Amazon’s Same Day Delivery Will Kill Local Retailers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Will Amazon's same day service will kill local retailers? Personally, I don't think so but what do you think?

But now Amazon has a new game. Now that it has agreed to collect sales taxes, the company can legally set up warehouses right inside some of the largest metropolitan areas in the nation. Why would it want to do that? Because Amazon’s new goal is to get stuff to you immediately—as soon as a few hours after you hit Buy.
 
No, if your local and you have what people want they will shop with you.

Sure there are alot of lazy people who rather go online, click and be done with it....

Change with the times, you don't adopt, you die... maybe local store need to look into getting an online presence, i mean it is only 2012!!!
 
I can't wait until Amazon destroys all of the retail chains in the states that gave it trouble. You shouldn't call them to the field unless hardball is the game you want to play.
 
Sounds like you're paying for the convenience of not going to the store and getting it yourself, and there will be increased overhead costs, and whatnot, so I am not sure they will be able to compete on price anymore, they will have to raise prices to make that business model work.

They COULD be the Wal Mart of convenience (as in delivery), but I do not think it is a sustainable business model.

Didn't they have that one online grocery shopping operation a while back that fizzled out after a lot of hype?
 
Sounds like you're paying for the convenience of not going to the store and getting it yourself, and there will be increased overhead costs, and whatnot, so I am not sure they will be able to compete on price anymore, they will have to raise prices to make that business model work.

They COULD be the Wal Mart of convenience (as in delivery), but I do not think it is a sustainable business model.

Didn't they have that one online grocery shopping operation a while back that fizzled out after a lot of hype?

Don't be silly. Amazon not coming up with a viable business strategy?

Also, their grocery service is still running and gaining traction. I see them all over these days.
 
I already choose Amazon w\ local delivery over Fry's 95% of the time, and here's the kicker; Fry's is only 2 miles from my house. The ONLY time I still buy from Fry's is if I need a part right now and it's past the cutoff for same-day local delivery. Amazon saves me money every time and their return policy is much easier to deal with.
 
Don't be silly. Amazon not coming up with a viable business strategy?

Also, their grocery service is still running and gaining traction. I see them all over these days.

You didn't read my post correctly, part of the appeal of Amazon.com wasn't so much that you were having shit delivered to your door, but that sales tax was not collected.

Now that they ARE collecting sales tax, they will be competing on convenience only, and they will not be able to have the low prices as they do online because of the increased overhead costs of having a local operation, employees, rent, product, etc all in one space, and this is across a lot of cities, that's a significant amount of money to invest in this kind of operation, and for it to work, prices will have to be raised.

Not sure if that works, buddy.
 
though
I can't wait until Amazon destroys all of the retail chains in the states that gave it trouble. You shouldn't call them to the field unless hardball is the game you want to play.

I personally agree with this.

While not for the fact for the them having to get taxed, but for them having to get taxed on previously sold online items, that did not require it previously. I hope though, that they keep it to those states, only. While it would be awesome to have one down the road from me, I'd prefer them to use it as a strategy to dissuade the BS tax that they shouldn't have to pay unless they are present in the state.
 
I can't wait until Amazon destroys all of the retail chains in the states that gave it trouble. You shouldn't call them to the field unless hardball is the game you want to play.

Dream on.

If Amazon claims same day delivery they're going to have to start delivering themselves ($) upside to that, is that will create jobs locally (win), no way they can rely on FedEx/UPS/etc to do that ($$$$) either way prices of goods will go up as a result, free shipping? yeah maybe the 2 day variety, the cost advantage of Amazon is not so good that it'll get rid of retail outlets, now that shipping will cost more, and taxes will make it cost more, the playing field is leveled finally.

Also lets be honest, not everything is in every Amazon warehouse, so same day delivery might have some stipulations, in the same way free 2-day shipping now doesn't include many items (affiliates).
 
Same thing as mom and pop shops complaining about Wal-Mart. Adapt to consumer demand or fuck off.
 
Sounds like you're paying for the convenience of not going to the store and getting it yourself, and there will be increased overhead costs, and whatnot, so I am not sure they will be able to compete on price anymore, they will have to raise prices to make that business model work.

They COULD be the Wal Mart of convenience (as in delivery), but I do not think it is a sustainable business model.

Didn't they have that one online grocery shopping operation a while back that fizzled out after a lot of hype?
People have less and less time to even shop. They can probably charge a slight premium on cost and still make it work. I guess these shops got what they asked for. Also a reasonably local return drop off point would be icing on the cake.
 
I live in the sticks so I doubt this will ever be an option. Overnight is as good as it gets for me since if I am buying off amazon it is because either a local retailer does not carry an item or it is significantly cheaper at amazon.
 
You didn't read my post correctly, part of the appeal of Amazon.com wasn't so much that you were having shit delivered to your door, but that sales tax was not collected.

Now that they ARE collecting sales tax, they will be competing on convenience only, and they will not be able to have the low prices as they do online because of the increased overhead costs of having a local operation, employees, rent, product, etc all in one space, and this is across a lot of cities, that's a significant amount of money to invest in this kind of operation, and for it to work, prices will have to be raised.

