5 Features Windows 9 Needs To Succeed

1. Cascading All Programs menu
2. Animated gif support in the Windows Photo Viewer
3. Fix the sound compression (XP's was perfect)
4. Let you right click programs on the task bar and have an option for "send to Monitor #"
5. Bring back the windows start up / shut down sounds and extra mouse pointer schemes (like 3D-White)
 
1. Classic theme
2. Aero theme
3. Windows 7 Start Menu
4. Proper DPI support for high-DPI displays
5. Stop trying to force Microsoft logon account
 
If I have to stare at floating / docked squares at all on my desktop I will go full tilt mental and will make sure to bitch to the point I at least turn a few hundred people away from Windows 9. And those people will tell an average of 8 or 9 other people, so on and so forth.

Microsoft is a sham as far as I'm concerned. A joke. I really hate that I have to use products from a company that has come in last place in mobile phones, next gen console, operating systems, etc. Would be cool if they could just get something, anything right for a change.

But the sad truth is, we all know they will continue to fail and I suspect Windows 9 will be no different.
 
<snipped other things>
4) Pure Desktop Experience mode. Last time I checked it was pretty easy to get to desktop mode even in Windows 8.
How competent are you with computers? Judging by what you say it sounds like you know your way around computers/OSes fairly well. The problem is 90-99% of the user base is probably no where near your level of skill, so when you say "it was pretty easy" it was pretty easy for you to do it. Other people not so much, I know I got particularly frustrated with the task myself, simply due to the way the interface worked it was so foreign to me that even with step-by-step videos it made me hate the Win8 interface with a passion. Yeah it works like a desktop should work now, and I love the fact that Windows 8 boots in record fast time, but getting to that point where I was happy did take some wrangling. Also did Windows 8 actually have desktop built into it? I seem to recall needing an "app" to do most of the stuff for me, yeah it was free, yeah I simply downloaded it, but for one who doesn't have a tablet that whole touch interface threw me quite a bit.

A better method would be upon installation or first-startup perhaps simply asking "Is this going to be used as a desktop computer, or a touch device" then it can configure it for you in that way. The way Win8 is now is that it really is trying to force you to use the touch interface, even with a mouse. You really get the feeling that Microsoft is saying "This is the future damnit, and you're going to like it"
 
A better method would be upon installation or first-startup perhaps simply asking "Is this going to be used as a desktop computer, or a touch device" then it can configure it for you in that way. The way Win8 is now is that it really is trying to force you to use the touch interface, even with a mouse. You really get the feeling that Microsoft is saying "This is the future damnit, and you're going to like it"

Supposedly going to be that way in Windows 9. :)
 
There was incredible value in Microsofts installed user base knowing the ins and outs of Windows prior to Windows 8 that when they threw all that away, they were doomed.
 
That is a pretty horrible list. I don't think I really agreed on any of his points except maybe the update roll-ups.
 
How competent are you with computers? Judging by what you say it sounds like you know your way around computers/OSes fairly well. The problem is 90-99% of the user base is probably no where near your level of skill, so when you say "it was pretty easy" it was pretty easy for you to do it. Other people not so much, I know I got particularly frustrated with the task myself, simply due to the way the interface worked it was so foreign to me that even with step-by-step videos it made me hate the Win8 interface with a passion. Yeah it works like a desktop should work now, and I love the fact that Windows 8 boots in record fast time, but getting to that point where I was happy did take some wrangling. Also did Windows 8 actually have desktop built into it? I seem to recall needing an "app" to do most of the stuff for me, yeah it was free, yeah I simply downloaded it, but for one who doesn't have a tablet that whole touch interface threw me quite a bit.

A better method would be upon installation or first-startup perhaps simply asking "Is this going to be used as a desktop computer, or a touch device" then it can configure it for you in that way. The way Win8 is now is that it really is trying to force you to use the touch interface, even with a mouse. You really get the feeling that Microsoft is saying "This is the future damnit, and you're going to like it"

Seriously, how hard do people think it is to get to the desktop in Windows 8? It is just clicking the Desktop tile on the start screen. How hard is that to understand? Do people just not see the tile?? It's right in the first column in a default install, double wide. Seriously, how do people not understand this?

