Amazon Launching AutoRip CDs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Amazon has just launched AutoRip. Now when you buy a CD online, you automatically get a digital version of the CD in your cloud player. It even works for CDs you bought from Amazon in the past. :cool:

Amazon today announced the launch of Amazon AutoRip, a new service that gives customers free MP3 versions of CDs they purchase from Amazon. When customers purchase AutoRip CDs, the MP3 versions are automatically added to their Cloud Player libraries, where they are available, free of charge, for immediate playback or download – no more waiting for the CD to arrive. Additionally, customers who have purchased AutoRip CDs at any time since Amazon first opened its Music Store in 1998 will find MP3 versions of those albums in their Cloud Player libraries – also automatically and for free. More than 50,000 albums, including titles from every major record label, are available for AutoRip, and more titles are added all the time – customers can just look for the AutoRip logo.
 
People still buy CD's? Must be those eclectic types who still buy records.
/s

Actually that is fairly cool, wonder how they got the rights to do this seeing as physical and digital media have different rights and are often owned by different people. Yea! legal rights fragmentation!
 
People still buy cd's and Vinyl because they sound better.. MP3's are great for my phone when i'm at the gym or about to go to bed. Vinyl crushes mp3's and cd's. I also have a SACD player.. People that actally sit down and listen to music and enjoy it know the difrence in sound.
 
While I try not to buy CD's anymore - I do make an exception, mostly in cases where I can meet the actual group themselves and have them sign the CD.

This is a really cool service.
 
People still buy cd's and Vinyl because they sound better.. MP3's are great for my phone when i'm at the gym or about to go to bed. Vinyl crushes mp3's and cd's. I also have a SACD player.. People that actally sit down and listen to music and enjoy it know the difrence in sound.

Give me FLAC or give me death.
 
ya.. this is a very cool service.. right on amazon. I have been buying mp3's from them for years anyways.. DRM free... screw iTunes..
 
People still buy CD's? Must be those eclectic types who still buy records.
/s

Actually that is fairly cool, wonder how they got the rights to do this seeing as physical and digital media have different rights and are often owned by different people. Yea! legal rights fragmentation!

Unless I want a one-off track, I always buy the CD if I'm buying an entire album.

I then rip it to a lossless format, and from there generate whatever MP3's I need for my devices with DBPowerAmp.

Then the CD goes in a storage locker never to be seen again unless I need to make new lossless masters.
 
Though it's cool of them to automatically upload the MP3's for past CD purchases, I already had ripped them and uploaded to my Amazon Cloud so now I have duplicates :)

Luckily their AutoRips have a special tag making them easy to find.
 
Big deal. Crappy mp3 rips. Where are the FLAC downloads? I buy a lot of my music on vinyl and a majority of the time the album comes with a download card. Of those download cards about half let me choose mp3 or FLAC.
 
Just wait until the MAFIAA get's wind of this!

It's good to see someone actually working towards a system that's favorable to the consumer.
 
I don't really buy new CD's any more, but I do occasionally put them on my wish list for others to buy for me. Only "new" CD's I have personally paid money for in the last few years have been local bands from live music venues.

I guess this could be handy for heavy users of the Amazon cloud.... ie - Kindle fire people?
 
Vinyl crushes mp3's and cd's.

Yeah, CDs just can't reproduce those scratches and pops like Vinyl can.

I'd rather have (imaginary) 90% quality that's still 90% quality after listening 1000 times than 100% that's 50% after 10 playbacks.

Of course Vinyl junkies can't explain how they can discern 16 Bits of audio values or hear frequencies up to 22050Hz. They just "feel" it. :rolleyes:

And we're not even talking about SACD or HDCD.
 
Yeah, CDs just can't reproduce those scratches and pops like Vinyl can.

I'd rather have (imaginary) 90% quality that's still 90% quality after listening 1000 times than 100% that's 50% after 10 playbacks.

Of course Vinyl junkies can't explain how they can discern 16 Bits of audio values or hear frequencies up to 22050Hz. They just "feel" it. :rolleyes:

And we're not even talking about SACD or HDCD.

Right on! A man after my own heart.
 
I'm quite happy about this. I received 4 free MP3 albums (3 of which I no longer own) today thanks to Amazon.
 
This kind of defeats the purpose of buying the CD.

I buy CD's because I can rip them myself, and make sure the rip is performed correctly and compressed the way I like it.
 
Yeah, CDs just can't reproduce those scratches and pops like Vinyl can.

I'd rather have (imaginary) 90% quality that's still 90% quality after listening 1000 times than 100% that's 50% after 10 playbacks.

