ActiveVideo Seeks Injunction to Stop FIOS

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
It hasn’t been a really good week for Verizon. After suffering through a crippling strike from 45K union workers, Verizon lost a settlement battle for $115 million with ActiveVideo for patent infringement. To add insult to injury, ActiveVideo will be seeking an injunction which will basically shut down FIOS. Some weeks you just can’t catch a break.

Verizon has an enormous incentive to try and fight the injunction, as FiOS now accounts for 57 percent of Verizon's consumer revenue, which totaled $3.4 billion.
 
I love my FiOS service.... I'd be fucking pissed if I woke up one morning and had no service because of this.....
 
If the patents were just for the VOD service, then fine (well, not really), but shutting down the entire thing is ludicrous and well beyond the scope of this.
 
I love my FiOS service.... I'd be fucking pissed if I woke up one morning and had no service because of this.....

They just want more money, I would bet the shirt on my back that there will be no service interruptions, and if there are you can just call up dish or direct tv since this is all about video on demand and not internet.
 
If the patents were just for the VOD service, then fine (well, not really), but shutting down the entire thing is ludicrous and well beyond the scope of this.

Indeed. I hope Verizon beats this, and finds something to destroy Active Video, another money grubbing company that ... no one has probably heard of.
 
Another example of why patent law needs reform in this country... Hell IP law in general needs massive reform.
 
I swear some of you people... a company rightfully has a patent to a particular service, seriously Google them these are not patent trolls who simply buy up patents to sue and just because "you've never heard of them" does not give some big fucking company the right Verizon from stealing their technology (whether they had knowledge of what they were doing has yet to be seen).

This is not an example of why patent law need reform, this is David vs Goliath .. Just because it might affect you, you think this is all bullshit.

I swear when Tivo sued DirecTV (and DIsh) for stealing their DVR patent technology, I was a bit pissed I had to pay more to record stuff, but shit happens, I'm not blinding backing "my company" just because it is an inconvenient to me.
 
FIOS is pretty much the best in the US. They're asses if they push for this.
 
Fios is only the best if you're among the chosen few who live in an area Verizon deems profitable enough to service. I've waited years for it,and I'm not out in the sticks. I just dropped their so called high speed DSL after years of problems and speeds not much better than dial-up. If this company can stick it to the lying thieves,more power to them!
 
These are the 4 patents in question.

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-...5,550,578.PN.&OS=PN/5,550,578&RS=PN/5,550,578

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-...6,034,678.PN.&OS=PN/6,034,678&RS=PN/6,034,678

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-...6,100,883.PN.&OS=PN/6,100,883&RS=PN/6,100,883

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-...6,100,883.PN.&OS=PN/6,100,883&RS=PN/6,100,883

They are all pretty much the same, some are pretty detailed but include a lot of vague terms that I have seen in many of these tech patents. Use of works like "server", "client", "controller" which all technically can fit many types of software. I suppose that is why we have courts, don't know if those terms are actually a factor in patent law or just descriptive...

I guess the question is at what point is an idea actually patentable? The thought of on-demand cable came way before 1992-94 when these patents were created. This could be oversimplifying the case.

Now I am nowhere close to being a cable or patent expert... Some of these sound vague but I just don't know if there is some phrase or technology which makes this truely unique.

Patents are a tough thing... You want to protect ideas, but at what level of detail should an idea be protected. "Interactive data over cable"? Aka virtually anything "interactive" or some detailed method of providing that "interactive data".

Example RAID 5 Which do you think should be patentable? I am sure there are actual patents that cover probably all these examples... Bear with me descriptions are simplified just to make a point.

Patent 1: System/Method of storing data that uses multiple disks to provide data redundancy and prevent loss in case of hard drive failure.

Patent 2 : System.Method of breaking up data, spreading chunks equally, along with recovery data along multiple drives in equal sizes to provide data redundancy and prevent loss in case of hard drive failure. Recovery data calculation provided by (patent 12345).


imho Patent 2 is obviously a better example, enough to protect the idea that was made but yet does not lock down all the OTHER ways to provide data redundancy.
 
It still protecting a "thought". There are 6 billion people on this planet. The same thought process that leads one person to "think" of an idea will undoubtedly occur in another person at some point in time. Are we encouraging the idea of though crimes?

Just because these patents deal with technology that is outside many of our understandings doesn't mean that its fundamentaly different then anything else. Why not patent a chicken sandwhich, or drinking glass or clapping your hands? Patent the recipe that you use for cooking the chicken. Patent the composition of the glass that you develop. Patent the gloves that you make that amplifies the sound of clapping your hands.