Not sure if that works, buddy.

I did understand your post just fine. I live in WA, and Amazon is still cheaper than most even when my high King County sales tax is included. Delivery is already typically super fast.

Will same day delivery cost more? Probably. Is it convenient to get shit delivered to you at work or at home when you don't have time to run to the store? Fuck yes.
 
I'd prefer them to use it as a strategy to dissuade the BS tax that they shouldn't have to pay unless they are present in the state.

Translation: Fuck that shit, I don't want to pay sales tax, because I damn sure am not going to declare the Use Tax because *political rant blah blah politicians too spendy.. etc same arguments*
 
I don't use Amazon for the tax "discount," although I know alot of people do. I use it because I can get stuff shipped anywhere I happen to be since I travel quite a bit and they don't hassle me with changing the shipping destination like new egg or fry's. It is also handy if you live in a big metro city and you don't own a car which is what I did for awhile.
 
Smart company changing its strategy, it isn't just the low prices that make me shop at Amazon it is the massive selection of items, they have everything, I generally look around locally for items as I hate waiting for stuff to be delivered, but they usually don't have it.
 
I already choose Amazon w\ local delivery over Fry's 95% of the time, and here's the kicker; Fry's is only 2 miles from my house. The ONLY time I still buy from Fry's is if I need a part right now and it's past the cutoff for same-day local delivery. Amazon saves me money every time and their return policy is much easier to deal with.

Frys has the most lax return policy on the face of the earth, they are literally the easiest people to return stuff to.
 
Translation: Fuck that shit, I don't want to pay sales tax, because I damn sure am not going to declare the Use Tax because *political rant blah blah politicians too spendy.. etc same arguments*

Translation: I don't understand what I just read and will assume.
 
Dream on.

If Amazon claims same day delivery they're going to have to start delivering themselves ($) upside to that, is that will create jobs locally (win), no way they can rely on FedEx/UPS/etc to do that ($$$$) either way prices of goods will go up as a result, free shipping? yeah maybe the 2 day variety, the cost advantage of Amazon is not so good that it'll get rid of retail outlets, now that shipping will cost more, and taxes will make it cost more, the playing field is leveled finally.

Also lets be honest, not everything is in every Amazon warehouse, so same day delivery might have some stipulations, in the same way free 2-day shipping now doesn't include many items (affiliates).

Amazon does have its own delivery service. Do you really think they haven't tested this stuff in their home state? The sales tax does not level the playing field. Amazon is still usually cheaper.

I'm sure same day delivery will have stipulations, you just have to understand this isn't new it's only new to those who live in states that cracked down on sales tax collection.
 
I did understand your post just fine. I live in WA, and Amazon is still cheaper than most even when my high King County sales tax is included. Delivery is already typically super fast.

Will same day delivery cost more? Probably. Is it convenient to get shit delivered to you at work or at home when you don't have time to run to the store? Fuck yes.
Yup. And using those Amazon drop-off boxes, I often get my stuff same-day already. Even normal shipping for me is next day where I am (also in King Co). I can order an item right now, and have it in hand Saturday AM. I still go to Fry's and whatnot to price compare and sometimes I like to try things before I buy (though if the price difference is only a few bucks, I generally buy from the place I'm "trying it out" at).
 
Frys has the most lax return policy on the face of the earth, they are literally the easiest people to return stuff to.
I don't know about that. I bought a router one time and was returning it. It came with a driver CD and they didn't want to give me cash for it since it came with "software" and software is not returnable:rolleyes:. Luckily I was just swapping it for another router.
 
. Amazon saves me money every time and their return policy is much easier to deal with.

This I don't understand. Let me first say that I have never tried to return anything I bought online. The way I picture it is that I have to fill out some online form, get approval, package up the item, go to the post office and mail it back at my expense. If that is how it works, then it is a huge pain in the ass. Returning things to my local computer store consists of walking in the front door and returning it. I don't even need the receipt because they have it on file.
 
A 64GB microSDXC card from Amazon is $65. It's $150 from Best Buy. Somehow, I don't think sales tax is really the issue there.
 
Dream on.

If Amazon claims same day delivery they're going to have to start delivering themselves ($) upside to that, is that will create jobs locally (win), no way they can rely on FedEx/UPS/etc to do that ($$$$) either way prices of goods will go up as a result, free shipping? yeah maybe the 2 day variety, the cost advantage of Amazon is not so good that it'll get rid of retail outlets, now that shipping will cost more, and taxes will make it cost more, the playing field is leveled finally.

Also lets be honest, not everything is in every Amazon warehouse, so same day delivery might have some stipulations, in the same way free 2-day shipping now doesn't include many items (affiliates).

Hiring a team of drivers to work from the warehouse will save them a fortune over ups/FedEx not cost them more. Not having to hire salespeople and all the site that comes with retail will still give them quite a price advantage.
 
This I don't understand. Let me first say that I have never tried to return anything I bought online. The way I picture it is that I have to fill out some online form, get approval, package up the item, go to the post office and mail it back at my expense. If that is how it works, then it is a huge pain in the ass. Returning things to my local computer store consists of walking in the front door and returning it. I don't even need the receipt because they have it on file.