Of course Vinyl junkies can't explain how they can discern 16 Bits of audio values or hear frequencies up to 22050Hz. They just "feel" it. :rolleyes:

And we're not even talking about SACD or HDCD.

Exactly the way I feel.

Vinyl is more or less junk.

It sounds more "warm" because it rounds off the rough edges in the original recording. The same effect could probably be achieved by running some sort of filter over a CD rip, if you really wanted to :p
 
Big deal. Crappy mp3 rips. Where are the FLAC downloads? I buy a lot of my music on vinyl and a majority of the time the album comes with a download card. Of those download cards about half let me choose mp3 or FLAC.

I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.


FLAC - however - is a tremendous waste of disk space.

You may think you can hear the difference between a raw source (or lossless compression) and a well encoded mp3, but the truth is you can't. It's all placebo effect.

There ARE certainly poorly encoded mp3's, (many of them predating modern good encoders, or encoded by people not knowing what they were doing) but a well encoded mp3 is indistinguishable from source, even by audiophiles with expensive listening equipment.

Hydrogenaudio.org did a well publicized double blind study a few years back, in which they wrote a program that performed a A-B double blind test ad asked people to run it on their equipment. The program contained several samples across genres of music. One sample consisted of raw WAV data extracted directly off of the disc. The other contained the same WAV file, compressed to mp3 using LAME with "--alt-preset standard" settings which produces a high quality ~128kbit+ bitrate VBR file.

The program allowed subjects to listen to each sample as many times as they liked, and then select which one they thought was the mp3 and which one the original, before they moved on to the next sample.

Test subjects were encouraged to download the program and run it on their own equipment. Being hydrogenaudio.org, a lot of serious audiophiles with expensive equipment part took in the study.

The results? The "audiophiles" could only pick the right "compressed" sample approximately 50% of the time. In other words, no better than chance.

The conclusion of the study was that many were biased from hearing too many poorly encoded mp3's, and that hearing quality issues in well encoded mp3's is merely placebo effect.

That's not to say that you can't produce sounds to intentionally make audio compression sound poorly. Slow upwards frequency sweeps is one way to do this very well, but this type of special cases are very rarely (if ever) present in music.

Essentially, uncompressed audio, or lossless audio compression (like flac) is just a huge waste of disk space. Which is fine if that's really what you want to do...

Many people who swore up and down they could tell an mp3 from source material and that mp3's were unlistenable were very humbled that day.
 
Yeah, CDs just can't reproduce those scratches and pops like Vinyl can.

I'd rather have (imaginary) 90% quality that's still 90% quality after listening 1000 times than 100% that's 50% after 10 playbacks.

Of course Vinyl junkies can't explain how they can discern 16 Bits of audio values or hear frequencies up to 22050Hz. They just "feel" it. :rolleyes:

And we're not even talking about SACD or HDCD.

Actually you need 18 bits to get most of the population.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501795 said:
Exactly the way I feel.

Vinyl is more or less junk.

It sounds more "warm" because it rounds off the rough edges in the original recording. The same effect could probably be achieved by running some sort of filter over a CD rip, if you really wanted to :p

That's why you only play a record once, while ripping it to FLAC.
 
Good start. Now make the download FLAC instead of MP3 and we're talking. Then again, I might not buy the CD in the first place if they did... maybe that's the point. ;)
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501809 said:
I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.


FLAC - however - is a tremendous waste of disk space.

You may think you can hear the difference between a raw source (or lossless compression) and a well encoded mp3, but the truth is you can't. It's all placebo effect.

There ARE certainly poorly encoded mp3's, (many of them predating modern good encoders, or encoded by people not knowing what they were doing) but a well encoded mp3 is indistinguishable from source, even by audiophiles with expensive listening equipment.

Hydrogenaudio.org did a well publicized double blind study a few years back, in which they wrote a program that performed a A-B double blind test ad asked people to run it on their equipment. The program contained several samples across genres of music. One sample consisted of raw WAV data extracted directly off of the disc. The other contained the same WAV file, compressed to mp3 using LAME with "--alt-preset standard" settings which produces a high quality ~128kbit+ bitrate VBR file.

The program allowed subjects to listen to each sample as many times as they liked, and then select which one they thought was the mp3 and which one the original, before they moved on to the next sample.

Test subjects were encouraged to download the program and run it on their own equipment. Being hydrogenaudio.org, a lot of serious audiophiles with expensive equipment part took in the study.