On top of that, Microsoft made Windows 8.1 a FREE upgrade for Windows 8 users. This makes a lot of things even easier.

Seriously, in order to not understand the Windows 8 interface, they'd just have to not try. It's not even a hard thing. It's not as hard as trying to get all the gluten out of your diet, or trying to avoid refined sugars. Heck, it's not even as hard as learning how to park straight in a parking place. (There are certain people who don't seem to be able to get this right, though.) Don't try to convince me that the Windows 8 interface is difficult. It took me all of about 2 minutes to be able to get around anywhere I needed. To an average user, that would be an effort for about a hour, at most, to learn the whole thing. It just takes a little bit of effort. The problem is that so many people are just lazy asses.
 
There was incredible value in Microsofts installed user base knowing the ins and outs of Windows prior to Windows 8 that when they threw all that away, they were doomed.

Things didn't change quite that radically. For instance, many people complained about modern apps as the defaults yet if one understood the ins and outs of how setting program default in Windows 7 works, that knowledge applies directly to Windows 8. There are tons of other things that aren't that different. What is different shouldn't take an experienced computer user that long to pick up.

But sure, anything that seems to get in people's way I can understand them not liking it. But in many cases I'm not sure they knew the old stuff as well as they may have thought.
 
Fresh Windows 8 installations can take almost a day to fully patch,

Turn on auto updates and walk away, problem 1 solved....

and what are you updating it on, dial up?
 
Give me the Windows 7 UI with whatever under the hood upgrades are made with Windows 8, call it Windows 9, and I'll buy it. :p
 
It's not a bad OS at all. It's a step up from Windows 7. The biggest complaint is the UI. A lot of people refuse to upgrade because of it. Not that they CAN'T use it, but they don't like it and don't WANT to use it.

For me it is a combination of the UI (even with a start menu it is ugly and harder to see) and the updater. I've had Win 8 corrupt itself a variety of times, and the "recovery" options are not as straight forward as XP/Vista was. I never had to use anything like that in Win 7, but I believe it is similar to Vista.

I've seen a bunch of Win 8 laptops screw up over updates. It may have been caused by Classic Shell, shitty laptop drivers/firmware, or Win 8 itself. But all I can say is Win 8 seems more fragile to me than 7.
 
Of course, even Linux based machines are needing a reboot now after updates so I am not sure how Microsoft could pull it off.

I dunno about the reboot requirement you're talking about for Linux. I just installed Mint 17 on a netbook and ran updates to make it current. It didn't need to reboot after lots and lots of updates. In the following couple weeks it had a few more updates and they didn't require any restarting either. In fact, my experiences with Mint 16, and Mint 14 were the same. No restarts were necessary. They aren't required for software installation or removal either.

Thoss are all just me only things, but yeah, I haven't really seen mandatory reboots for updates in Linux.
 
You done fucked it up now!

start-menu.jpg
 
things I'd appreciate:
a) built-in display of the seconds count in the system time
b) virtual desktops (probably coming, worth mentioning anyway)
c) shutdown confirmation dialog
d) animated wallpaper again :D
 
I've been on windows 8.1 since 8.1 came out, I really have not a single complaint. Best windows OS i've ever used.
 
Seriously, how hard do people think it is to get to the desktop in Windows 8? It is just clicking the Desktop tile on the start screen. How hard is that to understand? Do people just not see the tile?? It's right in the first column in a default install, double wide. Seriously, how do people not understand this?

On top of that, Microsoft made Windows 8.1 a FREE upgrade for Windows 8 users. This makes a lot of things even easier.

Seriously, in order to not understand the Windows 8 interface, they'd just have to not try. It's not even a hard thing. It's not as hard as trying to get all the gluten out of your diet, or trying to avoid refined sugars. Heck, it's not even as hard as learning how to park straight in a parking place. (There are certain people who don't seem to be able to get this right, though.) Don't try to convince me that the Windows 8 interface is difficult. It took me all of about 2 minutes to be able to get around anywhere I needed. To an average user, that would be an effort for about a hour, at most, to learn the whole thing. It just takes a little bit of effort. The problem is that so many people are just lazy asses.

