4Ghz CPU or 4GB more Ram

LawGiver

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Oct 16, 2005
Messages
2,077
I'm not looking for opinions on IF i should be doing this, just on which one as I will do one or the other. Thinking about adding 4 more gigs for a total of 8 or getting a E8400 to overclock to 4Ghz. Im leaning towards more ram.
 
You would benefit more from the e8400. You can disable paging file with 8GB.... not exactly the most exciting thing in the world. Your performance gains with 8GB over 4GB would be nil in most circumstances.
 
You can easily go up to 8GB with video editing/animation work. I'll be up to 8GB of ram this weekend, and 12gb soon.
 
This is among the only times I would recommend this, but buy a newer CPU. I have 8 GB RAM in my main rig (Q9450) and in my HTPC (Athlon X2 4850e). For my tasks, I push my CPU much more than my RAM usage, and 3D modeling is the only realistic task everyday that I think would use over 4GB anyway.
 
I'm not looking for opinions on IF i should be doing this, just on which one as I will do one or the other. Thinking about adding 4 more gigs for a total of 8 or getting a E8400 to overclock to 4Ghz. Im leaning towards more ram.

Get an E8400. Overclock to 4Ghz to show off here, then put it back down to a sane level for everyday use.
 
4GHz is a sane, 24/7, setting for everyday use with an E8400. There's something seriously wrong if a new E8400 E0 can't hit 4GHz.
 
The E8400 is definitely a much better upgrade. Adding 4GB of RAM will only improve performance in certain RAM-heavy applications, but putting in an E8400 would give a pretty hefty boost to the speed of general usage, especially when overclocked to 4GHz.
 
E8400 unless you have a specific need for more than 4GB.
I have an early (not as clockable) E8400 and its has been running at 4.1GHz since January without any issues.
 
i wish Q9450's were the same ;)

I ran my q9450 at stock voltage at 3.4 GHZ and I have never overclocked before. I think that it is great... Really, a 4 GHZ quad is very difficult to achieve unless you have an extreme to pump up the multiplier.
 
4GHz is a sane, 24/7, setting for everyday use with an E8400. There's something seriously wrong if a new E8400 E0 can't hit 4GHz.

Could an E8400 E0 hit 4 Ghz easily with DDR2 PC800 Ram?

or at least 3.6 .. 9x400 ?

btw: to the OP , go with E8400..4gigs is enough..buy the other 4 gigs some time next
 
4GHz is a sane, 24/7, setting for everyday use with an E8400. There's something seriously wrong if a new E8400 E0 can't hit 4GHz.

Mine can hit 4Ghz too. It just takes more power and shortens the life of not only the CPU, but the motherboard. It may not be [H] to say so, but it is what it is.
 
8GB of ram is more uncommon than a 4GHz E8400, so you'll have more e-peen with 8GB of ram. Go for it!

Ninja edit: I forgot that 8GB of ram is definitely more [H]ard than a 4GHz cpu.
 
..... and shortens the life of not only the CPU, but the motherboard.

I've been hearing that for years now. When I bumped my Pentium 3 from 450 MHz to 600 MHz with a little bit of extra core voltage everyone told me the end was near for that chip. Damn thing is still running.

Could an E8400 E0 hit 4 Ghz easily with DDR2 PC800 Ram?

DDR2 memory is so incredibly cheap these days that if you can't get your present memory to run at DDR2-900 then go buy some memory that can. I picked up 2GB of top of the line, OCZ DDR2-9200 Reapers last month for less than $50 after rebates. Now it's half that price!

2GB OCZ Reaper DDR2-8500 for $19.99 after rebates would also work well.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227191

With an E0 the question won't be whether you hit 4GHz but whether you'll be able to hit 4.5GHz. :D

superpi4500mhz1mfg9.png
 
Considering what you're running processor wise, I'd suggest the E8400 and overclocking it a bit. It would be a more noticeable improvement for more general tasks than an extra 4 gig of RAM.

Now, if you only had two gig of RAM, it might be a different story. At that point I would suggest both. As it is, if you can sell your current CPU for whatever, you shouldn't have too much trouble getting enough out of it to buy another 4 gig of RAM. With the current prices of DDR2 right now, it's almost a drop in the bucket price wise.

 
RAM is cheap now but it can be expensive later when DDR3 is the norm. CPU will always be cheaper.
 
I just put my 4GB of ram so I got 8GB now. I'm reinstalling to 64bit vista today. I think I'm gonna go with the e8400 or e8500 as well.
 
CPU. Returns over 4GB is very small, where getting a faster CPU will net all around better performance. If you want to do something unique or rare, there are a lot of other things out there than 8GB of ram. Be practical about it and get something that will really help.
 
Back
Top