AGP upgrade or new MB?

xavierq

Gawd
Joined
Jul 27, 2000
Messages
562
I'm current running with an Radeon 9600 Pro. It's met my needs for quite some time, but it's starting to be slow now, so I'm considering replacing it. Problem is I'm still on an AGP form factor. Is there anything decent in the 150ish range to replace it with, or do I really need to upgrade to something PCIX? I'm using the Abit IC7-Max3 right now, and I don't wanna replace it unless I'm gonna see a huge increase in performance.
 
The performance increase you see is in direct proportion to the amount of money you are willing to spend on the video card.
 
chances are all your other parts are older too. You need to list out your whole machine... but most likely there are other factors here that are limiting your gaming ability.
 
Yes, but I know that even if I'd drop a grand on a PCI card it still couldn't compete anymore. Has AGP reached that point, or do I still have a realistic upgrade path without going PCIX?

Also, if it's more cost effective to upgrade the MB and get a less expensive PCIX than get a higher end AGP just to dodge a bottleneck...
 
What are the specs of your machine.
What do you play currently and what do you want to play in the near future?
How much $ do you have budgeted for this endeavor?
Agp is dead, but there are many agp systems that are good enough for an upgrade.
If your cpu is 3.2 or faster and you have 1 gig (preferably 2gig) of ram you may want to get a $300 agp card.
If you got the money for a motherboard, ram, psu, video card, and cpu you should go for a c2d upgrade...
But as always $ is a factor...
A decent c2d upgrade will cost at least $600 for the lower end...
You are at the same point as many, max out your aging system to suck that last bit of life out of it for $300-400 or move on to the next generation for $600-1200...
 
A 7600 GS or X1650 PRO is about the best you are going to do for ~$150 in an AGP card.

For ~$150 on PCI-Express, you are looking at a 7900 GS or an X1950 PRO. Yes, they are dramatically faster than the 7600 GS and X1650 PRO.
 
P4 3.0 with HT. 512MB of what I think is cas2 dual channel DDR400.

A x1950 pro and 2 gigs of ram will max that machine out and will play newer titles quite well.
Your cpu isn't much of a bottleneck as of now but will become more so over the next year...
 
A 7600 GS or X1650 PRO is about the best you are going to do for ~$150 in an AGP card.

For ~$150 on PCI-Express, you are looking at a 7900 GS or an X1950 PRO. Yes, they are dramatically faster than the 7600 GS and X1650 PRO.

The 7600GTs were running less than $150 after rebates on newegg last week, if you're willing to deal with that sort of thing. This will be significantly faster than the GS
 
Can't seem to find a GT for under $150.00 right now.. stupid rebates:mad:

Spend an extra $25.00 and go with something like this..

And you might want to add another 512mb ram... couldn't hurt.
 
sometimes you can get the 7800GS OC for under 150 you just have to look out for it. i just picked one up a couple of weeks ago for 140 after rebate
 
well after reading this thread, and having gone through this exact same process one year ago, I would tell you the easiest way to get a solid return would be to get this card,

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814143045

You would need to spend about 5 times that to set up a solid gaming rig. I could help you spec something out if you wish.

The other issue is, does it make sense to spend the better part of $200 on a card that you wont be able to use on any other computer other than the one you are running right now.
I would suggest that you upgrade the mobo, cpu, ram and video card. Here are some links for you to consider;

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814130056

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16820227117

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16813130059

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16819115005

and in case your current psu wont cut it grab one of these,

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16817103512

goodluck!
 
I'm pretty sure the 7600 GS would be better than the 6800 GS. And you can get a 7600 GS for $113.
 
the 7600 gs wouldnt be better than the 6800 gs due to the fact that the 6800 is 256 mg achitecture and the 7600 is only 128mg.
 
Providing you've got some stuff you could re-use:
ASUS P5N32-E Plus SLI
2 GB DDR2 RAM
Core2Duo e6600
Nvidia 8800 gtx/gts depending on how much money you have
PC P&C Silencer 750W PSU

nice gaming rig, if you have the time and money.....

