Amazon Yanks Macmillan Books Over Pricing

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Raise your hand if you didn’t see this coming. Amazon has pulled the books of one of the largest publishers in the US, Macmillan, from its virtual shelves. The reason? Pricing of e-books. Strangely enough, Macmillan is one of the publishers slated to offer books on the new iBooks store for the iPad. What an amazing coincidence!

I’ve talked to a person in the industry with knowledge of the dispute who says the disappearance is the result of a disagreement between Amazon.com and book publishers that has been brewing for the last year. Macmillan, like other publishers, has asked Amazon to raise the price of electronic books from $9.99 to around $15. Amazon is expressing its strong disagreement by temporarily removing Macmillan books, said this person.
 
They are greedy. $10 is more than fair, $15 is just way.
 
$15 for an ebook novel would be ridiculous for standard market stuff... $10 is already pushing it for mass-market/paperback texts done as ebooks, frankly, let alone $17 paperbacks which are crazy. They don't have ANY of the traditional costs of books other than royalties with ebooks, yet they want to charge just as much as though they had to print, ship, consign, and front tons of costs associated with physical books. Absurd.
 
This is getting a bit stupid. I can understand charging around $10 for a paperback, but as far as I am concerned an ebook can be generated for a fraction of the cost of a paperback book (as long as the infrastructure is in place, which it obviously is). I understand the author, publisher and distributor must get the profits, but seriously $15 for an ebook????

They could easily charge $5-7 and make a ton more profit from the increasing sales. Stupid corporate morons. God I am getting sick of these greedy bastards.
 
This stuff blows my mind. Pure digital media should be a lot cheaper (at least 50%) than hardcopy versions. Zero reproduction cost, zero warehousing cost, zero transportation costs.

So an e-novel should be ~$5.
 
This stuff blows my mind. Pure digital media should be a lot cheaper (at least 50%) than hardcopy versions. Zero reproduction cost, zero warehousing cost, zero transportation costs.

So an e-novel should be ~$5.

+∞

The greedy bastards got what they deserved on this one.
 
How long before these prices kill sales and rather than admit it they try to blame piracy or lament that people just don't read as much as they used to without a clue why that might be?
 
This stuff blows my mind. Pure digital media should be a lot cheaper (at least 50%) than hardcopy versions. Zero reproduction cost, zero warehousing cost, zero transportation costs.

So an e-novel should be ~$5.

Well, quite a few Hardcover books have a $30 cover price (or more) so $15 is half price, but to me is too much.

btw, Booksellers pay 50% of the cover price from the publisher.
 
This stuff blows my mind. Pure digital media should be a lot cheaper (at least 50%) than hardcopy versions. Zero reproduction cost, zero warehousing cost, zero transportation costs.

So an e-novel should be ~$5.

New physical hardcovers are $30, on Amazon Kindle they're $10.

So Amazon meets you halfway. :)
 
Ummm. Why should the price be compared to Hardcovers and not softcovers.

Clearly the E version cost much less to produce than a soft cover.

It should be something like:

Ebook: $5
Softcover: $10
Hardcover: $20
 
Ummm. Why should the price be compared to Hardcovers and not softcovers.

Clearly the E version cost much less to produce than a soft cover.

It should be something like:

Ebook: $5
Softcover: $10
Hardcover: $20

New hardcovers retail for around $30.

In any case, a voluntary transaction for a non-essential good that is sold as advertised is not ripping off a customer in any way. That is how markets work.
 
To be clear, Macmillan wanting to charge more for their books is asinine and it obviously isn't going to work since Amazon is and will continue to be the major source of e-book sales. I actually think the iPad has tons of potential due to third party applications, but the last thing I'd use it for is reading books.

e-paper > LCD for reading books
 
http://www.webscription.net/

Baen Books, Del Rey, E-Reads, Night Shade Books, SRM Publisher, Subterranean Press, and Tor Books all sell ebooks through the site.

Which shows that ebooks can and due go for reasonable amounts of money. If it did not work Baen would have shut it down years ago and all the other publishers would not have joined up. The only authors who pulled out wanted DRM in the books. (well the only ones who mentioned why they left, others may have but I've only heard about three of them.)
 
$10 ebooks are FUCKING BULLSHIT... PERIOD END OF STORY

Why should I pay $10 for a book I cant trade, sell or otherwise make use of?
 
I have wanted an eReader for a while now, but the cost has had me stalling. I buy about 5 or 6 books(softcover and hardcover) a month, and I have something to show for it. I think they should give you a digital copy when you purchase a physical copy, would be a huge selling point for me since I prefer to hold a book at home, but an eReader is really appealing for travel.
 
To be clear, Macmillan wanting to charge more for their books is asinine and it obviously isn't going to work since Amazon is and will continue to be the major source of e-book sales. I actually think the iPad has tons of potential due to third party applications, but the last thing I'd use it for is reading books.

e-paper > LCD for reading books

Which begs the question, why use a device of this size if not for reading. Video media playback. Okay, but to be honest if I wanted to watch a movie, a laptop might be easier to deal with unless of course you're we're going to tote around all of the iPad accessories to keep it upright.