There are several problems with this:

1) There is not always a Desktop tile on the Metro/Start screen (the install image doesn't place it there, the user deletes it, etc). I have had a number of people bring me laptops without a Desktop tile. If the masses can't figure it out, it isn't going to sell well, despite every power user's wishes that computers have literacy requirements...

2) Microsoft built a user base that has been trained since Windows 95 to use the Start menu. I know a bunch of people that had a hard time wrapping their heads around the Vista/7 change to a Start button that didn't say "Start" on it. There are people like this in offices everywhere.

3) The Windows 8.1 Upgrade/Update was botched in large part by OEMs that didn't take the time to update their drivers/software to work with 8.1. I worked on plenty of computers where the 8.1 Upgrade/Update would fail to install only to find out that Dell's wireless card software/driver or Toshiba's Service Station were preventing the installation. This is not necessarily Microsoft's failing, but with such a fragmented hardware marketplace, it is something that definitely has the potential to impact adoption in a negative way.

4) A lot of software that was not made for Windows 8/8.1/8.1u1, but a user will still want to install, did not know how to interact with the Metro/Start screen. If the program didn't make a desktop shortcut, and it didn't register properly in Windows Search on the Metro/Start screen, the user might be forced to find the program directory, then manually create a shortcut on the desktop. Again, not Microsoft's fault, and not a problem for an experienced user, but for a lot of the people buying these computers, we're talking about an entirely different story.

Windows 9 will supposedly give us the option at installation/first-boot to choose our environment. This will go a long way to fixing these problems. The familiarity of the Start Menu returning will also help. A bit more corralling of the OEMs to ensure a bit more uniform implementation of features wouldn't necessarily hurt either.

With respect to the article's points, I think the two keys are the update process and windows backup. My in-laws had no trouble keeping OS X up-to-date or figuring out Time Machine backups/restorations. The Windows world has been a lot more challenging for them. Are the OS X systems perfect? Not really, but for a lot of people they are more intuitive/easier to figure out. This is definitely an area where Windows 9 can improve upon.
 
I've seen a bunch of Win 8 laptops screw up over updates. It may have been caused by Classic Shell, shitty laptop drivers/firmware, or Win 8 itself. But all I can say is Win 8 seems more fragile to me than 7.

It's Windows 8 itself. A lot of people had issues where it craps out due to an update. I've fixed several, and the forums are full of them.

Plus, Win8 lacks a Safe Mode, which makes some recovery options difficult.
 
No edit or I would add this to one of my other posts: The only thing I would prefer is that the computer does not need a reboot after installing updates. Of course, even Linux based machines are needing a reboot now after updates so I am not sure how Microsoft could pull it off.

It's not just annoying, it's rage inducing. The other day I was working on a graphic for a company and mid work Windows 8 forced a reboot. This PC never shuts off, so why couldn't it do this during non-peak hours? Took 15 minutes to do its update, while I saw twiddling my thumbs.

They also need to remove the default "Restart and Update" option. Users shouldn't have to use GPIO to allow themselves a restart without update.
 
Or in other words:

1. Be a Mac.
2. Be a Mac.
3. Be a Mac.
4. Be a Mac.
5. Be a Mac.

You mean the Fisher-Price GUI for people who don't know how to use a real computer?
I though they already tried that with Windows 8?
 
Is this finally getting announced tomorrow or something?

Yes. :D

Not sure about tech preview. Some say tomorrow, some say Enterprise edition only tomorrow, others say November.... Depends on what rumor mill your listening to. I'm hoping tomorrow. If not, maybe the 1st or 2nd.
 
Then stay with the old OS and lose support :D MS can't do the same thing over and over again! They need to evolve. But once people start hating on it, the hate spreads even to people that have never even tried the OS. I have Win 8 on all my devices.

Even my niece who mainly used a Mac before college hated the Windows 8 GUI. End up switching to a MAC for her 1st year, and then switched to a Windows 7 laptop.
 
I know I got particularly frustrated with the task myself, simply due to the way the interface worked it was so foreign to me that even with step-by-step videos it made me hate the Win8 interface with a passion. Yeah it works like a desktop should work now, and I love the fact that Windows 8 boots in record fast time, but getting to that point where I was happy did take some wrangling.

