680i or 780i

Right now 8800gtx SLI gives me top perf and STILL isnt enough (behold Crysis)... so i f you want TOP perf, and dont have a hard on *against* sli, its the only way to go. people keep grinding on sli for some reason, yet i find i never feel i can just disable 1 gpu and be good... is it great economy of scale? no. is it top perf if cost is secondary? yes. people on this thread are oclocking 8gb quad extremes. cost is a primary factor? no, Come show me a rig faster than my PC that doesnt utilize SLI and Ill listen. And realize that "fast enough" for some doesnt equal "fast enough" for all... some people want "fastest possible right now"
 
Oh damn guys...I got that xfx 780i board. it was a beauity to behold.

the best part was they have a new bios out today that drastically helps overclocking

I felt brave after reading a few posts on some other forums.
turned off spread spectrum, CE1/Speedstep/Thermal stuff
Set SLI ready memory to enabled/expert
Set my board up with the following:

left the ram synced and linked...was advised to try this first...
CPU 1.45v
Ram 1/10th lesser than your rams specs
FSB 1.4v
SPP/NB 1.45v
MCP/SB 1.525v
HT 1.25v
Aux 1.5v(auto)
GtRleds (auto)
You will notice on a xfx board these values are all still in the "Green" zone
What I did then is take a small chance. Instead of starting small and working my way up, I put in the values I would like ot be running and see how it goes.

would you believe t worked alike a charm. running at 3600 and prime for ovr 30 mins with narey a hickup. I', gonna run it overnight and see whats everything at then.

3600woot.jpg
 
Damn man! What kind of cooling you got packed on that thing?

A very impressive 1.2GHz overclock. I hope it goes well and all remains stable.

Maybe when I get my system going I will be brave and overclock a bit. I'd like to reach 3GHz with the Q6600 I plan to be using.

- Joey
 
Anyone else wanna jump in with their experiences of the 780i, I'm going to be getting one soon, doing the $90 upgrade from the 680i route and wanted to see more results.

I run water cooling so I'm hoping I might be able to push this mobo past the 500 mhz fsb... I've never done that yet, with any stability.
 
You might consider buying a water block for your north bridge. That thing gets really hot. Not sure how you will cool the other components that are connected to the heat pipe. (Of course you could allways mod your brand new mother board by chopping of the fins and mounting your WB to that, doubt you want the voided warrenty that would come with that. :()
 
I have NB, SB, CPU, GTX in a single loop with a 120.3 Thermochill. temps never reach 50c (the loop that is, obviously my cpu reaches higher)

on my 680i
 
Based on what I have read, I would go with a 780i simply because it's just a more mature 680i and offers a little bit more future protection.

No it isn't. The 780i SLI should be a more mature solution but initial reports say that it isn't. I'd say that based on my limited 780i SLI experiences as well. I do agree that if you don't need SLI avoid the NVIDIA 680i/780i SLI chipsets and go with X38/X48.
 
Hmm I'm wondering if I should just sell my 780i NIB and go with an X38/48 board. I could recoup about 200 for new in box and head toward a true performing mobo. I could even sell off my other GTX and end up with maybe 200 in the bank when it is all done. Eh when I sell off my nb/sb blocks and rebuy ones that fit the x48 probably end up with 100, and then sell off the E6600 and get an E8400 or E8500 and OC that puppy to 5ghz if it lets me... then I'm at dead zero!

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
 
Hmm I'm wondering if I should just sell my 780i NIB and go with an X38/48 board. I could recoup about 200 for new in box and head toward a true performing mobo. I could even sell off my other GTX and end up with maybe 200 in the bank when it is all done. Eh when I sell off my nb/sb blocks and rebuy ones that fit the x48 probably end up with 100, and then sell off the E6600 and get an E8400 or E8500 and OC that puppy to 5ghz if it lets me... then I'm at dead zero!

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

If you aren't having problems with your 780i SLI there is no point in ditching SLI. Two video cards will provide you more performance in games than an E8400 could ever provide.
 
If you aren't having problems with your 780i SLI there is no point in ditching SLI. Two video cards will provide you more performance in games than an E8400 could ever provide.

Well see I'm in the queue for upgrade. So really the time to decide to ditch 780i or not is now before I open it. Its either that or I have to add my other GTX into my loop to get the max performance. I have been running two monitors off a single GTX lately and thus could not run SLI.


