50 Open Source Replacements for Windows XP

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I knew there were a lot of different flavors of Linux out there but I didn't think there was this many. This is definitely a good list of alternative operating systems and not just for Windows XP users.

No doubt, many are home users who simply aren't very technology savvy and/or may not have the desire or the money to upgrade to a newer version of Windows. Some probably have older, underpowered PCs that can't run Windows 7 or 8. And others have specific software—often custom business applications—that only runs on Windows XP. Fortunately, the open source community has free operating systems that meet the needs of users in all of these situations.
 
First time I've heard of Zorin OS. It does look quite interesting, has anyone had any experience with it before?
 
First time I've heard of Zorin OS. It does look quite interesting, has anyone had any experience with it before?

seems like everyone has been mentioning it.

Looks like every other linux distro.
 
The thing is... if you have 50 different GOOD Linux Distros... that's a lot of OSs to distribute talent across. If you have that many, how good could each possibly be?
 
A lot of Linux distros vary in the packages, but are generally similar in setup and use. Obviously Gentoo is an exception. Still, most are pretty easy graphically or even by text. I'm strongly ingrained in Windows, but I keep my toes wet.
 
The thing is... if you have 50 different GOOD Linux Distros... that's a lot of OSs to distribute talent across. If you have that many, how good could each possibly be?

That's the problem with Linux, extreme fragmentation of OS's to the point of ridiculousness. Choice is good but come on...
 
I built two replacement systems for my parents to get them off Windows XP. I didn't want them to have to deal with Linux just because their systems couldn't handle Windows 7. So I gave them systems that could handle Windows 7.

However, after I got their old systems back, I wiped them, thoroughly, and installed Ubuntu 12.04 and donated them to the Salvation Army. It worked great. Ubuntu doesn't have the major overhead of Windows, but I wouldn't call it a replacement for Windows. I wouldn't give it to anyone I would have to support, but for a basic system to just surf the web, it might do the trick.
 
Aren't about 45 of those basically the exact same thing as each other?

I guess this is what I don't really understand about Linux. Sure having choices is awesome, but when an already small community divides up into even smaller communities, the fragmentation seems to kill it.
 
Really the Linux distros should be looked at in the form of "which ecosystem" does this or that distro draw from.
Ubuntu is based on the Debian and there a lot of distros that use the Ubuntu repositories (Kubuntu,Xbuntu, Mint, )
Personally I experimented with several and found I leaned more and more toward a light weight GUI so I have been using Xubuntu for a while with is the Xfce desktop.
 
Someone who is still on Windows XP is probably not tech savy enough to know what Linux is. Much less research a distro, download the image onto USB, set their bios setting to boot from USB (if supported, otherwise they'll have to make a startup CD, and then set BIOS to boot from CD)...derp derp... get where I'm going.


This is actually demeaning to Linux. You're suggesting it as an alternative to a 4-generations old OS, rather than as an alternative to what's out now.
 
Someone who is still on Windows XP is probably not tech savy enough to know what Linux is. Much less research a distro, download the image onto USB, set their bios setting to boot from USB (if supported, otherwise they'll have to make a startup CD, and then set BIOS to boot from CD)...derp derp... get where I'm going.


This is actually demeaning to Linux. You're suggesting it as an alternative to a 4-generations old OS, rather than as an alternative to what's out now.

Agree.

If MS offered a "windows lite" that has say WinXP functionally but was up to par on modern security, and the core coding (and was cheap) these types would be all over it like stink.
 
Agree.

If MS offered a "windows lite" that has say WinXP functionally but was up to par on modern security, and the core coding (and was cheap) these types would be all over it like stink.
They tried that on netbooks and cheap laptops. Somewhat reduced functionality in exchange for a MUCH cheaper computer. People HATED it.
Windows 7 Stater Limitations
 
They had Windows CE for a long time for thin clients, PPCs, and embedded devices and there was XP embedded too. Microsoft probably won't do something like that for mainstream systems though because they'd put a lot of revenue at risk. Windows 8 hurt PC sales so badly HP and Dell restarted Win 7 sales. MS really can't afford to give people inexpensive options when flagship OS development was so expensive and has managed to hurt the company's brand identity.
 
That's the problem with Linux, extreme fragmentation of OS's to the point of ridiculousness. Choice is good but come on...