The results? The "audiophiles" could only pick the right "compressed" sample approximately 50% of the time. In other words, no better than chance.

The conclusion of the study was that many were biased from hearing too many poorly encoded mp3's, and that hearing quality issues in well encoded mp3's is merely placebo effect.

That's not to say that you can't produce sounds to intentionally make audio compression sound poorly. Slow upwards frequency sweeps is one way to do this very well, but this type of special cases are very rarely (if ever) present in music.

Essentially, uncompressed audio, or lossless audio compression (like flac) is just a huge waste of disk space. Which is fine if that's really what you want to do...

Many people who swore up and down they could tell an mp3 from source material and that mp3's were unlistenable were very humbled that day.

Entirely depends on what you're listening to. Certain instrumental timbres and textures get eaten alive by mp3. Also depends on how trashed the subjects ears are and what gear they're listening on.

//As someone in the audio biz.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501809 said:
I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.

...

Audiophiles rarely ever have equipment that measures studio flat. They prefer terms like "warm" "bright" "forward" and so on. On equipment that actually measures properly, you have a better chance of picking out compression in an MP3 vs. lossless. Most people still don't show an ear for it, but there is a difference.

Never trust audiophiles, listen to people who actually record music.

As far as the disk space argument goes... come on, man.
 
This could be a nice money saver, as some albums are cheaper (with prime shipping) than the mp3 album. So right there you save a few bucks. Then you can still sell the cd to the record store and get another few bucks. Sure a 1/2 digital album isn't a huge deal given the legwork, but if you do this in one big shot with 10 or more cds, this could be a real money saver.

My autorip gave me some old random Industrial tributes to Radiohead and NIN I bought. Stuff so obscure it was never even pirated.
 
Entirely depends on what you're listening to. Certain instrumental timbres and textures get eaten alive by mp3. Also depends on how trashed the subjects ears are and what gear they're listening on.

//As someone in the audio biz.

Give it up all ready. I could properly encode anything you wanted into a lossy format and play it back on any equipment of your choosing and you couldn't tell the source material from the compressed material.

The study he talked about sampled music from multiple genres and let people play it on their own equipment. Perhaps the results wouldn't hold up under scientific peer review, but I'm sure a scientific study would reach the same conclusions.

Back to the article. I like this and got a couple of past purchased CDs thrown into my cloud player.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501809 said:
I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.


FLAC - however - is a tremendous waste of disk space.

You may think you can hear the difference between a raw source (or lossless compression) and a well encoded mp3, but the truth is you can't. It's all placebo effect.

There ARE certainly poorly encoded mp3's, (many of them predating modern good encoders, or encoded by people not knowing what they were doing) but a well encoded mp3 is indistinguishable from source, even by audiophiles with expensive listening equipment.

Hydrogenaudio.org did a well publicized double blind study a few years back, in which they wrote a program that performed a A-B double blind test ad asked people to run it on their equipment. The program contained several samples across genres of music. One sample consisted of raw WAV data extracted directly off of the disc. The other contained the same WAV file, compressed to mp3 using LAME with "--alt-preset standard" settings which produces a high quality ~128kbit+ bitrate VBR file.

The program allowed subjects to listen to each sample as many times as they liked, and then select which one they thought was the mp3 and which one the original, before they moved on to the next sample.

Test subjects were encouraged to download the program and run it on their own equipment. Being hydrogenaudio.org, a lot of serious audiophiles with expensive equipment part took in the study.

The results? The "audiophiles" could only pick the right "compressed" sample approximately 50% of the time. In other words, no better than chance.

The conclusion of the study was that many were biased from hearing too many poorly encoded mp3's, and that hearing quality issues in well encoded mp3's is merely placebo effect.

That's not to say that you can't produce sounds to intentionally make audio compression sound poorly. Slow upwards frequency sweeps is one way to do this very well, but this type of special cases are very rarely (if ever) present in music.

Essentially, uncompressed audio, or lossless audio compression (like flac) is just a huge waste of disk space. Which is fine if that's really what you want to do...

Many people who swore up and down they could tell an mp3 from source material and that mp3's were unlistenable were very humbled that day.
I would agree that 256-320 kbps MP3 (encoded with LAME) is usually impossible to distinguish from lossless with most music.

However, that's simply no excuse for us as consumers to accept a regression in audio quality vs. what we were buying in the mid 1980s. Disk space is cheap these days. I have over 300 full albums in FLAC on my HD and it barely takes up 100 GB, or the equivalent of 2-3 Blu-Ray movies.