Hmmmm, so my alternative an additiona EK8800gtx water block and keep the soon to arrive 780i or go single card and get a better performing mobo.
 
Well see I'm in the queue for upgrade. So really the time to decide to ditch 780i or not is now before I open it. Its either that or I have to add my other GTX into my loop to get the max performance. I have been running two monitors off a single GTX lately and thus could not run SLI.

Why do people say this? Dude, running two monitors does not stop you from being able to enjoy SLI in your games. All you have to do is disable SLI-mode whenever you want to use both monitors and enable SLI-mode when you wish to play games. It isn't that hard. A slight pain in the ass I'll agree, but it isn't the end of the world.

Hmmmm, so my alternative an additiona EK8800gtx water block and keep the soon to arrive 780i or go single card and get a better performing mobo.

Well an X38 or X48 motherboard doesn't perform that much better. Certainly not enough to make up for the loss of the second video card. Your motherboard and overclocked CPU aren't as important in gaming performance as your video cards are.
 
because the time I need two monitors is while I am gaming. Vanguard + ventrillo + web searchs = need for 2 monitors, thus removing the SLI option from that game.

Now all other games = SLI no doubt.

Well in vanguard both my cores are pegged at about 60% usage. Thus my desire to upgrade to 45nm at a higher ghz or even to quad core 45nm when that hits mainstream.

I'm wondering how much of that overhead is due to onboard sound, and raid... I should try disabling both the raid and the sound and see how that impacts that before doing anything. Maybe running my 150 raptors in raid-0 for games is not worth the cpu performance hit.
 
because the time I need two monitors is while I am gaming. Vanguard + ventrillo + web searchs = need for 2 monitors, thus removing the SLI option from that game.

Now all other games = SLI no doubt.

Well in vanguard both my cores are pegged at about 60% usage. Thus my desire to upgrade to 45nm at a higher ghz or even to quad core 45nm when that hits mainstream.

I'm wondering how much of that overhead is due to onboard sound, and raid... I should try disabling both the raid and the sound and see how that impacts that before doing anything. Maybe running my 150 raptors in raid-0 for games is not worth the cpu performance hit.

The performance hit from those two things is miniscule. I still don't know why you would need that crap running while you are gaming but to each their own I guess.
 
The performance hit from those two things is miniscule. I still don't know why you would need that crap running while you are gaming but to each their own I guess.

Well long story short, Vanguard is an MMO, thus in 18 man raids we use ventrillo to communicate and you need to see who is talking in a raid. The use of a website relates to the fact that I'm an officer in a guild and am responsible for updating information real time related balances of dkp (think of it as currency) that individuals have throughout the night to buy items that drop from kills. I'm sure that made no sense, but...

As I think about it I think you are prolly right. Keep the 780i, utilize SLI where and when I need it and maybe down the road just upgrade to a 45nm quad core is the best move overall... that gives me some solid performance in games that I can run SLI and would also enhance performance down the road of games where I can't use SLI...

Thanks for your feedback Dan!
 
Well long story short, Vanguard is an MMO, thus in 18 man raids we use ventrillo to communicate and you need to see who is talking in a raid. The use of a website relates to the fact that I'm an officer in a guild and am responsible for updating information real time related balances of dkp (think of it as currency) that individuals have throughout the night to buy items that drop from kills. I'm sure that made no sense, but...

As I think about it I think you are prolly right. Keep the 780i, utilize SLI where and when I need it and maybe down the road just upgrade to a 45nm quad core is the best move overall... that gives me some solid performance in games that I can run SLI and would also enhance performance down the road of games where I can't use SLI...

Thanks for your feedback Dan!

Anytime man. :cool:
 
SLI FTW, though do you have a second machine by you that you can run vent on??
 
I do, but honestly its a pita to use cuz I have to hit a key on that keyboard to activate the ability to talk. I tried that for a while and it just really screwed up my ability to play fluently. Maybe I can rig up something on that second machine to allow me to talk with somethign mounted on my main keyboard... but regardless... this is 680i vs 780i and I'm curious if anyone else has performance #'s. Anyone break 500mhz?
 
I been pondering this question also. I purchased my 680i on 1/23/07 the "AR", then swapped it out to what was it, the "A1" I really can't remember, it was the update that EVGA had to help with overclocking.

