ACLU Fights N.C. Quest for Amazon Customer Data

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The American Civil Liberties Union, on behalf of seven Amazon customers, is fighting a request by the North Carolina Department of Revenue for personally identifiable information from Amazon. The ACLU believes the request is unconstitutional and violates the consumers right to privacy.

The ACLU, on behalf of seven Amazon customers, has intervened in a lawsuit that Amazon filed in April over an information request from the North Carolina Department of Revenue (NCDOR) for all the purchase records of customers with a North Carolina shipping address since August 2003, as part of a tax audit.
 
See, the ACLU IS good for something.

95% of the stuff they're involved with I disagree with, LOL. But there's stuff like this that I agree with.


Is it legal for NC to audit any other company that does business in NC? If it is, Amazon probably doesn't have a prayer. If they can't, then Amazon shouldn't be any different.
 
This is the first time I applaud the ACLU.

Yeah I am torn. On the one hand the ACLU has lost it's way (such as their involvement in the illegal immigration fiasco, think that they forget that the A in their name stands for American) on the other if the courts make Amazon give up the info we are all fucked.
 
Meh, this stuff is commonplace already. The cell companies and many other web portals have specific law enforecement access built into them so they can grab information as they need it.
 
Meh, this stuff is commonplace already. The cell companies and many other web portals have specific law enforecement access built into them so they can grab information as they need it.

Naw, this is different. This has little to do with traditional law enforcement its about tax collection (which technically is law enforcement but not of the kind that most people think of when the phrase law enforcement is used) and telling state government what you're buying with your money without the need for a warrant.
 
Go ACLU! Fight the good fight to allow people to illegally dodge taxes!

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love buying out of state and paying no sales taxes on products, however the sad fact (yeah it is sad) is that if you live in one of those tax happy states you are supposed to report those purchases and essentially pay taxes on them. Whether or not you agree with that law, that is the law. I'm really surprised judges haven't ruled on this already.
 
Go ACLU! Fight the good fight to allow people to illegally dodge taxes!

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love buying out of state and paying no sales taxes on products, however the sad fact (yeah it is sad) is that if you live in one of those tax happy states you are supposed to report those purchases and essentially pay taxes on them. Whether or not you agree with that law, that is the law. I'm really surprised judges haven't ruled on this already.

You are correct, that said now the state has to have access to ALL of your purchases to enforce this?

I would rather just have the eTailer charge me the tax than to have the state reviewing everything I buy.
 
Go ACLU! Fight the good fight to allow people to illegally dodge taxes!

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love buying out of state and paying no sales taxes on products, however the sad fact (yeah it is sad) is that if you live in one of those tax happy states you are supposed to report those purchases and essentially pay taxes on them. Whether or not you agree with that law, that is the law. I'm really surprised judges haven't ruled on this already.

So problem = people dodging taxes.

Many ways to deal with this, govt going through people's purchases fishing for tax dodgers is obviously a more retarded way of going about it.
 
Many states with a use tax ask you to voluntarily report it. Voluntary is voluntary, and as long as it remains voluntary, most people won't pay it. That's not dodging anything, that's just not being an idiot and throwing your money away. If it's mandatory that's a different matter, but that still does not give the government the right to bully corporations into handing over confidential data just because the citizenry is not doing what the government wants. Tax revenue agencies are the only ones that seem able to operate from a presumption of guilt. That concept ruffles my feathers in a bad way.

For once I have to agree with the ACLU. I normally hate that organization, but once in a very get it right. I hope they win this one.
 
Voluntary is voluntary? Filing your taxes is voluntary too, I mean they can't force you to do so? You might end up in jail but whateva.
 
Many tax systems would fix this. I'm not sure what is so special about a flat tax. Often the idea is sold along with doing away with tax credits / deductions / blah blah balh, all that bs. You could have a progressive tax without any of those either, not sure what is so special about a flat tax. Regardless, at this point any kind of tax reform would be better than nothing as it would be pretty damn difficult to make us worse off than we are now.
 
Many tax systems would fix this. I'm not sure what is so special about a flat tax. Often the idea is sold along with doing away with tax credits / deductions / blah blah balh, all that bs. You could have a progressive tax without any of those either, not sure what is so special about a flat tax. Regardless, at this point any kind of tax reform would be better than nothing as it would be pretty damn difficult to make us worse off than we are now.

The flat tax is only paid when you buy something. No income tax period! Then as people consume more they would pay more in taxes. The way it is now the moochers consume more than the producers pay into the system. The only things not taxed would be cloths and food.
 
Actually I meant a flat tax on everything.

Russia was in our position in the early 2000's... Debt up to their eyeballs and no way out. Their income taxes and everything was like ours (insane). Middle class paying upwards of 40% income taxes, your poor paying 12%.
Guess what they did? Flat tax of 13% on sales and incomes. This meant for most of the country, more money in everyone's pockets. It also meant Russia had a budget SURPLUS that year.
You can speculate as to why, but getting rid of stupid tax benefits and loopholes is the reason why.

But, that makes too much sense. Tried and true methods don't seem to be of interest to the US. I'd also venture to guess that something along the lines of 10% might work here just as well as Russia's 13%. I'd gladly pay 10% on purchases when my income taxes go down to 10% as well. It's net savings for everyone.
 
I see this as an illegal witch hunt by NC. Its also an attempt at an illegal search and seizure. You can't just demand some business give you all their customer data... especially when federal law states they aren't required to collect any tax.
 
I would rather just have the eTailer charge me the tax than to have the state reviewing everything I buy.
I agree with this. Its way too hard to set aside money come tax time, and try to remember what you would owe taxes on... or even what the rate is. Its ridiculous.
 
Back
Top