That plus too many elitist snobs that don't want to actually help people learn the OS, or make it easier to learn.


ReactOS shouldn't be on that list, its pretty terrible as it is right now.
 
That plus too many elitist snobs that don't want to actually help people learn the OS, or make it easier to learn.


ReactOS shouldn't be on that list, its pretty terrible as it is right now.

I have yet to find any community that's actually like that just a few folks making the claim.
 
That plus too many elitist snobs that don't want to actually help people learn the OS, or make it easier to learn.

This is the problem I've run into. I used to try a new Linux Distro once every February, just to say i did, and to measure my options. The worst was when I'd inevitably run into a driver I couldn't get to work (usually wifi), and I'd have to go to the distro's forums.
I'm no tech idiot, and I generally know how to use a command line, even if i am not familiar with all of the commands; but while I'd preface any questions with a noobie disclaimer, I'd get one of two possible answers:

1- A set of instructions so arcane, providing a general how-to with no real instructions, that it was useless. I.e., if I asked how to build a car from scratch, and you said, put an engine on a frame with wheels and tires at each corner, brakes, a steering wheel and seats, you technically answered the question, but with information that is essentially useless.

2- One of the aforementioned elitist snobs, asking why I was trying [insert purportedly noob-friendly distro here] if I didn't know what I was doing.

That's not really the way to garner new users or fans.
 
I have yet to find any community that's actually like that just a few folks making the claim.

Ever do a search on how to do things with Linux, especially NAT routing, file shares, or DHCP server? It's horrible. Right now, I've been told to set up a postfix mail relay that can filter out all emails to a specific address. I haven't been able to find a thing that I can actually understand. I have yet to find an actually helpful community.
 
The thing is... if you have 50 different GOOD Linux Distros... that's a lot of OSs to distribute talent across. If you have that many, how good could each possibly be?

That's because anyone can create their own Linux distro. For the most part, distros are like this.

#1 They choose an environment to create their OS. For example Debian is the backbone to Ubuntu/Mint and a number of other OS's, including SteamOS. Some create their own, like Arch and Fedora. Some are even based off Arch. It's a lot more work to do it yourself. You can tell if the OS is derived from Debian if it can use .deb files, which are like installers for Debian OS's.

#2 They include software. Some may include Libre Office or Open Office. Some may use Firefox or Chromium. Of course you can download your own software from the repository, or get it from another repository. Backporting software is a lot of work, that's why it's better to get the repository made specifically for that software, cause it's likely to be newer.

#3 Customizations are probably what distros use to differentiate themselves from each other. With some exceptions like Ubuntu and Mint who actually create some of the software in their UI's. Like Unity and Cinnamon, which are both derived from Gnome. But for the most part, custom icons and themes are what's done.

For the most part, a Linux distro is like walking around a store and picking the parts off the shelf. Distro's are just conveniently put together for you. You don't have to use the kernel that came with it, or the software, or the UI. You can pretty much rebuild a linux distro if you wish. But it's much easier to choose one that fits your liking, then to have to sit there and rebuild an OS. That's why there's so many choices, and they're all good.
 
That's why there's so many choices, and they're all good.
That's where you lost me.
See, imho, an OS fails if you are required to access the command line except in an emergency. EVERY distro of Linux I've tried, I've needed to do something in the command line. That's just not acceptable for me, and neither is it acceptable for anyone looking to switch. The switch should be easier than what you left.
Similarly, if you're leaving Microsoft, fine, but what you leave it for better be a better option. There are no Linux Office clones that are worth a darn. They mangle .docx files on a regular basis. And that's computing 101.

So, yea, i understand WHY there are so many options, my question is why so few are good?
 
They tried that on netbooks and cheap laptops. Somewhat reduced functionality in exchange for a MUCH cheaper computer. People HATED it.
Windows 7 Stater Limitations

That was more because people assumed that it was like Vista Starter, which could only open 3 apps at a time, only supported 1gb of memory among other stupid limitations. While 7 got rid of the major limitations, it was still a netbook only product, which by late 2009 everyone realized wasn't as big of a deal as originally thought.

I think doing a free version for tablets like they are currently doing, along with office is a good move, if companies follow through and drop the price. I have a Venue 8 Pro, at the $200 I paid for it, it's a much better deal than a Nexus 7. At $299 though? I can't recommend it at all.
 