To me, if tablets don't get a decent amount of a reading audience they are just going to have it rough. They simply don't do anything well enough for the size that don't work better with a phone and a laptop.
 
$10 ebooks are FUCKING BULLSHIT... PERIOD END OF STORY

Why should I pay $10 for a book I cant trade, sell or otherwise make use of?

For me, the convenience of not having to carry or store those books. I travel for work all the time and the Kindle has been a godsend. The heaviest, bulkiest thing in my carry on was always the books I'd pack. They were worse than my notebook computer. Now I just carry a little 10 ounce piece of plastic and aluminum, its genius.

It isn't for everyone, clearly, but you can't fault people for buying them either as they can have huge advantages over physical media.
 
Which begs the question, why use a device of this size if not for reading. Video media playback. Okay, but to be honest if I wanted to watch a movie, a laptop might be easier to deal with unless of course you're we're going to tote around all of the iPad accessories to keep it upright.

To me, if tablets don't get a decent amount of a reading audience they are just going to have it rough. They simply don't do anything well enough for the size that don't work better with a phone and a laptop.

I keep saying it over and over again: Third-party applications.

They will define its usefulness just like they defined the usefulness of the iPhone and iPod Touch.
 
its just like walmart... if they dont think a certain price will move enough units then they have no desire to carry that product. its just smart cutthroat business.
 
$10 ebooks are FUCKING BULLSHIT... PERIOD END OF STORY

Why should I pay $10 for a book I cant trade, sell or otherwise make use of?

To add to the post I made above, it is also why I'll spend the same amount for a PC game on Steam. Autopatching, no CD keys, no DVD required in the drive, unlimited downloads, no physical clutter, these are actual benefits that certain customers value.

It obviously isn't for everyone, but to say that physical media (or digital media) is the only way is ridiculous.
 
Serpico said:
... the last thing I'd use [the iPad] for is reading books.

e-paper > LCD for reading books

Ditto - MacMillian must be thinking the iPad user base will be larger than the Kindle's and they're probably right, but what portion will be reading books on the thing? (Though I suppose that same market would pay > $10 / book.)

I wish the books I purchased were that cheap. Damn text books you are lucky to find 1/2 of them for under $150 new any more. :(
Don't even get me started - I'll buy a Kindle the minute they sell e-textbooks.
 
I wonder if this is an indication of what the prices will be on the iPad iBookstore. If so, gl selling much.
 
$10 ebooks are FUCKING BULLSHIT... PERIOD END OF STORY

Why should I pay $10 for a book I cant trade, sell or otherwise make use of?

I know, right? At least you can burn a paperback for a fair amount of heat if you needed.

Don't even get me started - I'll buy a Kindle the minute they sell e-textbooks.

Of course, the e-books will cost $50-100, and the publishers will still change 5 things to make a new "edition", giving a free copy to professors and forcing students to buy a new copy nearly every year.
Out of the several thousand I spent on books in university, I probably could have saved 1000 if there hadn't been new editions required all the time. Can't buy used, can't sell used.
 
I know, right? At least you can burn a paperback for a fair amount of heat if you needed.
Of course, the e-books will cost $50-100, and the publishers will still change 5 things to make a new "edition", giving a free copy to professors and forcing students to buy a new copy nearly every year.
Out of the several thousand I spent on books in university, I probably could have saved 1000 if there hadn't been new editions required all the time. Can't buy used, can't sell used.

Th truth with Math and English textbooks.
 
why would it be though? math and english shouldnt really change. its the same with our electrical books... i mean i get the code update books but why are there always new revisions on hundred year old science? $$$$ is why, these publishers are like mafia. schools, unions, businesses... theyre like crack dealers always pushin the newest cut.
 
Looks like amazon is giving consumers a choice in their overpriced digital bits as they restored the catalog at the higher price. Meh. I don't mind buying kindle books if they are for reference or encompass a huge series but for most things I prefer to get my pleasure reading done on something that doesn't require batteries.
 
Aaaaaaand Amazon has already thrown in the towel: http://www.amazon.com/tag/kindle/fo...Thread=Tx2MEGQWTNGIMHV&displayType=tagsDetail

That didn't take long, very disappointing. Oh well, people will vote with their wallets. If Macmillan decides that an eBook is worth $15 and people pay $15, then they will be $15.

I guess they feared it would create a chain reaction of other publishers raising their prices, pissing off customers who always relied on Amazon to provide fair prices.

They really couldn't win this one any other way but pull the rug from under Macmillan and hope they come crawling back to Amazon with promises to lower their prices again.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I guess they feared it would create a chain reaction of other publishers raising their prices, pissing off customers who always relied on Amazon to provide fair prices.

They really couldn't win this one any other way but pull the rug from under Macmillan and hope they come crawling back to Amazon with promises to lower their prices again.

I'm just surprised that it only lasted two days. Maybe just one weekend made them feel the hurt from not having their content. Oh well, hopefully everyone else doesn't follow suit.
 
Back
Top