutter glasses is so much more noticeable at 30Hz. 120Hz is a practical minimum.

I think anaglyph glasses would actually be a fairly practical workaround for those limited to 60Hz displays. You lose a lot of color depth/intensity, but at least the glasses are cheap and you wouldn't have to upgrade your monitor.
 
What? 120Hz is the minimum requirement for the 3D vision. Next thing you're gonna tell me you want to use the Red-Blue glasses

It's only a requirement on nVidia's proprietary version. Legacy 3D stereo doesn't care what refresh rate you're using.
 
If this were even vaguely close to the truth then people wouldn't be shelving their 30" 2560x1600 screens for 22-24" 3x1 Landscape setups.

After a few months trial with Eyefinity, I've already arranged to sell my 30". You can't compare BFBC2 in Eyefinity with a 16:10 or 16:9 setup. It's a completely different experience. I can't imagine ever going back to a single screen now. It would be like going back from 16:10 to 4:3 but even more pronounced. Would you go back to a 4:3 display if it had better resolution than 2560x1600?

If you don't like the idea of Eyefinity then fine, but don't make out like it's bunkum on a forum of people that have experience of it.


Eyefinity is the new hotness. There's always a small group that fall in line...

I'll stick with my 30" 2560x1600 since it's a lot more practical and guaranteed to work in games.

Imo.
 
Back
Top