Here's the key point for me: if I want to transcode to a different format, I should be able to do so at will. For example, I transcode my whole library to 160 kbps AAC for my phone, and to V0 MP3 for my work computer. If I only had 320 kbps MP3 as originals of everything, I wouldn't be able to do this (without a big hit in transcoded quality, at least).

Lossy downloads like MP3/AAC have their place for consumers who just don't give a shit, but should be priced at a substantial discount from CDs: $6-7 per album, at most. You should feel dirty paying the $11.99 that Apple often wants for an album that you could walk into Wal Mart and buy the real thing for the same or cheaper.

Lossless, on the other hand, should also be a download option with all the major content distributors. Myself and many semi-audiophiles would be willing to pay closer to what the real CD costs, since we're getting the digital part of the real CD, unadulterated.

In reality, I'm quickly losing hope that this will ever happen, since the mass market already has accepted the regression in quality and transcode-ability at the same price point that CDs used to be. If anything, once CDs are out of production, I envision the record industry exploiting audiophiles by charging $18.99 for "SuperRes HD" tracks that are simply the 16/44 versions you used to get standard.
 
This is a pretty cool thing for them to do. Makes buying CDs from Amazon even more appealing really.

As for this mess about lossless formats, I primarily do it for archival purposes. I mean, I have the storage and figure, should I ever lose a CD for whatever reason (from damage to theft to stupidity on my own part) I have it on my drive good to go and can burn it to replace what was lost. But, for my own listening, and especially on portable devices, I just use MP3 because it's easiest to work with and neither my equipment nor environment are conducive to being able to pick out the difference between the lossless encode and the high quality MP3 encodes. I mean, I currently live in the city so background noise is frequent and muddles even the highest quality encodes. Perhaps if I have my dream house in the country that is quiet enough and that I have high enough quality equipment to discern the difference I'll care. But, until then lossy is good enough for most situations.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501809 said:
I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.


FLAC - however - is a tremendous waste of disk space.

You may think you can hear the difference between a raw source (or lossless compression) and a well encoded mp3, but the truth is you can't. It's all placebo effect.

There ARE certainly poorly encoded mp3's, (many of them predating modern good encoders, or encoded by people not knowing what they were doing) /QUOTE]

Storing FLAC means when you find out you encoded poorly, you don't have to re-rip all your cds again. (Although in my case, I found out I ripped poorly, so I was screwed anyway). You can also reencode at a different bitrate for other purposes without a second lossy transform.
 
Sweet! I'm buying my CDs from Amazon from now on.

(Yes, I still buy CDs. My car stereo, which is the only place I listen to music these days, only has a CD player, no MP3. I hope to upgrade someday, but my car is kind of low priority compared to my PC.)
 
Here's the key point for me: if I want to transcode to a different format, I should be able to do so at will. For example, I transcode my whole library to 160 kbps AAC for my phone, and to V0 MP3 for my work computer. If I only had 320 kbps MP3 as originals of everything, I wouldn't be able to do this (without a big hit in transcoded quality, at least).

That's a good point, and one I hadn't thought of.

I don't do a whole lot (any?) transcoding, but should the need arise, you are correct, that having to re-encode a lossy format would be problematic, and lead to significant quality degradation.

Lame's --alt-preset standard is deprecated these days in favor of the quality option. I typically encode with lame at a high quality (can't remember the number right now) but it usually (depending on file content) will wind up with a VBR bitrate average of about 190 - 210, which I have found acceptable for my needs (in other words, with my dedicated DAC, headphone amp and decent headphones, I can't tell the difference), and it has a small enough file size.

Fortunately VBR mp3's are universal enough these days, that I have had no need to reencode anything.

Vorbis would probably have been slightly better choice, but I chose mp3 due to the compatibility/portability concern.
 
Zarathustra[H];1039501809 said:
I agree that it is important to make sure the encodes are good. Some encodes out there are not.


FLAC - however - is a tremendous waste of disk space.

You may think you can hear the difference between a raw source (or lossless compression) and a well encoded mp3, but the truth is you can't. It's all placebo effect.

There ARE certainly poorly encoded mp3's, (many of them predating modern good encoders, or encoded by people not knowing what they were doing) but a well encoded mp3 is indistinguishable from source, even by audiophiles with expensive listening equipment.

Hydrogenaudio.org did a well publicized double blind study a few years back, in which they wrote a program that performed a A-B double blind test ad asked people to run it on their equipment. The program contained several samples across genres of music. One sample consisted of raw WAV data extracted directly off of the disc. The other contained the same WAV file, compressed to mp3 using LAME with "--alt-preset standard" settings which produces a high quality ~128kbit+ bitrate VBR file.