Anyway I can't take advantage of the promo because I have w/c my north and south bridges.(I cant find the original stuff that was on it either) Which is problably why I haven't had any problems with this board. However I want to upgrade and run the Q9450 and still use my SLI.

So should it be the EVGA or ASUS board?
 
right now the Asus offerings don't seem to hold up to well as of right now but possibly with some bios updates down the road this might change.
 
right now the Asus offerings don't seem to hold up to well as of right now but possibly with some bios updates down the road this might change.

Well I've heard reasonably good things about the ASUS Striker II Formula. It isn't perfect though. The last time around with the 680i SLI boards the reference boards were thought to be the way to go until a couple months down the line when the reference boards started dying. Now more than a year later the P5N32-E SLI and Striker Extreme were definitely the best 680i SLI boards out of the bunch.
 
Well, in some german forums you mainly read bad things about the Asus 780i boards. Temperature is bad, replacing the default thermalgrease is a must. Stability problems, below average overclocking. Some people already replaced their Striker II with EVGA/XFX and were really happy with the exchange.

Personally I had problems with my memory not running well, FSB above 400 MHz was a pain in the ass and I had to take off the heatsink to apply new thermalgrease.
At the moment I have a MSI P7N Diamond, which would be the fourth player in the 780i game. It's the latest board and you can barely find any hands-on articles about it. So far, it seems to be okay and performing better than the Striker II. But again, all boards are in quite early stages, nobody knows how the situation will look like in two, maybe three months.
 
Well, in some german forums you mainly read bad things about the Asus 780i boards. Temperature is bad, replacing the default thermalgrease is a must. Stability problems, below average overclocking. Some people already replaced their Striker II with EVGA/XFX and were really happy with the exchange.

Personally I had problems with my memory not running well, FSB above 400 MHz was a pain in the ass and I had to take off the heatsink to apply new thermalgrease.
At the moment I have a MSI P7N Diamond, which would be the fourth player in the 780i game. It's the latest board and you can barely find any hands-on articles about it. So far, it seems to be okay and performing better than the Striker II. But again, all boards are in quite early stages, nobody knows how the situation will look like in two, maybe three months.

Well I have always been a fan of SLI and I wouldn't put a 780i SLI of any make or model in my machine. I'd rather stick with the 680i SLI or shell out for the Intel D5400XS and a pair of Xeons than deal with the damn 780i SLI boards.
 
I own the XFX offering on the 780i boards. At the time, people were saying good things about them and singing thier praises. The North bridge runs very hot, no question about that. When not OCing, it has been very stable. I was really hoping to push my E8400 to 4.5Ghz, but I had trouble getting it anywhere near that. I havn't messed with OCing in about a week and 1/2 since I got it. Just been busy and not ready to mess with it. Really hoping that this board doesn't crap out on me in 3 months as I bought the system builders copy of Vista and don't want those problems. On the plus side though, like I said earlier, it has been very stable when not OCing. Time will tell.... Time will tell.
 
I own the XFX offering on the 780i boards. At the time, people were saying good things about them and singing thier praises. The North bridge runs very hot, no question about that. When not OCing, it has been very stable. I was really hoping to push my E8400 to 4.5Ghz, but I had trouble getting it anywhere near that. I havn't messed with OCing in about a week and 1/2 since I got it. Just been busy and not ready to mess with it. Really hoping that this board doesn't crap out on me in 3 months as I bought the system builders copy of Vista and don't want those problems. On the plus side though, like I said earlier, it has been very stable when not OCing. Time will tell.... Time will tell.

Time will certainly tell. However I won't be the one finding out in my personal machine this time around.
 
I own a p5n32-e sli and so far it's been rock solid EXCEPT when overclocking beyond a certain point. Beyond 1.4ghz fsb, it seems to get flakey. This is undoubtedly due to the fact that the northbridge gets painfully hot. I touch the northbridge heatpipe heatsink and it will almost burn me. Leave my finger on the northbridge heatsink for a few seconds and it is painful. Bear in mind that this is all with an Antec p182 case with all 120mm fans.

This is, undoubtedly, the reason why I cannot get past 1.4ghz fsb. If you get a 680i board, you may want to consider immediately throwing away the stock chipset cooling system or finding some way to upgrade it.
 