I knew Windows 8 was going to be in trouble the first time I installed it on a system, and tried to do a restart.

I had to do a Google search to figure out how to restart the system, since the Start/Restart button no longer existed, and there was no obvious way to shutdown or restart the system.
Instead I had a "hover" the mouse on the right side of the screen hoping the charms menu would come up, choose settings from the charms menu and then click on the power icon and choose restart.
 
It's one of the most often heard phrases on construction job sites these days: GIVE ME A FUCKING FLIPPHONE. lol
 
There are several problems with this:

1) There is not always a Desktop tile on the Metro/Start screen (the install image doesn't place it there, the user deletes it, etc). I have had a number of people bring me laptops without a Desktop tile. If the masses can't figure it out, it isn't going to sell well, despite every power user's wishes that computers have literacy requirements...

2) Microsoft built a user base that has been trained since Windows 95 to use the Start menu. I know a bunch of people that had a hard time wrapping their heads around the Vista/7 change to a Start button that didn't say "Start" on it. There are people like this in offices everywhere.

3) The Windows 8.1 Upgrade/Update was botched in large part by OEMs that didn't take the time to update their drivers/software to work with 8.1. I worked on plenty of computers where the 8.1 Upgrade/Update would fail to install only to find out that Dell's wireless card software/driver or Toshiba's Service Station were preventing the installation. This is not necessarily Microsoft's failing, but with such a fragmented hardware marketplace, it is something that definitely has the potential to impact adoption in a negative way.

4) A lot of software that was not made for Windows 8/8.1/8.1u1, but a user will still want to install, did not know how to interact with the Metro/Start screen. If the program didn't make a desktop shortcut, and it didn't register properly in Windows Search on the Metro/Start screen, the user might be forced to find the program directory, then manually create a shortcut on the desktop. Again, not Microsoft's fault, and not a problem for an experienced user, but for a lot of the people buying these computers, we're talking about an entirely different story.

Windows 9 will supposedly give us the option at installation/first-boot to choose our environment. This will go a long way to fixing these problems. The familiarity of the Start Menu returning will also help. A bit more corralling of the OEMs to ensure a bit more uniform implementation of features wouldn't necessarily hurt either.

With respect to the article's points, I think the two keys are the update process and windows backup. My in-laws had no trouble keeping OS X up-to-date or figuring out Time Machine backups/restorations. The Windows world has been a lot more challenging for them. Are the OS X systems perfect? Not really, but for a lot of people they are more intuitive/easier to figure out. This is definitely an area where Windows 9 can improve upon.

1. by default, it is there. If the idiot user unpins it from the start screen, which is hard to do, then they're on their own.

2. It isn't hard, however they're trained. It just takes effort and thought, something that has apparently become anathema to the majority in the US these days. They keep wanting the government to take care of them and make their decisions. It's not a real surprise. It's just pitiful. I will keep screaming against this until people wake up and get their heads out of their butts.

3. Win8.1 uses the EXACT SAME DRIVERS as Win 8. It's the same kernel with a UI update. I have never heard of a driver of piece of software that works with Win8 that doesn't work with 8.1. If a hardware manufacturer manages that, they're completely incompetent.

4. If people actually put the thought behind it, they'd know that Microsoft designed the start screen just like the start menu of Windows 7 and Windows XP. There's this thing called "All programs" that lists their newly installed program in alphabetical order. They can right click on the tile for their program and pin it to the start screen or to the task bar. It only takes an intelligence level slightly above that of a German Shepherd to figure that out. However, what it takes is effort, or actually trying to figure it out. That's the problem.

The big problem with Windows 8 isn't Windows 8. It's the average user these days. They don't put any effort into figuring anything out. If it isn't just handed to them, they look at it and just quit.
 
The big problem with Windows 8 isn't Windows 8. It's the average user these days. They don't put any effort into figuring anything out. If it isn't just handed to them, they look at it and just quit.

Average user is just like that. That's how it's been for a long time. Should the user bend to learn a new OS, or should the OS bend for them? Depends on who wants the money. IT people will bend and learn a new OS. Regular users won't. Developers of the OS - if they want the money, they will cater to the largest segment - clueless users.

