AM2 cpu/mobo/memory clarification

e1guapo

n00b
2FA
Joined
Apr 10, 2007
Messages
9
Hey, all.

Looking for some clarity on a budget AM2 build primarily geared for graphics/photo/multimedia and some light gaming. Not really interested in OC'ing.

I've already read a number of the Budget Box Guides/threads at various sites (ArsTechnica, Tom's, Anandtech, here). I'm coming from a low-end s754 setup.

I've been debating between a few sub-$100 mobos. These nforce 550s:

- ABit KN9S (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16813127007)
- MSI K9N Neo-F (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16813130050)

And the only 570 Ultra really in my budget:

- Asus M2N-E (http://www.newegg.com/product/product.asp?item=N82E16813131022)

I didn't include the Biostar TForce 550 as I'm generally not a big fan of Biostar, and it's not really much cheaper (even with the 'egg combo deals). And the MSI K9N Platinum non-SLI (570 Ultra) doesn't seem to be available anymore.

I also recently came across this apparently older Asus M2V (VIA K8T890 chipset): http://www.directron.com/m2v.html#caption

How does the K8T890 compare with the nforce 500s?

Should I also be looking at the nforce 4 boards? I figured the 500s would be better as the newer chipset designed explicitly for the AM2 socket. Maybe I'm wrong.

Nevertheless, I was initially leaning towards one of the 550s, as that would allow me to spend a little more on the processor (like an X2 4600+). And at stock speeds there doesn't appear to be any differences betweeen the various nforce 500 series chipsets (at least according to this piece: http://www.tweaktown.com/articles/950/16/page_16_final_thoughts/index.html)

Reading up more on the differences, I'm not sure if the M2N-E (and 570 Ultra, in general) may ultimately be better for me, even though that would pretty much limit my CPU choices to the X2 3800+. I don't need the extra Ethernet port, and 4 SATAs should be enough, but the FirstPacket and TCP/IP Accel. sound intriguing as I do use VOIP and once in a while do some LAN gaming, in addition to multitasking. But I don't know how much of a benefit these techs. really would be in practical terms.

The main advantage seems to be that the 570s are compatible with FX CPUs, while the 550s don't appear to be (as specified here: http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2764&p=2 and elsewhere, though some of the nforce 4's say they are. Confusing.). If I wanted to upgrade in the near future, that would give me some more options (X2 or FX) as prices continue to drop and the newer AM2+ gear comes out.

So, the M2N-E would appear to be a decent compromise, but the memory voltage issue is something of a turn-off. With mostly higher latency RAM available at 1.95v and below, it seems to limit upgradeability in that respect, as the low latency, higher spec'd sticks are all higher voltages.

Is this still an issue with this board? Or has it been remedied in current versions?

Last question regarding memory and multipliers -- was reading about the fact that with CPUs with even multipliers, it seems to be better to go with DDR2-800, and for odd multipliers, DDR2-667 (http://tinyurl.com/yw9c3r -- Black Jacque's post in particular). With the new Brisbanes having half-step multipliers, how does this affect memory choice?

Is this only an issue for hardcore OC'ing? Is this really an issue at all?

Apologies for the length of this. Just trying to get a better grasp on my options. Been out of the mix for a couple years.
Thanks ahead of time.
 
Theres an M2N-E thread over at the AT forums. I suggest you check it out, to find out if those problems still exist with that board. If the 550 suits your needs, then don't bother with the 570u.

Interesting question on the half-step mulitpliers. So, with an odd CPU mulitplier and stock base FSB, this leaves the FSB:DRAM ratio as a half number...

[CPU model]: [cpu mulitplier] x [fsb] = [cpu clock speed]Mhz, [cpu clock speed] / [DDR2-800 clock speed] = FSB:DRAM ratio
3500+: 11 x 200 = 2200Mhz, 2200 / 400 = 5.5
whereas
3800+: 12 x 200 = 2400Mhz, 2400 / 400 = 6
but..
3600+: 9.5 x 200 = 1900Mhz, 1900 / 400 = 4.75

So... you could either bump the FSB a bit higher, or lower the CPU multiplier to get that FSB:DRAM ratio at a nice whole number. This would get you the desired DDR2-800 speed.

3500+: 10 x 200 = 2000Mhz, 2000 / 400 = 5
3500+: 11 x 218 = 2400Mhz, 2400 / 400 = 6
or
3600+: 9 x 222 = 2000Mhz, 2004 / 400 = 5
3600+: 9.5 x 211 = 2004Mhz, 2004 / 400 = 5

Another option would be some RAM thats overclockable (sticks that use Micron ICs; ramlist link).

If you'd rather not tweak with any settings, just run the ram at whatever the detected speed is, which is hopefully stable, lol.

