Aluminum and copper in the same loop...

No, everyone would be pounding their chest how great Swiftech product is and without this 1/2" high flow system it wouldn't be possible....... That is what is funny about this conversation (Victors overclock).

Some might, I admit. There are fools everywhere.
 
No, everyone would be pounding their chest how great Swiftech product is and without this 1/2" high flow system it wouldn't be possible....... That is what is funny about this conversation (Victors overclock).

Gee, I always thought WC'ing was mostly for the "quiet" factor over air-cooling. I *believe* that has been discussed in many posts over the years.

It was my impressiom that the serious OC'ers used peltiers, LN2 and other exotic methods to achieve their insane OC's. So wouldn't it make sense that anyone who would say that "great OC 'cause of the WC setup" looses credibility almost instantly?

Perhaps this should be made into a new thread: Why WC? Maybe have a poll? Perhaps RC/TN/Ranker can be the designated co-OP's.:p
 
No, everyone would be pounding their chest how great Swiftech product is and without this 1/2" high flow system it wouldn't be possible....... That is what is funny about this conversation (Victors overclock).

Not really, because it's sort of expected from a company that focuses on high performance setups.

But take your shots as you may.
 
Gee, I always thought WC'ing was mostly for the "quiet" factor over air-cooling. I *believe* that has been discussed in many posts over the years.

It was my impressiom that the serious OC'ers used peltiers, LN2 and other exotic methods to achieve their insane OC's. So wouldn't it make sense that anyone who would say that "great OC 'cause of the WC setup" looses credibility almost instantly?

Perhaps this should be made into a new thread: Why WC? Maybe have a poll? Perhaps RC/TN/Ranker can be the designated co-OP's.:p

Water is the best method for mainstream enthusiasts to get great OC's for 24/7 use. LN2 can only be used for benching and is not sustainable. Phase won't gain mainstream appeal until the prices come down and until they get more user friendly. All alternative options for great OC's require making ones motherboard condensation proof which is a pain in the ass, makes the board look horrible and voids the warranty for most motherboard makers.

If you want to bench like a champ, water is not that way to go. If you want 24/7 sustainable OC's, water is the most affordable and has the most penetration.
 
I have constantly been trying to argue with R1ck and TopNurse that overclocking is NOT a good measure of cooling performance. Overclocking is a measure of the hardware and cooling melded into one. Because there is the hardware component however, you simply can't measure anything about the cooling accurately. Therefore the only logical measure of cooling performance is temperature. They still like to be deluded that overclocking is the only way to measure cooling.
 
You just don't get it do you? What we have said time and time again is that "cooling performance" is just a lark for the rest of us joes. What's important is the ability to use your computer.

I have by your standards a shitty cooling solution (compared to the Swiftech, DD, etc.) that doesn't work well. On the other hand my cooling solution allows me to run my AMD 3500+ (stock 2.2 Ghz) at 2.75 Ghz and juice the CPU to the voltage limits of the motherboard. By doing so I create a lot of heat that is effectively taken care of by my shitty cooling solution. It also has aluminum in it to boot that hasn't produced the big bugaboo called corrosion because I use an intelligent solution to prevent it.

So what could possibly motivate someone to build a water cooling solution that cools better when the cooling doesn't do anything better for what your doing?
 
No one can tell you that, it will depend on the quality of construction, size, airflow etc etc. If you had a high quality copper and high quality alum rad with the same physical dimensions and mounting (shroud, fan clearance etc.) and the same fans there would probally not be more than a 3C difference if even that.

Considering your ambient conditions, those are pretty decent temps !

Frankly I would suggest a small window air conditioner installed tightly and good dark curtains or dark shade to keep the sun out. I have seen people even glue styrofoam to the crappy pull out panels that make the AC fit in the window and duct tape does wonders for cracks air might get in. Might as well make yourself comfortable and the machine too.

Thanks for the reply. I would like to put a small air conditioner in the window but the Apt. complex will not allow it, so I am stuck with the fans. I can all so raise the fan speed on the EXOS. When I took the temp reading it was set on 6 out of 10, but then the fans get pretty loud.
 