Protecting tangible items that function I am more onboard with. Protecting thoughts that anybody given similar experience could come up with I am not so confident in.
 
I guess the question is at what point is an idea actually patentable? The thought of on-demand cable came way before 1992-94 when these patents were created. This could be oversimplifying the case.
I'm sure Verizon would have gone right after that if it was in fact an out, I'm sure they're spending a few bucks on a patent attorney or two.

Protecting tangible items that function I am more onboard with. Protecting thoughts that anybody given similar experience could come up with I am not so confident in.

According to the USPTO
"invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent,"

So its not just about a thought, it's a useful process... don't think it's terribly unique? Then improve on it, and get your own patent on the improved version. I don't believe for one damn second that Verizon came up with the same idea, unless you count going "oh hey look how that's done, lets do it"
 
I swear some of you people... a company rightfully has a patent to a particular service, seriously Google them these are not patent trolls who simply buy up patents to sue and just because "you've never heard of them" does not give some big fucking company the right Verizon from stealing their technology (whether they had knowledge of what they were doing has yet to be seen).

This is not an example of why patent law need reform, this is David vs Goliath .. Just because it might affect you, you think this is all bullshit.
Posters on the East Coast might be more aware of CableVision than ActiveVideo. CableVision is ActiveVideo's customer.
 
So its not just about a thought, it's a useful process... don't think it's terribly unique? Then improve on it, and get your own patent on the improved version. I don't believe for one damn second that Verizon came up with the same idea, unless you count going "oh hey look how that's done, lets do it"


--- This should be easy for all patent troll companies. Executing the idea should be example enough to improve on the idea which was done as a proof of concept on paper.
 
So its not just about a thought, it's a useful process... don't think it's terribly unique? Then improve on it, and get your own patent on the improved version. I don't believe for one damn second that Verizon came up with the same idea, unless you count going "oh hey look how that's done, lets do it"


--- This should be easy for all patent troll companies. Executing the idea should be example enough to improve on the idea which was done as a proof of concept on paper.

Uh, no. Change the damn law so a "process" cannot be patented. Its that simple.
 
This is not an example of why patent law need reform, this is David vs Goliath .. Just because it might affect you, you think this is all bullshit.

I swear when Tivo sued DirecTV (and DIsh) for stealing their DVR patent technology, I was a bit pissed I had to pay more to record stuff, but shit happens, I'm not blinding backing "my company" just because it is an inconvenient to me.

The patent isn't the Fios Service itself, it's other things that is part of the fios, and you know what? They seem vague as hell. That is why it needs to be reformed.
 
So its not just about a thought, it's a useful process... don't think it's terribly unique? Then improve on it, and get your own patent on the improved version. I don't believe for one damn second that Verizon came up with the same idea, unless you count going "oh hey look how that's done, lets do it"

--- This should be easy for all patent troll companies. Executing the idea should be example enough to improve on the idea which was done as a proof of concept on paper.

Umm, not to sound snitty here, but you realize that this company in question already licenses this technology (i.e. they fucking use it), and Verizon simply decided to use it without any compensation.

This isn't the case of a patent troll who simply buys up patents for the sake of buying them up until someone uses them then goes after them. They came up with it, they made it work, they found others who could benefit from using it and sold it to them.
 
"as FiOS now accounts for 57 percent of Verizon's consumer revenue, which totaled $3.4 billion."

Then why he hell did they sell it to Frontier up here in the northwest? Frontier sucks giant redneck retard balls. The first thing they did is jack TV rates $30 a month.

Fucking hate Verizon for selling and hate Frontier for being some anachronism from the 1980s.
 
Forgot to add: after RTFA this is just another cable vs/ cable litigate, not innovate tit for tat legal exchange. I mean, all these crap STBs just run some fucked up version of Genstar abortionware.

All I need in Hulu/Netflix on my xbox and my two Ceton tuners in the PC. Fuck PPV and onDemand.
 
Umm, not to sound snitty here, but you realize that this company in question already licenses this technology (i.e. they fucking use it), and Verizon simply decided to use it without any compensation.

This isn't the case of a patent troll who simply buys up patents for the sake of buying them up until someone uses them then goes after them. They came up with it, they made it work, they found others who could benefit from using it and sold it to them.

Isn't it still a troll? It's just a troll that got the goat instead of the troll that got gored by the Billy Goat Gruff (granted the ability to license a generic thing).
 
Back
Top