But, they really don't like being called clueless and stupid. Even if they are dumb at computers. They know enough about computers to do their job or browse the internet. If it gets tricky, they won't play, they won't try it out. They'll do a few little things, then give up. That's why IT people have jobs. To do stuff the average user won't.
 
Average user is just like that. That's how it's been for a long time. Should the user bend to learn a new OS, or should the OS bend for them? Depends on who wants the money. IT people will bend and learn a new OS. Regular users won't. Developers of the OS - if they want the money, they will cater to the largest segment - clueless users.

But, they really don't like being called clueless and stupid. Even if they are dumb at computers. They know enough about computers to do their job or browse the internet. If it gets tricky, they won't play, they won't try it out. They'll do a few little things, then give up. That's why IT people have jobs. To do stuff the average user won't.

It's not clueless or stupid. It's lazy. There is a significant difference. It wasn't someone's stupidity that parked a truck on ramps up to a loading dock. It was the laziness that caused her to not go back to the truck rental place and get a higher truck, or to make sure the truck was tall enough to begin with, that killed my best friend. I HATE laziness. Lazy people need to be smacked, hard and often.

We are human beings. We adapt. That's our big superpower, and how we spread all over the globe and became the one dominant species over the whole planet. Only two species even come close, rats and mice, and they depend on us. To spurn our major power of adaptation in favor of laziness cannot be simply accepted. We must fight against that tendency, or we will all suffer the consequences.
 
The comment I liked from the article was:
Tone back the animations. I want an operating system, not a Pixar movie.
While animations look cool on a television show or movie, quite frankly, I want to use the computer to GET STUFF DONE! If you want animations, go for it. I find that I end up just going into preferences and turning the animations off.
 
It's not clueless or stupid. It's lazy. There is a significant difference. It wasn't someone's stupidity that parked a truck on ramps up to a loading dock. It was the laziness that caused her to not go back to the truck rental place and get a higher truck, or to make sure the truck was tall enough to begin with, that killed my best friend. I HATE laziness. Lazy people need to be smacked, hard and often.

We are human beings. We adapt. That's our big superpower, and how we spread all over the globe and became the one dominant species over the whole planet. Only two species even come close, rats and mice, and they depend on us. To spurn our major power of adaptation in favor of laziness cannot be simply accepted. We must fight against that tendency, or we will all suffer the consequences.

This argument is so tired it's worn a hole through the Earth to wherever-is-opposite-of-where-we're-sitting.

"You refuse to learn, you won't adapt, you're lazy!"

Get off your high horse and realize that businesses faced significant retraining costs with the Win8 interface. If people couldn't figure out where the Start menu was when MS took the word "Start" off (which as was noted in earlier posts happened), don't be surprised that when the whole screen is changed, users are even more confused.

Do you work with the world as it is (which is what businesses and other users are saying) or do you constantly whine about the alleged inferiority of people who won't Have It Your Way?

I choose the former. Your argument suggests you've chosen the latter.

Just because something can be changed doesn't mean the change is beneficial. MS learned that lesson the hard way.
 
This argument is so tired it's worn a hole through the Earth to wherever-is-opposite-of-where-we're-sitting.

"You refuse to learn, you won't adapt, you're lazy!"

I'm paying for a service or product- I don't expect to walk into a steak house and get served fish after ordering prime rib. And be told to like it! Screw you I'm going to take my money elsewhere.

Ultimately the consumer is king ($$$) and it is in Microsoft's best interest in producing a product that is faster, more stable and easier to use than the one proceeding it.

I have used MS since the days of DOS 6.22 and Windows for Workgroups 3.11, I despise Win 8 as the most counter intuitive OS I have ever used on a PC and that is saying a lot.
 
I've been on windows 8.1 since 8.1 came out, I really have not a single complaint. Best windows OS i've ever used.

Don't know if I'd go that far. But it is a good OS. I wish navigation would be easier though. Finding things and having to go through search all the time sucks.
 
You mean the Fisher-Price GUI for people who don't know how to use a real computer?
I though they already tried that with Windows 8?

No, that is how I think the article writers 5 points sounded like to me. :D
 
Back
Top