I own a p5n32-e sli and so far it's been rock solid EXCEPT when overclocking beyond a certain point. Beyond 1.4ghz fsb, it seems to get flakey. This is undoubtedly due to the fact that the northbridge gets painfully hot. I touch the northbridge heatpipe heatsink and it will almost burn me. Leave my finger on the northbridge heatsink for a few seconds and it is painful. Bear in mind that this is all with an Antec p182 case with all 120mm fans.

This is, undoubtedly, the reason why I cannot get past 1.4ghz fsb. If you get a 680i board, you may want to consider immediately throwing away the stock chipset cooling system or finding some way to upgrade it.

I wish they had used the Striker Extreme's cooling setup on the P5N32-E SLI. It is only slightly different but far more effective in my experience.
 
I own a p5n32-e sli and so far it's been rock solid EXCEPT when overclocking beyond a certain point. Beyond 1.4ghz fsb, it seems to get flakey. This is undoubtedly due to the fact that the northbridge gets painfully hot. I touch the northbridge heatpipe heatsink and it will almost burn me. Leave my finger on the northbridge heatsink for a few seconds and it is painful. Bear in mind that this is all with an Antec p182 case with all 120mm fans.

This is, undoubtedly, the reason why I cannot get past 1.4ghz fsb. If you get a 680i board, you may want to consider immediately throwing away the stock chipset cooling system or finding some way to upgrade it.


Um 1.4ghz FSB? WTH? I do hope you are really saying 350mhz FSB.

Cuz i'm confused.
 
Um 1.4ghz FSB? WTH? I do hope you are really saying 350mhz FSB.

Cuz i'm confused.

Yeah that must be the case. That poster is talking about how the FSB is listed in the P5N32-E SLI BIOS. It lists the FSB numbers in quad-pumped phone.
 
I wish they had used the Striker Extreme's cooling setup on the P5N32-E SLI. It is only slightly different but far more effective in my experience.

I saw massive gains in stability by tossing the Strikers stock cooling and going to liquid. I had to raise voltages across the board at stock speeds to prevent all sorts of goofy errors I was getting. But temps went to hell.
 
Yeah I read that part about the 1.4Ghz FSB and thought to my self that I wish I could get a mobo to clock just 1 Ghz FSB :D
 
I saw massive gains in stability by tossing the Strikers stock cooling and going to liquid. I had to raise voltages across the board at stock speeds to prevent all sorts of goofy errors I was getting. But temps went to hell.

My Striker Extreme works very well at stock speeds. It is very stable, but it doesn't overclock worth a shit. The temperatures don't seem to be the cause of this but rather just a poor chipset. Mine just doesn't overclock very well.
 
My Striker Extreme OCs fairly well I think. It took the right BIOS though.

I have a stable 475 Bus/RAM speed, topping my E6750 to 3.8GHz (on Air, no case)
I have even hit 500 Bus/RAM but it hasn't been gaming stable.
I haven't replaced the original thermal paste though. Should I?

Considering all of the above, should I even bother with a 780i? I mean a Q6600 will soon be even cheaper.
 
wow I'd be pretty happy with 475 stable 24/7. WOW!!! Highest I've hit is right around 450 and it was not stable. 427 was my max stable ever on a board. I just have not been blessed with OC friendly boards yet.

 
Actually my highest stable with the E6750 and the 2GB OCZ SLI 7200 is somewhere around 483 but above that it becomes an issue of what the CPU/RAM can do, not the mobo.

I mean considering these numbers is it worth making the switch to 780i?
I do want to get a Quad and overclock it a bit over 3GHz (it doesn't seem to make much of a difference beyond that). Won't the 680i and a Q6600 achieve that?

P.S. Is my Striker's good performance a good selling point? I'm no stranger to eBay...
 
If I were going to go 680i I just get an LT and save some cash. I 've seen those as low as 149usd.

If I was going to go high end I'd get the 780i.
 
I sold my eVGA 680i SLI SE and bought an XFX 680i LT. Still have an original NF68-TR board in another machine, though it's a horrible OCer and I bought it second-hand, can't RMA it for something better.

Having worked with both, if you aren't trying to run stupid high vcore (higher than 1.6v before vdroop) and don't need Tri-SLI support, I agree that the 680i LT is the way to go. All the good stuff about 680i, almost none of the bad stuff.

