50 Open Source Replacements for Windows XP

The problem with Linux is that there's always something broken. It does not just works most of the time.

That's not to say it's hard to fix, a few Google searches and done. But then again, I can find my away around the command line and other stuff, so I can do it. I'm sure that my wife can't, for example. And that's the issue.

Installed Fedora on a notebook (AMD C-50) with Gnome 3. Besides Gnome 3 sucking huge balls (how are you supposed to multitask on a interface like that is beyond me), it worked fine, except for updates. It just won't check for updates. After a Google search, I found out that on Fedora 20 there's a package missing by default, and if I don't install it it won't update. Simple fix: go to command line and install the package. Done, can update now. But my wife wouldn't be able to do that by herself (and she's not tech illiterate, can find her way around most things at Windows, and is able to not install junkware when upgrading software for example), and things like that are exactly what kills Linux for most people.

Now I'm running Fedora 20 w/ XFCE (lighter and can multitask fine, updates out-of-the-box). But I had to do some additional steps on setup to make it the default window manager.

It's the small details that kill Linux right now. They are not hard to fix, but still annoying.

I installed Xubuntu 12.04 for a guy who needed a computer. I shipped it to him. I told him how to get to the update manager. He's asked me maybe 2 questions about how to do things in the last year (one was setting up his internet via wireless) and I haven't heard a peep since. He is DEFINATELY not someone who would use the CLI.
 
I installed Xubuntu 12.04 for a guy who needed a computer. I shipped it to him. I told him how to get to the update manager. He's asked me maybe 2 questions about how to do things in the last year (one was setting up his internet via wireless) and I haven't heard a peep since. He is DEFINATELY not someone who would use the CLI.

Probably put Windows 7 on it.

Not kidding.
 
XP comes from a different era that was designed for PCs with less hardware than modern tablets and smart phones, x86 Windows 8.1 can now fit on devices with as little as 1 GB of RAM and 16 GB of storage, which is modest by todays mobile device standards but significantly more than XPs base requirements. But XP won't even run modern Atom CPUs any better than 8.1 would run on a 64 MB Pentium 4 system.

I guess, but XP didn't really run well, IMO, with less than 1.5GB (post SP2). With much more than that, it really didn't matter, because it rarely used the memor, even when it was available. That's one nice thing about 7 (though there's a bug on some systems where it eats up memory over time. Dad has it as does my work PC. My home PC doesn't. Not sure what the cause is.
 
I installed Xubuntu 12.04 for a guy who needed a computer. I shipped it to him. I told him how to get to the update manager. He's asked me maybe 2 questions about how to do things in the last year (one was setting up his internet via wireless) and I haven't heard a peep since. He is DEFINATELY not someone who would use the CLI.

Linux has come a long way, but I know some diehard Linux users that don't use it at work, because of issues with wireless drivers on some laptops. Say what you want, but Windows generally just works on a very wide range of hardware. If you limit that H/W, then Apple and *nix are killer, but if you do that with Windows, you'd likely find the same results. Ultimately, you use what you like. I know people who manage PCs for their extended family, and they moved them to *nix, because of malware. It's not that Windows is insecure, so much as it's targeted and the family members manage to always have issues. I do the same but with windows and my mom has no issues. My dad manages to get some malware, mostly because he's never met a link he wouldn't click on.
 
Someone who is still on Windows XP is probably not tech savy enough to know what Linux is. Much less research a distro, download the image onto USB, set their bios setting to boot from USB (if supported, otherwise they'll have to make a startup CD, and then set BIOS to boot from CD)...derp derp... get where I'm going.


This is actually demeaning to Linux. You're suggesting it as an alternative to a 4-generations old OS, rather than as an alternative to what's out now.

Hell of a blanket statement.

I've been building for 20 years and I currently have XP on my machine because it works, I am used to it and some of the little things I like [taskbar, tabs, etc] were removed in 7.
Sure you can get some hacks and regedit to get them back but it should have been included in their "classic shell" in the first place.

That said I've installed Fedora, Mint and Ubuntu on various systems just for the hell of it to give them a test run and root around.

They are not too shabby but you will never get the widespread adoption like you can with windows or support.

99% of my programs and games would not even install in linux.

If you only browse the net and their built in programs work for you then linux is solid but for everybody else it's just not a viable option.
 
If you only browse the net and their built in programs work for you then linux is solid but for verybody else it's just not a viable option.

Ah, but there's the kicker. What does Joe Average do? They surf the internet, listen to music, maybe watch some movies, and occasionally type up a letter for someone who doesn't use eMail. If you build a stable Linux desktop/laptop that did all the basics, did them well, and was cheep, Then given proper promotion, MS's market-share for home PCs would crumble.

However, it's the last part that's the problem. I ran Mint Linux on my laptop for a while and it worked beautifully. The laptop was old so I couldn't game on it or do much beyond the basics, and Mint gave me everything I needed.

Sadly, when you ask Joe Average, they'll only know about Windows and Macintosh (and not knocking Mac, I actually prefer OSX to windows). Marketing is the biggest problem - hide the dangerous features (like command prompt, window-manager chooser, etc) behind several warnings to keep the average person out of them and make sure the bugs are ironed out for the basics and that's all that most people will want.

Yes, nearly everyone on this forum can tell a horror story about linux not running certain hardware or games, but none of us are joe-average who buys whatever PC is on the shelf at wallyworld. For them, Linux would work great I think.
 
50 different distros, 50 different implementations. What works on one may not work on others. Hours of recompiling when things need to be changed. Gods help you if you ever need help with something.
 
50 different distros, 50 different implementations. What works on one may not work on others. Hours of recompiling when things need to be changed. Gods help you if you ever need help with something.

What? Such complete nonsense. Do you actually believe that or are you just trolling?
 
The thing is... if you have 50 different GOOD Linux Distros... that's a lot of OSs to distribute talent across. If you have that many, how good could each possibly be?

Well since the code is all open sourced, if one guy writes a great network driver package they all can use it. The differences in these different distros is alot like someone customizing their collection of their favorite pieces. But most of the really good pieces are the same piece. That means many of the distos are remarkably the same.

On a side not, just like the OpenSSL issue, if there is a vulnerability with a popular package then most everyone will have that same problem as well.
 
zorin.png
 
First time I've heard of Zorin OS. It does look quite interesting, has anyone had any experience with it before?

Zorin is great.

Just went through a bit of trouble cause of supposed fake website of theirs. They even removed the Wikipedia entry about it due to the mystery. Supposedly its coded by a Russian who lives in Ireland. That's all I know
 
Back
Top