Whats your budget? Have you considered an Intel build? I feel an AM2 platforum build would require more tweaking than an Intel build... from my own personal experience.
 
Thanks for the reply (& the nice breakdown of the half-step issue. I found some more discussion here).

I went through that AT thread quite a bit after my OP. Still seems like there are too many issues with the board. Also came across a couple reviews (like this one), confirming its limitations. It may be an Asus, but I'd rather not deal with it, plus the price just got bumped up to $100 + shipping on the 'egg.

After some more digging, the Gigabyte GA-M57SLI-S4 seems like a good option. I may not need SLI, but the additional options are always nice to have (and its got Firewire, yay!), and not much more than the M2N-E ($115 shipped at mwave, $110 at buy.com with GoogleCheckout discount). Good reviews, and it sounds like stability is a strong point (which I like to hear), though there are now three revisions of the board, with the third (v2.0 -- model name GA-M57SLI-DS4) due in May (I emailed them about it). They'd only verify the differences being the PCB, and the newest revision is to come with Vista drivers.

Coupled with a X2 3800+ Windsor (the Brisbanes are probably overkill for my purposes, even if I do do some minor tweaking. Nice for hardcore OC'ing, but from what I've been reading, actually perform a touch slower at comparable speeds), it should be good enough for the time being for an AM2 build, and fits in my sub-$200 goal for CPU/mobo.

The Windsor also has an even multiplier (a la, this nice li'l clock rate chart), so I can stick with DDR2-800 which has some great prices right now (and probably more future-proof).

I've been reading about the Micron D9, but I don't think I would come anywhere close to needing that kind of tweakability. As you mention, as long as I can get things running at DDR2-800, whatever I find that's reasonably priced & compatible should be good enough.

[my dirtcheap budget for cpu/mobo/ram is about $300-325:

~ sub-$200 for cpu/mobo -- and I'd rather spend more on a decent mobo than the CPU, at least that's what I've always understood, and it makes sense. But maybe I'm wrong and the cheaper nf550 board + X2 4600+ is the better way to go;
~ $125-135 or so for 2gb memory -- I could go 1gb and spend more on the cpu/mobo but I don't know if that's a good idea;

Case, drives, GPU, and PSU are mostly taken care of, though I might need to beef up my PSU (350w SmartPower) depending on what I get]

That brings me to the ever-popular C2D question. Considering my desire to keep CPU/mobo under $200, that limits me right now. But I see on the 'egg they're selling E4300s for $150 (and $225 for a combo deal with an Abit IL9 Pro -- don't know if that's a good mobo, and it's an older chipset, I believe). And Fry's been having E4300+ECS mobo combos going for $129 at their B+M stores, $180 for an E6300+ECS (according to this AT thread)! If that's a sign of things to come then I may have to reconsider.

Either way, with the supposed April 22 Intel price drops, it's probably worth waiting. I'll be keeping the Gigabyte 570SLI + X2 3800 (or MSI/ABIT 550 + X2 4600 alternative) in mind as my AM2 choices, but if I can get an E4300 and decent board in the same price range, that'll be hard to pass up. It will still probably be more of a stretch with projected prices on the E4300 being about $115, and AM2 prices will probably continue to fall as a result.

What do you recommend for a good, affordable C2D board that's comparable in functionality to the AM2 Gigabyte? The 650is look decent (like this MSI one. I don't see any non-SLI 650is available yet), or maybe I should just go with a cheaper P965 board, though the lack of native IDE connections is troubling as one of my HDDs and my DVD burner are IDE.
 
The 650i Ultras aren't out yet. Theres a huge thread on the MSI board in the mobo subforum: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1164174

If you want a P965 Express board, I'd recommend the DS3. You could always get a PCI IDE controller card if you have some IDE devices you'd like to keep. One of my friends just moved his IDE HDD to an external enclosure instead of keeping it in the system. Its now his backup drive.
 
Thanks for the suggestions (and putting up with my blather. Been good just to get things down on virtual paper). That thread looks great.

One other question. I may add a new boot/system drive. Besides the Raptors, should I be looking at something with a 16mb cache? How much difference does it make over the standard 8mbs, especially as I'll be moving/processing some large image/media files?

People have mentioned video encoding, which I don't do much of; anything else it would benefit?
 
Yah, get something with a 16MB cache, like the 7200.10 320GB Seagate or WD5000AAKS. I don't think it makes much difference outside of video encoding, but it doesn't hurt (not much of a price premium over 8mb drives). I'd look more into the drives performance. Check out the performance database over at storagereview.com. From my personal experience, the Seagate 7200.10 320GB drives are rather fast (65MB/s) compared to my Raptor (78MB/s). My 250GB WD SE16 (WD2500KS) drive isn't as fast (52MB/s), though.
 
Back
Top