Advice on second hard drive for HTPC/Server

Leo123

n00b
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
57
Hi there,

I currently have an HTPC in my living room with the current specs -

Athlon II X2 240e
M4A785TD-M Evo
NSK2480 Case with PSU
4GB TW3X4G1333 C9A Corsair Ram (2x2GB)
1.5TB WD Green (AV-GP version)
Windows 7
Hauppage HVR-220 twin freeview tuner card
Nova S2 freesat card
Pioneer DVD

I also have on my network, a laptop, an acer revo aspire in the bedroom and a regular pc in my study.

I was originally worried about picking an eco-drive (5,400 rpm) that was said to be capable of recording three channels and also streaming recorded video in the living room and the revo in the bedroom all at the time, but the WD handles it all just fine.

The reason I went for the more expensive AV-GP version of the hard drive was because it was said that thaty are better (and specifically designed) at writing multiple streams.

My problem is that I want to consider using the my HTPC also as a server/NAS, and decided that the best thing to do would be to add a second hard drive (preferably2TB). I would then use the 1.5TB hard drive just for recording and streaming videos that I was not planning on keeping and then use the new hard drive for storing all recorded files that I want to keep, plus all my music, photos, camcorder footage etc.

My first question is can anyone suggest why this is a bad thing to do (for example combining an HTPC with a NAS/Server).

Secondly, if I should go ahead with this, which hard drive should I use? To keep noise down, I reckon either the Samsung 2TB or WD 2TB - they both have similar reviews so just go with the cheqpest - OR should I spend a bit more and get the AV-GP version of the WD 2TB that has come out (my thinking being that I probably won't need this as I am going to be doing all my recording on the other hard drive and only streaming from this new hard drive).

Sorry for the long question, your views would be much appreciated.

A
 
Hi there.

Thanks for the reply.

Going by that other thread, would you think it would be a better idea to put the second hard drive in an esata hard drive enclosure or a nas instead and just turning that on whenever I need my saved media?
 
I say NAS since then you can share the data with other PCs in the home.
 
Sorry to come back to this after a big delay - can I not share the date from the second hard drive by putting it in my HTPC? What are the benefits of putting it in a NAS instead?
 
Sorry to come back to this after a big delay - can I not share the date from the second hard drive by putting it in my HTPC? What are the benefits of putting it in a NAS instead?

Hmm, well you do have relatively low storage requirements. So yes you can share the data from the 2nd hard drive. The main advantage of keeping your data on a NAS is the following:
- You can easily expand the storage without interrupting your HTPC.
- You can lower the heat generation in the HTPC
- You can take down the HTPC for repair or what have you without it affecting every other PC that still needs to access the data.
- There are a few occasions where streaming videos or serving files to other PCs will affect playback of video on the HTPC itself (Jerkiness, slow-down, skipped frames, frozen frames, etc, etc)
- You can actually use an OS more suitable for NAS/file serving duty like Windows Home Server, FreeNAS, FreeBSD with ZFS, Linux with MDADM RAID, etc, etc. That means that your data is safer

Note that 9 people in the thread I linked to said that comibing the NAS and HTPC was a bad idea. Only one person said it was a good idea and that was due to him having a relatively small amount of data.
 
Back
Top