I have been searching for an AGP card for a shuttle G5 and truely, there just arent many choices for a SFF in AGP......so I feel your pain.
If you are set on AGP then I'd look long and hard at an ATI X1950Pro......good prices now for a really fine card and available in AGP.
 
the 7600 gs wouldnt be better than the 6800 gs due to the fact that the 6800 is 256 mg achitecture and the 7600 is only 128mg.

huh? what does the weight of it have to do with anything? Anyways, the 7600 is faster then the 6800.
 
as far as I know the 6800 which is a true 256 will process 256mg at a time while the 7600 will do it at 128mgs. Maybe someone can confirm this? The 7600 gt says its 256mg but on a 128 bit achitecture.
 
A x1950 pro and 2 gigs of ram will max that machine out and will play newer titles quite well.
Your cpu isn't much of a bottleneck as of now but will become more so over the next year...

I agree

I have P4 2.6C @ 3.25 with x1950 and I can run every game in max silk smooth.

If you have a decent CPU and the CPU usage history never hits 100% during games, get a x1950 Pro.

I have x1950 Pro AGP and I am very happy!

Worth every penny!
 
buy my albatron s478 PCI-E 16x mobo for 150$, ran my p4 3.0E @ 3.3 with a 7800GT great, i should of just bought a 8800GTS for it instead of going dual-core :p
 
as far as I know the 6800 which is a true 256 will process 256mg at a time while the 7600 will do it at 128mgs. Maybe someone can confirm this? The 7600 gt says its 256mg but on a 128 bit achitecture.

The memory bus width has nothing to do with capacity. The bus width defines how much data can be written to and/or read from the memory in a single request. Memory with 256-bit width can read and/or write 32 bytes at a time. Memory with a 128-bit bus can read and/or write 16 bytes at a time. Bus width and memory speed taken together will define how fast the memory is. This bit about processing 256 MB vs 128 MB at a time....I have no idea where you are getting that.
 
I have a P4 3ghz HT as well and 1GB PC3200, my HIS x1950pro 512mb is arriving tomorrow. I would say that you need to have at least 1GB RAM in your system and 512mb on your card. Won't be too long until you might want to consider 2GB but ATM 1GB sys and 512mb on board should be sufficient. People that spent a ton of money to upgrade will tell you upgrade from a technical standpoint, not a economical standpoint, plus for your specs the overhaul strategy is not necessitated ATM.

Most games have not been programmed to utilize Dual Core or even SLI, not saying there aren't any, just limited amount when compared to the whole. Might as well wait until these technologies are utilized and by then quad-core will probably be out and dual core will be cheaper. Plus if you on XP you don't need to worry about your RAM costs too much, Vista is a hog and wants 2GB, maybe more for gaming, not to mention Vista drivers suck right now and there are no games available for it, so why get it? IMHO, you will need to spend $1200 or more to get a system that justifies the upgrade, relative to the x1950pro solution. If are rich and you love constant 60+ fps then you better do the overhaul, other wise, opt for the RAM and x1950pro upgrade. Or if you love resolutions 1600x1200 or above and all the eye candy on (AF,AA) then you might want to consider the overhaul as well.

You may also want to consider upgrading to a THermaltake power booster since that damn card wants 30a on the 12v rail (although this is a little overstated) and at least a 450watt power suppy (which is also slightly overstated)

Here are some links,

http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=371322 -- PSU $50 shipped

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814161069 -- GPU $269 after rebate

The x1950pro can be had for around $200 with other brands but be warned this puppy runs hot so I recommend the HIS 512 version for cooling and performance reasons (overclocked turbo edition and 256mb is crippling on this card at this point). Hope this helps, and know that the cheaper solution won't be awesome with the likes of Crysis, but I for one don't want to spend the extra $800 or more (trying to be realistic, I know it can be done for less but do you want that system?) just to play one freaking game that I can always play retroactively once I do a system overhaul. Also, PCI-E has no real advantage over AGP at this point which is finally starting to reach it's peak limitations. Linky: http://www6.tomshardware.com/2007/02/01/agp-platform-analysis/page11.html
If you play around in Tom's Hardware you will seen that the same PCI-E version has extremely marginal advantages 1-9FPS and in some cases it's actually worse than the AGP card. Whatever you do, good luck.

Edit: Heck if you want I'll let you know how if performs, I'm upgrading from a x800xtpe and I will be benching it in FutureMark (where I primarily post) 05' and 06' and I will be playing GRAW for awhile too.

Edit: Just remembered that Supreme Commander is bringing CPU's to their knees so if that's a game that your into, take that into consideration.
 
Back
Top