You just don't get it do you? What we have said time and time again is that "cooling performance" is just a lark for the rest of us joes. What's important is the ability to use your computer.

Why invest in watercooling altogether then? High performance air lags behind by about only 20-30% in terms of temps. If your focus is to just use your computer, then stick with stock. If you insist on water cooling then why not just buy the cheapest kit possible. Why even pay for either high performance parts like Swiftech/Thermochill/D-Tek/EK or even expensive bling parts like AC?

I have by your standards a shitty cooling solution (compared to the Swiftech, DD, etc.) that doesn't work well. On the other hand my cooling solution allows me to run my AMD 3500+ (stock 2.2 Ghz) at 2.75 Ghz and juice the CPU to the voltage limits of the motherboard. By doing so I create a lot of heat that is effectively taken care of by my shitty cooling solution. It also has aluminum in it to boot that hasn't produced the big bugaboo called corrosion because I use an intelligent solution to prevent it.

Actually, I wouldn't call AC shitty. I consider them to be mediocre. Their cooling performance isn't top notch and their prices are higher than their competitors. However, I haven't ruled out using AC myself. If their new Cuplex block can actually perform as well as a GTX/Fuzion at the same price point, I'll be singing its praises, especially if it does not contain aluminum and offers a delrin top replacement.

So what could possibly motivate someone to build a water cooling solution that cools better when the cooling doesn't do anything better for what your doing?
Because the better the cooling performance, the more you are prepared to achieve better overclocks.

Chips themselves are half of the equation in overclocking. I have two e6600 chips at home (also a Q6600 and an e67000. One of my e6600's can hit 3.2 on stock voltages. The other can't even break the 3.0 barrier on stock voltages. Obviously, the chip itself is going to dictate a respectable part of how much you can overclock.

Now, my ceiling for a 24/7 overclock is going to be 60C load. I migrate my components often within my systems at home (I have 4 watercooled comps at home alone). I recently moved the better of my e6600 to another computer with a subpar loop (my graveyard for old WC'ing components I no longer use in my high performance setups). There is a significant difference in cooling capabilities between the loops of my home office high performance machine and the loop in an older machine consisting of a G5/D4 pump/etc. With the exact same chip, I can hit 3.7Ghz on one machine and still stay under 60c load, while my other can only hit 3.4 Ghz and stay under 60c load.

Obviously, how low one's loop performs can keep down temps affects one's overclocking. The better your loop is (in terms of keeping temps as low as possible) the better one is PREPARED to achieve/sustain good overclocks.

Since one must remove the chip itself from the equation due to the variances in capabilities of a chip, the only thing that can be measure when comparing water cooling components is temperature.
 
The only thing I found in post 146 is this:

Really...because there is one of your fellow low flow fellows taking something out of context. Something you specifically said you didn't want being done.... Pot. Kettle. Black.
 
Really...because there is one of your fellow low flow fellows taking something out of context. Something you specifically said you didn't want being done.... Pot. Kettle. Black.

Well then how about telling us what was done because like I said it only said "The defense rests."
 
Well then how about telling us what was done because like I said it only said "The defense rests."

Don't worry about it..... These guys will constantly flip back and forth on what "performance" means. For years I have asked this forum to define performance and it goes un-answered.

To make it worse, their world has crumbled in light of knowing the TRUE impact on using smaller tubing. Hell I see peoples signature files change based on a comment on forums these days. :eek:
 
Don't worry about it..... These guys will constantly flip back and forth on what "performance" means. For years I have asked this forum to define performance and it goes un-answered.

To make it worse, their world has crumbled in light of knowing the TRUE impact on using smaller tubing. Hell I see peoples signature files change based on a comment on forums these days. :eek:



and what is the TRUE impact of using smaller tubing other than a temp gain of a few degrees...
 
and what is the TRUE impact of using smaller tubing other than a temp gain of a few degrees...


ahhh.... try .7 from 1/4" to 1/2"

Since the "myth" was it was anywhere from 2-5c and impacts "performance" I would say this is earth shattering to some; just not the ones who actually have been doing it.

Bare in mind if you don't have the right pump and radiator all bets are off.
 
Back
Top