I went water on the northbridge because it does run very hot, but you could just as easily swap out for a Thermalright HR-05 or similar as the LTs don't use heatpipes, so you already have the little southbridge fan on there, ready to go. I kind of miss the LCD readout and power/reset buttons on the board, but they weren't really needed, or all that especially useful. Back to shorting pins with spare jumpers. :cool: I never used the dual NICs, so the fact that there's only one now doesn't matter to me at all.

4 USB ports on the back panel does suck, but the XFX board comes with a PCI slot cover with another 4 you can connect to the internal headers for a total of 8... but I don't use this because my case uses a header for the front panel, as I imagine most people's will. All things considered, that's the only thing I don't like about it -- fewer USB ports -- and it's not like 8 (counting the 4 from the two internal headers) isn't enough for most.

I never had stability problems with my 680i SLIs, so I can't really comment comparatively there, but the LT is at least as stable as the other boards. Many seem to think it's more stable. Also, I've seen them as low as $100 AR new, so a $150 savings over a 780i when you aren't losing much (third 16x slot, PCIe 2.0, 1 NIC, LCD readout, fewer USB) doesn't seem like a bad deal to me.
 
I sold my eVGA 680i SLI SE and bought an XFX 680i LT. Still have an original NF68-TR board in another machine, though it's a horrible OCer and I bought it second-hand, can't RMA it for something better.

Having worked with both, if you aren't trying to run stupid high vcore (higher than 1.6v before vdroop) and don't need Tri-SLI support, I agree that the 680i LT is the way to go. All the good stuff about 680i, almost none of the bad stuff.

I went water on the northbridge because it does run very hot, but you could just as easily swap out for a Thermalright HR-05 or similar as the LTs don't use heatpipes, so you already have the little southbridge fan on there, ready to go. I kind of miss the LCD readout and power/reset buttons on the board, but they weren't really needed, or all that especially useful. Back to shorting pins with spare jumpers. :cool: I never used the dual NICs, so the fact that there's only one now doesn't matter to me at all.

4 USB ports on the back panel does suck, but the XFX board comes with a PCI slot cover with another 4 you can connect to the internal headers for a total of 8... but I don't use this because my case uses a header for the front panel, as I imagine most people's will. All things considered, that's the only thing I don't like about it -- fewer USB ports -- and it's not like 8 (counting the 4 from the two internal headers) isn't enough for most.

I never had stability problems with my 680i SLIs, so I can't really comment comparatively there, but the LT is at least as stable as the other boards. Many seem to think it's more stable. Also, I've seen them as low as $100 AR new, so a $150 savings over a 780i when you aren't losing much (third 16x slot, PCIe 2.0, 1 NIC, LCD readout, fewer USB) doesn't seem like a bad deal to me.

For stability the 680i LT boards were better. I'm not sure exactly what NVIDIA changed to make them more stable, but they are. That has been my expereience anyway.
 
I prefer the 780i layout and placement over the 680i. Also it's a huge bonus for those who are into wire management that the 780i does not have the molex power on the mobo as the 680i did.

However, a big downside to the 780i is the relocated case headers... not a downside, just a PITA when using a TJ-10...cables are too short.
 
I prefer the 780i layout and placement over the 680i. Also it's a huge bonus for those who are into wire management that the 780i does not have the molex power on the mobo as the 680i did.

However, a big downside to the 780i is the relocated case headers... not a downside, just a PITA when using a TJ-10...cables are too short.

You get less usable expansion slots on the 780i SLI boards. The only improvement they really made was in regard to the location of the front panel switches.
 
You get less usable expansion slots on the 780i SLI boards. The only improvement they really made was in regard to the location of the front panel switches.

Yeah it was a bummer that the top slot got nixed. But I guess an advantage to that would be that not many x1 devices are out that can populate it and nvidia now has physx. Still, I do like options.

The relocated front panel headers are nice but are also a pita for example in my case of wires not reaching (I kinda blame silverstone for lacking foresight). The 680i location was nice in the sense that if you ran your molex power and your sata cables, you could bundle them all for one neat grouping.


There are some good improvments they made. They included locking sata cables (doesn't work well with the sata 0 header), they have a better fan mounting mechanism for the bridge that can easily be removed even if you have large sinks.. the 680i screw in mechanism with the tiny screws was a pita if you decide to mount it after the fact. No power molex header was another bonus. Better heatpipe setup (although, it may not be better in benchmarks), More black :p :cool:... other than that it's pretty much the same.
 
Back
Top