The program allowed subjects to listen to each sample as many times as they liked, and then select which one they thought was the mp3 and which one the original, before they moved on to the next sample.

Test subjects were encouraged to download the program and run it on their own equipment. Being hydrogenaudio.org, a lot of serious audiophiles with expensive equipment part took in the study.

The results? The "audiophiles" could only pick the right "compressed" sample approximately 50% of the time. In other words, no better than chance.

The conclusion of the study was that many were biased from hearing too many poorly encoded mp3's, and that hearing quality issues in well encoded mp3's is merely placebo effect.

That's not to say that you can't produce sounds to intentionally make audio compression sound poorly. Slow upwards frequency sweeps is one way to do this very well, but this type of special cases are very rarely (if ever) present in music.

Essentially, uncompressed audio, or lossless audio compression (like flac) is just a huge waste of disk space. Which is fine if that's really what you want to do...

Many people who swore up and down they could tell an mp3 from source material and that mp3's were unlistenable were very humbled that day.

Could you point me toward the programs, proper tools, and methods for a GOOD encode? In my experience - I can tell the difference with 100% accuracy between a CD and an MP3 on good stereo equipment. It intrigues me that a good encode can be just as good.

MP3s have been fine for my phone (music on the go) or streaming. But when it's time to turn the volume up and rock out - it's CDs all the way. Yes I still buy CDs for the quality. Yes, I'd like to move to FLAC or even better - an MP3 that sounds just as good.
 
Sweet! I'm buying my CDs from Amazon from now on.

(Yes, I still buy CDs. My car stereo, which is the only place I listen to music these days, only has a CD player, no MP3. I hope to upgrade someday, but my car is kind of low priority compared to my PC.)

If I were to buy music, I'd buy CD's.

Truth is though, I haven't bought any music at all since the late 90s.

It's not that I pirate my music or anything like that. I just haven't heard any new music in the last 15 years or so that I thought was interesting, so when I listen to music, I listen to my old stuff.

I guess that means I'm an old fart. I am COMPLETELY out of touch with current (or even 2000's) music.

Overheard some people I knew a few weeks ago talking about a Dell. Took me a little bit until I realized they weren't discussing a computer. :p Turns out there's some artist now named Adele.
 
Could you point me toward the programs, proper tools, and methods for a GOOD encode? In my experience - I can tell the difference with 100% accuracy between a CD and an MP3 on good stereo equipment. It intrigues me that a good encode can be just as good.

MP3s have been fine for my phone (music on the go) or streaming. But when it's time to turn the volume up and rock out - it's CDs all the way. Yes I still buy CDs for the quality. Yes, I'd like to move to FLAC or even better - an MP3 that sounds just as good.

100% accuracy? I'd like to see some blind testing to verify that claim. You're possibly Superman.
 
Could you point me toward the programs, proper tools, and methods for a GOOD encode? In my experience - I can tell the difference with 100% accuracy between a CD and an MP3 on good stereo equipment. It intrigues me that a good encode can be just as good.

MP3s have been fine for my phone (music on the go) or streaming. But when it's time to turn the volume up and rock out - it's CDs all the way. Yes I still buy CDs for the quality. Yes, I'd like to move to FLAC or even better - an MP3 that sounds just as good.

Well, it's actually been a while since I ripped anything (since - as I explained above, I don't buy music particularly frequently, and have completely alienated myself from modern music)

If I were to rip something today though, I would use Exact Audio Copy (windows) or cdparanoia (linux) for the rip to WAV.

Then I would manually encode using command line Lame.

I'd probably use -V2 -q0, to ensure good quality.


If you can ear a difference after doing this (on real music tracks, not some sine wave sweep intentionally intended to confuse the encoder), I would see if you can use some sort of programmed blind test to see if you really can tell the difference, or if your brain is just fooling you into thinking you can, by introducing bias.

Our brains are surprisingly biased things. They constantly alter our perception to mimick what we expect to experience, not what we actually do. No one is immune to this, which is why medical experiments use double blind studies.

For more info (including some software that can be used to set up an ABX test read this:
http://wiki.hydrogenaudio.org/index.php?title=ABX
 
Unless I want a one-off track, I always buy the CD if I'm buying an entire album.

I then rip it to a lossless format, and from there generate whatever MP3's I need for my devices with DBPowerAmp.

Then the CD goes in a storage locker never to be seen again unless I need to make new lossless masters.

I do the same thing except I use Exact Audio Copy to rip them.
 
Back
Top