That was more because people assumed that it was like Vista Starter, which could only open 3 apps at a time, only supported 1gb of memory among other stupid limitations. While 7 got rid of the major limitations, it was still a netbook only product, which by late 2009 everyone realized wasn't as big of a deal as originally thought.

I think doing a free version for tablets like they are currently doing, along with office is a good move, if companies follow through and drop the price. I have a Venue 8 Pro, at the $200 I paid for it, it's a much better deal than a Nexus 7. At $299 though? I can't recommend it at all.

Ditto, as a V8P owner. I paid $230, and am VERY happy at that price. Even $300 would be appropriate now that the kinks are worked out (for the most part), though there should be more accessories.
But yea, this is a great move by MS to stay competitive in the super-mobile space (i.e. not laptops).
 
That's where you lost me.
See, imho, an OS fails if you are required to access the command line except in an emergency. EVERY distro of Linux I've tried, I've needed to do something in the command line. That's just not acceptable for me, and neither is it acceptable for anyone looking to switch. The switch should be easier than what you left.
Similarly, if you're leaving Microsoft, fine, but what you leave it for better be a better option. There are no Linux Office clones that are worth a darn. They mangle .docx files on a regular basis. And that's computing 101.

So, yea, i understand WHY there are so many options, my question is why so few are good?

Terminal on modern linux distro's aren't required. At least it hasn't been for me to get a basic setup working. Ubuntu even makes it slightly difficult to find Terminal, like in Mac OSX. Everything works out of the box, but that does depend on your hardware. For example on Ubuntu, if you need a retail driver, then you run driver manager. From there you can pick and choose what driver for your hardware. If you want software then go to software manager.

The only time terminal commands are required is when you want the latest drivers, or latest kernel, or latest software. Maybe a piece of hardware doesn't work, then you would need terminal.

As for Office suites, I have no problems with Libre. I rarely use office applications to begin with. Once in a while I need to type documents or create something, but nothing beyond that. From what I hear, Libre is a good competitor to MS Office. Also the lack of MS Office is entirely on Microsoft. They can put office on an iPad but not Linux?
 
There are a bazillion times (that's an official number) more iPads than users of linux on a desktop, so the money's there.
But you hit the nail on the head. I always have some kind of device that doesn't have official linux drives (usually a networking device like a wireless USB dongle or a soundcard). I remember back when i was really trying, I got all messed up in ndiswrapper or some sort of command that wasn't doing what I needed, despite the community's INSISTENCE that it should.

As far as Libre office, it's ok, but again, ti has a tendency to mangle the formatting in Office docs.
 
There are a bazillion times (that's an official number) more iPads than users of linux on a desktop, so the money's there.

Microsoft has the same issue to mull as would any commercial desktop software developer for Linux. Is it worth it given the small market share. Moreover, Microsoft in particular has another issue to contend with. There is strong anti-Microsoft sentiment among Linux users and it's hard to see many sales of a MS Office client when so many Linux folks are all about free alternatives to Office.
 
I have a Venue 8 Pro, at the $200 I paid for it, it's a much better deal than a Nexus 7. At $299 though? I can't recommend it at all.

The 64 GB version of the Venue 8 Pro is running around $300 now. That's more than a fair price for that amount of storage when compared to iPads and even Android tablets.
 
I have yet to find any community that's actually like that just a few folks making the claim.

I dealt with it trying out Slackware, Debian, and PCLinuxOS.

With the Debian install I had an issue with X starting up and was looking for ideas to fix it and one guy actually wanted me to read an entire free to view book online before he'd answer me.

Most times its people that speak in cryptic phases and command line instructions, and when asked WTF they mean are like "god, do I have to do all the work for you?"

That shit kills my interest real fast.
 
Yeah I remember posting the basic comment of -

"well maybe more of us would try Linux if the help and support wasnt so terrible and aggressive. Ranging from help tutorials that assume you have 5 years Linux experience already and miss out the 6 initial steps to aggressive users who basically tell people trying to learn to F*** OFF AND GET SKILLS NOOB!"

I posted that up on a general Tech Forum and boy oh boy two Linux guys went off at me just as you would expect. I kept telling them that they were proving my point exactly, much to everyones amusement but we couldnt tell them.