With amazon, you sign in, hit return, and print the return label. You will likely have to drop it off at a UPS spot, but with B&M spots you still have to drive somewhere anyway. At least with Amazon, you can get the return approved before wasting gas money.
 
The new "add on" items program will cut their shipping costs a bunch. The days of Prime customers ordering a $3 item with two day shipping are numbered and I am surprised it took so long.

With the new warehouses I doubt they will have a problem with same day delivery at close to the current prices.
 
It will be great if Amazon can pull this off. I have to pay tax when buying from Newegg but I do get the benefit of next day delivery for free. Buy today get it tomorrow. With Amazon, I save on tax but shipping take about a week on average to get to me. No Prime since I don't buy enough crap to make it worth it.
 
A 64GB microSDXC card from Amazon is $65. It's $150 from Best Buy. Somehow, I don't think sales tax is really the issue there.

Well said. The prices at brick & mortar shops are so ridiculous that Amazon could charge the cigarette and liquor taxes on top of sales tax and still be cheaper than local retail.
 
If I were to press buy, and get my product within 12 hours to my door. That would kill
 
As much as I like online shopping, if I can find it close in price to online I like to buy it locally as its much easier to return a defective item in person.
 
Frys has the most lax return policy on the face of the earth, they are literally the easiest people to return stuff to.

bullshit. They're one of the few stores left that charges a restocking fee.
That's the only reason I don't buy shit from them unless their prices are really good.

Fry's will pm online prices, but usually online prices suck, and online items differ from store items.

BB will pm fry's, and any local store, and has no hassle return policy. So I have even more reason not to buy at frys
 
I always check Amazon first before buying just about everything. Only if it's the weekend or if I just need something immediately will I go to a local store.

I prefer returning stuff through Amazon alot more than driving back to the store and having the clerk go through the routine there.
 
Amazon! What is best in life?
Amazon: To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentation of their women.
 
That all really depends. If we're talking about cloths, shoes, furniture, and food then yes local retail stores all the way. For electronics and machinery, that's one size fits all, then yes they're dead.

Just to give you a couple of examples I wanted to get a protective case for my cell phone, and protection for the touch screen. Local stores want $30 - $40 for these things, but on Amazon it's $1 with free shipping. That is a pretty silly difference.

Another example is getting tires for my car. I want Goodyear tires and a local shop wants $700 for 4 tires. TireRack though isn't my favorite tire shopping place anymore, as they want $648. Ebay though wants it for $90 per tire, free shipping. Same exact Goodyear tires.

Amazon and Ebay tend to be very close to each other in prices. It depends on what you're looking for. More importantly is that Amazon and Ebay will destroy the price discrepancy that you see from living in different areas. Local retailers go by the average income of the area. So their prices will go up and down depending on where you live. That is something that Amazon will certainly destroy.
 
Internet shopping already took away a lot of sales from local retailers for the last decade or more. I doubt same day shipping will really change things much.
 
This reminds me of all the times I've tried to get staples, home depot, target, best buy, walmart, office depot, etc. to price match to amazon (or even newegg + shipping/tax that may or may not exist) only to have them laugh in my face and tell me to pay 30% more just because they are local.

I love competition as much as the next person but these retail outlets simply don't even care to compete so for all I care they can drop dead and go fuck themselves. ;)
 
This author admits that he subscribes to Amazon Prime but then goes on to claim all the benefits of Amazon's "Free" shipping.

It's not "free" if you're paying a subscription fee.

As a subscriber to Amazon’s Prime subscription service, I’m used to getting two-day shipping on most items for free. But on about a third of my purchases, my package arrives after just one day for no extra charge. Sometimes the service is so speedy it seems almost magical. One Friday afternoon last month, I ordered three smoke alarms, and I debated paying extra for shipping so that I could install them over the weekend. The $9 per item that Amazon charges for Saturday delivery seemed too steep, though, so I went with standard two-day service. The next morning, the delivery guy arrived with my smoke detectors. I’d gotten next-day Saturday service for free. I have no idea how Amazon made any money on my order (the whole bill was less than $30) but several people on Twitter told me that they’ve experienced similarly delightful service.

If Amazon can send me stuff overnight for free without a distribution center nearby, it’s not hard to guess what it can do once it has lots of warehouses within driving distance of my house.

In reality the only truly "Free" shipping they offer is their "Super Saver Shipping". The problem with that is that they will wait in average of 5 business days before they even ship your item if you select that shipping method. That means I could be living next door to their distribution center and still not get my package in a timely manner... so I can't say I'm super excited about them opening up new distribution facilities.

Buying from Amazon and paying full sales tax, and then having to choose to either pay a subscription fee or wait 2 weeks for your package isn't exactly appealing. When I can get truly free shipping that takes 2 days or less, wake me up. I'm lucky enough to have a Fry's Electronics nearby and if I'm going to pay tax either way, the decision is pretty simple.
 
If I ever buy outside of amazon and pay MORE locally it is because I NEED it that same day. If Amazon introduces same day shipping it will STOMP and/or CRUSH local chains.
 
Back
Top