"Why should we teach you noobs stuff when we had to learn it! Go away get skills THEN we might help you, asshat!"

That was pretty much their 'Welcome to Linux' speech.

Linux - Just so warm and inclusive.
 
Oh and I still cant work out how exactly using a command line to type a load of crap out on a terminal window can be faster than simply clicking one icon.

To me its like someone telling me starting your car with a choke and a cranking handle is faster than push button Start.
 
Oh and I still cant work out how exactly using a command line to type a load of crap out on a terminal window can be faster than simply clicking one icon.

To me its like someone telling me starting your car with a choke and a cranking handle is faster than push button Start.

You haven't used a Linux distro in the last 10 years, have you?
 
You haven't used a Linux distro in the last 10 years, have you?

Oh I have Fedora running in a VM.

I'm just repeating the matra you will always here when Linux 'experts' want to waggle their epeen at you.

"Man you just aint using it right if you dont use the Command Line...its just so much quicker!"

Then you look up the info how to install non spoon fed software and its obscure pages of how to handle tar.gz files and typing stuff in via Command Line.

On a windows box is three clicks and done...
 
You haven't used a Linux distro in the last 10 years, have you?

Oh I have Fedora running in a VM.

I'm just repeating the mantra you will always hear when Linux 'experts' want to waggle their epeen at you.

"Man you just aint using it right if you dont use the Command Line...its just so much quicker!"

Then you look up the info how to install non spoon fed software and its obscure pages of how to handle tar.gz files and typing stuff in via Command Line.

On a windows box is three clicks and done...
 
I've never head that from the Linux community. Though I have heard it from a growing number of Windows systems admins thanks to the introduction of Power Shell and Server Core ... that is totally okay too, by the way since a lot of sysad chores benefit from scripting and use of CLI, but for home Linux distros that's not really true anymore and hasn't been for a while.

There are some uber nerd losers who act like that, but you don't get that very often and when you do, it's in a forum where you can easily just wait for a more reasonable response to a question or discussion.
 
I knew there were a lot of different flavors of Linux out there but I didn't think there was this many. This is definitely a good list of alternative operating systems and not just for Windows XP users.

If you've got an XP PC that can't handle 7, it must be really REALLY old. 7 is faster than XP at some tasks, slower in others, but it's a lot better OS. Certainly if you have 4GB of ram (for 32bit 7) you should be good, unless your graphics totally blow. If that's the case, less than $50.00 would easily buy a solid card for desktop use on 7 or 8 (which I don't use, but I've read is faster than 7)
 
If you've got an XP PC that can't handle 7, it must be really REALLY old. 7 is faster than XP at some tasks, slower in others, but it's a lot better OS. Certainly if you have 4GB of ram (for 32bit 7) you should be good, unless your graphics totally blow. If that's the case, less than $50.00 would easily buy a solid card for desktop use on 7 or 8 (which I don't use, but I've read is faster than 7)

XP comes from a different era that was designed for PCs with less hardware than modern tablets and smart phones, x86 Windows 8.1 can now fit on devices with as little as 1 GB of RAM and 16 GB of storage, which is modest by todays mobile device standards but significantly more than XPs base requirements. But XP won't even run modern Atom CPUs any better than 8.1 would run on a 64 MB Pentium 4 system.
 
The problem with Linux is that there's always something broken. It does not just works most of the time.

That's not to say it's hard to fix, a few Google searches and done. But then again, I can find my away around the command line and other stuff, so I can do it. I'm sure that my wife can't, for example. And that's the issue.

Installed Fedora on a notebook (AMD C-50) with Gnome 3. Besides Gnome 3 sucking huge balls (how are you supposed to multitask on a interface like that is beyond me), it worked fine, except for updates. It just won't check for updates. After a Google search, I found out that on Fedora 20 there's a package missing by default, and if I don't install it it won't update. Simple fix: go to command line and install the package. Done, can update now. But my wife wouldn't be able to do that by herself (and she's not tech illiterate, can find her way around most things at Windows, and is able to not install junkware when upgrading software for example), and things like that are exactly what kills Linux for most people.

Now I'm running Fedora 20 w/ XFCE (lighter and can multitask fine, updates out-of-the-box). But I had to do some additional steps on setup to make it the default window manager.

It's the small details that kill Linux right now. They are not hard to fix, but still annoying.
 
Back
Top